Religion as Social Reality

A Take on the Emic–Etic Debate in Light of John Searle’s Philosophy of Society

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

In this article I argue that the shift from a private to a public–social understanding of religion raises new ontological and epistemological questions for the scientific study of religion\s. These questions are deeply related to three central features of the emic–etic debate, namely the problems of intentionality, objectivity, and comparison. Focusing on these interrelated issues, I discuss the potential of John Searle’s philosophy of society for the scientific study of religion\s. Considering the role of intentionality at the social level, I present Searle’s concept of “social ontology” and discuss its epistemological implications. To clarify Searle’s position regarding the objectivity of the social sciences, I propose a heuristic model contrasting different stances within the scientific study of religion\s. Finally, I explore some problematic aspects of Searle’s views for a comparative study of religion\s, and sketch a solution within his framework. I shall argue that a distinction between the epistemological and ontological dimensions of religious affairs would help clarify the issues at stake in the past and future of the emic–etic debate.

Method & Theory in the Study of Religion

Journal of the North American Association for the Study of Religion

Sections

References

ArnalWilliam E.BraunWilliMcCutcheonRussell T. Failure and Nerve in the Academic Study of Religion: Essays in Honor of Donald Wiebe 2012 Sheffield Equinox

BergunderMichael What is religion? The unexplained subject matter of religious studies Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 2014 26 246 286

BoghossianPaul A. Fear of Knowledge: Against Relativism and Constructivism 2007 Oxford Oxford University Press

BourdieuPierre Rites of institution Language and Symbolic Power 1991 Cambridge Polity Press 117 126

DurkheimEmile The Rules of Sociological Method [1894] 1982 New York The Free Press

DurkheimEmile The Elementary Forms of Religious Life [1912] 1995 New York The Free Press

DurkheimEmile Sucide [1897] 2002 London Routledge

GeertzArmin W. Brain, body and culture: A biocultural theory of religion Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 2010 22 4 304 321

GladigowBurkhard GladigowBurkhardKippenbergHans G. Religion im Rahmen der theoretischen Biologie Neue Ansätze in der Religionswissenschaft 1983 München Kösel Verlag 97 112

GladigowBurkhard Mögliche Gegenstände und notwendige Quellen einer Religionsgeschichte Religionswissenschaft als Kulturwissenschaft 2005 Stuttgart Kohlhammer 23 39

GrossNeil Comment on Searle Anthropological Theory 2006 6 1 45 56

HarrisMarvin The Rise of Anthropological Theory: A History of Theories of Culture 1968 updated ed. Walnut Creek, CA Altamira Press

HarrisMarvin History and significance of the emic/etic distinction Annual Review of Anthropology 1976 5 329 350

JensenJeppe S. The Study of Religion in a New Key: Theoretical and Philosophical Soundings in the Comparative and General Study of Religion 2003 Aarhus Aarhus University Press

JensenJeppe S. StausbergMichael Religion as the unintended product of brain functions in the “standard cognitive science of religion model”: On Pascal Boyer, Religion Explained (2001) and Ilkka Pyysiäinen, How Religion Works (2003) Contemporary Theories of Religion: A Critical Companion 2009 New York Routledge 129 149

JensenJeppe S. Revisiting the insider–outsider debate: Dismantling a pseudo-problem in the study of religion Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 2011 23 1 29 47

JensenJeppe S. What is Religion? 2014 Durham, UK Acumen

JensenJeppe S. How institutions work in shared intentionality and “we-mode” social cognition Topoi. An International Review of Philosophy 2015 Online First Articles, see http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11245-015-9306-7

KippenbergHans GerhardStuckradKocku von Einführung in die Religionswissenschaft: Gegenstände und Begriffe 2003 Munich C.H. Beck

KlimkeitHans-Joachim Vergleichen und Verstehen in der Religionswissenschaft 1997 Wiesbaden Harrassowitz Verlag

LukesSteven TsohatzidisSavas L. Searle versus Durkheim Intentional Acts and Institutional Facts: Essays on John Searle’s Social Ontology 2007 Dordrecht Springer 191 202

MartinCraig Delimiting religion Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 2009 21 157 176

MaussMarcel The Gift [1925] 1966 London Cohen & West

McCutcheonRussell T. The Insider/Outsider Problem in the Study of Religion: A Reader 1999 London Cassell

NeubertFrank LüddeckensDorotheaWalthertRafael Von der verfolgten “Sekte” zur etablierten Religionsgemeinschaft. Die Wandlungen der Hare Krishna Bewegung Fluide Religion. Neue religiöse Bewegungen im Wandel. Theoretische und empirische Systematisierungen 2010a Bielefeld Transcript 77 92

NeubertFrank Western Hindus and “global Hinduism”—Discourses on conversion to “Hindu-religions,” acceptance of converts, and social engagement Finnish Journal of Ethnicity and Migration 2010b 5 2 56 62

NeubertFrank Die kommunikative Konstitution von “Religion” 2013 Institut für Religionswissenschaft, University of Bern unpublished Habilitation thesis

NeubertFrank AngermullerJohannesNonhoffMartinHerschingerEvaMacgilchristFelicitasRiesiglMartinWedlJulietteWarnaDanielZiemAlexander Diskursforschung in der Religionswissenschaft Diskursforschung. Ein interdisziplinäres Handbuch 2014 Bielefeld Transcript 261 275

PattonKimberleyRayBenjamin C. A Magic Still Dwells: Comparative Religion in the Postmodern Age 2000 Berkeley University of California Press

PikeKenneth L. Language In Relation to a Unified Theory of the Structure of Human Behavior, Part 1 1954 Glendale, CA Summer Institute of Linguistics

PopperKarl Three Worlds (The Tanner Lecture on Human Values) 1978 Delivered at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor (available at: http://tannerlectures.utah.edu/_documents/a-to-z/p/popper80.pdf)

PotterJonathanHepburnAlexandra HolsteinJames A.GubriumJaber F. Discursive constructionism Handbook of Constructionist Research 2008 New York The Guilford Press 275 293

PyysiäinenIlkka Cognitive science of religion: State-of-the-art Journal for the Cognitive Science of Religion 2013 1 1 5 28

RappaportRoy A. Ritual and Religion in the Making of Humanity 1999 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

RybaThomas Phenomenology as insider trading: Some stipulations for the religious “skin trade.” Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 2007 19 3-4 255 280

SarasinPhilipp Geschichtswissenschaft und Diskursanalyse 2003 Frankfurt am Main Suhrkamp

SchülerSebastian Naturalistische Religionstheorien aus Sicht der Religionswissenschaft Zeitschrift für Religionswissenschaft 2004a 22 1 1 4

SchülerSebastian Zwischen Naturalismus und Sozialkonstruktivismus. Kognitive, körperliche, emotionale und soziale Dimensionen von Religion Zeitschrift für Religionswissenschaft 2004b 22 1 5 36

SearleJohn R. A taxonomy of illocutionary acts Expression and Meaning: Studies in the Theory of Speech Acts 1979 Cambridge Cambridge Universsity Press 1 29

SearleJohn R. Intentionality: An Essay in the Philosophy of Mind 1983 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

SearleJohn R. Minds, Brains, and Science 1984 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

SearleJohn R. The Construction of Social Reality 1996 London Penguin Books

SearleJohn R. Mind, Language, and Society: Philosophy in the Real World 1998 New York Basic Books

SearleJohn R. Rationality in Action (The Jean Nicod Lectures) 2001 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

SearleJohn R. Collective intentions and actions Consciousness and Language 2002 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 90 105

SearleJohn R. Social ontology: Some basic principles Anthropological Theory 2006a 6 1 12 29

SearleJohn R. Reality and relativism: Shweder on a which? hunt Anthropological Theory 2006b 6 1 112 121

SearleJohn R. Reality and social construction: Reply to Friedman Anthropological Theory 2006c 6 1 81 88

SearleJohn R. Searle versus Durkheim and the waves of thought: Reply to Gross Anthropological Theory 2006d 6 1 57 69

SearleJohn R. TsohatzidisSavas L. Social ontology: The problem and steps toward a solution Intentional Acts and Institutional Facts: Essays on John Searle’s Social Ontology 2007 Dordrecht Springer 11 28

SearleJohn R. What is language? Some preliminary remarks Etica & Politica / Ethics & Politics 2009 11 1 173 202

SearleJohn R. Making the Social World: The Structure of Human Civilization 2010 Oxford and New York Oxford University Press

SegalRobert A. In defense of reductionism Journal of the American Academy of Religion 1983 51 1 97 124

ShwederRichard A. John Searle on a witch hunt: A commentary on John R. Searle’s essay “Social ontology: Some basic principles.” Anthropological Theory 2006 6 1 89 111

StausbergMichael StausbergMichael There is life in the old dog yet: An introduction to contemporary theories of religion Contemporary Theories of Religion: A Critical Companion 2009 London Routledge 1 21

StausbergMichael Distinctions, differentiations, ontology, and non-humans in theories of religion Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 2010 22 354 374

StuckradKocku von Discursive study of religion: Approaches, definitions, implica-tions Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 2013 25 5 25

WiebeDonald McCutcheonRussell T. Does understanding religion require religious understanding? The Insider / Outsider Problem in the Study of Religion: A Reader 1999 London Cassell 260 273

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 14 14 11
Full Text Views 12 12 12
PDF Downloads 5 5 5
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0