False But Significant: The Development of Falsity in Religious Cognition in Light of the Holism of the Mental

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



I elaborate the idea first proposed by Hans Penner that religious language is patently false in a rereading of Donald Davidson’s essay, “What Metaphors Mean.” I explore a Davidsonian paradigm concerning the semantics of superhuman agents. Religious language is meaningful because it is patently false or trivially true. Patency entails a breakdown at the surface that runs counter to the normative meaning of words. Since no special form of cognition or semantics is necessary to account for religious language, following Nancy Frankenberry’s argument about how metaphor and religious language are used, I explore the possibility that false reasoning is a kind of costly signal. Finally I suggest that literacy alters this matrix because it focuses attention on the literal instantiation of sentences in the form of inscriptions, thus exaggerating the role of false reasoning in relation to religion.

False But Significant: The Development of Falsity in Religious Cognition in Light of the Holism of the Mental

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion



BartschKarenWellmanHenry Children talk about the mind 1995 New York Oxford University Press

BoyerPascal Religion explained: the evolutionary origins of religious thought 2001 New York Basic Books

BrandomRobert Making it Explicit: Reasoning Representing and Discursive Commitment 1998 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

BrandomRobert Articulating Reasons: An Introduction to Inferentialism 2001 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

BulbuliaJoseph Religious Costs as Adaptations that Signal Altruistic Intention Evolution and Cognition 2004 10 1 19 38

ChafeWallace Discourse Consciousness and Time: The Flow and Displacement of Conscious Experience in Speaking and Writing 1994 Chicago University of Chicago Press

ChildWilliam On the Dualism of Scheme and Content Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society New Series 1994 94 53 71

ClarkAndy Material Symbols Philosophical Psychology 2006 19 3 291 307

“Darmok” Star Trek: The Next Generation 1991 Paramount Television. Episode 102. September 30 1991

DavidsonDonald True to the Facts The Journal of Philosophy 1969 66 748 764

DavidsonDonald What Metaphors Mean Critical Inquiry Special Issue on Metaphor 1978 5 1 31 47

DavidsonDonald Subjective Intersubjective Objective 2001 Oxford Clarendon Press

DavidsonDonald Truth and Predication 2005 Cambridge Belnap Press

de VilliersJillPyersJennie Complements to cognition: A longitudinal study of the relationship between complex syntax and false-belief understanding Cognitive Development 2002 17 1037 1060

de VilliersJillde VilliersPeter MitchellP.RiggsK. Linguistic determinism and the understanding of false beliefs Children’s reasoning and the mind 2000 Hove, England Psychology Press 191 228

EnglerStevenGardinerMark Quentin StausbergMichael Religion as superhuman agency: on E. Thomas Lawson and Robert N. McCauley (1990) Rethinking Religion: Connecting Cognition and Culture 2009 London Routledge 22 38 Contemporary Theories of Religion: A Critical Companion

EnglerStevenGardinerMark Quentin Ten Implications of Semantic Holism for Theories of Religion Method and Theory in the Study of Religion 2010 22 283 292

FrankenberryNancy Radical interpretation in religion 2002a Cambridge Cambridge University Press

FrankenberryNancyFrankenberryNancy K. Religion as a ‘mobile army of metaphors.’ Radical Interpretation in Religion 2002b Cambridge Cambridge University Press 171 187

FrankenberryNancy K.PennerHans H. Language Truth and Religious Belief: Studies in Twentieth-Century Theory and Method in Religion 1999 Atlanta Scholars Press

GardinerMark QuentinEnglerSteven FrankenberryNancy K. Review essay Radical Interpretation in Religion. Method and Theory in the Study of Religion 2008 20 2 185 190

GodloveTerry F.Jr. Religion Interpretation and Diversity of Belief: The Framework Model from Kant to Durkheim to Davidson 1989 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

GopnikAllisonMeltzoffAndrew Words thoughts and theories 1997 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

HomerBruce OlsonDavidTorranceNancy Literacy and Metalinguistic Development The Cambridge Handbook of Literacy 2009 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 487 500

JensenJeppe Sinding AntesPeterGeertzArmin W.WarneRandi R. Meaning and religion: On semantics in the study of religion New Approaches to the Study of Religion. Volume 1: Regional Critical and Historical Approaches 2004 Berlin Walter de Gruyter 219 252

LambertKarel Philosophical Applications of Free Logic 1991 New York Oxford University Press

LawsonThomasMcCauleyRobert Rethinking Religion: Connecting Cognition and Culture 1990 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

LeslieAlan Pretense and Representation: The Origins of “Theory of Mind.” Psychological Review 1987 94 4 412 426

LevyGabriel Judaic Technologies of the Word: A Cognitive Analysis of Jewish Cultural Formation 2012 Oct. Sheffield Equinox Forthcoming

LevyGabriel Rabbinic Philosophy of Language: Not in Heaven Journal of Jewish Thought and Philosophy 2010 18 2 167 202

MartinLuther H. GeertzArmin Origins of Religion, Cognition and Culture: The Bowerbird Syndrome Origins of Religion Cognition and Culture 2012 Sheffield Equinox

McCauleyRobert Why Religion is Natural and Science is Not 2011 Oxford Oxford University Press

ObeyesekereGananath The Apotheosis of Captain Cook: European Mythmaking in the Pacific 1997 Princeton Princeton University Press

OlsonDavid AstingtonJ.W.HarrisP.L.OlsonD.R. On the origins of beliefs and other intentional states in children Developing theories of mind 1988 Cambridge, England Cambridge University Press 414 426

OlsonDavid What Writing Is Pragmatics and Cognition 2001 9 2 239 258

PennerHans Rediscovering the Buddha: legends of the Buddha and their interpretation 2009 Oxford Oxford University Press

PennerHans Why does semantics matter to the study of religion Method and Theory in the Study of Religion 1995 7 2 221 249

PyersJennie E.SenghasAnn Language Promotes False-Belief Understanding: Evidence From Learners of a New Sign Language Psychological Science 2009 20 7 805 812

PyysiainenIlkka Holy Book—A Treasury of the Incomprehensible: the Invention of Writing and Religious Cognition Numen 1999 46 269 290

SalmonNathan CampbellJosephO’RourkeMichaelShierDavid Mythical Objects Meaning and Truth: Investigations in Philosophical Semantics 2000 New York, NY Seven Bridges 105 123

SchallerSusan A Man Without Words 1991 Berkeley University of California Press

SearleJohn Expression and Meaning: Studies in the Theory of Speech Acts 1979 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

SørensonJesper A Cognitive Theory of Magic 2007 Plymouth AltaMira

“Words” 2010 Radiolab. Narr. Jad Abumrad and Robert Krulwich. Prod. Jad Abumrad and Pat Walters. WNYC/NPR New York Season 8 Episode 2


Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 16 16 15
Full Text Views 3 3 3
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0