Governmentality and the Analytics of Development

in Perspectives on Global Development and Technology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

In this article, I discuss the extension of Foucault’s work on governmentality into the fields of global studies in general and development studies in particular. Drawing on insights from postdevelopment theory and critical race theory, I present an adaptation of governmentality—labeled developmentality—that is intended to bridge the gap between those studies dealing with the regulatory aspects of development in the global South and those dealing with construction of ethical identities in the North.

Governmentality and the Analytics of Development

in Perspectives on Global Development and Technology

Sections

References

AndersonB. Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism 1991 2nd ed. New York, NY Verso

BarryA. “The European community and European government: Harmonization, mobility, and space.” Economy and Society 1993 22 3 314 326

BarryA. BarryA.OsborneT.RoseN. “Lines of communication and spaces of rule.” 1996 Foucault and political reason: Liberalism neo-liberalism and rationalities of government 123 142 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

BarryA.OsborneT.RoseN. Foucault and political reason: Liberalism neo-liberalism and rationalities of government 1996 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

BhabhaH. The location of culture 1994 New York, NY Routledge Classics

BornsteinE. “Developing faith: Theologies of economic development in Zimbabwe.” Journal of Religion in Africa 2002 32 1 4 31

BourdieuP. NiceR. The logic of practice 1980/1990 Cambridge, UK Polity Press

BratichJ.PackerJ.McCarthyC. Foucault cultural studies and governmentality 2003 New York, NY SUNY Press

BurchellG. BarryA.OsborneT.RoseN. “Liberal government and techniques of the self.” Foucault and political reason: Liberalism neo-liberalism and rationalities of government 1996 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press 19 36

BurchellG.GordonC.MillerP. The Foucault effect: Studies in governmentality 1991 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

CixousH. SchriftA. “Sorties: Out and out: Attacks/ways out/forays.” The logic of the gift: Toward an ethic of generosity 1975/1997 New York, NY Routledge 148 173

CruikshankB. BarryA.OsborneT.RoseN. “Revolutions within: Self-government and self-esteem.” Foucault and political reason: Liberalism neo-liberalism and rationalities of government 1996 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press 231 252

CruikshankB. The will to empower: Democratic citizens and other subjects 1999 Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press

DeanM. Governmentality: Power and rule in modern society 1999 Los Angeles, CA Sage

DeanM. HansenT.StepputatF. “Demonic Societies: Liberalism, biopolitics, and sovereignty.” States of imagination: Ethnographic explorations of the post-colonial state 2001 Durham, NC Duke University Press 41 64

DeanMHindessB. Governing Australia: Studies in contemporary rationalities of government 1998 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press

DebD. Beyond developmentality: Constructing inclusive freedom and sustainability 2009 London, UK Earthscan

DelgadoR.StefancicJ. Critical race theory: An introduction 2001 New York, NY New York University Press

DerridaJ. KamufP. Given time: Counterfeit money (Vol. 1) 1992 Chicago, IL Chicago University Press

DillonM. LarnerW.WaltersW. “The security of governance.” Global governmentality: Governing international spaces 2004 London, UK Routledge 76 94

DuttonM. “9/11: The after-life of colonial governmentality.” Postcolonial Studies 2009 12 3 303 314

EscobarA. Encountering development: The making and unmaking of the third world 1995 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press

EstevaG. SachsW. “Development.” The development dictionary: A guide to knowledge as power 1992 London, UK Zed books 6 25

FabreC. Justice in a changing world 2007 Cambridge, UK Polity

FanonF. PhilcoxR. Black skin white masks 1952/2008 New York, NY Grove

FendlerL. HultqvistK.DahlbergG. “Educating flexible souls: The construction of subjectivity through developmentality and interaction.” Governing the child in the new millennium 2001 New York, NY Routledge 199 142

FergusonJ. The anti-politics machine: Development depoliticization and bureaucratic power in Lesotho 1994 Minneapolis, MN University of Minnesota Press

FishkinJ. EllisA. “Theories of justice and international relations: The Limits of liberal theory.” Ethics and international relations 1986 Manchester Manchester University Press 1 23

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “What is critique?” The essential Foucault 1971/2003 New York, NY New Press 263 278

FoucaultM. MaceyD. Society must be defended: Lectures at the Collège de France 1975-1976 1976/2003 New York, NY Picador

FoucaultM. HurleyR. The history of sexuality: An introduction 1978/1990 New York, NY Vintage Books

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “Governmentality.” The essential Foucault 1978/2003 New York, NY New Press 229 245

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “The birth of biopolitics.” The essential Foucault 1979a/2003 New York, NY New Press 202 207

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “ ‘Omnes et Singulatim’: Toward a critique of political reason.” The essential Foucault 1979b/2003 New York, NY New Press 180 201

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “The masked philosopher.” The essential Foucault 1980a/2003 New York, NY New Press 174 179

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “Questions of method.” The essential Foucault 1980b/2003 New York, NY New Press 246 262

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “The subject and power.” The essential Foucault 1982a/2003 New York, NY New Press 126 144

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “Technologies of the self.” The essential Foucault 1982b/2003 New York, NY New Press 145 173

FoucaultM. RabinowP.RoseN. “The Ethics of the Concern of the Self as a Practice of Freedom.” The essential Foucault 1984a/2003 New York, NY New Press 25 42

FoucaultM. SenellartM. BurchellG. Security territory population: Lectures at the Collège de France 1977-1978 2007 New York, NY Palgrave Macmillan

FoucaultM. SenellartM. BurchellG. The birth of biopolitics: Lectures at the Collège de France 1978-1979 2008 New York, NY Palgrave Macmillan

GordonC. BurchellG.GordonC.MillerP. “Governmental rationality: An introduction” “The Foucault effect: Studies in governmentality” 1991 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press 1 52

Government of Canada “Personal income tax relief for all taxpayers” “Canada’s economic action plan” 2010 May 29 (http://www.actionplan.gc.ca/)

HallS. HallS. “The spectacle of the ‘Other’” “Representation: Cultural representations and signifying practices” 1997 London, UK Sage 223 290

HelliwellC.HindessB. “The ‘Empire of Uniformity’ and the government of subject peoples” “Cultural Values” 2002 6 1-2 139 152

HindessB. “Citizenship in the international management of populations” “American Behavioural Scientist” 2000 43 9 1486 1497

HindessB. “The liberal government of unfreedom” “Alternatives” 2001 26 93 111

HindessB. “Neo-liberal citizenship” “Citizenship Studies” 2002 6 2 127 143

HultqvistK.DahlbergG. “Governing the child in the new millennium” 2001 London, UK Routledge

IlcanS.PhillipsL. “Global developmentalities” 2006 Keynote address: “Technocracy@Development Conference”. The University of Wageningen The Netherlands. June 26-28 2006 (http://www.ceres.wur.nl/)

KellyP. “Liberalism” 2005 Cambridge, UK Polity Press

KingS. BratichJ.PackerJ.McCarthyC. “Doing good by running well: Breast cancer, the race for the cure, and new technologies of ethical citizenship” “Foucault cultural studies and governmentality” 2003 New York SUNY Press 295 316

KurasawaF. “The exotic effect: Foucault and the question of cultural alterity” “European Journal of Social Theory” 1999 2 2 147 165

LacanJ. FinkB. “Ecrits: The first complete edition in English” 1977/2006 New York W.W. Norton & Company

LarnerW.WaltersW. LarnerW.WaltersW. “Introduction: Global governmentality” “Global governmentality: Governing international spaces” 2004a London, UK Routledge 1 20

LarnerW.WaltersW. “Global governmentality: Governing international spaces” 2004b London, UK Routledge

LemkeT. “The birth of bio-politics: Michael Foucault’s lectures at the Collège de France on neo-liberal governmentality” “Economy and Society” 2001 30 2 190 207

LemkeT. “Foucault, governmentality, and critique” “Rethinking Marxism” 2002 114 3 49 64

LemkeT. “An indigestible meal: Foucault, governmentality, and state theory” “Distinktion: Scandinavian Journal of Social Theory” 2007 15 43 66

LevinasE. LingisA. 1969 Totality and infinity: An essay on exteriority Pittsburgh, PA Duquesne University Press

LiT. M. The will to improve: Governmentality development and the practice of politics 2007 Durham Duke University Press

LieJ. “Developmentality: CDF and PRSP as governance mechanisms.” Conference presentation: The Public Reconfigured: The Production of Poverty in an Age of Advancing Neoliberalism. Rosendahl Barony Norway. September 23-25 2005. (http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/csgr/events/workshops/2006ws/world_bank/papers/developmentality1._cdf_and_prsp_as_governance_mechanisms.pdf)

LomaskyL. PaulE.MillerF.Jr.PaulJ. “Liberalism beyond borders.” Liberalism: Old and new 2007 206 233 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press

LutzC. A.CollinsJ. L. Reading national geographic 1993 Chicago, IL Chicago University Press

MaussM. The gift: Forms and functions of exchange in archaic societies 1954 Glencoe, IL Free Press

Mawuko-YevugahL. Governing through developmentality: The politics of international aid reform and the (re)production of power neoliberalism and neocolonial interventions in Ghana 2010 (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses. (NR55972)

McClintockA. Imperial leather: Race gender and sexuality in the colonial contest 1995 New York Routledge

MoellerS. Compassion fatigue: How the media sell disease famine war and death 1999 London, UK Routledge

MohantyC. T. MohantyC. T.RussoA.TorresL. “Under Western eyes: Feminist scholarship and colonial discourses.” Third world women and the politics of feminism 1991 51 80 Bloomington Indiana University Press

Nederveen PieterseJ. White on black: Images of Africa and blacks in Western popular culture 1992 New Haven, CT Yale University Press

Nederveen PieterseJ. “Hybridity, so what? The anti-hybridity backlash and the riddles of recognition.” Theory Culture & Society 2001 18 2-3 219 245

O’NeillJ. “Oh, my Others, There is no Other! Civic recognition and Hegelian Other-­wiseness.” Theory Culture & Society 2001a 18 2-3 77 90

O’NeillJ. “The time(s) of the gift.” Angelaki 2001b 6 2 41 48

PelsP. “The anthropology of colonialism: Culture, history, and the emergence of western governmentality.” Annual Review of Anthropology 1997 26 163 183

PorterD. CrushJ. “Scenes from childhood: The homesickness of development discourse.” Power of development 1995 63 86 London, UK Routledge

RawlsJ. A theory of justice 1971 Cambridge MA Belknap Press

RawlsJ. The law of peoples 1999 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

RahnemaM.BawtreeV. The post-development reader 1997 London, UK Zed Books

RistG. The history of development: From western origins to global faith 2002 2nd ed. London, UK Zed Books

RojasC. LarnerW.WaltersW. “Governing through the social: Representations of poverty and global governmentality.” Global governmentality: Governing international spaces 2004 97 115 London, UK Routledge

RoseN. Inventing our selves: Psychology power and personhood 1998 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press

RoseN. Powers of freedom: Reframing political thought 1999 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press

RoseN.MillerP. “Political power beyond the state: Problematics of government.” The British Journal of Sociology 1992 43 2 173 205

RostowW. The stages of economic growth: A non-communist manifesto 1960 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press

SachsW. Planet dialectics: Explorations in environment and development 1999 London, UK Zed Books

SaidE. Orientalism 1979 New York Vintage Books

SaidE. Culture and Imperialism 1994 New York Vintage Books

Salskov-IversenD.HansenH. K.BislevS. “Governmentality, globalization and local practice: Transformations of a hegemonic discourse.” Alternatives 2000 25 2 183 222

SchriftA. The logic of the gift: Toward an ethic of generosity 1997 New York Routledge

ScottD. “Colonial governmentality.” Social Text 1995 42 191 220

ShaninT.RahnemaM.BawtreeV. “The idea of progress.” The post-development reader 1997 65 72 London, UK Zed Books

SmithM. SmithM. “Representations of postcolonial Africa.” Globalizing Africa 2003 Trenton, N.J. Africa World Press

SontagS. 2003 Regarding the pain of others New York Farrar, Strauss, and Giroux

StennerP.MarshallH. “On developmentality: Researching the varied meanings of ‘independence’ and ‘maturity’ extant amongst a sample of young people in East London.” Journal of Youth Studies 1999 2 3 297 316

StolerA. “Rethinking colonial categories: European communities and the boundaries of rule.” Comparative Studies in Society and History 1989 31 1 134 161

ValverdeM. “‘Despotism’ and ethical liberal governance.” Economy and Society 1996 25 357 372

WattsM. “Development and governmentality.” Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 2003 24 1 6 34

YoungR. “Foucault on race and colonialism.” New Formations 1995 25 57 65

3

Dean (1999) uses the term “mentality of government” as the possible source behind Foucault’s neologism governmentality; other scholars such as Colin Gordon (1991) describe it in terms of “governmental rationality.” The difference appears largely immaterial as the concepts are described in basically the same light.

4

See Dean (1999) for a discussion of the tension in liberalism as it “seeks to balance the bio-political imperative of the optimization of the life of the population against the rights of the juridical-political subject and the norms of an economic government” (p. 49).

7

See also Dean (2001) Hindess (2001) Helliwell and Hindess (2002) and Valverde (1996) for discussions of how liberal modes of government can effectively legitimize removing freedoms in some societies usually those considered uncivilized or undeveloped.

8

Mawuko-Yevugah (2010) looks extensively at the discursive construction of Africa and its effect on development interventions. While this goes beyond looking at the intersection between governmentality and international development solely in terms of (self-)regulation his case study deals with Ghana and is therefore largely concerned with the South.

11

As with Li (2007) this approach focuses on the way certain conceptualizations of the problems of development are ‘rendered technical’ and the resulting interventions appear natural and apolitical.

15

Bornstein (2002) also makes the interesting observation that faith is used as a disciplinary technique in central NGO offices.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 20 20 8
Full Text Views 39 39 26
PDF Downloads 4 4 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0