Rethinking Secrecy in Religion

Cognition and the Intimacy of Secrecy

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Secrecy is often studied as a social phenomenon in which certain information is concealed from a targeted audience out of fear of the repercussions, if this information were to fall into the wrong hands. It is therefore surprising that people are relatively willing to share their secrets with others. Traditionally, this behaviour has been explained on the bases of the assumption that people are naturally inclined to reveal their secrets. However, new evidence from the cognitive sciences and social psychology calls this assumption, and thus the theories of secrecy which rely on it, into question. In this article I present a re-interpretation of secrecy in light of this new evidence and evaluate what implications this holds for the study of secrecy in religion.

Rethinking Secrecy in Religion

Cognition and the Intimacy of Secrecy

in Method & Theory in the Study of Religion



Abraham von Worms (2006). “The Book of Abramelin.” In: Georg Dehn ed. The Book of Abramelin: A New TranslationLake Worth: Ibis Press pp. 1-184.

AirentiGabriella (2015). “The Cognitive Bases of Anthropomorphism: From Relatedness to Empathy.International Journal of Social Robotics 7 (1) pp. 117-127.

Asprem E. (2015). “Travelling Secrets: Reflections on the Epidemiology of Secretive Representations.” Presented at: The IAHR XXI Quinquennial World Congress Erfurt August 23-29.

BarrettJustin L. and KeilFrank C. (1996). “Conceptualizing a Nonnatural Entity: Anthropomorphism in God Concepts.Cognitive Psychology 31 (3) pp. 219-247.

BeringJesse (2011). The Belief Instinct: The Psychology of Souls Destiny and the Meaning of Life. New York: W.W. Norton & Company.

BokSissela (1983). Secrets: On the Ethics of Concealment and Revelation. New York: Pantheon Books.

BolleKees (1987). “Secrecy in Religions.” In: BolleK. Secrecy in ReligionsLeiden: E.J. Brill pp. 1-24.

BonusPeter (1894). “Pretiosa Margarita Novella (1546).” In: A. E. Waite trans. The New Pearl of Great PriceLondon: James Elliott & Co pp. 1-428.

BovensiepenJudith (2014). “Words of the Ancestors: Disembodied Knowledge and Secrecy in East Timor.Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 20 (1) pp. 56-73.

BulbuliaJoseph (2004). “The Cognitive and Evolutionary Psychology of Religion.Biology and Philosophy 19 (5) pp. 655-686.

ButterfieldMax E.HillSarah E. and LordCharles G. (2012). “Mangy Mutt or Furry Friend? Anthropomorphism Promotes Animal Welfare.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48 (4) pp. 957-960.

CarlsonStephanie M. and MosesLouis J. (2001). “Individual Differences in Inhibitory Control and Children’s Theory of Mind.Child Development 72 (4) pp. 1032-1053.

CasasantoDaniel and BoroditskyLera (2008). “Time in the Mind: Using Space to Think about Time.Cognition 106 (2) pp. 579-593.

CasoLetiziaGnisciAugustoVrijAldert and MannSamantha (2005). “Processes Underlying Deception: An Empirical Analysis of Truth and Lies When Manipulating the Stakes.Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling 2 (3) pp. 195-202.

CottrellCatherine A. and NeubergSteven L. (2005). “Different Emotional Reactions to Different Groups: A Sociofunctional Threat-Based Approach to ‘Prejudice’.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 88 (5) pp. 770-789.

DarwinHannahNeaveNick and HolmesJoni (2011). “Belief in Conspiracy Theories. The Role of Paranormal Belief, Paranoid Ideation and Schizotypy.Personality and Individual Differences 50 (8) pp. 1289-1293.

DebeyEvelyneVerschuereBruno and CrombezGeert (2012). “Lying and Executive Control: An Experimental Investigation Using Ego Depletion and Goal Neglect.Acta Psychologica 140 (2) pp. 133-141.

DunbarR. I. M. (2010). How Many Friends Does One Person Need?: Dunbar’s Number and Other Evolutionary Quirks. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.

EkmanP. and FriesenW. (1972). “Hand MovementsThe Journal of Communication 22 pp. 353-374.

EkmanPaul (1992). Telling Lies: Clues to Deceit in the Marketplace Politics and Marriage. New York: W.W. Norton.

GentnerDedreImaiMutsumi and BoroditskyLera (2002). “As Time Goes by: Evidence for Two Systems in Processing Space → Time Metaphors.Language and Cognitive Processes 17 (5) pp. 537-565.

GibsonDavid R. (2014). “Enduring Illusions The Social Organization of Secrecy and Deception.Sociological Theory 32 (4) pp. 283-306.

GinoFrancescaSchwietzerMaurice E.MeadNicole L. and ArielyDan (2011). “Unable to Resist Temptation: How Self-Control Depletion Promotes Unethical Behavior.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 115 (2) pp. 191-203.

GoffmanErving (1956). The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh Social Sciences Research Centre.

GordonHeidi M.LyonThomas D. and LeeKang (2014). “Social and Cognitive Factors Associated With Children’s Secret-Keeping for a Parent.Child Development.

GuniaB. C.WangL.HuangL.WangJ. and MurnighanJ. K. (2012). “Contemplation and Conversation: Subtle Influences on Moral Decision Making.Academy of Management Journal 55 (1) pp. 13-33.

HanegraaffWouter J. (2012). Esotericism and the Academy: Rejected Knowledge in Western Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

HanegraaffWouter J. (2013). “The Power of Ideas: Esotericism, Historicism, and the Limits of Discourse.Religion 43 (2) pp. 252-273.

HanegraaffWouter J. (2006). “Esotericism.” In: Wouter J. Hanegraaff ed. Dictionary of Gnosis & Western EsotericismLeiden ; Boston: Brill pp. 336-340.

IronsWilliam (1996). “Morality, Religion and Human Evolution.Religion and Science: History Method and Dialogue pp. 375-399.

JohnsonPaul Christopher (2006). “Secretism and the Apotheosis of Duvalier.Journal of the American Academy of Religion 74 (2) pp. 420-445.

JohnsonPaul Christopher (2006). “Secrets, Gossip, and Gods: The Transformation of Brazilian Candomblé.Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions 9 (4) pp. 129-130.

JütteDaniel (2015). The Age of Secrecy: Jews Christians and the Economy of Secrets 1400-1800. New Haven: Yale University Press.

KellyA. E. (1998). “Clients’ Secret Keeping in Outpatient Therapy.Journal of Counseling Psychology 45 pp. 50-57.

KellyAnita E. (2002). The Psychology of Secrets. The Plenum Series in Social/Clinical Psychology. Boston, MA: Springer US.

KellyAnita E. and YipJonathan J. (2006). “Is Keeping a Secret or Being a Secretive Person Linked to Psychological Symptoms?Journal of Personality 74 (5) pp. 1349-1370.

KurzbanRobert and LearyMark R. (2001). “Evolutionary Origins of Stigmatization: The Functions of Social Exclusion.Psychological Bulletin 127 (2) pp. 187-208.

KurzbanR. & NeubergS. (2005). “Managing Ingroup and Outgroup Relationships.” In: David M. Buss ed. The Handbook of Evolutionary PsychologyHoboken, N.J: John Wiley & Sons pp. 653-675.

LakoffGeorge and JohnsonMark (1980). Metaphors We Live By. Chicago, London: Chicago University Press.

LaneJulie D. and WegnerDaniel M. (1995). “The Cognitive Consequences of Secrecy.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 69 (2) pp. 237-253.

LarsonDale G. and ChastainRobert L. (1990). “Self-Concealment: Conceptualization, Measurement, and Health Implications.Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology 9 (4) pp. 439-455.

LawsonE. Thomas and McCauleyRobert N. (1996). Rethinking Religion: Connecting Cognition and Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

LeBelEtienne P. and WilburChristopher J. (2014). “Big Secrets Do Not Necessarily Cause Hills to Appear Steeper.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 21 (3) pp. 696-700.

LevineT. R. (2014). “Truth-Default Theory (TDT): A Theory of Human Deception and Deception Detection.Journal of Language and Social Psychology 33 (4) pp. 378-392.

LevineTimothy R.ParkHee Sun and McCornackSteven A. (1999). “Accuracy in Detecting Truths and Lies: Documenting the ‘Veracity Effect.’Communication Monographs 66 (2) pp. 125-144.

LongPamela O. (2001). Openness Secrecy Authorship: Technical Arts and the Culture of Knowledge from Antiquity to the Renaissance. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

LuhrmannTanya M. (1989) “The Magic of Secrecy.Ethos 17 (2) pp. 131-165.

McCornackS. A. (1997). “The Generation of Deceptive Messages: Laying the Groundwork for a Viable Theory of Interpersonal Deception.” In: J. O. Greene ed. Messages Production: Advances in Communication Theory Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers pp. 91-126.

McCornackS. A.MorrisonK.PaikJ. E.WisnerA. M. and ZhuX. (2014). “Information Manipulation Theory 2: A Propositional Theory of Deceptive Discourse Production.Journal of Language and Social Psychology 33 (4) pp. 348-377.

MeadNicole L.BaumeisterRoy F.GinoFrancescaSchweitzerMaurice E. and ArielyDan (2009). “Too Tired to Tell the Truth: Self-Control Resource Depletion and Dishonesty.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 45 (3) pp. 594-597.

MeierBrian P.David J. HauserMichael D. RobinsonChris Kelland Friesen and Katie Schjeldahl (2007). “What’s ‘Up’ with God? Vertical Space as a Representation of the Divine.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 93 (5) pp. 699-710.

MeierBrian P. and Michael D. Robinson (2006). “Does ‘Feeling Down’ Mean Seeing Down? Depressive Symptoms and Vertical Selective Attention.Journal of Research in Personality 40 (4) pp. 451-461.

MillerGeoffrey F. (2007). “Sexual Selection for Moral Virutes.The Quarterly Review of Biology 82 (2) pp. 97-125.

NewheiserAnna-KaisaMiguel Farias and Nicole Tausch (2011). “The Functional Nature of Conspiracy Beliefs: Examining the Underpinnings of Belief in the Da Vinci Code Conspiracy.Personality and Individual Differences 51 (8) pp. 1007-1011.

PecherDianeHeleen van MierloRouwen Cañal-Bruland and René Zeelenberg (2015). “The Burden of Secrecy? No Effect on Hill Slant Estimation and Beanbag Throwing.Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 144 (4) pp. e65-e72.

PetronioSandra Sporbert (2002). Boundaries of Privacy: Dialectics of Disclosure. SUNY Series in Communication Studies. Albany: State University of New York Press.

PiazzaJared and Jesse M. Bering (2010). “The Coevolution of Secrecy and Stigmatization: Evidence from the Content of Distressing Secrets.Human Nature 21 (3) pp. 290-308.

RigneyDaniel (1979). “Secrecy and Social Cohesion.Society 16 (4) pp. 52-55.

RodriguezNoelie and Alan L. Ryave (1992). “The Structural Organization and Micropolitics of Everyday Secret Telling Interactions.Qualitative Sociology 15 (3) pp. 297-318.

SabbaghMark A.Louis J. Moses and Sean Shiverick (2006). “Executive Functioning and Preschoolers’ Understanding of False Beliefs, False Photographs, and False Signs.Child Development 77 (4) pp. 1034-1049.

SchallerMarkJustin Park and Jason Faulkner (2003). “Prehistoric Dangers and Contemporary Prejudices.European Review of Social Psychology 14 pp. 105-137.

SchjoedtU.H. Stodkilde-JorgensenA. W. GeertzT. E. Lund and A. Roepstorff (2011). “The Power of Charisma—Perceived Charisma Inhibits the Frontal Executive Network of Believers in Intercessory Prayer.Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 6 (1) pp. 119-127.

ShalviS.EldarO. and Bereby-MeyerY.(2012). “Honesty Requires Time (and Lack of Justifications).Psychological Science 23 (10) pp. 1264-1270.

SlepianMichael L.E. J. MasicampoNegin R. Toosi and Nalini Ambady (2012). “The Physical Burdens of Secrecy.Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 141 (4) pp. 619-624.

SlepianM. L.E. J. Masicampo and N. Ambady (2014). “Relieving the Burdens of Secrecy: Revealing Secrets Influences Judgments of Hill Slant and Distance.Social Psychological and Personality Science 5 (3) pp. 293-300.

SimmelGeorg (1906). “The Sociology of Secrecy and secret Societies.American Journal of Sociology 11 (4) pp. 441-498.

SosisRichard and Candace Alcorta (2003). “Signaling, Solidarity, and the Sacred: The Evolution of Religious Behavior.Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues News and Reviews 12 (6) pp. 264-274.

Stuckrad vonK. (2010). “Secrecy as Social Capital.” In: Andreas B. Kilcher ed. Constructing Tradition: Means and Myths of Transmission in Western Esotericism. Aries Book Seriesv. 11. Leiden ; Boston: Brill pp. 239-252.

SunsteinCass R. and Adrian Vermeule (2009). “Conspiracy Theories: Causes and Cures*.Journal of Political Philosophy 17 (2) pp. 202-227.

TamKim-PongSau-Lai Lee and Melody Manchi Chao (2013). “Saving Mr. Nature: Anthropomorphism Enhances Connectedness to and Protectiveness toward Nature.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 49 (3) pp. 514-521.

ThibodeauPaul H. and Lera Boroditsky (2011). “Metaphors We Think with: The Role of Metaphor in Reasoning.PLoS One 6 (2) e16782.

UrbanHugh B. (2001). The Economics of Ecstasy: Tantra Secrecy and Power in Colonial Bengal. New York: Oxford University Press.

UrbanHugh B. (2007). “Secrecy and New Religious Movements: Concealment, Surveillance, and Privacy in a New Age of Information.Religion Compass 2 (1) pp. 66-83.

Urquiza-HaasEsmeralda G. and Kurt Kotrschal (2015). “The Mind behind Anthropomorphic Thinking: Attribution of Mental States to Other Species.Animal Behaviour 109 pp. 167-176.

VendemiaJennifer MCRobert F. Buzan and Eric P. Green (2005). “Practice Effects, Workload, and Reaction Time in Deception.The American Journal of Psychology 118 (3) pp. 413-429.

VenetisMaria K.Kathryn GreeneKate Magsamen-ConradSmita C. BanerjeeMaria G. Checton and Zhanna Bagdasarov (2012). “‘You Can’t Tell Anyone but …’: Exploring the Use of Privacy Rules and Revealing Behaviors.Communication Monographs 79 (3) pp. 344-365.

VerschuereB. and S. Shalvi (2014). “The Truth Comes Naturally! Does It?Journal of Language and Social Psychology 33 (4) pp. 417-423.

VrijAldertGun R. Semin and Ray Bull (1996). “Insight into Behavior Displayed during Deception.Human Communication Research 22 (4) pp. 544-562.

VrijAldertKarl NunkoosingBeth PatersonAnnerieke Oosterwegel and Stavroula Soukara (2002). “Characteristics of Secrets and the Frequency, Reasons and Effects of Secrets Keeping and Disclosure.Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology 12 (1) pp. 56-70.

VrijAldertSamantha A. MannRonald P. FisherSharon LealRebecca MilneRay Bull (2008). “Increasing Cognitive Load to Facilitate Lie Detection: The Benefit of Recalling an Event in Reverse Order.Law Hum Behav 32 pp. 253-265.

WismeijerAndreas and Marcel van Assen (2008). “Do Neuroticism and Extraversion Explain the Negative Association between Self-Concealment and Subjective Well-Being?Personality and Individual Differences 45 (5) pp. 345-349.

WismeijerAndreasMarcel van Assen and Marrie Bekker (2014). “The Relations Between Secrecy, Rejection Sensitivity and Autonomy-Connectedness.The Journal of General Psychology 141 (2) pp. 65-79.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 67 67 28
Full Text Views 104 104 49
PDF Downloads 14 14 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0