Sulla and the Invention of Roman Athens

in Mnemosyne
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

In 86 BC Sulla sacked Athens. The siege left deep marks in the cityscape and in the literary sources. This article traces a diachronic development in the ancient reception of the sack of Athens in Greek literature, from the first century BC through the second century AD. In earlier authors the siege is presented primarily in a military context, while in later authors the emphasis shifts onto Sulla’s destruction of cultural capital. His treatment of Athens comes to be understood as irrational and excessive. I argue that this latter depiction is an anchoring device that roots the new perception of the city during the Empire in the Republican past. In the first two centuries AD Athens increasingly came to be seen as the symbol of Greek culture. Plutarch and Pausanias react to this growing Athenocentrism by retrojecting an image of Athens as cultural symbol onto the first century BC.

Sulla and the Invention of Roman Athens

in Mnemosyne

Sections

References

AkujärviJ. 2005. Researcher Traveller Narrator. Studies in Pausanias’ Periegesis (Lund)

ArafatK.W. 1996. Pausanias’ Greece. Ancient Artists and Roman Rulers (Cambridge)

AssenmakerP. 2013. Poids symbolique de la destruction et enjeux idéologique de ses récits. Réflexion sur les sacs d’Athènes et d’Ilion durant la première guerre mithridatique in: DriessenJ. (ed.) Destruction. Archaeological Philological and Historical Perspectives (Louvain-la-Neuve) 391-414

AubergerJ. 2011. Pausanias le Périégète et la Seconde Sophistique in: SchmidtT.S.FleuryP. (eds.) Perceptions of the Second Sophistic and Its Times (Toronto/Buffalo/London) 133-145

BeckM. (ed.) 2013. A Companion to Plutarch (Chichester)

BernhardtR. 1985. Polis und römische Herrschaft in der späten Republik (149-31 v. Chr.) (Berlin/New York)

de BloisL.BonsJ.KesselsT.SchenkeveldD.M. (eds.) 2005. The Statesman in Plutarch’s Works. Vol. 2: The Statesman in Plutarch’s Greek and Roman Lives (Leiden)

BoatwrightM.T. 2000. Hadrian and the Cities of the Roman Empire (Princeton, NJ)

BowieE.L. 1970. Greeks and Their Past in the Second SophisticP&P 463-41

BremerJ.M. 2005. Plutarch and the Liberation of Greece in: de Bloiset al. (eds.) 257-268

BughG.R. 1992. Athenion and Aristion of AthensPhoenix 46108-123

BuraselisK. 2006. Zum hadrianischen Regierungsstil im griechischen Osten oder vom kaiserlichen Agieren und Reagieren in: WiemerH.U. (ed.) Staatlichkeit und politisches Handeln in der römischen Kaiserzeit (Berlin) 41-54

CampJ.M. 2001. The Archaeology of Athens (New Haven)

Candau MorónJ.M. 2000. Plutarch’s Lysander and Sulla. Integrated Characters in Roman Historical PerspectiveAJPh 121.3453-478

CarusoC. 2013. Akademia. Archeologia di una scuola filosofica ad Atene da Platone a Proclo (387 a.C.-485 d.C) (Paestum)

ConnollyJ. 2007. Being Greek/Being Roman. Hellenism and Assimilation in the Roman EmpireMillennium 493-119

ConnollyJ. forthcoming. Beyond ‘Identity’. Roman Imaginings of Greece

CookB. 2001. Plutarch’s Use of λέγεται. Narrative and Source in AlexanderGRBS 42329-360

DesideriP. 2000. Strabone e la cultura asiana in: BiraschiA.M.SalmeriG. (eds.) Strabone e l’Asia Minore (Naples) 25-44

DowdenK. 2013. Poseidonios in: Brill’s New Jacoby Online (Leiden)

DowlingM.B. 2000. The Clemency of SullaHistoria 49.3303-340

DueckD. 2000. Strabo of Amasia. A Greek Man of Letters in Augustan Rome (London)

DuffT. 1999. Plutarch’s Lives. Exploring Virtue and Vice (Oxford/New York)

EckertA. 2016. Lucius Cornelius Sulla in der antiken Erinnerung. Jener Mörder der sich Felix nannte (Berlin/New York)

EngelsJ. 1999. Augusteische Oikumenegeographie und Universalhistorie im Werk Strabons von Amaseia (Stuttgart)

EngelsJ. 2005. Ἄνδρες ἔνδοξοι or ‘Men of High Reputation’ in Strabo’s Geography in: DueckD.LindsayH.PothecaryS. (eds.) Strabo’s Cultural Geography. The Making of a Kolossourgia (Cambridge/New York) 129-143

FerraryJ.L. 1988. Philhellénisme et impérialisme. Aspects idéologiques de la conquête romaine du monde hellénistique (Rome)

FlacelièreR.ChambryE. (eds.) 1971. Plutarque. Vies. Tome VI (Paris)

GowingA. 2009. The Roman Exempla Tradition in Greek Imperial Historiography. The Case of Camillus in: FeldherrA. (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to the Roman Historian (Cambridge) 332-347

GraindorP. 1934. Athènes sous Hadrien (Cairo)

GruenE. 1992. Culture and National Identity in Republican Rome (Ithaca, NY)

HabichtC. 1985. Pausanias’ Guide to Ancient Greece (Berkeley/Los Angeles/London)

HabichtC. 1997². Athens From Alexander to Antony (Cambridge, Mass.)

HoffM.C. 1997. Laceratae Athenae. Sulla’s Siege of Athens in 87/6 B.C. and its Aftermath in: HoffM.C.RotroffS.I. (eds.) 33-51

HoffM.C.RotroffS.I. (eds.) 1997. The Romanization of Athens (Oxford)

HopkinsonN. 2008. Lucian. A Selection (Cambridge)

HuttonW. 2005. Describing Greece. Landscape and Literature in the Periegesis of Pausanias (Cambridge)

JohnsonW.A. 2010. Readers and Reading Culture in the High Roman Empire. A Study of Elite Communities (New York/Oxford)

JonesC.P. 1996. The PanhellenionChiron 2629-56

Kallet-MarxR.M. 1995. Hegemony to Empire. The Development of Roman Imperium in the East from 148 to 62 BCE (Berkeley/Los Angeles)

KeaveneyA.P. 2005. Sulla. The Last Republican (Hoboken, NJ)

KeaveneyA.P.MaddenJ.A. 2011. Memnon in: Brill’s New Jacoby Online (Leiden)

LambertonR. 1997. Plutarch and the Romanization of Athens in: HoffM.C.RotroffS.I. (eds.) 150-160

LindsayH. 1997. Strabo on Apellicon’s LibraryRhM 140.3290-298

MangoE. 2010. Tanta vis admonitionis inest in locis. Zur Veränderung von Erinnerungsräumen im Athen des 1. Jahrhunderts v. Chr. in: KrumeichR.WitschelC. (eds.) Die Akropolis von Athen im Hellenismus und in der römischen Kaiserzeit (Wiesbaden) 117-156

McGingB.C. 1986. The Foreign Policy of Mithridates VI Eupator King of Pontus (Leiden)

MilesM.M. 2008. Art as Plunder. The Ancient Origins of Debate about Cultural Property (New York)

OliverJ.H. 1981. Roman Emperors and AthensHistoria 30.4412-423

OpsomerJ. 2013. Plutarch and the Stoics in: BeckM. (ed.) 88-103

PellingC. 2011. Plutarch and History. Eighteen Studies (Havertown)

PorterJ. 2001. Ideals and Ruins. Pausanias, Longinus, and the Second Sophistic in: AlcockS.CherryJ.ElsnerJ. (eds.) Pausanias. Travel and Memory in Roman Greece (Oxford) 63-92

PretzlerM. 2005. Comparing Strabo with Pausanias. Greece in Context vs. Greece in Depth in: DueckD.LindsayH.PothecaryS. (eds.) Strabo’s Cultural Geography. The Making of a Kolossourgia (Cambridge/New York) 144-160

PretzlerM. 2007. Pausanias: Travel Writing in Ancient Greece (London)

PretzlerM. 2009. Form over Substance? Deconstructing Ecphrasis in Lucian’s Zeuxis and Eikones in: BartleyA. (ed.) A Lucian for Our Times (Newcastle upon Tyne) 157-171

RawsonE. 1985. Intellectual Life in the Late Roman Republic (London)

RomeoI. 2002. The Panhellenion and Ethnic Identity in Hadrianic GreeceCPh 97.421-40

RuggeriC.2006. Silla e la conquista di Atene nell’ 86 a.C. in: AmannP.PedrazziM.TaeuberH. (eds.) Italo-Tusco-Romana. Festschrift für Luciana Aigner-Foresti zum 70. Geburtstag am 30. Juli 2006 (Vienna) 315-324

SantangeloF. 2007. Sulla the Elites and the Empire. A Study of Roman Policies in Italy and the Greek East (Leiden)

SchettinoM.T. 2013. The Use of Historical Sources in: BeckM. (ed.) 417-437

SchmitzT.A. 2011. The Image of Athens in Diodorus Siculus in: SchmitzT.A.WiaterN. (eds.) The Struggle for Identity. Greeks and Their Past in the First Century BCE (Stuttgart) 235-251

SchmitzT.A. 2013. Plutarch and the Second Sophistic in: BeckM. (ed.) 32-42

StadterP.A. 1992. Paradoxical Paradigms. Lysander and Sulla in: StadterP. (ed.) Plutarch and the Historical Tradition (London) 41-55

StadterP.A. 2013. Plutarch and Rome in BeckM. (ed.) 13-31

StadterP.A. 2014. Plutarch and his Roman Readers (Oxford/New York)

SpawforthA.J.S. 2012. Greece and the Augustan Cultural Revolution (Cambridge)

SwainS. 1991. Plutarch Hadrian and DelphiHistoria 40.3318-330

SwainS. 1996. Hellenism and Empire (Oxford)

TheinA. 2014. Reflecting on Sulla’s ClemencyHistoria 63.2166-186

TosiR. 2010². Dictionnaire des sentences latines et grecques (Grenoble)

WhitmarshT. 2001a. Greek Literature and the Roman Empire. The Politics of Imitation (Oxford)

WhitmarshT. 2001b. ‘Greece Is the World’. Exile and Identity in the Second Sophistic in: GoldhillS. (ed.) Being Greek under Rome. Cultural Identity the Second Sophistic and the Development of Empire (Cambridge) 269-305

WhitmarshT. 2005. The Second Sophistic (Oxford)

WoolfG. 1994. Becoming Roman Staying Greek. Culture Identity and the Civilizing Process in the Roman EastPCPhS 40116-143

WoolfG. 2006. Playing Games with Greeks. One Roman on Greekness in: SaïdS.KonstanD. (eds.) Greeks on Greekness. Viewing the Greek Past under the Roman Empire (Cambridge) 162-178

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 30 30 8
Full Text Views 20 20 15
PDF Downloads 8 8 6
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0