China’s Evolving Development Dilemma in the Context of the North-South Climate Governance Debate

in Perspectives on Global Development and Technology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This paper examines China’s policy and position in relation to the evolving climate change negotiations in order to explain how China is dealing with the dilemma of meeting its growing development needs while reducing ghg emissions. It argues that global climate governance requires steering and leadership to deal with the interlocked political process; that the developing countries (dcs) right to develop is challenged by the need for ecosystemic standards especially as climate change is seen as a zero-sum game as the more one country emits the less another one can. This is especially problematic as Industrialized countries (ics) appear to be both unwilling and unable to increase growth without increasing emissions. This explains China’s policy of insisting on its right to develop, of demanding that ics reduce their emissions and that they fulfil their obligations under the fccc, while expressing its willingness to take on a voluntary target. The paper argues that China’s state-led transition has eight unique characteristics that may allow it to lead as it moves beyond a no-regrets policy to a circular and green economy, cooperating with other dcs and mobilizing conscious green values in citizens. The question remains—will the initial success and scale of state-led transition lead the global green transition to a sustainable world?

China’s Evolving Development Dilemma in the Context of the North-South Climate Governance Debate

in Perspectives on Global Development and Technology



ADB Emerging Asia: Changes and Challenges 1997 Manila ADB

BaerT.FieldmanG.AthanasiouT.KarthaS. ‘Greenhouse Development Rights: Towards an Equitable Framework for Global Climate Policy.’ Cambridge Review of International Affairs 2008 21 4 649 669

BodanskyDaniel ‘United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change: A Commentary.’ The Yale J. Int’l l 1993 18 451

Byrd Hagel Resolution ‘US Senate Resolution 98 on Global Warming.’ Congressional Record Senate 1997 S10308 S10311

CarbonTracker ‘Unburnable Carbon—Are the World’s Financial Markets Carrying a Carbon Bubble?’ Carbon Tracker Initiative 2012 Retrieved 20 June 2014 from:

CarrapatosoAstrid ‘Climate Policy Diffusion: Interregional Dialogue in China-EU Relations.’ Global Change Peace & Security 2011 23 177 194

Caviglia-HarrisJill L.ChambersDustinKahnJames R. ‘Taking the “U” out of Kuznets: A Comprehensive Analysis of the EKC and Environmental Degradation.’ Ecological Economics 2009 68 1149 1159

ChandlerW.GuoY.LoganJ.ShiY.ZhaoD. China’s Electric Power Options: An Analysis of Economic and Environmental Costs 1998 Washington Advanced International Studies Unit, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Battle Memorial Institute

CherniJudith A.KentishJoanna ‘Renewable Energy Policy and Electricity Market Reforms in China.’ Energy Policy 2007 35 3616 3629

Commission on Climate Change and Development Closing the Gaps: Report of the Commission on Climate Change and Development 2009 Stockholm Swedish Ministry of Foreign Affairs

CopelandBrian R.Scott TaylorM. ‘Trade, Growth, and the Environment.’ Journal of Economic Literature 2004 42 7 71

De BruynSander M.OpschoorHans ‘Developments in the Throughput-Income Relationship: Theoretical and Empirical Observations.’ Ecological Economics 1997 20 255 269

DellinkRobHarry AikingMichel den ElzenBergsmaEmmyBerkhoutFransDekkerThijsGuptaJoyeeta ‘Sharing the Burden of Financing Adaptation to Climate Change.’ Global Environmental Change 2009 19 411 421

DindaSoumyananda ‘Environmental Kuznets Curve Hypothesis: A Survey.’ Ecological Economics 2004 49 431 455

EIA ‘China Report 1.’ 1998 Retrieved 24 May 2014 from:

European Community ‘Conclusions on Climate Change.’ European Council 1990

GOC ‘People’s Republic of China: Initial National Communications on Climate Change.’ 2004 Retrieved 23 June 2014 from:

GongGloria J. ‘What China Wants: China’s Climate Change Priorities in a Post-Copenhagen World.’ Global Change Peace & Security 2011 23 159 175

GuptaJoyeetaVlasblomJaklienKroezeCarolien ‘An Asian Dilemma: Modernising the Electricity Sector in China and India in the context of Rapid Economic Growth and the Concern for Climate Change.’ NOP RIVM NOP report no. 410200097 2002 with contributions from K. Blok M. Hisschemoller C. Boudri & K. Dorland

GuptaJoyeeta The Climate Change Convention and Developing Countries—From Conflict to Consensus? 1997 Dordrecht Kluwer Academic Publishers

GuptaJoyeeta GuptaJ.van de GrijpN. ‘Global Governance: Development Cooperation.’ Mainstreaming Climate Change in Development Cooperation: Theory Practice and Implications for the European Union 2010b Cambridge Cambridge University Press 99 133

GuptaJoyeeta The History of Global Climate Governance 2014a Cambridge Cambridge University Press

GuptaJoyeeta ‘Sharing our Earth.’ 2014b Inaugural address as Professor of Environment and Development in the Global South 5 June 2014 University of Amsterdam Retrieved 20 June 2014 from:

Hague Declaration 1989 Declaration of The Hague. Meeting of Heads of State 11 March 1989

HarrisPaul G. ‘China and Climate Change: From Copenhagen to Cancun.’ Environmental Law Reporter: News & Analysis 2010 40 10858 10863

HarrisPaul G. ‘Peace, Security and Global Climate Change: The Vital Role of China.’ Global Change Peace & Security 2011 23 141 145

HeJiankunYuZhiweiZhangDa ‘China’s Strategy for Energy Development and Climate Change Mitigation.’ Energy Policy 2012 51 7 13

HisschemollerMatthijsBodeRiesvan de KerkhofMarleen ‘What Governs the Transition to a Sustainable Hydrogen Economy? Articulating the Relationship between Technologies and Political Institutions.’ Energy Policy 2006 34 1227 1235

Information Office of the State Council 1996 Ref 157

IPCC-III Climate Change: The IPCC Response Strategies 1990 Washington D.C. Island Press

IPCC-III Climate Change: Mitigation 2014 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

JiangBingSunZhenqingLiuMeiqin ‘China’s Energy Development Strategy under the Low-Carbon Economy.’ Energy 2010 35 4257 4264

JohnsonTodd M.LiJunfengJiangZhongxiaoTaylorRobert P. China Issues and Options in Greenhouse Gas Emissions Control 1996 330 Washington D.C. World Bank Discussion Paper World Bank

KaulIngeConceicaoPedroKatell LeGoulvenMendozaRonald KaulIngeConceicaoPedroLe GoulvenKatellMendozaRonald ‘Why do Global Public Goods Matter Today?’ Providing Global Public Goods 2003 New York Oxford University Press 2 20

KoehnPeter H. ‘Underneath Kyoto: Emerging Subnational Government Initiatives and Incipient Issue-Bundling Opportunities in China and the United States.’ Global Environmental Politics 8 2008 53 77

LewisJoanna I. ‘China’s Strategic Priorities in International Climate Change Negotiations.’ Washington Quarterly 2007 31 155 174

LiHaoGuptaJoyeetavan DijkMeine Pieter ‘China’s Drought Strategies in Rural Areas along the Lancang River.’ Water Policy 2013 15 1 18

LiuYingqiKokkoAri ‘Wind Power in China: Policy and Development Challenges.’ Energy Policy 2010 38 5520 5529

MayrhoferJan P. ‘The Politics of Co-benefits: India’s Energy Sector.’ MSc thesis 2014 Governance and Inclusive Development University of Amsterdam

MenJ.BartonB. China and the European Union in Africa: Partners or Competitors 2011 Farnham Ashgate

NDRC (National Development and Reform Commission) ‘China Medium-Long Term Renewable Energy development Planning.’ 2007 Beijing National Development and Reform Commission, People’s Republic of China Retrieved 24 May 2014 from:

NDRC (National Development and Reform Commission) ‘China’s Policies and Actions for Addressing Climate Change.’ National Development and Resource Council 2012 China

Noordwijk Declaration VellingaPierKendallPeterGuptaJoyeeta ‘Noordwijk Declaration on Climate Change.’ Noordwijk Conference Report: Volume I 1989 The Hague Netherlands Ministry of Housing, Physical Planning and Environment

OberthürSebastianOttHerman E. The Kyoto Protocol: International Climate Policy for the 21st Century 1999 Dordrecht Springer

OECD China Environmental and Sustainable Development Resource Book 1996 Paris OECD

OpschoorHans ‘Sustainable Development and a Dwindling Carbon Space.’ Public Lecture Series 2009 2009 No. 1 The Hague Institute of Social Studies (JB)

PrescottJ. ‘It’s Time For a Deal.’ International Herald Tribune 2000 November 18-9

QijiaL. WangJ. ‘Chinese Legalisation on Pollution Prevention and Control.’ Papers of Chinese Environmental Law 1998 Beijing Environment and Resources Law Institute, Peking University

RicherzhagenCarmenScholzImme ‘China’s Capacities for Mitigating Climate Change.’ World Development 36 2008 308 324

RockströmJohan ‘Planetary Boundaries: Exploring the Safe Operating Space for Humanity.’ Ecology & Society 2009 14

SantalcoAldo ‘How and When China will Exceed its Renewable Energy Deployment Targets.’ Energy Policy 2012 51 652 661

SantariusTilman ‘Pit Stop Poznan. An Analysis of Negotiations on the Bali Action Plan at the Stopover to Copenhagen.’ Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law 2009 6 75 96

ScholtenDaniel Energy Transition Governance Paradigms and their Impact on Green Innovation Processes 2012 London Brill Academic Publishers

ShiweiShao China Power Sector Regulation in a Socialist Market Economy 1997 361 Washington D.C. World Bank Discussion Paper World Bank

SPC (State Planning Commission) 2006 11th Five Year Plan

State Council China’s Politics and Actions for Addressing Climate Change 2008 Beijing Information office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China Retrieved 24 May 2014 from:

State Planning Commission Priority Programme for China’s Agenda 21 1994 Beijing First Tranche

StensdalIselin China’s Climate-Change Policy 1988-2011: From Zero to Hero? 2012 Fridtjof Nansen Institute

Stockholm Declaration ‘Declaration of the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment.’ 1972 Stockholm 16 June 1972

SWCC Scientific Declaration Scientific Declaration of the Second World Climate Conference 1990 Geneva World Meteorological Organization

TangenKristianHeggelundGorildBuenJorund ‘China’s Climate Change Positions: At a Turning Point?’ Energy & Environment 2001 12 237 252

TaylorRobert P.BogachSusan China a Strategy for International Assistance to Accelerate Renewable Energy Development 1998 WashingtonD.C. World Bank Discussion Paper, World Bank

UNDP ‘Global Public Goods: International Cooperation in the 21st Century.’ 1999 New York

UNDP ‘Fighting Climate Change: Human Solidarity in a Divided World.’ UNDP Human Development Report 2007-2008 2007

UNDP Human Development Report Sustainability and Equity: A Better Future for All 2011 Basingstoke Palgrave Maxmillan

UNFCCC ‘United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Signed 9 May 1992, New York, entered into force 21 March 1994.’ International Legal Materials 1992 31 849

UNGA ‘Declaration on the Right to Development.’ United Nations General Assembly Resolution A/RES/41/128 1986 4 December 1986

UNGA ‘Protection of Global Climate for Present and Future Generations of Mankind.’ United Nations General Assembly Resolution A/RES/43/53 of 6 December 1988 1988

UNGA ‘Protection of Global Climate for Present and Future Generations of Mankind.’ UN General Assembly Resolution 45/212 1990

UNIDO Public Goods for Economic Development 2008 Vienna UNIDO

Van der HeijdenJeroen ‘The Philippines Challenge: Merging Development and Climate Change.’ MSc thesis 2014 Governance and Inclusive Development University of Amsterdam

Van HamJ. CO2 Emissions in China: Breakdown into Provinces and Economic Sectors 1996 Delft TNO Institute of Environmental Sciences, Energy Research and Process Innovation TNO Report: TNO-MEP—R96/130

VellingaPierKendallP.GuptaJoyeeta Noordwijk Conference Report Volume II Ministry of Housing Physical Planning and the Environment 1990 The Hague VROM

WangQiang ‘Effective Policies for Renewable Energy—the Example of China’s Wind Power—Lessons for China’s Photovoltaic Power.’ Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2010 14 702 712

WangYanjiaGuAlunZhangAlin ‘Recent Development of Energy Supply and Demand in China, and Energy Sector Prospects through 2030.’ Energy Policy 2011 39 6745 6759

WCED Our Common Future 1987 Oxford The World Commission on Environment and Development

World Bank ‘World Development Indicators.’ 2014 Retrieved 24 May 2014 from:

XiaChangliangSongZhanfeng ‘Wind Energy in China: Current Scenario and Future Perspectives.’ Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2009 13 1966 1974

Xinhua ‘China reaffirms Stance on Climate Change Ahead of Talks.’ 2011 Retrieved 24 May 2014 from:

YehEmily T. ‘Greening Western China: A Critical view.’ Geoforum 40 2009 884 894

YehEmily T. GoldembergJ.ReidW. ‘Is China Taking Actions to Limit its Greenhouse Gas Emissions? Past Evidence and Future Prospects.’ Promoting Development while Limiting Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trends and Baselines 1999 New York UNDP and WRI

ZhangZhongXiang Energy and Environmental Policy in China: Towards a Low-Carbon Economy 2011a Cheltenham and Northampton Edward Elgar Publishing

ZhangZhongXiang MenJ.BartonB. ‘China’s Aid to Africa: A Challenge to the EU.’ China and the European Union in Africa: Partners or Competitors 2011b Farnham Ashgate

ZhaoZhen-Yu ‘Impacts of Renewable Energy Regulations on the Structure of Power Generation in China: A Critical Analysis.’ Renewable Energy 2011 36 24 30

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 12 12 7
Full Text Views 6 6 6
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0