Extraordinary Experiences and Religious Beliefs

Deconstructing Some Contemporary Philosophical Axioms

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Many contemporary scholars believe that all experience is dependent upon language and culture, meaning that it is unintelligible to speak of some cross-cultural event which can be called “mystical” or “religious”; and that the notion of the origins of religious beliefs lying in such experiences is thus methodologically and theoretically unsound. Challenges to these perspectives leave one open to charges of naivety, or of having crossed a boundary from the (ostensibly) objective Study of Religions into a kind of universalist crypto-theology. In defense of the study of such experiences, this article attempts to demonstrate the weaknesses in these arguments by showing that they are based upon a number of mutually-reliant but unproven culturally-situated philosophical axioms. With particular reference to near-death and out-of-body experiences, a reflexive, theoretically eclectic approach to this area of study is suggested.

Extraordinary Experiences and Religious Beliefs

Deconstructing Some Contemporary Philosophical Axioms

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion



AlmondP. FormanR.K.C. Mysticism and its contents The Problem of Pure Consciousness 1990 Oxford University Press 211 19

BaggerM.C. Religious Experience Justification and History 1999 Cambridge and New York Cambridge University Press

BarnardG.W. Explaining the unexplainable: Wayne Proudfoot’s “Religious Experience.” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 1992 60 2 231 256

BarnardG.W. Rejoinder Journal of the American Academy of Religion 1993 61 4 803 812

BelantiJ.PereraM.JagadheesanK. Phenomenology of near-death experiences: a cross-cultural perspective Transcultural Psychiatry 2008 45 1 121 33

BlankeO.LandisT.SpinelliL.SeeckM. Out‐of‐body experience and autoscopy of neurological origin Brain 2003 127 2 243 58

BockingB. Mysticism: no experience necessary? diskus 2006 accessed June 6 2013 7 http://www.basr.ac.uk/diskus/diskus7/bocking.htm

BrainardF.S. Defining “mystical experience.” jaar 1996 LXIV 2 359 93

BrébeufJ. HunterJ.M.ThwaitiesR.B. Relation of What Occurred in the Country of the Hurons in the Year 1636 Travels and Explorations of the Jesuit Missionaries in New France 1636 vol. X Cleveland Burrows Brothers (1897)

ClancyS. Abducted: How People Come to Believe They Were Kidnapped by Aliens 2005 Cambridge Mass., and London Harvard University Press

CupittD. Mysticism After Modernity 1998 Oxford Blackwell

DavisC.F. The Evidential Force of Religious Experience 1989 Princeton and Oxford Oxford University Press

DayM. Magic feathers, Wittgensteinian boxes and the politics of deeming Religion 2010 40 293 295

DownyG. Life without language Neuroanthropology 2010 accessed June 6 2013 blog July 21 2010 entry. http://neuroanthropology.net/2010/07/21/life-without-language/

EvansD. Can philosophers limit what mystics can do? Religious Studies 1988 25 53 60

FogesP. An atheist meets the Masters of the Universe Lapham’s Quarterly 2010 March 8 accessed June 6 2013 http://www.laphamsquarterly.org/roundtable/roundtable/an-atheist-meets-the-masters-of-the-universe.php

FormanR.K.C. FormanR.K.C. Mysticism, constructivism, and forgetting The Problem of Pure Consciousness 1990 Oxford University Press 3 49

GabbardG.O.TwemlowS.W. With the Eyes of the Mind: An Empirical Analysis of Out-of-Body States 1984 New York Praeger Publishers Inc.

GreysonBruce The near-death experience scale: Construction, reliability, and validity Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 1983 171 6 369 75

HariotT. A Briefe and True Report of the New Found Land of Virginia 1588 London n.p.

HuffordD. The Terror that Comes in the Night: An Experience-Centered Study of Supernatural Assault Traditions 1982 Philadelphia University of Pennsylvania Press

HuffordD. The scholarly voice and the personal voice: reflexivity in belief studies Western Folklore 1995 Jan Vol. 54 No. 1 57 76

HuffordD. Sleep paralysis as spiritual experience Transcultural Psychiatry 2005 42 1 11 45

HultkrantzA. The spirits of the dead in Saulteaux life and thought Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland 1940 70 1 29 51

HultkrantzA. The North American Indian Orpheus Tradition 1957 Stockholm Statens Etnografiska

JansenK. Ketamine: Dreams and Realities 2001 Santa Cruz Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies

JosipovicZ. Duality and nonduality in meditation research Consciousness and Cognition 2010 19 4 1119 1121

JonesR.M. Mysticism in present day religion Harvard Theological Review 1915 8 2 155 65

KalweitH. Dreamtime and Inner Space: The World of the Shaman Boston Shambhala (1984; trans. 1988)

KatzS.Τ. KatzS.T. Language, epistemology, and mysticism Mysticism and Philosophical Analysis 1978 OUP 22 74

KellehearA. Experiences Near Death: Beyond Medicine and Religion 1996 OUP

KingS. Two epistemological models for the interpretation of mysticism Journal of the American Academy of Religion 1988 56 2 257 280

Le ClercqC. GanongW.F. New Relation of Gasperia Toronto The Champlain Society (1691; rpt. 1910)

McClenonJ. Wondrous Events: Foundations of Religious Belief 1994 Philadelphia Pennsylvania University Press

McClenonJ. Wondrous Healing: Shamanism Human Evolution and the Origin of Religion 2002 DeKalb University of Northern Illinois

MetzingerT. Out-of-body experiences as the origin of the concept of a “soul.” Mind & Matter 2005 3 1 57 84

OsisK. RollW.G. Insider’s view of the obe: a questionnaire study Research in Parapsychology 1979 Methuen, NJ Scarecrow Press 50 51

PankseppJ. Affective Neuroscience: The Foundations of Human and Animal Emotions 2004 Oxford Oxford University Press

ParniaS. What Happens When We Die? 2006 Carlsbad, CA Hay House

ProudfootW. Religious Experience 1985 Berkeley University of California Press

ProudfootW. Response Journal of the American Academy of Religion 1993 61 4 793 803

RennieBryan Manufacturing McCutcheon: the failure of understanding in the academic study of religion Culture and Religion 2000 1 1 105 112

RockA.J.BaynesP.B.CaseyP.J. Experimental study of ostensibly shamanic journeying imagery in naïve participants Anthropology of Consciousness 2005/2006 15 2 72 92 (pt. 1); 17(1): 65-83 (pt. 2)

SchmidtL.E. The making of modern “mysticism.” jaar 2003 71 2 273 302

SharfR. TaylorM.C. Experience Critical Terms in Religious Studies 1998 Chicago University of Chicago Press 94 115 (Reprinted as: The rhetoric of experience and the study of religion. Journal of Consciousness Studies 7[11-12] [2000]: 267-87)

ShielsD. A cross-cultural study of beliefs in out-of-the-body experiences Journal of the Society for Psycchical Research 1978 49 775 697 741

ShortL. Mysticism, mediation, and the non-lingusitic jaar 1995 LXIII 4 659 675

ShushanG. Conceptions of the Afterlife in Early Civilizations: Universalism Constructivism and Near-Death Experience 2009 London & New York Continuum (Advances in Religious Studies)

ShushanG. Rehabilitating the neglected “similar”: Confronting the issue of cross-cultural similarities in the Study of Religions Paranthropology: Journal of Anthropological Approaches to the Paranormal 2013 April 4 2 48 53

ShushanG. Afterlife Beliefs Near-Death Experience and Shamanism in Indigenous Religions: A Theoretically Eclectic Ethnohistorical Approach (forthcoming)

StevensonI.GreysonB. BaileyL.W.YatesJ. ndes: relevance to the question of survival after death The Near-Death Experience: A Reader 1996 London Routledge 199 206

StoeberM. Constructivist epistemologies of mysticism: a critique and a revision Religious Studies 1991 28 107 16

StroebeW.S.StroebeM.S. Bereavement and Health: The Psychological and Physical Consequences of Partner Loss 1987 Cambridge and New York Cambridge University Press

TavesA. Religious Experience Reconsidered 2009 Princeton and Oxford Princeton University Press

WadeJ. In a sacred manner we died: Native American near-death experiences Journal of Near-Death Studies 2003 22 2 83 115

WireduK. Cultural Universals and Particulars: An African Perspective 1996 Bloomington Indiana University Press

Wren-LewisJ. The dazzling dark: a near-death experience opens the door to a permanent transformation What is Enlightenment? accessed June 6 2013 (n.d.) http://www.nonduality.com/dazdark.htm

YaoX.BadhamP. Religious Experience in Contemporary China 2007 Cardiff University of Wales

ZaleskiC. Otherworld Journeys: Accounts of Near-Death Experiences in Medieval and Modern Times 1987 OUP


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 27 27 13
Full Text Views 83 83 70
PDF Downloads 5 5 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0