How to Know You’ve Survived Death

A Cognitive Account of the Popularity of Contemporary Post-mortem Survival Narratives

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

Reports of people who have survived death have captured the attention of mainstream audiences. Why do these ideas enjoy persistent and widespread success in contemporary Western culture? Adopting a cognitive approach to the study of afterlife accounts and drawing upon our own research, we argue that mainstream survival narratives are popular because they provide convincing evidence that one has journeyed to another realm. Such accounts are convincing, in part, because they meet default cognitive assumptions about what human survival would look like if it were possible. We support this claim by highlighting recurring common themes in recounted episodes of near-death experiences and past life accounts and outlining how key findings in the cognitive science of religion, in conjunction with culturally situated accounts, can help scholars concerned with ideas about anomalous experiences to better understand their appeal.

How to Know You’ve Survived Death

A Cognitive Account of the Popularity of Contemporary Post-mortem Survival Narratives

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion

Sections

References

AddisDonna R. and Lynette J. Tippett (2004). “Memory of Myself: Autobiographical Memory and Identity in Alzheimer’s Disease.” Memory 12 (1) pp. 56-74.

AlbaneseCatherine L. (2006). A Republic Of Mind And Spirit: A Cultural History Of American Metaphysical Religion. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

AlexanderEben (2012). Proof Of Heaven: A Neurosurgeon’s Journey Into The Afterlife. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.

AndersenSusan M. and Steve W. Cole (1990). “ ‘Do I Know You?’ The Role Of Significant Others In General Social Perception.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 59 (3) pp. 384-399.

AndersenSusan M.Noah S. Glassman and Serena Chen (1995). “Transference In Social Perception: The Role Of Chronic Accessibility In Significant-Other Representations.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 69 (1) pp. 41-57.

AstutiRita and Paul L. Harris (2008). “Understanding Mortality And The Life Of The Ancestors In Rural Madagascar.” Cognitive Science 32 (4) pp. 713-740.

BarrettJustin L. (1999). “Theological Correctness: Cognitive Constraint And The Study Of Religion.” Method and Theory in the Study of Religion 11 (4) pp. 325-339.

BarrettJustin L. (2000). “Exploring The Natural Foundations Of Religion.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 4 (1) pp. 29-34.

BarrettJustin L. (2007). “Cognitive Science Of Religion: What Is It And Why Is It?” Religion Compass 1 (6) pp. 768-786.

BenderCourtney (2007). “American Reincarnations: What The Many Lives Of Past Lives Tell Us About Contemporary Spiritual Practice.” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 75 (3) pp. 589-614.

BeringJesse M. (2002). “Intuitive Conceptions Of Dead Agent’s Minds: The Natural Foundations Of Afterlife Beliefs As A Phenomenological Boundary.” Journal of Cognition and Culture 2 (4) pp. 264-308.

BeringJesse M. (2006). “The Folk Psychology Of Souls.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 29 (05) pp. 453-462.

BeringJesse M. and David F. Björklund (2004). “The Natural Emergence Of Reasoning About The Afterlife As A Developmental Regularity.” Developmental Psychology 40 (2) pp. 217-233.

BlankeOlaf and Shahar Arzy (2005). “The Out-of-Body Experience: Disturbed Self-Processing at the Temporo-Parietal Junction.” Neuroscientist 11 (1) pp. 16-24.

BlokSergeyGeorge Newman and Lance J. Rips (2005). “Individuals And Their Concepts.” In Ahn Woo-kyoungRobert L. GoldstoneBradley C. LoveArthur B. Markman and Phillip Wolff eds. Categorization Inside and Outside the Lab: Essays in Honor of Douglas L. Medin Washington, DC: American Psychological Association pp. 127-149.

BloomPaul (2004). Descartes’ Baby: How Child Development Explains What Makes Us Human. London, UK: William Heinemann Ltd.

BowmanCarol (2012). Children’s Past Lives: How Past Life Memories Affect Your Child. New York, NY: Bantam Books.

BoyerPascal (2001). Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origins Of Religious Thought. New York, NY: Basic Books.

BoyerPascal and Sheila Walker (2000). “Intuitive Ontology And Cultural Input In The Acquisition Of Religious Concepts.” In Karl S. RosengrenCarl N. Johnson and Paul L. Harris eds. Imagining The Impossible: Magical Scientific And Religious Thinking In ChildrenNew York, NY: Cambridge University Press pp. 130-156.

ClarkKimberly (1984). “Clinical Interventions With Near-Death Experiencers.” In Bruce Greyson and Charles P. Flynn eds. The Near-Death Experience: Problems Prospects PerspectivesSpringfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas pp. 242-255.

CohenEmma (2007). The Mind Possessed. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

CohenEmma and Justin Barrett (2008). “When Minds Migrate: Conceptualizing Spirit Possession.” Journal of Cognition and Culture 8 (1) pp. 23-48.

CohenEmmaEmily BurdettNicola Knight and Justin Barrett (2011). “Cross‐Cultural Similarities And Differences In Person‐Body Reasoning: Experimental Evidence From The United Kingdom And Brazilian Amazon.” Cognitive Science 35 (7) pp. 1282-1304.

ConwayMartin A. (2005). “Memory and the Self.” Journal of Memory and Language 53 (4) pp. 594-628.

CorazzaOrnella and K.A.L.A. Kuruppuarachchi (2012). “Dealing with Diversity: Cross-cultural Aspects of the Near Death Experiences.” In Mahendra PereraKaruppiah Jagadheesan and Anthony Peake eds. Making Sense of Near-Death Experiences: A Handbook for CliniciansLondon, UK: Jessica Kingsley Publishers pp. 51-63.

CorriveauKathleen H.Elisabeth S. Pasquini and Paul L. Harris (2005). “ ‘If It’s In Your Mind, It’s In Your Knowledge:’ Children’s Developing Anatomy Of Identity.” Cognitive Development 20 (2) pp. 321-340.

CoulianoIoan P. (1991). Out of this World: Otherworldly Journeys from Gilgamesh to Albert Einstein. Boston, MA: Shambhala.

CountsDorothy E. (1983). “Near-Death And Out-Of-Body Experiences In A Melanesian Society.” Anabiosis: The Journal for Near-Death Studies 3 (2) pp. 115-135.

DawsonLorne L. (2006). Comprehending Cults: The Sociology Of New Religious Movements. Toronto, Canada: Oxford University Press.

De CruzHelen (2013). “Religious Concepts As Structured Imagination.” International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 23 (1) pp. 63-74.

EdelmannJonathan and William Bernet (2007). “Setting Criteria For Ideal Reincarnation Research.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 14 (12) pp. 92-101.

EdwardsPaul (1996). Reincarnation: A Critical Examination. New York, NY: Prometheus Books.

FariasMiguelGordon Claridge and Mansur Lalljee (2005). “Personality And Cognitive Predictors Of New Age Practices And Beliefs.” Personality and Individual Differences 39 (5) pp. 979-989.

FenwickPeter and Elizabeth Fenwick (1995). The Truth In The Light: An Investigation Of Over 300 Near Death Experiences. New York, NY: Berkley Books.

FiskeSusan T. and Shelley E. Taylor (1991). Social Cognition. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

FoxMark (2003). Religion Spirituality and the Near-Death Experience. New York, NY: Routledge.

FullerRobert C. (2001). Spiritual But Not Religious: Understanding Unchurched America. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

GauldAlan (2007). “Chapter 4: Memory.” In Edward F. KellyEmily Williams KellyAdam CrabtreeAlan GauldMichael Grosso and Bruce Greyson eds. Irreducible Mind: Toward a Psychology for the 21st CenturyReprintLanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers pp. 241-300.

GopnikAlisonAndrew N. Meltzoff and Patricia K. Kuhl (1990). The Scientist In The Crib: Minds Brains And How Children Learn. New York, NY: William Morrow and Co.

GottliebAlma (2004). The Afterlife Is Where We Come From. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

GreysonBruce and Ian Stevenson (1980). “The Phenomenology Of Near-Death Experiences.” American Journal of Psychiatry 137 (10) pp. 1193-1196.

GuthrieStewart Elliot (1993). Faces In The Clouds: A New Theory Of Religion. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

GutheilGrant and Karl S. Rosengren (1996). “A Rose By Any Other Name: Preschoolers’ Understanding Of Individual Identity Across Name And Appearance Changes.” British Journal of Developmental Psychology 14 (4) pp. 477-498.

HallD. GeoffreySharon C. Lee and Julie Bélanger (2001). “Young Children’s Use Of Syntactic Cues To Learn Proper Names And Count Nouns.” Developmental Psychology 37 (3) pp. 298-307.

HaraldssonErlendur (1997). “A Psychological Comparison Between Ordinary Children And Those Who Claim Previous-Life Memories.” Journal of Scientific Exploration 11 (3) pp. 323-335.

HaraldssonErlendur (2006). “Popular Psychology, Belief In Life After Death And Reincarnation In The Nordic Countries, Western And Eastern Europe.” Nordic Psychology 58 (2) pp. 171-180.

HaraldssonErlendur and Godwin Samararatne (1999). “Children Who Speak Of Memories Of A Previous Life As A Buddhist Monk: Three New Cases.” Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 63 (857) pp. 268-291.

HicklingAnne K. and Susan A. Gelman (1995). “How Does Your Garden Grow? Evidence Of An Early Conception Of Plants As Biological Kinds.” Child Development 66 (3) pp. 856-876.

HodgeK. Mitch (2008). “Descartes’ Mistake: How Afterlife Beliefs Challenge The Assumption That Humans Are Intuitive Cartesian Substance Dualists.” Journal of Cognition and Culture 8 (3-4) pp. 387-415.

HodgeK. Mitch (2011). “On Imagining The Afterlife.” Journal of Cognition and Culture 11 (3-4) pp. 367-389.

HodgeK. Mitch (2012). “Context Sensitivity and the Folk Psychology of Souls: Why Bering et al. got the Findings They Did.” In Dirk EversMichael FullerAntje Jackelén and Taede A. Smedes eds. Is Religion Natural?New York, NY: T & T Clark International pp. 49-63.

JamesWilliam (1985). The Varieties Of Religious ExperienceVolume 13. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

KellehearAllan (2009). “Census of Non-Western Near-Death Experiences to 2005: Observations and Critical Reflections.” In Janet Miner HoldenBruce Greyson and Debbie James eds. The Handbook of Near-Death Experiences: Thirty Years of InvestigationSanta Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO pp. 135-158.

KinsellaMichael (2016). “Near-Death Experiences and Networked Spirituality: The Emergence of an Afterlife Movement.” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 85 (1) pp. 168-198.

KinsellaMichael (2012). “Near-Death Studies as Spiritual Practice.” Paper presented at the Society for the Scientific Study of Religion Annual Meeting; November 9-11; Phoenix AZ.

KleinStanley. B.Tim P. GermanLeda Cosmides and Rami Gabriel (2004). “A Theory Of Autobiographical Memory: Necessary Components And Disorders Resulting From Their Loss.” Social Cognition 22 (5) pp. 460-490.

LamontPeter (2012). “The Making Of Extraordinary Psychological Phenomena.” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 48 (1) pp. 1-15.

LeiningerAndreaBruce Leininger and Ken Gross (2009). “Soul Survivor: The Reincarnation of a World War II Fighter Pilot.” Journal of Scientific Exploration 23 (4) pp. 550.

LeveroniCatherine L.Michael SeidenbergAndrew R. MayerLarissa A. MeadJeffrey R. Binder and Stephen M. Rao (2000). “Neural Systems Underlying The Recognition Of Familiar And Newly Learned Faces.” Journal of Neuroscience 20 (2) pp. 878-886.

LindemanMarjaana and Annika M. Svedholm (2012). “What’s In A Term? Paranormal, Superstitious, Magical And Supernatural Beliefs By Any Other Name Would Mean The Same.” Review of General Psychology 16 (3) pp. 241-255.

van LommelPirnRuud van WeesVincent Meyers and Ingrid Elfferich (2001). “Near-Death Experience in Survivors of Cardiac Arrest: A Prospective Study in the Netherlands.” Lancet 358 (9298) pp. 2039-2045.

LongJeffrey and Paul Perry (2010). Evidence of the Afterlife: The Science of Near-Death Experiences. New York, NY: Harper One.

LyonsSean (2013). “The Science Of Reincarnation: U.Va. Psychiatrist Jim Tucker Investigates Children’s Claims Of Past Lives.” University of Virginia MagazineDecember 102013 http://uvamagazine.org/articles/the_science_of_reincarnation.

MalleBertram F. (2004). How The Mind Explains Behavior: Folk Explanations Meaning And Social Interaction. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

MasumianFarnaz (2009). “World Religions and Near-Death Experiences.” In Janet Miner HoldenBruce Greyson and Debbie James eds. The Handbook of Near- Death Experiences: Thirty Years of InvestigationSanta Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO pp. 159-212.

MillerLisa (2010). “Remembrances of Lives Past.” New York Times Magazine. August 272010 http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/29/fashion/29PastLives.html?_r=0.

MatlockJames (1993). “A Cross-Cultural Study Of Reincarnation Ideologies And Their Social Correlates.” Master’s thesis Hunter College New York.

MatlockJames G. and Antonia Mills (1994). “A Trait Index To North American Indian And Inuit Reincarnation Beliefs.” In Antonia Mills and Richard Slobodin eds Amerindian Rebirth: Reincarnation Belief Among North American Indians And InuitToronto, Canada: University of Toronto Press pp. 299-356.

MeyersburgCynthia A.Ryan BogdanDavid A. Gallo and Richard J. McNally (2009). “False Memory Propensity In People Reporting Recovered Memories Of Past Lives.” Journal of Abnormal Psychology 118 (2) pp. 399-404.

Moreman Christopher M. (2008). Beyond the Threshold: Afterlife Beliefs and Experiences in World Religions. New York, NY: Rowman & Littlefield.

MyersFrederic W. H. (1903). Human Personality and Its Survival of Bodily Death (Two Volumes). London, UK: Longmans, Green and Co.

MoodyRaymond A. (1975). Life After Life: The Investigation of a Phenomenon—Survival of Bodily Death. Atlanta, GA: Mockingbird Books.

MoyeDavid (2014). Reincarnated kids: 9 signs your child had a past life.” Huffington Post. February 222014 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/02/21/reincarnated-kids_n_4832071.html.

NicholsShaun (2007). “Imagination And Immortality: Thinking Of Me.” Synthese 159 (2) pp. 215-233.

ObeyesekereGananath (2002). Imagining Karma: Ethical Transformation In Amerindian Buddhist And Greek Rebirth. London, UK: University of California Press.

OronaCelia J. (1990). “Temporality And Identity Loss Due To Alzheimer’s Disease.” Social Science and Medicine 30 (11) pp. 1247-1256.

ParniaSamKen SpearpointGabriele de VosPeter FenwickDiana GoldbergJie YangJiawen Zhuet al. (2014). “AWARE—AWAreness during REsuscitation— A Prospective Study.” Resuscitation 85 (12) pp. 1799-1805.

PartridgeChristopher (2006). The Re-Enchantment of the West Vol 2: Alternative Spiritualities Sacralization Popular Culture and Occulture. London, UK: Bloomsbury Publishing.

RichertRebekah A. and Paul L. Harris (2006). “The Ghost In My Body: Children’s Developing Concept Of The Soul.” Journal of Cognition and Culture 6 (3-4) pp. 409-427.

RitchieGeorge C. and Elizabeth Sherrill (1978). Return from Tomorrow. Ada, MI: Chosen Books.

RoazziMairaMelanie Nyhof and Carl Johnson (2013). “Mind, Soul and Spirit: Conceptions of Immaterial Identity in Different Cultures.” International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 23 (1) pp. 75-86.

RonchJudah L. (1996). “Mourning And Grief In Late Life Alzheimer’s Dementia: Revisiting The Vanishing Self.” American Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease and Other Dementias 11 (4) pp. 25-28.

RosengrenKarl S.Susan A. GelmanCharles W. Kalish and Michael McCormick (1991). “As Time Goes By: Children’s Early Understanding Of Growth In Animals.” Child Development 62 (6) pp. 1302-1320.

ShahNadim J.John C. MarshallOliver ZafirisAnna SchwabKarl Ziles and Hans J. Markowitsch and Gereon R. Fink (2001). “The Neural Correlates Of Person Familiarity: A Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study With Clinical Implications.” Brain 124 (4) pp. 804-815.

ShushanGregory (2009). Conceptions of the Afterlife in Early Civilizations: Universalism Constructivism and Near-Death Experience. New York, NY: Continuum.

SpanosNicholas P.Evelyn MenaryNatalie J. GaboraSusan C. DuBreuil and Bridget Dewhirst (1991). “Secondary Identity Enactments During Hypnotic Past-Life Regression: A Sociocognitive Perspective.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 61 (2) pp. 308-320.

SperberDan (1996). Explaining Culture: A Naturalistic Approach. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.

StevensonIan (1974). Twenty Cases Suggestive Of Reincarnation. Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia Press.

StevensonIan (1997). Reincarnation And Biology [2 Volumes]: A Contribution To The Etiology Of Birthmarks And Birth Defects. New York, NY: Praeger.

StevensonIan (2001). Children Who Remember Previous Lives: A Question Of Reincarnation. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

SutherlandCherie (1995). Children Of The Light: The Near-Death Experiences Of Children. Sydney: Bantam books.

TanneJanice Hopkins (2007). “Ian Pretyman Stevenson: Psychiatrist Who Researched Reincarnation With Scientific Rigour.” British Medical Journal 334 (7595) p. 700.

TavesAnn (2014). “A Tale Of Two Congresses: The Psychological Study Of Psychical, Occult, And Religious Phenomena, 1900-1909.” Journal for the History of the Behavioral Sciences 50 (4) pp. 376-399.

TuckerJim B. (2005). Life Before Life: A Scientific Investigation Of Children’s Memories Of Previous Lives. New York, NY: Macmillan.

TuckerJim B. (2007). “Children Who Claim To Remember Previous Lives: Past, Present, And Future Research.” Journal of Scientific Exploration 21 (3) pp. 543-552.

TuckerJim B. (2013). Return to Life: Extraordinary Cases of Children Who Remember Past Lives. New York, NY: St. Martin’s Press.

TulvingEndel (1972). “Episodic And Semantic Memory.” In Endel Tulving and Wayne DonaldsonOrganization Of MemoryNew York, NY: Academic Press pp. 381-402.

WallisDavid (1999). “Conversations/Dr. Ian Stevenson: You May Be Reading This In Some Future Past-Life.” The New York Times. September 261999. http://www.nytimes.com/1999/09/26/weekinreview/conversations-dr-ian-stevenson-you-may-be-reading-this-in-some-future-past-life.html.

WalterTony (2001). “Reincarnation, Modernity and Identity.” Sociology 35 (1) pp. 21-38.

WeissBrian and Amy E. Weiss (2012). Miracles Happen: The Transformational Healing Power of Past Life Memories. New York, NY: Hay House, Inc.

WeissBrian L. (1988). Many Lives, Many Masters: The True Story Of A Prominent Psychiatrist, His Young Patient, And The Past-Life Therapy That Changed Both Their Lives. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.

WeissBrian L. (1994). “A Trait Index to North American Indian and Inuit Reincarnation Beliefs.” In Antonia Mills and Richard Slobodin eds. Amerindian Rebirth: Reincarnation Belief Among North American Indians And InuitToronto, Canada: University of Toronto Press pp. 299-356.

WhiteClaire (2017). “What the Cognitive Science of Religion is and is Not” In Aaron Hughes ed. Theory in a Time of Excess: The Case of the Academic Study of ReligionSheffield: Equiniox pp. 95-138.

WhiteClaire (2016a) “Cross-Cultural Similarities In Reasoning About Personal Continuity In Reincarnation: Evidence From South India.” Religion Brain and Behavior 6 (2) pp. 130-153.

WhiteClaire (2016b) “The Cognitive Foundations of Reincarnation.” Method and Theory in the Study of Religion pp. 1-23.

WhiteClaire (2015) “Establishing Personal Identity in Reincarnation: Minds and Bodies Reconsidered.” The Journal of Cognition and Culture15 pp. 402-429.

WhiteClaireRobert Kelly and Shaun Nichols (2016) “Remembering Past Lives: Intuitions about Memory and Personal Identity in Reincarnation.” In Helen De Cruz & Ryan Nichols eds. Advance in Religion Cognitive Science and Experimental PsychologyLondon and New York: Bloomsbury pp. 169-196.

WhiteClairePaulo Sousa and Renatas Berniunas (2014). “Psychological Essentialism in Selecting the 14th Dalai Lama: An Alternative Account.” The Journal of Cognition and Culture 14 (1-2) pp. 157-158.

WinfreyO. (Host). (2013) The Oprah Winfrey Show Super Soul Sunday “Oprah and Dr. Brian Weiss: Reincarnation past lives and miracles” Produced by J. Barancik and C. Koehl. OWNJune 22013.

YoungerS. J.ArnoldR. M.SchapiroR. (2002). The Definition of Death: Contemporary Controversies. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 23 23 20
Full Text Views 6 6 6
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0