An Ambiguous Literary Genre

The Origins of Early Greek Mythography

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

The purpose of this paper is to investigate the origins of early Greek mythography, exemplarily represented by Hecataeus of Miletus and Acusilaus of Argos. The paucity of verbatim quotations and a total lack of information about the publication of their prose works and their audience makes it difficult to frame them within a specific literary genre. Despite that, a better understanding of their cultural milieu could help us approach their literary production in a new way. What arises from this investigation is how unprofitable it is to rely upon a rigid distinction among the production of early prose writers who clearly share a common goal and, to some extent, a similar communicative strategy.

Mnemosyne

A Journal of Classical Studies

Sections

References

BertelliL., 'Hecataeus. From Genealogy to Historiography', in N. Luraghi (ed), The Historian’s Craft in the Age of Herodotus, (Oxford 2001) 67-94.

BowieE.L., 'Ancestors of Historiography in Early Greek Elegiac and Iambic Poetry?', in N. Luraghi (ed), The Historian’s Craft in the Age of Herodotus, (Oxford 2001) 45-66.

BowieE.L., 'Historical Narrative in Archaic and Early Classical Greek Elegy', in D. Konstan and K.A. Raaflaub (eds), Epic and History, (Chichester/Malden, MA/Oxford 2010) 145-166.

CalameC., 'Le funzioni di un racconto genealogico. Acusilao di Argo e la nascita della storiografia', in Angeli Bernardini P. (ed), La città di Argo. Mito, storia, tradizioni poetiche. Atti del convegno internazionale, Urbino, 13-15 giugno 2002, (Roma 2004) 229-243.

CameronA., Greek Mythography in the Roman World, (Oxford 2004).

G. Colesanti and M. Giordano (eds), Submerged Literature in Ancient Greek Culture, (Berlin 2014).

CorcellaA., '“Ecateo di Mileto così dice”' (1996) 43 Quaderni di Storia: 295-301.

M. Depew and D. Obbink (eds), Matrices of Genres. Authors, Canons and Society, (Cambridge, MA 2000).

DolcettiP., Ferecide di Atene. Testimonianze e frammenti, (Alessandria 2004).

FabianiR., 'Epigrafi greche in Erodoto', in A.M. Biraschi (ed), L’uso dei documenti nella storiografia antica, (Perugia 2003) 163-185.

C.A. Faraone and D. Obbink (eds), The Getty Hexameters. Poetry, Magic and Mystery in Ancient Selinous, (Oxford 2013).

FowlerR.L., 'Herodotus and his Contemporaries', in jhs, (Oxford/New York ) 6246-8783 now reprinted with minor revisions in: Vignolo Munson, R. (ed.) 2013. Herodotus. Volume 1, Herodotus and the Narrative of the Past. Oxford Readings in Classical Studies.

FowlerR.L., 'The Authors named Pherecydes' (1999) 52 Mnemosyne: 1-15.

FowlerR.L., Early Greek Mythography. Volume I. Text and Introduction, (Oxford 2000).

FowlerR.L., 'Early historiē and Literacy', in N. Luraghi (ed), The Historian’s Craft in the Age of Herodotus, (Oxford 2001) 95-115.

FowlerR.L., 'How to Tell a Myth. Genealogy, Mythology, Mythography' (2006) 19 Kernos: 35-46.

FowlerR.L., 'Mythos and Logos' (2011) 131 jhs: 45-66.

FowlerR.L., Early Greek Mythography. Volume II. Commentary, (Oxford 2013).

GoldhillS., The Invention of Prose, (Cambridge 2002).

GoodyJ.WattI., 'The Importance of Literacy' (1963) 5(3) Comparative Studies in Society and History: 304-345.

HawesG., Rationalizing Myth in Antiquity, (Oxford 2014).

HenrichsA., 'Three Approaches to Greek Mythography', in J. Bremmer (ed), Interpretations of Greek Mythology, (London/Sydney 1987) 242-277.

HigbieC., 'Hellenistic Mythographers', in R.D. Woodard (ed), The Cambridge Companion to Greek Mythology, (Cambridge 2007) 237-254.

JacobyF., 'Über die Entwicklung der griechischen Historiographie und den Plan einer neuen Sammlung der griechischen Historikerfragmente' (1909) 9 Klio: 80-123.

JacobyF., 'Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, Erster Teil. Genealogie und Mythographie', in Neudruck vermehrt um Addenda zum Text, Nachträge zum Kommentar, Corrigenda und Konkordanz, (Leiden 1957) 2.

JordanD.R.KotanskyR.D., 'Ritual Hexameters in the Getty Museum. Preliminary Edition' (2011) 178 zpe: 54-62.

KahnC.H., 'Writing Philosophy. Prose and Poetry from Thales to Plato', in H. Yunis (ed), Written Texts and the Rise of Literate Culture in Ancient Greece, (Cambridge 2003) 139-161.

KenensU., 'The Sources of Ps.-Apollodorus’s Library. A Case Study' (2011) 97 qucc: 129-146.

KurkeL., 'Aesopic Conversations', in Popular Tradition, Cultural Dialogue and the Invention of Greek Prose, (Princeton/Oxford 2011).

LanzillottaE., 'Due fiumi per una cronologia', in C. Marangio and G. Laudizi (eds), Παλαιὰ φιλία. Studi di topografia antica in onore di Giovanni Uggeri, (Lecce 2009) 33-37.

LincolnB., Theorizing Myth. Narrative, Ideology and Scholarship, (Chicago/London 1999).

MaasP., Kleine Schriften, (München 1973).

MalinowskiB., Myth in Primitive Psychology, (London 1926).

MartinR.P., 'The Myth before the Myth Began' () Proceedings of ucla Conference on Mythography see http://www.princeton.edu/~pswpc/pdfs/rpmartin/021204.pdf(forthcoming).

MazzarinoS., Il pensiero storico classico, (Roma/Bari 1990) 2.

MeliadòC., 'Mythography', in F. Montanari, A. Rengakos and S. Matthaios (eds), The Brill’s Companion on Ancient Greek Scholarship, (Leiden/Boston 2015) 1057-1089.

MinchinE., 'The Performance of Lists and Catalogues in the Homeric Epics', in I. Worthington (ed), Voice into Text. Orality and Literacy in Ancient Greece, (Leiden 1996) 3-20.

MoyerI.S., 'Herodotus and an Egyptian Mirage. The Genealogies of the Theban Priests' (2002) 122 jhs: 70-90.

NenciG., 'Ecateo da Mileto e la questione del suo razionalismo' (1951) 6 Rendiconti dell’Accademia nazionale dei Lincei: 53-58.

NicolaiR., 'Pater semper incertus.Appunti su Ecateo' (1997) 56 qucc: 143-164.

NicolaiR., 'La biblioteca delle Muse. Osservazioni sulle più antiche raccolte librarie greche' (2000) 23 gb: 213-227.

Pàmias i MassanaJ., 'Acusilau d’Argos i els primers mitògrafs. Entre oralitat i escriptura' (2008) 30(1) Faventia: 161-170.

Pàmias i MassanaJ., 'Phaedrus’ Cosmology in the Symposium. A Reappraisal' (2012) 62 cq: 532-540.

PearsonL., Early Ionian Historians, (Oxford 1939).

PellizerE., 'La mitografia', in G. Cambiano (ed), Lo spazio letterario della Grecia antica, (Roma 1993) 283-303.

PorcianiL., 'Prime forme della storiografia greca', in Prospettiva locale e generale della narrazione storica, (Stuttgart 1997).

RoccaG., 'I libri di Numa Pompilio', in D. Maras (ed), Corollari. Studi di antichità etrusche e italiche in onore di Giovanni Colonna, (Pisa/Roma 2011) 84-86.

ThomasR., Oral Tradition and Written Record in Classical Athens, (Cambridge 1989).

ThomasR., Herodotus in Context. Ethnography, Science and the Art of Persuasion, (Cambridge 2000).

ThomasR., 'Prose Performance Texts. Epideixis and Written Publication in the Late Fifth and Early Fourth Centuries', in H. Yunis (ed), Written Texts and the Rise of Literate Culture in Ancient Greece, (Cambridge 2003) 162-188.

ToyeD.L., 'Pherecydes of Syros. Ancient Theologian and Genealogist' (1997) 50 Mnemosyne: 530-560.

TrzaskomaS.M., 'Citation, Organization and Authorial Presence in Ps.-Apollodorus’ Bibliotheca', in R.S. Smith and S.M. Trzaskoma (eds), Writing Myth. Mythography in the Ancient World, (Leuven/Paris/Walpole, MA 2013) 75-94.

UlmA.Pherekydes von AthenGrundriß und Einheit des Werkes(Diss. München)

WeçowskiM., 'Friends or Foes? Herodotus in Thucydides’ Preface', in J. Pigo (ed), The Children of Herodotus. Greek and Roman Historiography and Related Genres, (Newcastle 2008) 34-57.

WendelC., 'Mythographie', in Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft, (Stuttgart 1935) 1352-1374.

WestS.R., 'Herodotus’ Epigraphical Interests' (1985) 35(2) cq: 278-305.

WestS.R., 'Herodotus’ Portrait of Hecataeus' (1991) 111 jhs: 140-160.

WestS.R., Demythologisation in Herodotus, (Toruń 2002).

Wilamowitz-MoellendorffU. von, Der Glaube der Hellenen, (Berlin 1932).

WilsdorfH., 'Der Weise Achikaros bei Demokrit und Theophrast' (1991) 135 Philologus: 191-206.

2

Firstly stated by Jacoby 1909. See also Porciani 1997 for a systematic dismissal of Jacoby’s thesis.

7

About these writers see Fowler 1996, 63ff.

9

Cf. Ercolani in Colesanti and Giordano 2014, 12: “a description of the textual production of ancient Greek culture in terms of a ‘theory of the genre’ proves indeed both misguided and misleading in the examination of prose texts”.

11

Depew and Obbink 2000, 6.

16

Dolcetti 2004, 9ff.

18

See Ulm 1963, 13ff., and Fowler, egm ii, 710-715.

26

Cf. Calame 2004, 234.

27

Thomas 1989, 155ff.

28

Minchin 1996, 9ff.

29

Thomas 1989, 155.

31

Goody and Watt 1963, 325.

32

Malinowski 1926, 23.

33

Goody and Watt 1963, 308-11.

34

Pearson 1939, 98 rightly underlines the aristocratic tone that Hecataeus used here; on this opening statement see Nenci 1951, 56ff., Corcella 1996, Porciani 1997, 47ff., Bertelli 2001, 80ff., Fowler 2000, 110ff., West 2002, 4-5.

35

Corcella 1996.

41

Lincoln 1999, whose conclusions are summed up in Fowler 2011, 52ff.

42

Fowler 2011, 53.

44

Fowler 2001, 101.

46

Bertelli 2001, 79.

48

See also Fowler 2011, 54.

49

Pellizer 1993.

50

On this point, I owe a lot to Thomas 2003.

51

On this, see Weçowski 2008.

53

Thomas 2000, 249ff.

54

Pàmias 2008.

61

Translation is from Faraone-Obbink 2013, 11-12.

63

On this point see Nicolai 2000.

64

Goldhill 2002, 5.

65

Thomas 2000, 4-9.

68

2001 and 2010.

70

See Nicolai 1997.

71

Fowler 2006, 44-45.

72

Fowler 2006, 36.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 9 9 2
Full Text Views 5 5 5
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0