Sôphrosunê and the Poets

Rival Interpretations in Plato’s Charmides

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

This paper considers the intertextual role of two citations in Plato’s Charmides. The first, from Homer, is introduced by Socrates. The second, from Hesiod, is introduced by Critias. I argue that these citations reveal their full meaning only when their original contexts are considered. In particular, the source context in Hesiod makes clear that Critias’ citation is meant as a response to Socrates’ quote. The dialectic between Critias and Socrates thus turns into a poetic rivalry. It is a rivalry with substantive implications about sôphrosunê and that raises larger questions about authority and interpretation.

Sôphrosunê and the Poets

Rival Interpretations in Plato’s Charmides

in Mnemosyne

Sections

References

van der BenN. 1985. The Charmides of Plato. Problems and Interpretations (Amsterdam)

BenardeteS. 1963. Some Misquotations of Homer in PlatoPhronesis 8173-178

BouvierD. 2004. Homère chez Platon. Citations et construction d’un silence in: Darbo-PeschanskiC. (ed.) La citation dans l’Antiquité (Grenoble) 33-49

Boys-StonesG.R.HauboldJ.H. (eds.) 2010. Plato and Hesiod (Oxford)

CanevaroL.G. 2015. Hesiod’s Works and Days. How to Teach Self-Sufficiency (Oxford)

CapraA. 2014. Plato’s Four Muses. The Phaedrus and the Poetics of Philosophy (Washington, DC)

DemosM. 1999. Lyric Quotation in Plato (Lanham, MD)

DorionL.-A. 2004. Platon. Charmide Lysis (Paris)

Emlyn-JonesC. 1986. True and Lying Tales in the OdysseyG&R 331-10

GiulianoF.M. 2005. Platone e la poesia. Teoria della composizione e prassi della ricezione (Sankt Augustin)

GraziosiB. 2010. Hesiod in Classical Athens. Rhapsodes Orators and Platonic Discourse in: Boys-StonesHaubold (eds.) 111-132

HalliwellS. 2000. The Subjection of Muthos to Logos. Plato’s Citations of the PoetsCQ 5094-112

HeitschE.von KutscheraF. 2000. Zu Platons Charmides (Stuttgart)

HunterR.L. 2014. Hesiodic Voices. Studies in the Ancient Reception of Hesiod’s Works and Days (Cambridge)

KahnC.H. 1996. Plato and the Socratic Dialogue. The Philosophical Use of a Literary Form (Cambridge)

KearnsE. 1982. The Return of Odysseus. A Homeric TheoxenyCQ 322-8

KoningH.H. 2010a. Hesiod: The Other Poet. Ancient Reception of a Cultural Icon (Leiden)

KoningH.H. 2010b. Plato’s Hesiod. Not Plato’s Alone in: Boys-StonesHaubold (eds.) 89-110

LabarbeJ. 1949. L’Homère de Platon (Liège)

LévystoneD. 2005. La figure d’Ulysse chez les Socratiques. Socrate polutroposPhronesis 50181-214

MartensE. 1973. Das selbstbezügliche Wissen in Platons “Charmides” (München)

MontiglioS. 2011. From Villain to Hero. Odysseus in Ancient Thought (Ann Arbor, MI)

MostG.W. 2006. Hesiod. Theogony Works and Days Testimonia (Cambridge, MA)

MurrayA.T.DimockG.E. 1995. Homer. Odyssey (Cambridge, MA)

NorthH. 1966. Sophrosyne. Self-Knowledge and Self-Restraint in Greek Literature (Ithaca, NY)

NotomiN. 2000. Critias and the Origin of Plato’s Political Philosophy in: RobinsonT.M.BrissonL. (eds.) Plato. Euthydemus, Lysis, Charmides. Proceedings of the Fifth Symposium Platonicum (Sankt Augustin) 237-250

RademakerA.M. 2005. Sôphrosynê and the Rhetoric of Self-Restraint. Polysemy and Persuasive Use of an Ancient Greek Value Term (Leiden)

RegaliM. 2012. Il poeta e il demiurgo. Teoria e prassi della produzione letteraria nel Timeo e nel Crizia di Platone (Sankt Augustin)

RousseauP. 1996Instruire Persès. Notes sur l’ouverture des Travaux d’Hésiode in: BlaiseF.Judet de La CombeP.RousseauP. (eds.) Le métier du mythe. Lecture d’Hésiode (Lille) 93-167

SchmidW.T. 1998. Plato’s Charmides and the Socratic Ideal of Rationality (Albany, NY)

SegvicH. 2006. Homer in Plato’s ProtagorasCPh 101247-262

SteinerD. 2010. Homer. Odyssey Books xvii-xviii (Cambridge)

TarrantD. 1953. Plato’s Use of Quotations and Other Illustrative MaterialCQ 159-67

TischerU. 2010. Aspekte des Zitats. Überlegungen zur Anwendung eines modernen Konzepts auf antike lateinische Texte in: TischerU.BinternagelA. (eds.) Fremde Rede—Eigene Rede. Zitieren und verwandte Strategien in antiker Prosa (Frankfurt am Main) 93-109

TuckeyT.G. 1951. Plato’s Charmides (Cambridge)

TulliM. 2000. Carmide fra poesia e ricerca in: RobinsonT.M.BrissonL. (eds.) Plato. Euthydemus, Lysis, Charmides. Proceedings of the Fifth Symposium Platonicum (Sankt Augustin) 259-264

WestM.L. 1978. Hesiod. Works and Days (Oxford)

WitteB. 1970. Die Wissenschaft vom Guten und Bösen. Interpretationen zu Platons ‘Charmides’ (Berlin)

WolfsdorfD. 2008. Hesiod Prodicus and the Socratics on Work and PleasureOSAPh 351-18

YamagataN. 2010. Hesiod in Plato. Second Fiddle to Homer? in: Boys-StonesHaubold (eds.) 68-88

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 38 38 12
Full Text Views 82 82 52
PDF Downloads 13 13 5
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0