Of Gods and Devils

Differential Cognition and the Adaptive Illusions of Control

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Perceiving the lack of control over the natural and social spheres is psychologically averse. The resulting depression has an effect upon the human animal’s inclusive fitness. In moments of despair and depression, sexual intercourse may be impossible. In order to restore a modicum of control, and thus libido, the human animal turns to religion. Religion provides compensatory, and thus adaptive illusions of control. It does this by first turning to the intentional stance and the presence of gods who may be socially manipulated to achieve a desired outcome. This is the nature of worship. Alternatively, religion employs the design stance and the presence of devils that may be mechanically compelled to withdraw. This is the nature of exorcism. Where the latter reflects the “illusion of control,” the former reflects the “illusion of qualified control.” Both cognitive stances are in the service of promoting illusions of power amidst truly random circumstances.

Of Gods and Devils

Differential Cognition and the Adaptive Illusions of Control

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion

Sections

References

AbramsonLyn Y.MetalskyGerald I.AlloyLauren B. Hopelessness depression: A theory-based subtype of depression Psychological Review 1989 96 2 358 372

AlloyLauren B.ClementsCaroline M. Illusion of control: Invulnerability to negative affect and depressive symptoms after laboratory and natural stressors Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1992 101 2 234 245

AlvaradoKatherine A.TemplerDonald I.BreslerCharlesThomas-DobsonShan The relationship of religious variables to death depression and death anxiety Journal of Clinical Psychology 1995 51 2 202 204

AtranScott In Gods We Trust: The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion 2002 New York, NY Oxford University Press

AvalosHector Fighting Words: The Origins of Religious Violence 2005 Amherst, NY Prometheus Books

BadcockPaul B. T.AllenNicholas B. ForgasJoseph P.HaseltonMartie G.von HippelWilliam Evolution, social cognition, and depressed mood: Exploring the relationship between depression and social risk taking Evolution and the Social Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and Social Cognition 2007 New York Psychology Press 125 142

BalonRichard Depression, antidepressants, and human sexuality Primary Psychiatry 2007 14 2 42 44 47 50

BarkowJerome H.CosmidesLedaToobyJohn The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture 1992 New York, NY Oxford University Press

Baron-CohenSimon Mindblindness: An Essay on Autism and Theory of Mind 1995 Cambridge, MA The MIT Press

BarrettH. Clark BussDavid M. Adaptations to predators and prey The Handbook of Evolutionary Psychology 2005 Hoboken, NJ John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 200 223

BarrettJustin L. Why Would Anyone Believe in God? 2004 Lanham, MD AltaMira Press

BarrettNathaniel F. Toward an alternative evolutionary theory of religion: Looking past computational evolutionary psychology to a wider field of possibilities Journal of the American Academy of Religion 2010 78 3 583 621

BarrettNathaniel F. WattsFraserTurnerLeon Skilful engagement and the “effort after value”: An axiological theory of the origins of religion Evolution Religion and Cognitive Science: Critical and Constructive Essays 2014 New York, NY Oxford University Press 92 108

BeringJesse M. EllisBruce J.BjorklundDavid F. The evolutionary history of an illusion Origins of the Social Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and Child Development 2005 New York, NY The Guilford Press 411 437

BerkeleyGeorge Philosophical Works: Including the Works on Vision Everyman’s Library 1993 North Clarendon, VT Tuttle Publishing

BloomPaul Descartes’ Baby: How the Science of Child Development Explains What Makes Us Human 2004 New York, NY Basic Books

BowlbyJohn Attachment 1969 New York, NY Basic Books

BoyerPascal Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origins of Religious Thought 2001 New York, NY Basic Books

BoyerPascal The Fracture of an Illusion: Science and the Dissolution of Religion 2010 Gottingen Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht GmbH & Co.

BurkertWalter Creation of the Sacred: Tracks of Biology in Early Religions 1996 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

ByersJohn A. American Pronghorn: Social Adaptations and the Ghosts of Predators Past 1998 Chicago, IL The University of Chicago Press

ChisholmJames S. HintonAlexander Laban Steps to an evolutionary ecology of mind Biocultural Approaches to the Emotions 1999 Cambridge, MA Cambridge University Press 117 150

CohenEmma WhitehouseHarveyLaidlawJames Witchcraft and sorcery Religion Anthropology and Cognitive Science 2007 Durham, NC Carolina Academic Press 135 160

CuneoMichael W. American Exorcism: Expelling Demons in the Land of Plenty 2001 New York, NY Doubleday

DaviesMartin F.KirkbyHillary E. Multidimensionality of the relationship between perceived control and belief in the paranormal: Spheres of control and types of paranormal phenomena Personality and Individual Differences 1985 6 5 661 663

DawkinsRichard The selfish gene 1976 New York, NY Oxford University Press

DawkinsRichard The God delusion 2006 Boston, MA Houghton Mifflin Co.

DayMatthew Let’s be realistic: Evolutionary complexity, epistemic probabalism, and the cognitive science of religion Harvard Theological Review 2007 100 1 47 64

DennettDaniel C. The Intentional Stance 1989 Cambridge, MA Massachusetts Institute of Technology

DennettDaniel C. Darwin’s Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life 2005 New York, NY Touchstone

DennettDaniel C. Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon 2006 New York, NY Viking

DurkheimEmile FieldsK. E. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life 1995/1915 New York, NY The Free Press

EdmondsonDonaldParkCrystal L.ChaudoirStephanie R.WortmannJennifer H. Death without god: Religious struggle, death concerns, and depression in the terminally ill Psychological Science 2008 19 8 754 758

EilamDavidIzharRonyMortJoel Threat detection: Behavioral practices in animals and humans Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 2011 35 999 1006

EllisThomas B. On spirituality: Natural and non-natural Religion Compass 2008 2 6 1117 1138

EllisThomas B. FeiermanJay R. Natural gazes, non-natural agents: The biology of religion’s ocular behaviors The Biology of Religious Behavior: The Evolutionary Origins of Faith and Religion 2009 Westport, CT Praeger 36 51

EllisThomas B. Evoked puja: The behavioral ecology of an equatorial ritual Journal of the American Academy of Religion 2015 83 4 1108 1156

FalesEvan PigliucciMassimoBoudryMaarten Is a science of the supernatural possible? Philosophy of pseudoscience: reconsidering the demarcation problem 2013 Chicago, IL The University of Chicago Press 247 262

FlanaganOwen Consciousness Reconsidered 1992 Cambridge, MA The MIT Press

FlanaganOwen The Really Hard Problem: Meaning in a Material World 2007 Cambridge, MA The MIT Press

FlanaganOwenBarackDavid Neuroexistentialism EurAmerica 2010 40 3 573 590

FodorJerry The Mind Doesn’t Work That Way: The Scope and Limits of Computational Psychology 2001 Cambridge, MA MIT Press

GilbertPaul Evolution and depression: Issues and implications Psychological Medicine 2006 36 287 297

GoodwinJeanHillSallyAttiasReina Historical and folk techniques of exorcism: Applications to the treatment of dissociative disorders Dissociation 1990 3 2 94 101

GreeneJoshua Moral Tribes: Emotion Reason and the Gap Between Us and Them 2013 New York, NY Penguin

GuthrieStewart Faces in the Clouds: A New Theory of Religion 1993 New York, NY Oxford University Press

HaidtJonathan The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion 2012 New York, NY Vintage Books

HarrisSam The End of Faith: Religion Terror and the Future of Reason 2004 New York, NY W. W. Norton & Co.

HortonRobin Patterns of Thought in Africa and the West: Essays on Magic Religion and Science 1993 New York, NY Cambridge University Press

HusserlEdmund CairnsDorion Cartesian Meditations: An Introduction to Phenomenology 1960 The Hague Martinus Nijhoff

JonasEvaFischerPeter Terror management and religion: Evidence that intrinsic religiousness mitigates worldview defense following mortality salience Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2006 91 3 553 567

KahnemanDaniel Thinking Fast and Slow 2013 New York, NY Farrar, Straus and Giroux

KaufmanGordon D. The Theological Imagination: Constructing the Concept of God 1981 Louisville, KY Westminster John Knox Press

KayAaron C.GaucherDanielleMcGregorIanNashKyle Religious belief as compensatory control Personality and Social Psychology Review 2010 14 1 37 48

KeinanGiora The effects of stress and desire for control on superstitious behavior Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2002 28 1 102 108

KendlerKenneth S.HettemaJohn M.ButeraFrankGardnerCharles O.PrescottCarol A. Life event dimensions of loss, humiliation, entrapment, and danger in the prediction of onsets of major depression and generalized anxiety Archives of General Psychiatry 2003 60 8 789 796

KimJaegwon Physicalism or Something Near Enough 2005 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press

KirkpatrickLee A. Attachment Evolution and the Psychology of Religion 2005 New York, NY Guilford Press

KochChristof The Quest for Consciousness: A Neurobiological Approach 2004 Englewood, CO Roberts & Company Publishers

KoenigHarold G. Medicine Religion and Health: Where Science and Spirituality Meet 2008 West Conshohocken, PA Templeton Foundation Press

KuhnThomas S. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions 1962 Chicago, IL The University of Chicago Press

LaidlawJames WhitehouseHarveyLaidlawJames A well-disposed social anthropologist’s problems with the “cognitive science of religion.” Religion Anthropology and Cognitive Science 2007 Durham, NC Carolina Academic Press 211 246

LaidlawJamesWhitehouseHarvey WhitehouseHarveyLaidlawJames Introduction Religion Anthropology and Cognitive Science 2007 Durham, NC Carolina Academic Press 3 34

LalandKevin N.BrownGillian R. Sense and Nonsense: Evolutionary Perspectives on Human Bahaviour 2002 New York, NY Oxford University Press

LambertWilliam W.TriandisLeigh MinturnWolfMargery Some correlates of beliefs in the malevolence and benevolence of supernatural beings: A cross-societal study Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 1959 58 162 169

LangerEllen J. The illusion of control Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1975 32 2 311 328

LaurinKristinKayAaron C.MoscovitchDavid A. On the belief in god: Towards an understanding of the emotional substrates of compensatory control Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2008 44 1559 1562

LeVineRobert A. LeidermanP. HerbertTulkinSteven R.RosenfeldAnne Child rearing as cultural adaptation Culture and Infancy: Variations in the Human Experience 1977 New York, NY Academic Press, Inc. 15 27

LeVineRobert A.LeVineSarahLeidermanP. HerbertBrazeltonT. BerryDixonSuzanneRichmanAmyKeeferConstance H. Child Care and Culture: Lessons from Africa 1994 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

LourencoMarioAzevedoLeandra PinheiroGouveiaJose Luis Depression and sexual desire: An exploratory study in psychiatric patients Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy 2011 37 32 44

MaimonidesMoses The Guide for the Perplexed 1956 Mineola, NY Dover Publications

MayrErnst What Evolution Is 2001 New York, NY Basic Books

McCauleyRobert N. Why Religion is Natural and Science is Not 2011 Oxford Oxford University Press

McGuireMichaelTroisiAlfonso Darwinian Psychiatry 1998 New York, NY Oxford University Press

MilnerMurrayJr. Status and Sacredness: A General Theory of Status Relations and an Analysis of Indian Culture 1994 New York, NY Oxford University Press

NiebhurReinhold Marx & Engels on Religion 1964 Berlin Schocken Books

NorenzayanAraHansenIan G. Belief in supernatural agents in the face of death Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2006 32 2 174 187

PalsDaniel L. Nine Theories of Religion 2015 3rd edition New York, NY Oxford University Press

PanchinAlexander Y.TuzhikovAlexander I.PanchinYuri V. Midichlorians—the biomeme hypothesis: Is there a microbial component to religious rituals? Biology Direct 2014 9 14 1 14 doi: 10.1186/1745-6150-9-14

PargamentKenneth I. The Psychology of Religion and Coping 2001 New York, NY Guilford Press

PinkerSteven The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature 2002 New York, NY Viking

PinkerSteven So how does the mind work? Mind & Language 2005 20 1 1 24

PlantingaAlvin Warrant and Proper Function 1993 New York, NY Oxford University Press

PressonPaul K.BenassiVictor A. Are depressive symptoms positively or negatively associated with the illusion of control? Social Behavior and Personality 2003 31 5 483 495

PurzyckiBenjamin GrantHaqueOmar SultanSosisRichard WattsFraserTurnerLeon Extending evolutionary accounts of religion beyond the mind: Religions as adaptive systems Evolution Religion and Cognitive Science 2014 New York, NY Oxford University Press 74 91

PyszczynskiTomGreenbergJeffSolomonSheldon In the Wake of 9/11: The Psychology of Terror 2003 Washington, DC American Psychological Association

RammohanA.RaoK.SubbakrishnaD. K. Religious coping and psychological wellbeing in carers of relatives with schizophrenia Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2002 105 356 362

RidleyMatt The Origins of Virtue: Human Instincts and the Evolution of Cooperation 1996 New York, NY Penguin

RizzutoAna-Maria The Birth of the Living God: A Psychoanalytic Study 1981 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

RohnerRonald P. They Love Me They Love Me Not: A Worldwide Study of the Effects of Parental Acceptance and Rejection 1975 New Haven, CT HRAF Press

RosenbergAlexander Instrumental Biology or The Disunity of Science 1994 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

RosenbergAlexander The Atheist’s Guide to Reality: Enjoying Life without Illusions 2011 New York, NY W. W. Norton & Company

SalsmanJohn M.BrownTamara L.BrechtingEmily H.CarlsonCharles R. The link between religion and spirituality and psychological adjustment: The mediating role of optimism and social support Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2005 31 4 522 535

SapolskyRobert M. The influence of social hierarchy on primate health Science 2005 308 648 652

ScheierMichael F.CarverCharles S. Optimism, coping, and health: Assessment and implications of generalized outcome expectancies Health Psychology 1985 4 3 219 247

SearleJohn Mind: A Brief Introduction 2005 New York, NY Oxford University Press

SegalRobert A. In defense of reduction Journal of the American Academy of Religion 1983 51 1 97 124

SegalRobert A. Explaining and Interpreting Religion: Essays on the Issue 1992 New York, NY Peter Lang

SegalRobert A. All generalizations are bad: Postmodernism on theories Journal of the American Academy of Religion 2006 74 1 157 171

SeligmanM. E. P. Helplessness: On Depression Development and Death 1975 San Francisco, CA Freeman

SmithAaron C. T. Thinking about Religion: Extending the Cognitive Science of Religion 2014 New York, NY Palgrave Macmillan

SmithTimothy B.McCulloughMichael E.PollJustin Religiousness and depression: Evidence for a main effect and the moderating influence of stressful life events Psychological Bulletin 2003 129 4 614 636

SpiroMelford E. Culture and Human Nature 1994 New Brunswick, NJ Transaction Publishers

StarkRodneyFinkeRoger Acts of Faith: Explaining the Human Side of Religion 2000 Berkeley, CA University of California Press

TambiahStanley J. Magic Science and Religion and the Scope of Rationality 1990 New York, NY Cambridge University Press

ToobyJohnCosmidesLeda BarkowJerome H.CosmidesLedaToobyJohn The psychological foundations of culture The Adapted Mind 1992 New York, NY Oxford University Press 19 136

TriversRobert The Folly of Fools: The Logic of Deceit and Self-Deception in Human Life 2011 New York, NY Basic Books

TurnerLeon WattsFraserTurnerLeon Neither friends nor enemies: The complex relationship between cognitive and humanistic accounts of religious belief Evolution Religion and Cognitive Science 2014 New York, NY Oxford University Press 152 172

VailKenneth E.3rdRothschildZachary K.WeiseDave R.SolomonSheldonPyszczynskiTomGreenbergJeff A terror management analysis of the psychological functions of religion Personality and Social Psychology Review 2009 14 1 84 94

VermaJyoti ValsinerJaan Transformation of women’s social roles in India Child Development within Culturally Structured Environments 1995 Norwood, NJ Ablex Publishing Corporation 138 163

WattCarolineWatsonSuzannahWilsonLindsey Cognitive and psychological mediators of anxiety: Evidence from a study of paranormal belief and perceived childhood control Personality and Individual Differences 2007 42 2 335 434

WattsFraser WattsFraserTurnerLeon Religion and the emergence of differentiated cognition Evolution Religion and Cognitive Science 2014 New York, NY Oxford University Press 109 131

WhitehouseHarvey WhitehouseHarveyLaidlawJames Towards an integration of ethnography, history, and the cognitive science of religion Religion Anthropology and Cognitive Science 2007 Durham, NC Carolina Academic Press 247 280

WhitehouseHarveyLaidlawJames Religion Anthropology and Cognitive Science 2007 Durham, NC Carolina Academic Press

WhitsonJennifer A.GalinskyAdam D. Lacking control increases illusory pattern perception Science 2008 322 115 117

WilliamsKatherineReynoldsMargaret F. Sexual dysfunction in major depression CNS Spectrums 2006 11 8 Suppl 9 19 23

WilsonDavid Sloan Darwin’s Cathedral: Evolution Religion and the Nature of Society 2002 Chicago, IL The University of Chicago Press

YoungMaia J.MorrisMichael W. GreenbergJeffKooleSander L.PyszczynskiTom Existential meanings and cultural models: The interplay of personal and supernatural agency in American and Hindu ways of responding to uncertainty Handbook of Experimental Psychology 2004 New York, NY The Guilford Press 215 230

ZuckermanMironSilbermanJordanHallJudith A. The relation between intelligence and religiosity: A meta-analysis and some proposed explanations Personality and Social Psychology Review 2013 17 4 325 354

15

McCauley (2011) notes that the promiscuous social psychology on display in religion threatens the scientific enterprise insofar as the latter is predicated precisely on reining in such social psychological liberalism.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 25 25 16
Full Text Views 83 83 72
PDF Downloads 3 3 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0