Invisible Fences

The Construction of “Insiders” and “Outsiders” in Jewish Historiography

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


On a superficial level, the differentiation between “Jews” and “non-Jews” functions as one of the best-known lines of demarcation in the representation of Jewish culture and religion. It draws on a hermeneutical boundary between “insiders” and “outsiders” with regard to the understanding of specific “Jewish experiences.” In this article, I add that this division, often supported by theologians and scholars in the scientific study of religion\s, influences the organizational structure of academic institutions as well, bestowing more “authenticity” on the research of Jewish scholars than on that of non-Jewish scholars. I furthermore assert that, from a methodological point of view, this form of insider–outsider distinction can be seen as part of the discourse on first-order essentialism in Jewish Studies, which includes significant regional differences. Whereas many European scholars are oriented toward mono-cultural images of Jewish religions, scholars from the United States are often eager to explore the plurality of the increasingly diverse religious field. In Israel the insider–outsider distinction occurs on quite a different level, since more and more Israeli scholars criticize ethnicized patterns in Jewish studies.

Invisible Fences

The Construction of “Insiders” and “Outsiders” in Jewish Historiography

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion



ArielYaakov Evangelizing the Chosen People: Missions to the Jews in America 1880-2000 2000 Chapel Hill and London The University of North Carolina Press

ArielYaakov Jews and new religious movements: An introductory essay Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions 2011 15 1 5 21

BaskinJudith R. Jewish Women in Historical Perspective 1991 Detroit Wayne State University Press

BaumanZygmunt CheyetteBryanMarcusLaura Allosemitism: Premodern, modern, postmodern Modernity Culture and “the Jew” 1998 Stanford Stanford University Press 143 156

BellerSteven HödlKlaus Knowing your elephant: Why Jewish Studies is not the same as Judaistik, and why that is a good thing Jüdische Studien: Reflexionen zu Theorie und Praxis eines wissenschaftlichen Feldes 2003 Innsbruck Studienverlag 13 23

Ben-RafaelEliezer Ben-RafaelEliezerGergelyThomasGornyYosef Contemporary dilemmas of identity: Israel and the diaspora Jewry between Tradition and Secularism: Europe and Israel Compared 2006 Leiden Brill 279 288

Ben-RafaelEliezerGlöcknerOlafSternbergYitzhak Jews and Jewish Education in Germany Today 2011 Leiden Brill

WaldeneggBergerChristophGeorg Antisemitismus: “Eine gefährliche Vokabel?”: Diagnose eines Wortes 2003 Vienna Böhlau

BialeDavid Cultures of the Jews: A New History 2002 New York Schocken

BialeDavidGalchinskyMichaelHeschelSusannah Insider/Outsider: Jews and Multiculturalism 1998 Berkeley University of California Press

BoyarinDaniel Border Lines: The Partition of Judaeo-Christianity 2004 Philadelphia University of Pennsylvania Press

BrennerMichael ChristophersenAlfVoigtFriedemann Theodor Herzl Religionsstifter der Moderne: Von Karl Marx bis Johannes Paul ii 2009 Munich Beck 150 156

Brink-DananMarcy Anthropological perspectives on Judaism: A comparative review Religion Compass 2008 2 4 574 588

CohenRichard I.FrankelJonathanHoffmanStefani Insiders and Outsiders: Dilemmas of East European Jewry 2010 Oxford Littman Library of Jewish Civilization

CohenShaye J.D. The Beginnings of Jewishness: Boundaries Varieties Uncertainties 2000 Berkley University of California Press

DeinSimon IqtidarHumeiraLehmannDavid Lubavitch: A contemporary messianic movement Fundamentalism and Charismatic Movements: Critical Concepts in Religious Studies 2012 London Routledge 30 46

DeshenShlomoLiebmanCharles S.ShokeidMoshe Israeli Judaism: The Sociology of Religion in Israel 1995 New Brunswick, NJ Transaction

DeutscherIsaac The non-Jewish Jew and Other Essays 1982 Boston Alyson

Doniger O’FlahertyWendy McCutcheonRussell T. The uses and misuses of other people’s myths The Insider/Outsider Problem in the Study of Religion: A Reader 1999 London and New York Cassell 331 349

GladigowBurkhard KippenbergHans G.LuchesiBrigitte Europäische Religionsgeschichte Lokale Religionsgeschichte 1995 Marburg Diagonal-Verlag 21 42

GoodridgeR. Martin HamiltonMalcolm “The ages of faith”: Romance or reality? The Sociology of Religion: Critical Concepts in Sociology vol. iv: Religion in the Contemporary World [1975] 2007 London and New York Routledge 264 277

GotzmannAndreas GotzmannAndreasWieseChristian Historiography as cultural identity: Toward a Jewish history beyond national history Modern Judaism and Historical Consciousness: Identities Encounters Perspectives 2007 Leiden Brill 494 528

GraetzHeinrich Geschichte der Juden von den ältesten Zeiten bis auf die Gegenwart 1996 Berlin Arani-Verlag (11 volumes reprint of the final edition)

GruberRuth Ellen Virtually Jewish: Reinventing Jewish Culture in Europe 2002 Berkeley University of California Press

HamacherElisabeth Gershom Scholem und die Allgemeine Religionsgeschichte 1999 Berlin De Gruyter

HeschelSusannah BialeDavidGalchinskyMichaelHeschelSusannah Jewish studies as counterhistory Insider/Outsider: American Jews and Multiculturalism 1998 Berkeley University of California Press 101 115

HödlKlaus HödlKlaus Der “virtuelle Jude”—ein essentialistisches Konzept? Der “virtuelle Jude”: Konstruktionen des Jüdischen 2005 Innsbruck StudienVerlag 53 70

HorowitzSara R. BialeDavidGalchinskyMichaelHeschelSusannah The paradox of Jewish studies in the new academy Insider/Outsider: Jews and Multiculturalism 1998 Berkley University of California Press 116 130

HughesAaron W. The Study of Judaism: Authenticity Identity Scholarship 2013 Albany State University of New York Press

Israel-CohenYael Between Feminism and Orthodox Judaism: Resistance Identity and Religious Change in Israel 2012 Leiden Brill

JaffeeMartin S. McCutcheonRussell T. Fessing up in theory: On professing and confessing in the religious studies classroom The Insider/Outsider Problem in the Study of Religion: A Reader 1999 London and New York Cassell 274 286

JensenJeppe Sinding Revisiting the insider–outsider debate: Dismantling a pseudoproblem in the study of religion Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 2011 23 29 47

KaplanDana Evan Contemporary American Judaism: Transformation and Renewal 2009 New York Columbia University Press

KatzJacob Exclusiveness and Tolerance: Studies in Jewish–Gentile Relations in Medieval and Modern Times 1980 Westport, CN. Greenwood

KatzJacob Tradition und Krise: Der Weg der jüdischen Gesellschaft in die Moderne 2002 Munich Beck

KleinDaniel VuijstFreke The Half-Jewish Book: A Celebration 2000 New York Villard

KnottKim HinnellsJohn R. Insider/outsider perspectives The Routledge Companion to the Study of Religion 2005 London Routledge 243 258

LincolnBruce McCutcheonRussell T. Theses on method The Insider/Outsider Problem in the Study of Religion: A Reader 1999 London and New York Cassell 395 398

LindholmCharles Culture and Authenticity 2008 Malden, MA Blackwell Publishing

LorenzDagmar C. G.WeinbergerGabriele Insiders and Outsiders: Jewish and Gentile Culture in Germany and Austria 1994 Detroit Wayne State University Press

LossJoseph Buddha-Dhamma in Israel: Explicit non-religious and implicit non-secular localization of religion Nova Religio 2010 13 4 84 105

MagidShaul American Post-Judaism: Identity and Renewal in a Postethnic Society 2013 Bloomington, IN Indiana University Press

McCutcheonRussell T. The Insider/Outsider Problem in the Study of Religion: A Reader 1999 London and New York Cassell

McCutcheonRussell T. The Discipline of Religion: Structure Meaning Rhetoric 2003 London and New York Routledge

MyersDavid N. Was there a “Jerusalem School?”: An inquiry into the first generation of historical researchers at the Hebrew University Studies in Contemporary Jewry 1994 10 66 92

MyersDavid N. Is there still a “Jerusalem School?” Reflections on the state of Jewish historical scholarship in Israel Jewish History 2009 23 389 406

NeusnerJacob Judaism: The Basics 2006 London and New York Routledge

NeusnerJacobAvery-PeckAlan J.Scott GreenWilliam The Encyclopedia of Judaism 2005 vol. I-IV 2nd ed. Leiden Brill

PotzRichardSchinkeleBrigitte Religionsrecht im Überblick 2007 2nd ed. Vienna Facultas WUV

RavitzkyAviezer GotzmannAndreasWieseChristian Dimensions and varieties of Orthodox Judaism Modern Judaism and Historical Consciousness: Identities Encounters Perspectives 2007 Leiden Brill 391 416

RedfieldRobert The Primitive World and Its Transformations 1967 Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press (ninth printing)

RohrbacherAngelika HödlHans GeraldPokornyLukas Austrian Reform Jews: In the pitfalls of “authenticity” Religion in Austria 2012 vol. 1 Vienna Praesens Verlag 1 29

RohrbacherAngelika Die Dramatisierung des Kontaktes: Abgrenzungsrhetorik im Religionsnarrativ “Judentum” 2013 University of Vienna (doctoral dissertation)

RoskiesDavid G. EstraikhGennadyKrutikovMikhail The shtetl as imagined community The Shtetl: Image and Reality: Papers of the Second Mendel Friedman International Conference on Yiddish 2000 Oxford Legenda 4 22

RosmanMoshe How Jewish is Jewish History? 2007 Oxford The Littman Library of Jewish Civilization

RothCecil The Standard Jewish Encyclopedia 1959 London Allen

RoyOlivier Heilige Einfalt. Über die politischen Gefahren entwurzelter Religionen 2010 Munich Siedler Verlag

RushkoffDavid Nothing Sacred: The Truth About Judaism 2003 New York Crown Publishers

SandShlomo Die Erfindung des jüdischen Volkes: Israels Gründungsmythos auf dem Prüfstand 2010 Berlin Propyläen

SatlowMichael L. Defining Judaism: Accounting for “religions” in the study of religions Journal of the American Academy of Religion 2006 74 4 837 860

SchlieterJens Methodologie als Shibboleth? Methodische und theoretische Differenzen zwischen theologischer und religionswissenschaftlicher Religionsforschung Berliner theologische Zeitschrift 2012 29 1 73 96

ShindlerColin A History of Modern Israel 2013 2nd ed. Cambridge Cambridge University Press

SlezkineYuri The Jewish Century 2004 Princeton Princeton University Press

SmithJonathan Z. Relating Religion: Essays in the Study of Religion 2004 Chicago The University of Chicago Press

SolomonNorman WebberJonathan Judaism in the new Europe: Discovery or invention? Jewish Identities in the New Europe 1994 London Littmann Library of Jewish Civilization 86 98

StrengerCarlo Israel: Einführung in ein schwieriges Land 2011 Berlin Jüdischer Verlag im Suhrkamp-Verlag

van RahdenTill HoffmannChristhard Treason, fate, or blessing: Narratives of assimilation in the historiography of German-speaking Jewry since the 1950s Preserving the Legacy of German Jewry: A History of the Leo Baeck Institute 1955-2005 2005 Tübingen Mohr Siebeck 349 373

van StratenJits The Origin of the Ashkenazi Jewry: The Controversy Revealed 2011 Berlin De Gruyter

WexlerPaul Ashkenazic Jews: A Slavo-Turkic People in Search of a Jewish identity 1993 Columbus, OH Slavica

WexlerPaul The Non-Jewish Origins of the Sephardic Jews 1996 New York State University of New York Press

WigoderGeoffreySkolnikFredHimelsteinShmuel The New Encyclopedia of Judaism 1989-2002 New York New York University Press

ZborowskiMarkHerzogElizabeth Das Schtetl: Die untergegangene Welt der osteuropäischen Juden 1991 Munich Beck


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 23 23 7
Full Text Views 75 75 64
PDF Downloads 4 4 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0