On a superficial level, the differentiation between “Jews” and “non-Jews” functions as one of the best-known lines of demarcation in the representation of Jewish culture and religion. It draws on a hermeneutical boundary between “insiders” and “outsiders” with regard to the understanding of specific “Jewish experiences.” In this article, I add that this division, often supported by theologians and scholars in the scientific study of religion\s, influences the organizational structure of academic institutions as well, bestowing more “authenticity” on the research of Jewish scholars than on that of non-Jewish scholars. I furthermore assert that, from a methodological point of view, this form of insider–outsider distinction can be seen as part of the discourse on first-order essentialism in Jewish Studies, which includes significant regional differences. Whereas many European scholars are oriented toward mono-cultural images of Jewish religions, scholars from the United States are often eager to explore the plurality of the increasingly diverse religious field. In Israel the insider–outsider distinction occurs on quite a different level, since more and more Israeli scholars criticize ethnicized patterns in Jewish studies.
BellerStevenHödlKlausKnowing your elephant: Why Jewish Studies is not the same as Judaistik, and why that is a good thingJüdische Studien: Reflexionen zu Theorie und Praxis eines wissenschaftlichen Feldes2003InnsbruckStudienverlag1323
Ben-RafaelEliezerBen-RafaelEliezerGergelyThomasGornyYosefContemporary dilemmas of identity: Israel and the diasporaJewry between Tradition and Secularism: Europe and Israel Compared2006LeidenBrill279288
GoodridgeR. MartinHamiltonMalcolm“The ages of faith”: Romance or reality?The Sociology of Religion: Critical Concepts in Sociology vol. iv: Religion in the Contemporary World 2007London and New YorkRoutledge264277
GotzmannAndreasGotzmannAndreasWieseChristianHistoriography as cultural identity: Toward a Jewish history beyond national historyModern Judaism and Historical Consciousness: Identities Encounters Perspectives2007LeidenBrill494528
JaffeeMartin S.McCutcheonRussell T.Fessing up in theory: On professing and confessing in the religious studies classroomThe Insider/Outsider Problem in the Study of Religion: A Reader1999London and New YorkCassell274286
van RahdenTillHoffmannChristhardTreason, fate, or blessing: Narratives of assimilation in the historiography of German-speaking Jewry since the 1950sPreserving the Legacy of German Jewry: A History of the Leo Baeck Institute 1955-20052005TübingenMohr Siebeck349373