Synesius of Cyrene and the American “Synesii”

In: Numen

This article explores the Hellenic/Christian synthesis of bishop Synesius and its later influence, especially on nineteenth-century America. Synesius accepted a bishopric despite Neoplatonic reservations concerning Christian doctrine: the uncreated soul pre-exists; the uncreated cosmos is eternal; and the “resurrection” an ineffable mystery, beyond the vulgar. Whether or not born a Christian, his study under Hypatia brought about a conversion to “pagan” Neoplatonism. His attempted synthesis of Hellenism and Christianity was unique, unlike that of any other late antique Christian Platonist.

Later, Renaissance thinkers scanned a new religious horizon reviving Hellenic Neoplatonism, Hermetic thought, Pythagoreanism, etc., included in a “primordial revelation,” contemporaneous with the Mosaic revelation and thereby in harmony with Christianity.

In Romantic-era England, Thomas Taylor revived Hellenic Neoplatonism as the “true” religion, in the spirit of the anti-Christian theurgic Neoplatonist Roman emperor, Julian. Taylor had a significant influence on the American “Synesii,” Transcendentalists and Neoplatonists, e.g., on Bronson Alcott’s Platonic/Pythagorean lifestyle. Reading Taylor’s translations, Ralph Waldo Emerson spoke of the “Trismegisti” whose Neoplatonic religion predated and superseded “parvenu” Christianity. Later Transcendentalists continued the work of Taylor, sympathizing with late antique “pagan” Neoplatonism, but, in the spirit of Synesius, synthesizing it with Christianity and with other religions. They sought a non-sectarian, universal “cosmic theism,” notably through Thomas M. Johnson’s journal, The Platonist, which included translations of Synesius and other Neoplatonists. One of its contributors, Alexander Wilder, also influenced Theosophy on its Neoplatonic side.

More recent Anglophone “Synesii” include Hilary Armstrong, who was a major presence in Neoplatonic scholarship, both in the uk and North America. He argued for a return to Hellenic inclusive monotheism, in which a Christian Platonist, like himself, could also venerate Hindu or Isis’ holy images as being true reflections of the divine.

  • AllenMichael J. B. Icastes: Marsilio Ficino’s Interpretation of Plato’s Sophist 1989 Berkeley and Los Angeles University of California Press

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • ArmstrongHilary A. 1992 Personal communication to author. May.

  • ArmstrongHilary A. 1993 Personal communication to author. January

  • BlavatskyHelena Petrovna Isis Unveiled 2 vols New York Bouton Introduction “Before the Veil” by Alexander Wilder

  • BregmanJay. Synesius of Cyrene: Philosopher-Bishop 1982 Berkeley and Los Angeles University of California Press

  • BregmanJay “The Neoplatonic Revival in North America.” Hermathena 1990 149 99 119

  • BregmanJay “Thomas M. Johnson the Platonist.” Dionysius 1991 15 91 112

  • BregmanJay “The Contemporary Christian Platonism of A. H. Armstrong.” Alexandria 1997 4 181 193

  • BregmanJay GersonLloyd P. “Synesius of Cyrene.” The Cambridge History of Philosophy in Late Antiquity 2010 Vol. 1 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 520 537

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • BregmanJay CorriganKevinRasimusTuomas “Neoplatonizing Gnosticism and Gnosticizing Neoplatonism in the ‘American Baroque.’ ” Gnosticism Platonism and the Late Ancient World: Essays in Honour of John D. Turner 2013 Leiden Brill 609 629

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • CulianuIoan P. Eros and Magic in the Renaissance 1987 Chicago University of Chicago Press

  • DoddsEric R. Proclus The Elements of Theology: A Revised Text With Translation Introduction and Commentary 1963 2nd ed Oxford Clarendon Press

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • EliadeMircea The Quest: History and Meaning in Religion 1969 Chicago University of Chicago Press

  • EmersonRalph Waldo RichardsonRobert D.Jr. Ralph Waldo Emerson: Selected Essays Lectures and Poems 1990 New York Bantam Classic

  • Eunapius François BoissonadeJean Vitae Sophistarum 1849 Paris Editore Ambrosio Firmin Didot

  • FullerRobert C. Spiritual But Not Religious: Understanding Unchurched America 2001 Oxford Oxford University Press

  • GarzyaAntonio Opere di Sinesio di Cirene: epistole operette inni 1989 Turin Unione Tipografico-Editrice Torinese

  • GodwinJoscelyn Music Mysticism and Magic: A Sourcebook 1987 New York and London Arkana Paperbacks

  • GodwinJoscelyn Harmonies of Heaven and Earth: Mysticism in Music from Antiquity to the Avant-Garde 1995 Rochester, Vt. Inner Traditions International

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • GodwinJoscelyn The Pagan Dream of the Renaissance 2002 Grand Rapids, Mich. Phanes Press

  • GrayJohn The Immortalization Commission: Science and the Strange Quest to Cheat Death 2011 New York Farrar, Strauss and Giroux

  • HarperGeorge Mills RaineKathleenMills HarperGeorge “Thomas Taylor in America.” Thomas Taylor the Platonist 1969 Princeton Princeton University Press 49 102

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • JohnsonThomas M. The Platonist i 1881 St Louis, Mo.

  • JohnsonThomas M. The Platonist iii 1887 Osceola, Mo.

  • JohnsonThomas M. The Platonist iv 1888 Osceola, Mo.

  • Julian WrightW.C. “Against the Galilaeans.” Julian 1923 vol. 3 London William Heinemann 313 427

  • KarlsonHenry “Theophilus of Alexandria iii: Synesius of Cyrene.” Vox Nova 2008 accessed 10 August 2013 url: Vox-Nova.com/2008/04/28

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • MarrouH. I. MomiglianoArnaldo “Synesius of Cyrene and Alexandrian Neoplatonism.” The Conflict Between Paganism and Christianity in the Fourth Century 1963 Oxford Oxford University Press 128 150

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • MyerIsaac Qabbalah: The Philosophy of Ibn Gebirol The Qabbalah and the Zohar 1988 San Diego Wizards Bookshelf

  • NockA. D. Conversion 1963 Oxford Oxford University Press

  • RaineKathleen RaineKathleenMills HarperGeorge “Thomas Taylor in England.” Thomas Taylor the Platonist 1969 Princeton Princeton University Press 3 48

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • “Synesius of Cyrene, 370?–415?” Amos Bronson Alcott Network accessed 10 August 2013 url: http://www.alcott.net/cgi-bin/home/champions/Synesius.html

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • TaylorThomas Sallust on the Gods and the World 1793 London

  • TaylorThomas Select Works of Plotinus the Great Restorer of the Philosophy of Plato; and Extracts from the Treatise of Synesius on Providence 1817 London

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • TaylorThomas Iamblichus’ Life of Pythagoras 1818 London

  • TaylorThomas The Arguments of the Emperor Julian against the Christians 1873 [1809] London

  • TerzaghiNicola Synesius Cyrenensis opuscula 1944 Rome Typis Publicae Officinae Polygraphicae

  • VersluisArthur American Transcendentalism and Asian Religions 1993 New York Oxford University Press

  • WilkenRobert L. John Chrysostom and the Jews: Rhetoric and Reality in the Late Fourth Century 1983 Berkeley and Los Angeles University of California Press

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 4

    Marrou 1963: 146. Augustine called it dificillima quaestio. Nemesius of Emesa openly proposed the pre-existence of the soul. He was refuting Methodius of Olympus’ naïve idea that the soul was created after the body implying ontological inferiority; the latter was trying to refute Origen’s pre-existence doctrine but Origen also posited a prior spiritual creation. See also Bregman 2010: 32–33.

  • 12

    Robert L. Wilken (1983) argues for the attitudes of a nervous recently triumphant Orthodoxy on many fronts versus Jews heretics and Hellenes during the still raging religious conflicts in the fourth-century Greek East.

  • 24

    See Versluis 1993: 131where he presents Brownson as an apologist against a “new paganism.”

  • 25

    Johnson 1881: 3–6. It is possible here that Wilder was influenced by Emerson’s Poem “The Sphinx” perhaps following a clue in Taylor’s footnote on the Sphinx. See note 22 above.

  • 30

    The Emerson passage is quoted in Bregman 1991: 96–97 n. 24. Harper emphasizes Emerson’s “revivalists” enthusiasm for Iamblichus (1969: 56).

  • 38

    Versluis 1993: 238. Thus Neoplatonism is the intellectual “key” to all Traditions which are grasped as the Self Joins the Over-Soul.

  • 4

    0 1987: 304–305 n. 7. The translator expands on the syncretism of Synesius: 304 n. 3: “Synesius sets the Harrowing of Hell in the classical Tartarus”; and 305 n. 7: “The passage through the sphere of the Fixed Stars brings the voyager to the end of the sensible realm and into the intelligible sometimes envisaged as a further series of concentric but immaterial spheres.” See also 1987: 304–305 nn. 1 2 4 5 8.

  • 41

    Godwin 1995: 180–181. On 1995: 178–180 Godwin presents Albert von Thimus’ complex discussion with detailed diagrams of the Lambdoma and the Pythagorean Table. The overtone/undertone series which Hans Kayser and von Thimus working from a discovered manuscript of Iamblichus’ Commentary on NichomachusArithmetic concluded provided a hint that Greeks had discovered those series and could diagrammatically express them in the shape of the Greek letter lambda.

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 53 46 7
Full Text Views 158 151 0
PDF Downloads 15 12 0