Mythographical and Literary Notes on the Catalogs of Argive and Theban Allies in Statius’ Thebaid

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

This article argues, in a series of discrete but interconnected notes, that Statius engages consistently and consciously with mythographical works—prose collections and exegesis on myth as myth—in the creation of his two major catalogs in the Thebaid, the catalog of Argive allies at 4.1-344 and that of Theban allies at 7.243-373. Both are patently based on Homer’s ‘Catalog of Ships’, but Statius reshapes his model by engaging ingeniously with mythographical and geographical works in prose to invent a unique pre-Iliadic landscape. This paper also explores some of the literary ways in which Statius reinvents Homer’s catalog, including offering his readers mythological puzzles that require knowledge both of Homer’s text and subsequent scholarship thereon.

Mythographical and Literary Notes on the Catalogs of Argive and Theban Allies in Statius’ Thebaid

in Mnemosyne

Sections

References

AhlF., 'Statius’ Thebaid. A Reconsideration' (1986) 32(5) anrw ii: 2803-2912.

AltonE.H., 'Notes on the Thebaid of Statius' (1923) 17 cq: 175-186.

AsquithH.C.A., 'Silver Epic Catalogues', in ma Thesis, (Durham 2001).

AtenstädtF., 'Apollodors κατάλογος νεῶν bei Strabon' (1943) 95 Philologus: 55-78.

BarchiesiA., 'Future Reflexive. Two Modes of Allusion and Ovid’s Heroides' (1993) 95 HSPh: 333-365.

BonnerS.F., Education in Ancient Rome from the Elder Cato to the Younger Pliny, (Berkeley 1977).

CameronA., Greek Mythography in the Roman World, (Oxford 2004).

CebriánJ.P., Mythographus Homericus. Estudi i edició comentada, (Diss. Barcelona 2007).

ColeT., 'Ovid, Varro, and Castor of Rhodes. The Chronological Architecture of the Metamorphoses' (2004) 102 HSPh: 355-422.

ColeT., Ovidius Mythistoricus. Legendary Time in the Metamorphoses, (Frankfurt am Main 2008).

ConteG.B.SegalC., The Rhetoric of Imitation. Genre and Poetic Memory in Virgil and Other Latin Poets, (Ithaca/London 1986).

CribioreR., Gymnastics of the Mind. Greek Education in Hellenistic and Roman Egypt, (Princeton 2001).

FarrellJ., 'Complementarity and Contradiction in Ovidian Mythography', in S.M. Trzaskoma and R.S. Smith (eds), Writing Myth. Mythography in the Ancient World, (Leuven 2013) 223-251.

GantzT., Early Greek Myth. A Guide to Literary and Artistic Sources, (Baltimore 1993).

GeorgacopoulouS., 'Ranger/déranger. Catalogues et listes de personnages dans la Thébaïde', in F. Delarue, S. Georgacopoulou, P. Laurens and A.-M. Taisne (eds), Epicedion. Hommage à P. Papinius Statius, (Poitiers 1996) 93-129.

GrafF., 'Myth in Ovid', in P. Hardie (ed), Cambridge Companion to Ovid, (Cambridge 2002) 108-121.

HelmR., De P. Papinii Statii Thebaide, (Diss. Berlin 1892).

HelmR., 'Nachaugusteische nichtchristliche Dichter i', in Lustrum, (Statius 1956) 121272-318299.

HexterR., 'On First Looking into Vergil’s Homer', in J. Farrell and M.C.J. Putnam (eds), A Companion to Vergil’s Aeneid and its Tradition, (Chichester/Malden, MA 2010) 26-36.

JuhnkeH., Homerisches in römischer Epik flavischer Zeit. Untersuchungen zu Szenennachbildungen und Strukturentsprechungen in Statius’ Thebais und Achilleis und in Silius’ Punica, (Munich 1972).

KleywegtA.J., Valerius Flaccus Argonautica Book i. A Commentary, (Leiden/Boston 2005).

KlotzA., P. Papini Stati Thebais, (Leipzig 1908).

KytzlerB., 'Imitatio und aemulatio in der Thebais des Statius' (1969) 97 Hermes: 209-232.

LegrasL., Étude sur la Thébaïde de Stace, (Paris 1905).

LevinD.N., 'An Epithet for Argos in Apollonius' (1963) 4 grbs: 9-17.

LightfootJ.L., Hellenistic Collection, (Cambridge, MA 2009).

LovattH., Statius and Epic Games. Sport Politics and Poetics in the Thebaid, (Cambridge 2005).

LübbertE., Diatriba in Pindari locum de Adrasti regno Sicyonio, (Bonn 1884) 3-22.

MatthewsV.J., Antimachus of Colophon. Text and Commentary, (Leiden 1996).

McNelisC., 'Greek Grammarians and Roman Society during the Early Empire. Statius’ Father and his Contemporaries' (2002) 21 ClAnt: 67-94.

McNelisC., Statius’ Thebaid and the Poetics of Civil War, (Cambridge 2007).

MicozziL., Il catalogo degli eroi. Saggio di commento a Stazio Tebaide 4 1-344, (Pisa 2007).

MontanariF., 'Mythographus Homericus', in J.G.J. Abbenes, S.R. Slings and I. Sluiter (eds), Greek Literary Theory after Aristotle. A Collection of Papers in Honour of D.M. Schenkeveld, (Amsterdam 1995) 135-172.

NelisD.P., 'Vergil’s Library', in J. Farrell and M.C.J. Putnam (eds), A Companion to Vergil’s Aeneid and its Tradition, (Chichester/Malden, MA 2010) 13-25.

NeumannG., Fragmente von Apollodors Kommentar zum homerischen Schiffskatalog im Lexicon des Stephanos von Byzanz, (Diss. Göttingen 1953).

NieseB., 'Apollodors Commentar zum Schiffskataloge als Quelle Strabos' (1877) 32 RhM: 267-307.

ParkesR., Statius Thebaid 4. Edited with an Introduction Translation and Commentary, (Oxford 2012).

PfeifferR., History of Classical Scholarship from the Beginnings to the End of the Hellenistic Age, (Oxford 1968).

PiotM., 'Hercule chez les poètes du 1er siècle ap. j.c.' (1965) 43 rel: 342-358.

PronteraF., 'Sull’esegesi ellenistica della geografia omerica', in G.W. Most, H. Petersmann and A.M. Ritter (eds), Philanthropia kai eusebeia. Festschrift für Albrecht Dihle zum 70. Geburtstag, (Göttingen 1993) 387-397.

ReitzC., 'Does Mass Matter? The Epic Catalogue of Troops as Narrative and Metapoetic Device', in G. Manuwald and A. Voigt (eds), Flavian Epic Interactions, (Berlin/Boston 2013).

RipollF., La morale héroïque dans les épopées latines d’époque flavienne. Tradition et innovation, (Paris 1998).

Rossum-SteenbeekM. van, Greek Readers’ Digests? Studies on a Selection of Sub-Literary Papyri, (Leiden 1997).

SchlunkR., The Homeric Scholia and the Aeneid. A Study of the Influence of Ancient Homeric Literary Criticism on Vergil, (Ann Arbor 1974).

Schmit-NeuerburgT., Vergils Aeneis und die antike Homerexegese. Untersuchungen zum Einfluss ethischer und kritischer Homerrezeption auf imitatio und aemulatio Vergils, (Berlin/New York 1999).

Shackleton BaileyD.R., Statius, (Cambridge, MA 2003) Silvae; Vol. 2 Thebaid books 1-7.

SmithR.S.TrzaskomaS.M., Apollodorus’ Library and Hyginus’ Fabulae. Two Handbooks of Greek Mythology, (Indianapolis 2007).

SmolenaarsJ.J.L., Statius Thebaid vii. A Commentary, (Leiden 1994).

SteinigerJ., P. Papinius Statius Thebais. Kommentar zu Buch 4 1-344, (Stuttgart 2005).

SternJ., Palaephatus ΠΕΡΙ ΑΠΙΣΤΩΝ. On Unbelievable Tales, (Wauconda, IL 1996).

ThomasR.F., 'Turning Back the Clock' (1988) 83 CPh: 54-69.

VesseyD., Statius and the Thebaid, (Cambridge 1973).

ZissosA., Valerius Flaccus’ Argonautica Book 1, (Oxford 2008).

3

For Ovid see Cameron 2004261-303 (contra Graf 2002 119); Cole 2004; Cole 2008; Farrell 2013 223-251. For a positive view that Valerius Flaccus engaged with prose mythographical texts see Zissos 2008 xxiv-xxv (for the scholia to Apollonius Rhodius see ad 1.413-419).

6

Cribiore 2001194-195.

9

Zissos 2008xxxiv-xxxix.

16

Kytzler 1969227.

18

Overviews: Legras 190551-55; Kytzler 1969 219-230; Juhnke 1972 88-92; Vessey 1973 196-204; Georgacopoulou 1996 103-107; Asquith 2001 67-72; Lovatt 2005 181-186; Steiniger 2005 11-53; McNelis 2007 81-86; Micozzi 2007 3-15; Parkes 2012 61-66 (ad 4.32-344); cf. Reitz 2013. Some towns however are taken directly from Homer e.g. Theb. 4.102-104  Il. 2.638-644; Theb. 4.286 = Il. 2.606; see Helm 1892 17-19.

19

See Levin 196311.

20

Vessey 1973198Parkes 2012 ad loc.

21

Vessey 1973200-201; Parkes 2012 ad loc.

22

Juhnke 197291Steiniger 2005 ad loc. and Micozzi 2007 ad loc. all note the Laconian presence but make nothing of it.

24

Cf. Ahl 19862867-2869.

30

Cf. Asquith 20016063.

33

See Smith and Trzaskoma 2007xlix-liv.

39

Overviews of the Theban catalog: Legras 190591-92; Juhnke 1972 117-118; Vessey 1973 205-209; Smolenaars 1994 119-123; Georgacopoulou 1996 112-117; McNelis 2007 101-119.

40

See Helm 189215-17; Smolenaars 1994 122.

44

Cf. Smolenaars 1994ad 7.243-373 (p. 121).

46

As noted by Smolenaars 1994ad 7.354f.

48

See RoscherLexicon 2665.41-57 s.v. ‘Hippasus’.

51

See Stern 1996ad loc.

53

Smolenaars 1994122 suggests that Statius “in adding 16 geographical names to Homer’s list . . . probably [drew] on Pliny’s enumeration of Boeotian and Phocian towns.” This includes Tanagra but this is improbable not least because Pliny’s list contains no mention of any myth in connection with Tanagra; in fact myth hardly figures into Pliny’s account at all.

54

See Lightfoot 2009297n. 93 ad fr. 65 “It is not clear whether Euphorion told all or part of the story.”

Figures

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 20 20 13
Full Text Views 17 17 17
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0