Let Us Obey. The Rhetoric of Spartan Identity in Tyrtaeus 2W

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



This paper examines the construction of a civic we-identity in the fragments of Tyrtaeus’ Eunomia, focusing on fr. 2 and the strategies by which the poet sought to create a salient we-identity predicated on obedience to the Herakleidai/kings of Sparta and on a past history shared by speaker and audience. I end the paper with a comparison of Herakleid descent in fr. 2 with that in fr. 11 to demonstrate how the rhetorical presentation of identity shifts depending on performance context and poetic genre.

Let Us Obey. The Rhetoric of Spartan Identity in Tyrtaeus 2W

in Mnemosyne



BenwellB.StokeE. 2006. Discourse and Identity (Edinburgh)

BoardmanJ. 1992. ‘For You are the Progeny of Unconquered Herakles’ in: SandersJ.M. (ed.) ΦΙΛΟΛΑΚΩΝ. Lakonian Studies in Honour of Hector Catling (London) 25-29

BoedekkerD. 1995. Simonides on Plataea. Narrative Elegy Mythodic HistoryZPE 107217-229

BowieE.L. 1986. Early Greek Elegy Symposium and Public FestivalJHS 10612-35

CampbellD.A. 19822. Greek Lyric Poetry. A Selection of Early Greek Lyric Elegiac and Iambic Poetry (London)

D’AlessioG.B. 2009. Defining Local Identities in Greek Lyric Poetry in: HunterR.RutherfordI. (eds.) Wandering Poets in Ancient Greek Culture. Travel Locality and Pan-Hellenism (Cambridge) 137-167

DaviesJ.K. 2004. The Concept of the ‘Citizen’ in: CataldiS. (ed.) Poleis e Politeiai. Esperienze politiche tradizioni letterarie progetti costituzionali. Atti del Convegno internazionale di Storia Greca Torino 29 maggio-31 maggio 2002 (Alessandria) 19-30

DonlanW. 1999. The Aristocratic Ideal and Selected Papers (Wauconda, IL)

DoughertyC. 1994. Archaic Greek Foundation Poetry. Questions of Genre and OccasionJHS 11435-46

DoverK.J. 1964. The Poetry of Archilochus in: Archiloque. Sept exposés et discussions (Genève) 181-212

FowlerR.L. 1998. Genealogical Thinking Hesiod’s Catalogue and the Creation of the HellenesPCPhS 141-19

FowlerR.L. 2013. Early Greek Mythographyvol. 2: Commentary (Oxford)

GentiliB. 1988. Poetry and its Public in Ancient Greece trans. ColeA.T. (Baltimore, MD)

GerberD.E. 1999. Greek Elegiac Poetry. From the Seventh to the Fifth Centuries BC (Cambridge, MA)

GrethleinJ. 2010. The Greeks and Their Past. Poetry Oratory and History in the Fifth Century BCE (Cambridge)

GriffithM. 2013. Cretan Harmonies and Universal Morals. Early Music and Migrations of Wisdom in Plato’s Laws in: PeponiA.-E. (ed.) Performance and Culture in Plato’s Laws (Cambridge) 15-66

GruenE. 2013. Did Ancient Identity Depend on Ethnicity? A Preliminary ProbePhoenix 671-22

HallJ.M. 1997. Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity (Cambridge)

HallJ.M. 2007. A History of the Archaic Greek World ca. 1200-479 BCE (Oxford)

HodkinsonS. 1997. The Development of Spartan Society and Institutions in the Archaic Period in: MitchellL.G.RhodesP.J. (eds.) The Development of the Polis in Archaic Greece (London) 83-102

HuttnerU. 1997. Die politische Rolle der Heraklesgestalt im griechischen Herrschertum (Stuttgart)

JaegerW.W. 1932. Tyrtaios über die wahre AreteSitzungsberichte der Preußischen Akad. der Wiss. (Berlin) 23537-568

JaegerW.W. 1966. Five Essays trans. FiskeA.M. (Montreal)

JenkinsR. 20042. Social Identity (London)

KennellN. 2010. Spartans. A New History (Oxford)

KõivM. 2005. The Origins Development and Reliability of the Ancient Traditions about the Formation of the Spartan ConstitutionHistoria 3233-264

LuginbillR.D. 2002. Tyrtaeus 12 West. Come Join the Spartan ArmyCQ 52405-414

LuraghiN. 2008. The Ancient Messenians. Constructions of Ethnicity and Memory (Cambridge)

MalkinI. 1994. Myth and Territory in the Spartan Mediterranean (Cambridge)

MeierM. 1998. Aristokraten und Damoden. Untersuchungen zur inneren Entwicklung Spartas im 7. Jahrhundert v. Chr. und zur politischen Funktion der Dichtung des Tyrtaios (Stuttgart)

MeierM. 2002. Tyrtaios fr. 1B G/P bzw. o14 G/P (=fr. 4 W) und die große Rhetra—kein Zusammenhang?GFA 565-87

MeleA. 2004. Costituzioni arcaiche ed Eunomia in: CataldiS. (ed.) Poleis e Politeiai. Esperienze politiche tradizioni letterarie progetti costituzionali. Atti del Convegno internazionale di Storia Greca Torino 29 maggio-31 maggio 2002 (Alessandria) 55-69

MillenderE.G. 2001. Spartan Literacy RevisitedClAnt 20121-164

MühlhäuslerP.HarréR. 1990. Pronouns and People. The Linguistic Construction of Social and Personal Identity (Oxford)

NafissiM. 1991. La nascita del kosmos. Studi sulla storia e la società di Sparta (Perugia)

PattersonL.E. 2010. Kinship Myth in Ancient Greece (Austin)

PratoC. 1968. Tirteo. Introduzione testo critico testimonianze e commento (Roma)

QuattrocelliL. 2006. Tirteo. Poesia e ἀνδρεία a Sparta arcaica in: VettaM.CatenaccoC. (eds.) I luoghi e la poesia nella Grecia antica. Atti del Convegno Università ‘G. d’Annuzuio’ di Chieti-Pescara 20-22 aprile 2004 (Alessandria) 133-144

QuattrocelliL. 2008. Tirteo e la retorica dell’éliteAION(filol.) 307-22

RabinowitzA. 2009. Drinking from the Same Cup. Sparta and Late Archaic Commensality in: HodkinsonS. (ed.) Sparta. Comparative Approaches (Swansea) 113-192

RicherN. 1998. Les éphores. Études sur l’histoire et sur l’image de Sparte (8e-3e siècles av. J-C) (Paris)

RomneyJ.M. 2014. Cowering Gumnētes. A Note on Tyrtaeus fr. 11.35-38 W.CQ 64828-832

RöslerW. 1990. Mnemosyne in the Symposion in: MurrayO. (ed.) Sympotica. A Symposium on the Symposion (Oxford) 230-237

SheyH.J. 1976. Tyrtaeus and the Art of PropagandaArethusa 95-28

SmythH.W. 1920. Greek Grammar (Cambridge, Mass.)

TarkowT.A. 1983. Tyrtaeus 9D. The Role of Poetry in New SpartaAC 5248-69

ThommenL. 2003. (eds.) Sparta. Verfassungs- und Sozialgeschichte einer griechischen Polis (Stuttgart)

van WeesH. 1999. Tyrtaeus’ Eunomia. Nothing to Do with the Great Rhetra in: HodkinsonS.PowellA. Sparta. New Perspectives (London) 1-41

WackernagelJ. 2004. Vorlesungen über Syntax. Mit besonderer Berücksichtigung von Griechisch Lateinisch und Deutsch. Vol. 2 (Cambridge)

WechslerS. 2010. What ‘You’ and ‘I’ Mean to Each Other. Person Indexicals Self-Ascription and Theory of MindLanguage 86332-365

WestM.L. (ed.) 1989-19922. Iambi et elegi Graeci ante Alexandrum cantatiVol. 1-2 (Oxford)


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 56 56 16
Full Text Views 93 93 75
PDF Downloads 4 4 2
EPUB Downloads 1 1 0