Secrecy is often studied as a social phenomenon in which certain information is concealed from a targeted audience out of fear of the repercussions, if this information were to fall into the wrong hands. It is therefore surprising that people are relatively willing to share their secrets with others. Traditionally, this behaviour has been explained on the bases of the assumption that people are naturally inclined to reveal their secrets. However, new evidence from the cognitive sciences and social psychology calls this assumption, and thus the theories of secrecy which rely on it, into question. In this article I present a re-interpretation of secrecy in light of this new evidence and evaluate what implications this holds for the study of secrecy in religion.
CasoLetiziaGnisciAugustoVrijAldert and MannSamantha (2005). “Processes Underlying Deception: An Empirical Analysis of Truth and Lies When Manipulating the Stakes.” Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling2 (3) pp. 195-202.
CottrellCatherine A. and NeubergSteven L. (2005). “Different Emotional Reactions to Different Groups: A Sociofunctional Threat-Based Approach to ‘Prejudice’.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology88 (5) pp. 770-789.
DarwinHannahNeaveNick and HolmesJoni (2011). “Belief in Conspiracy Theories. The Role of Paranormal Belief, Paranoid Ideation and Schizotypy.” Personality and Individual Differences50 (8) pp. 1289-1293.
GinoFrancescaSchwietzerMaurice E.MeadNicole L. and ArielyDan (2011). “Unable to Resist Temptation: How Self-Control Depletion Promotes Unethical Behavior.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes115 (2) pp. 191-203.
McCornackS. A. (1997). “The Generation of Deceptive Messages: Laying the Groundwork for a Viable Theory of Interpersonal Deception.” In: J. O.Greene ed. Messages Production: Advances in Communication TheoryMahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers pp. 91-126.
McCornackS. A.MorrisonK.PaikJ. E.WisnerA. M. and ZhuX. (2014). “Information Manipulation Theory 2: A Propositional Theory of Deceptive Discourse Production.” Journal of Language and Social Psychology33 (4) pp. 348-377.
MeadNicole L.BaumeisterRoy F.GinoFrancescaSchweitzerMaurice E. and ArielyDan (2009). “Too Tired to Tell the Truth: Self-Control Resource Depletion and Dishonesty.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology45 (3) pp. 594-597.
MeierBrian P.David J.HauserMichael D.RobinsonChris KellandFriesen and KatieSchjeldahl (2007). “What’s ‘Up’ with God? Vertical Space as a Representation of the Divine.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology93 (5) pp. 699-710.
NewheiserAnna-KaisaMiguelFarias and NicoleTausch (2011). “The Functional Nature of Conspiracy Beliefs: Examining the Underpinnings of Belief in the Da Vinci Code Conspiracy.” Personality and Individual Differences51 (8) pp. 1007-1011.
PecherDianeHeleenvan MierloRouwenCañal-Bruland and RenéZeelenberg (2015). “The Burden of Secrecy? No Effect on Hill Slant Estimation and Beanbag Throwing.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: General144 (4) pp. e65-e72.
SabbaghMark A.Louis J.Moses and SeanShiverick (2006). “Executive Functioning and Preschoolers’ Understanding of False Beliefs, False Photographs, and False Signs.” Child Development77 (4) pp. 1034-1049.
SchjoedtU.H.Stodkilde-JorgensenA. W.GeertzT. E.Lund and A.Roepstorff (2011). “The Power of Charisma—Perceived Charisma Inhibits the Frontal Executive Network of Believers in Intercessory Prayer.” Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience6 (1) pp. 119-127.
SlepianM. L.E. J.Masicampo and N.Ambady (2014). “Relieving the Burdens of Secrecy: Revealing Secrets Influences Judgments of Hill Slant and Distance.” Social Psychological and Personality Science5 (3) pp. 293-300.
Stuckrad vonK. (2010). “Secrecy as Social Capital.” In: Andreas B.Kilcher ed. Constructing Tradition: Means and Myths of Transmission in Western Esotericism. Aries Book Seriesv. 11. Leiden ; Boston: Brill pp. 239-252.
TamKim-PongSau-LaiLee and Melody ManchiChao (2013). “Saving Mr. Nature: Anthropomorphism Enhances Connectedness to and Protectiveness toward Nature.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology49 (3) pp. 514-521.
VenetisMaria K.KathrynGreeneKateMagsamen-ConradSmita C.BanerjeeMaria G.Checton and ZhannaBagdasarov (2012). “‘You Can’t Tell Anyone but …’: Exploring the Use of Privacy Rules and Revealing Behaviors.” Communication Monographs79 (3) pp. 344-365.
VrijAldertKarlNunkoosingBethPatersonAnneriekeOosterwegel and StavroulaSoukara (2002). “Characteristics of Secrets and the Frequency, Reasons and Effects of Secrets Keeping and Disclosure.” Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology12 (1) pp. 56-70.
VrijAldertSamantha A.MannRonald P.FisherSharonLealRebeccaMilneRayBull (2008). “Increasing Cognitive Load to Facilitate Lie Detection: The Benefit of Recalling an Event in Reverse Order.” Law Hum Behav32 pp. 253-265.
WismeijerAndreas and Marcelvan Assen (2008). “Do Neuroticism and Extraversion Explain the Negative Association between Self-Concealment and Subjective Well-Being?” Personality and Individual Differences45 (5) pp. 345-349.