The Unanswered Question: Music and Theory of Religion

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Several of the great “founding fathers” of theory of religion discerned a deep connection between religion and music, particularly Western “classical” music. Our relatively recent acceptance that “religion” as universal category was an early modern European invention should prompt suspicion that this connection is historically specific. Yet while scholars in many disciplines have recognized the importance of music in Western imagination, modern scholars of religion have largely ignored it. This article surveys three important discussions of music and religion, in Rudolf Otto, Johan Huizinga, and Max Weber, to provide groundwork for rethinking an important, unanswered question. In conclusion, some preliminary remarks are made about reconstituting this question in contemporary theory, using a brief discussion of Igor Stravinsky’s Rite of Spring to suggest the potential value of treating Western music as a discourse of imagining religion.

The Unanswered Question: Music and Theory of Religion

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion



AcocellaJoanGarafolaLynnGreenJonnie The Rite of Spring considered as a nineteenth-century ballet; Catalogue raisonné Ballet Review 1992 20 68 100

AdornoTheodor W. LeppertR. GoldbloomMaurice On the fetish-character in music and the regression of listening Essays on Music 2002 Berkeley and Los Angeles University of California Press 288 317

AyotteJuliePeretzIsabelleHydeKrista Congenital amusia: A group study of adults afflicted with a music-specific disorder Brain 2002 125 238 251

BenjaminWalter ZohnHarry The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction Illuminations 1968 New York Schocken 217 252

BenjaminWalter OsborneJohn The Origin of German Tragic Drama 1977 London NLB

BrownFrank Burch Music: Religious music in the west Encyclopedia of Religion 2005 August 14 2012

De CerteauMichel ConleyTom The Writing of History 1988 New York Columbia University Press

EllingsonTer EliadeMircea Music: Music and religion Encyclopedia of Religion 1987 16 New York Macmillan 153 172

EllingsonTer Music: Music and religion Encyclopedia of Religion 2005 (March 16 2012).

HanslickEduard PayzantGeoffrey On the Musically Beautiful: A Contribution Towards the Revision of the Aesthetics of Music 1986 8th (1891) edition Indianapolis, IN Hackett

HuizingaJohan Homo Ludens: The Play-Element in Culture 1955 New York Beacon Press

HuizingaJohan HolmesJ. S.van MarleH. The task of cultural history Men and Ideas 1959 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press 17 76

HydeKrista L.ZatorreRobert J.GriffithsTimothy D.LerchJason P.PeretzIsabelle Morphometry of the amusic brain: a two site study Brain 2006 129 2562 2570

JacobiBonnie Schaffhauser Music in higher education for females in nineteenth century America Journal of Historical Research in Music Education 2001 23 1 46 59

JamesonFredric Late Marxism: Adorno or The Persistence of the Dialectic 1990 London & New York Verso

LehrichChristopher I. Overture and finale: Lévi Strauss, music, and religion Method and Theory in the Study of Religion 2011 23 305 325

van der LeeuwGerardus GreenD. E. Sacred and Profane Beauty: The Holy in Art 2006 new edition Oxford and New York Oxford University Press

Lévi-StraussClaude WeightmanJohnWeightmanDoreen The Raw and the Cooked 1969 New York Harper

McDonaldIan Musical alexia with recovery: a personal account Brain 2006 129 2554 2561

MarcuseHerbert ShapiroJeremy J.WeberShierry M. Five Lectures 1970 Boston Beacon Press

MorrisonSimon Defining Russia musically: Historical and hermeneutical essays Journal of the American Musicological Society 2000 53 2 412 425 by Richard Taruskin (review).

NattiezJean-Jacques AbbateCarolyn Music and Discourse: Toward a Semiology of Music 1990 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press

OttoRudolf ArthurJ.ThomsonMargaret MorrisonW. D. Naturalism and Religion 1907 New York G. P. Putnam’s Sons

OttoRudolf HarveyJohn W. The Idea of the Holy 1950 2nd edition London Oxford University Press

PeretzIsabelleBellevilleSylvieFontaineSophie Dissociations entre musique et langage après atteinte cérébrale: Un nouveau cas d’amusie sans aphasie Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology/Revue canadienne de psychologie expérimentale 1997 51 4 354 368

PeretzIsabelleGagnonLise Dissociation between recognition and emotional judgements for melodies Neurocase: The Neural Basis of Cognition 1999 5 1 21 30

PiccirilliMassimoSciarmaTizianaLuzziSimona Modularity of music: evidence from a case of pure amusia Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery and Psychiatry 2000 69 541 545

RingerAlexander EliadeMircea Music: Religious music in the west Encyclopedia of Religion 1987 16 New York Macmillan 209 216

RothGuenther History and sociology in the work of Max Weber The British Journal of Sociology 1976 27 3 306 318

SacksOliver Musicophilia: Tales of Music and the Brain 2008 Revised and expanded edition New York Vintage/Knopf

SchluchterWolfgang The approach of Max Weber’s sociology of religion as exemplified in his study of ancient Judaism Archives de sciences sociales des religions 2004 49 127 33 56 Max Weber La Religion et la Construction du Social

SmithJonathan Z. Imagining Religion: From Babylon to Jonestown 1982 Chicago University of Chicago Press

SolomonNoémie Conducting movement: Xavier Le Roy and the amplification of Le sacre du printemps Dance Research Journal 2011 43 1 65 80

TaruskinRichard A myth of the twentieth century: The Rite of Spring, the tradition of the new, and ‘the music itself’ Modernism/Modernity 1995 2 1 1 26

TaruskinRichard Stravinsky and the Russian Traditions: A Biography of the Works Through 1996 Berkeley and Los Angeles University of California Press Mavra. 2 volumes.

TurleyAlan C. Max Weber and the sociology of music Sociological Forum 2001 16 4 633 653

WeberMax MartindaleDonRiedelJohannesNeuwirthGertrude The Rational and Social Foundations of Music 1958 Carbondale Southern Illinois University Press

WeberMax ParsonsTalcott The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism 1998 2nd edition Los Angeles Roxbury Publishing Company New introduction by Randall Collins


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 30 30 11
Full Text Views 83 83 65
PDF Downloads 12 12 7
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0