Parliamentary Inquiries: an Underestimated Anticorruption Tool
In: International Journal of Parliamentary StudiesSearch for other papers by Tilman Hoppe in
Current site
Google Scholar
Search for other papers by Juan Ticona in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
In countries with high levels of corruption, ruling elites rarely have an interest in meaningful anticorruption reforms. Thus, within state structures, the opposition is often key in controlling the government. At the same time, no state body has wider jurisdiction than parliament. Therefore, empowering the opposition to inquire into corruption (and other) scandals is a key factor in an integrity system. The German system of strong opposition rights in collecting evidence through parliamentary inquiry committees has been a unique selling point by global comparison until 2014, when it was emulated by Austria. An analysis of the 63 inquiry committees of the Bundestag since 1949 shows that a significant share concerned corruption cases. Had it not been for parliamentary inquiries, most of these cases would have remained without any follow-up by a state institution. In stark contrast to this finding, international anticorruption guidance more or less entirely ignores inquiry committees.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Austrian Parliament (2014). Parlamentskorrespondenz Nr. 1190 [Parliamentary Correspondence No. 1190]. December 10. https://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/PR/JAHR_2014/PK1190/index.shtml.
-
bka (2020). Korruption Bundeslagebild 2019 [Corruption Federal Situation Picture 2019], Wiesbaden: BKA.
-
bmi (2020). Polizeiliche Kriminalstatistik 2019 [Police crime statistics 2019]. Berlin: BMI.
-
Butzer, Hermann (2015). In: C. Waldhoff and K. F. Gärditz, eds. PUAG, Untersuchungsausschussgesetz [Committee of Inquiry Act], Vorbemerkungen. 1st ed. Munich: C.H. Beck.
-
Der Spiegel (1984, 2006). Ein hohes Maß an Heuchelei [A high degree of hypocrisy]. October 28. Ein Mann kaufte die Republik [One man bought the Republic]. October 6. https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/die-flick-affaere-ein-mannkaufte-die-republik-a-441136.html.
-
Der Spiegel (2009). Germany’s Schreiber Affair: The Scandal that Helped Merkel Become Chancellor. August 7. https://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/germany-s-schreiber-affair-the-scandal-that-helped-merkel-become-chancellor-a-640938.html.
-
Deutschlandfunk (2005). Jahrelange Bargeldzahlungen an prominente Politiker [Years of cash payments to prominent politicians]. August 29. https://www.deutschlandfunk.de/jahrelange-bargeldzahlungen-an-prominente-politiker.871.de.html?dram:article_id=125252.
-
Deutschlandfunk (2021). Politische Abgründe in Österreich [Political Abysses in Austria]. July 13. https://www.deutschlandfunk.de/ibiza-untersuchungsausschuss-politische-abgruende-in.724.de.html?dram:article_id=500205.
-
Diefenbach-Trommer, Stefan (2016). Wenn Politik gemeinnützig ist [When politics is charitable]. Frankfurter Rundschau. June 6.
-
European Parliament (2020). Committees of Inquiry in National Parliaments, Comparative Survey. Brussels: European Union.
-
German Bundestag (1951a). Abschlussbericht des Untersuchungsausschuss „Spiegel“ [Report of the Committee of Inquiry „Spiegel“]. bt-Drs. I/2274. Berlin: Bundestag.
-
German Bundestag (1974). Abschlussbericht des Untersuchungsausschuss „Steiner-Wienand“ [Report of the Committee of Inquiry „Steiner-Wienand”]. bt-Drs. 7/1803. Berlin: Bundestag.
-
German Bundestag (1986). Abschlussbericht des Untersuchungsausschuss „Flick-Affäre“ [Report of the Committee of Inquiry “Flick Affair”]. bt-Drs. 10/5079. Berlin: Bundestag.
-
German Bundestag (1990). Abschlussbericht des Untersuchungsausschuss „Atomskandal/Transnuklear“ [Report of the Committee of Inquiry „Nuclear Scandal/ Transnuklear“]. bt-Drs. 11/7800. Berlin: Bundestag.
-
German Bundestag (2002). Abschlussbericht des Untersuchungsausschuss „Parteispendenaffäre“ [Report of the Committee of Inquiry „Party donation affair”]. bt-Drs. 14/19300. Berlin: Bundestag.
-
German Federal Office for Radiation Protection (2015). Bundesamt für Strahlenschutz 1989–2014 [German Federal Office for Radiation Protection 1989–2014]. Salzgitter: German Federal Office for Radiation Protection.
-
gopac (2005). Controlling Corruption, A Parliamentarian’s Handbook. Ottawa: GOPAC.
-
gopac (2013). Anti-Corruption Assessment Tool for Parliamentarians. Ottawa: GOPAC.
-
Hellman, Joel, Jones, Geraint, and Kaufmann, Daniel (2003). Seize the state, seize the day: state capture and influence in transition economies. Journal of Comparative Economics 2003 (31), pp. 751–773.
-
Hoppe, Tilman (2011). Public Corruption: Limiting Criminal Immunity of Legislative, Executive and Judicial Officials in Europe. 5 Vienna Journal on International Constitutional Law 2011, pp. 538–549.
-
Hoppe, Tilman (2014). The case for asset declarations in the judiciary: Identifying illicit enrichment and conflicts of interests. U4 Brief May 2014 No. 5.
-
Hoppe, Tilman (2015). In: C. Waldhoff and K. F. Gärditz, eds. PUAG, Untersuchungsausschussgesetz [Committee of Inquiry Act], § 10. 1st ed. Munich: C.H. Beck.
-
Hoppe, Tilman (2021). Money Talks, The ECtHR is Getting Rid of Corrupt Judges. Verfassungsblog. May 5. https://verfassungsblog.de/money-talks/.
-
Institute Alternative (2012). Parliamentary Inquiry in Montenegro, Oversight Tool Lacking Political Support. Podgorica: Institute Alternative.
-
International Parliamentary Union – ipu (2007), Tools for parliamentary oversight, A comparative study of 88 national parliaments, Geneva.
-
Kirya, Monica Twesiime (2011). Performing “good governance”: Commissions of Inquiry and the Fight against Corruption in Uganda. Degree Thesis, School of Law, University of Warwick.
-
Klein, Hans-Hugo (2015). In: G. Dürig, R. Herzog, and R. Scholz, Grundgesetz-Kommentar [Commentary on the Constitution], Art. 44. 76th ed. Munich: C.H. Beck.
-
Lenz, Christofer (2002). Das neue Parteienfinanzierungsrecht [The new party financing law]. Neue Zeitschrift für Verwaltung 2002, pp. 769–779.
-
Mason, Phil (2019). Reflections of an anti-corruption fighter – part ii. May 20. https://voices.transparency.org/reflections-of-an-anti-corruption-fighter-638f3c5b2411.
-
ndr (2013). Gebeugte Wahrheit: Björn Engholms Rücktritt [Bent Truth: Björn Engholm’s Resignation]. May 5. https://www.ndr.de/geschichte/chronologie/Gebeugte-Wahrheit-Engholms-Ruecktritt,engholm123.html.
-
oecd (2014). Accountability and Democratic Governance: Orientations and Principles for Development, dac Guidelines and Reference Series. Paris: OECD.
-
osce (2016). Handbook on Combating Corruption. Vienna: OSCE.
-
Riede, Matthias, and Scheller, Henrik (2013). Parlamentarische Untersuchungsausschüsse im Deutschen Bundestag – bloßes Skandalisierungsinstrument der Opposition? [Parliamentary Committees of Inquiry in the German Bundestag - Mere Scandalising Instrument of the Opposition?]. Zeitschrift für Parlamentsfragen 2013 (1), pp. 93–114.
-
Stapenhurst, Rick, Pellizo, Riccardo, and Johnstonn, Niall (2006). The Role of Parliaments in Curbing Corruption. Washington, DC: World Bank.
-
Stern (2008). Geheimdienstler scheitern an Telefonbuch [Secret service dash against phone book]. April 28. https://www.stern.de/politik/deutschland/verfassungsschutz-geheimdienstler-scheitern-an-telefonbuch-3087960.html.
-
SZ.de (2020). Was ein Untersuchungsausschuss bewirken kann [What a Committee of Inquiry can achieve]. July 31. https://www.sueddeutsche.de/politik/wirecard-untersuchungsausschuss-olaf-scholz-bundestag-1.4985335.
-
UN (2014). Anti-corruption Toolkit. 2nd ed. Vienna: UNODC.
-
Van Aaken, Anne (2005). Genügt das deutsche Recht den Anforderungen der vn-Konvention gegen Korruption? [Does German law meet the requirements of the UN Convention against Corruption?]. Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 2005 (65), pp. 407–446.
-
Von Trapp, Lisa (2008). Enhancing the Effectiveness of Parliaments: Challenges and Opportunities. 934th Wilton Park Conference, 27–30 October 2008.
-
Wolf, Markus (1997). Spionagechef im geheimen Krieg, Erinnerungen [Spy Chief in the Secret War, Memories]. Munich: List.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 387 | 131 | 12 |
| Full Text Views | 97 | 4 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 143 | 11 | 0 |
Parliamentary Inquiries: an Underestimated Anticorruption Tool
In: International Journal of Parliamentary StudiesSearch for other papers by Tilman Hoppe in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Search for other papers by Juan Ticona in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
In countries with high levels of corruption, ruling elites rarely have an interest in meaningful anticorruption reforms. Thus, within state structures, the opposition is often key in controlling the government. At the same time, no state body has wider jurisdiction than parliament. Therefore, empowering the opposition to inquire into corruption (and other) scandals is a key factor in an integrity system. The German system of strong opposition rights in collecting evidence through parliamentary inquiry committees has been a unique selling point by global comparison until 2014, when it was emulated by Austria. An analysis of the 63 inquiry committees of the Bundestag since 1949 shows that a significant share concerned corruption cases. Had it not been for parliamentary inquiries, most of these cases would have remained without any follow-up by a state institution. In stark contrast to this finding, international anticorruption guidance more or less entirely ignores inquiry committees.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 387 | 131 | 12 |
| Full Text Views | 97 | 4 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 143 | 11 | 0 |
