Better than (when) a Magistrate? Caesar’s Suspension from Magisterial Functions in 62 bc

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



According to Suetonius, in 62 bc the praetor Caesar was ‘banished from the administration of the state’ and left the forum. A spontaneous gathering (coetus) offered him help in recovering his position. Unexpectedly he restrained the crowd, and the grateful senate itself restored him to his rank. Even though only Suetonius explicitly mentions Caesar’s suspension, in fact, all our sources allow this. I will argue that Caesar did not lose his magistracy, just like the plebeian tribune Metellus Nepos affected by the same measures. Nor did the suspension include the restriction of any magisterial prerogatives. Instead, it meant the loss of political initiative. However, Caesar was still able to respond to the initiative of others. Suetonius’ account raises a number of questions about the political role of those who found themselves at the moment of transition from a position of a magistratus to that of a privatus, and vice versa.

Better than (when) a Magistrate? Caesar’s Suspension from Magisterial Functions in 62 bc

in Mnemosyne



AgambenG. 2005. State of Exception (Chicago/London)

BaumanR.A. 1966. The Abdication of CollatinusActa Classica 9129-141

BrennanC.T. 2000. The Praetorship in the Roman Republic2 vols. (Oxford)

BroughtonT.R.S. 1951-1986. Magistrates of the Roman Republic3 vols. (Atlanta)

BrutscherC. 1958. Analysen zu Suetons Divus Iulius und der Parallelüberlieferung (Bern/Stuttgart)

ButlerH.E.CaryM. 1927. C. Suetoni Tranquilli Divus Iulius (Oxford)

CarcopinoJ. 19685. Jules César (Paris)

CordierP. 1994. M. Caelius Rufus, le préteur récalcitrantMEFRA 106.2533-577

EdwardsM.J. 1991. Plutarch. The Lives of Pompey Caesar and Cicero (Bristol)

FechnerD. 1986. Untersuchungen zu Cassius Dios Sicht der Römischen Republik (Hildesheim/Zürich/New York)

FehrleR. 1983. Cato Uticensis (Darmstadt)

FrolovR.M. (forthcoming) The ‘Wrong’ Meetings? Some Notes on the Linked Usage of the Terms coetus and contiones in the Political Language of the Roman Republic in: van der BlomH.GrayCh.SteelC. (eds.) Institutions and Ideology in Republican Rome. Speech Audience and Decision (Cambridge)

GarofaloL. 2008. In tema di iustitium in: GarofaloL. (ed.) Piccoli scritti di diritto penale romano (Padova) 61-83

GelzerM. 1968. Caesar Politician and Statesman (Oxford)

GescheH. 1976. Caesar (Darmstadt)

GoldenG.K. 2013. Crisis Management during the Roman Republic. The Role of Political Institutions in Emergencies (Cambridge/New York)

GreenidgeA.H.J. 1901. The Legal Procedure of Cicero’s Time (Oxford)

GruenE. 1995. The Last Generation of the Roman Republic (Berkeley)

Haimson LushkovA. 2015. Magistracy and the Historiography of the Roman Republic. Politics in Prose (Cambridge)

HansenM.H. 1976. Apagoge Endeixis and Ephegesis against Kakourgoi Atimoi and Pheugontes. A Study in the Athenian Administration of Justice in the Fourth Century BC (Odense)

HänischE. 1937. Die Caesar-Biographie Suetons. (Diss. Münster)

HölkeskampK.-J. 2011. The Roman Republic as Theatre of Power. The Consuls as Leading Actors in: BeckH.DupláA.JehneM.Pina PoloF. (eds.) Consuls and res publica. Holding High Office in the Roman Republic (Cambridge/New York) 161-181

JehneM. 1997. Caesar (München)

KemezisA.M. 2014. Greek Narratives of the Roman Empire under the Severans. Cassius Dio Philostratus and Herodian. Greek Culture in the Roman World (Cambridge/New York)

KloftH. 1977-1978. Bemerkungen zum Amtsentzug in der römischen RepublikZeitschrift des Aachener Geschichtsvereins 84/85161-180

KloftH. 1980. Caesar und die Amtsentsetzung der Volkstribunen im Jahre 44. v. Chr.Historia 29315-334

KunkelW.WittmannR. 1995. Staatsordnung und Staatspraxis der römischen Republik. Die Magistratur (München)

LintottA.W. 1968. Violence in Republican Rome (Oxford)

MasonH.J. 1974. Greek Terms for Roman Institutions. A Lexicon and Analysis (Toronto)

MeyerE. 19223. Caesars Monarchie und das Principat des Pompejus. Innere Geschichte Roms von 66 bis 44 v. Chr. (Stuttgart/Berlin)

MommsenTh. 1887-1888. Römisches Staatsrecht3 vols. (Leipzig)

PellingCh. 2011. Plutarch. Caesar. Translated with Introduction and Commentary (Oxford/New York)

RilingerR. 1989. Loca intercessionis und Legalismus in der späten RepublikChiron 19481-498

RyanF.X. 1998. Rank and Participation in the Republican Senate (Stuttgart)

ScantamburloC. 2011. Svetonio Vita di Cesare (Pisa)

SchäferTh. 1989. Imperii Insignia. Sella curulis und Fasces. Zur Repräsentation römischer Magistrate (Mainz)

SeagerR. 20022. Pompey the Great. A Political Biography (Oxford)

Shackleton BaileyD.R. 1977. Cicero. Epistulae ad familiares vol. 1 (Cambridge)

StadterP.A.WaterfieldR. 1999. Roman Lives. A Selection of Eight Lives (Oxford)

SteidleW. 1951. Sueton und die antike Biographie (München)

StevensonT. 2015. Julius Caesar and the Transformation of the Roman Republic (London/New York)

StrasburgerH. 1938. Caesars Eintritt in die Geschichte (München)

SymeR. 1939. The Roman Revolution (Oxford/New York)

TatumW.J. 1999. The Patrician Tribune. Publius Clodius Pulcher (London)

TaylorL.R. 1949. Party Politics in the Age of Caesar (Berkeley/Los Angeles)

ThommenL. 1989. Das Volkstribunat der späten Römischen Republik (Stuttgart)

von Ungern-SternbergJ. 1970. Untersuchungen zum spätrepublikanischen Notstandsrecht. Senatus consultum ultimum und hostis-Erklärung (München)

WalterG. 1947. César (Paris)

WinterlingA. 2009. Politics and Society in Imperial Rome (Malden, MA/Oxford/Chichester)


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 36 36 13
Full Text Views 97 97 63
PDF Downloads 4 4 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0