Rethinking eu Energy Security Considering Past Trends and Future Prospects

in Perspectives on Global Development and Technology
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


eu energy policy objectives are directed at three highly interdependent areas: energy supply security, competitiveness and decarbonization to prevent climate change. In this paper, we focus on the issue of energy supply security. Security of energy supply for the immediate and medium-term future is a necessary condition in the current context of the global political economy for the survival of the Union and its component member states. Since the Lisbon Treaty entered into force, energy policy no longer comes onto the agenda of the European Commission through the backdoor of the common market, environment and competitiveness. The Treaty created a new legal basis for the internal energy market. However, securing external supplies as well as deciding the energy mix, remain matters of national prerogative, though within the constraints of other parts of eu’s legislation in force. Without a common defense policy, the highly import dependent Union and its members face external instability in the energy rich Arab Middle East and North Africa.

Concern about energy security has been triggered by declining European energy production as well as the strain on global demand exerted by newly industrializing economies such as China and India and the Middle East, as well as the political instability in this reserve-rich part of the world. This paper explores the following two topics [1] the current situation and past trends in production, supply, demand and trade in energy in the eu, against the background of major changes in the last half decade and [2] threats to the security of the supply of oil and natural gas from import regions.

Fossil fuel import dependence in the eu is expected to continue to increase in the coming two decades. As global trends show, and despite new fields in the Caspian region and the Eastern Mediterranean, conventional fossil oil and gas resources remain concentrated in fewer geopolitically unstable regions and countries (i.e. the Middle East and North Africa (mena) and the Caspian Region (cr) including Russia), while global demand for fossil energy is expected to substantially increase also within the energy rich Gulf countries. This combination directly impacts eu energy supply security. It should be noted that the trend towards higher levels of import dependence was not interrupted when the era of low energy prices, between 1980 and 2003, came to an end.

Within the eu itself, domestic resistance to the development of unconventional resources is an obstacle to investment in unconventional sources in this part of the high-income world. This should therefore not put at risk investments in either renewables or alternative sources at home or conventional resources mainly in the Arab-Middle East.

The situation is exacerbated by the spread of instability in the Arab-Middle Eastern countries. There are three domestic and geopolitical concerns to be taken into consideration:

(1) In the Arab-Middle East, threats to eu energy supply security originate in the domestic regime of these countries. Almost all Arab resource-rich countries belong to a type of patrimonial, rentier-type of state-society relation. These regimes rely on rents from the exploitation of energy resources and the way in which rents are distributed.

Regimes of this type are being challenged. Their economies show uneven economic development, centralized power structures, corruption and poverty at the bottom of the social hierarchy. The discrimination of females is a major obstacle to the development of the service sector. At present, even the monarchies fear the spread of violent conflict.

Offshoots of these consequences have proven to cause civil unrest, exemplified by what optimists have called the ‘Arab Spring.’

(2) The second concern is the domestic and global impact of Sovereign Wealth Funds (swfs) managed by Arab patrimonial rentier states. swfs have proven to be an asset in both developing and developed economies due to their ability to buffer the ‘Dutch Disease,’ and to encourage industrialization, economic diversification and eventually the development of civil society. In patrimonial states, however, swfs are affected by corruption and the diversion of funds away from long-term socioeconomic development to luxury consumption by political elites. In fact, Arab swfs underpin the persistence of the Arab patrimonial rentier state system.

(3) Finally, the post-Cold War, me and cea geopolitical landscape is shifting. The emergence of China and other Asian economies has increased their presence in the Middle East due to a growing need for energy and the expansion of Asian markets. The recent discovery of energy resources in the us has led to speculation that there will be less us presence in the region. There would be a serious risk to eu energy security if emerging Asian economies were to increase their presence in the Middle East as us interests recede.

Rethinking eu Energy Security Considering Past Trends and Future Prospects

in Perspectives on Global Development and Technology



AbrahamianErvand The cia and the Roots of Modern U.S.-Iranian Relations 2013 New York and London The New Press

AminehM.P. Towards the Control of Oil Resources in the Caspian Region 1999 New York, Palgrave

AminehM.P. Globalisation Geopolitics and Energy Security in Central Eurasia and the Caspian Region 2003 Den Haag Clingendael International Energy Programme

AminehM.P. Ben-RafaelE.SternbergE. ‘Authoritarian Persistence and Barriers to Democracy in the Muslim Middle East: Beyond Cultural Essentialism.’ World Religions and Multilateralism—A Dialectic Relation 2010 Leiden-Boston Brill 152 192

AminehM.P. The Greater Middle East in Global Politics: Social Science Perspectives on the Changing Geography of the World Politics 2007 Leiden Brill

AminehM.P.HouwelingH. ‘Central Eurasia in Global Politics: Conflict, Security and Development.’ Journal Perspectives on Global Development and Technology 2003 Special Issue 2 3 4

AminehM.P.HouwelingH. Central Eurasia in Global Politics: Conflict Security and Development Second Edition 2005 Leiden & Boston Brill Academic Publishers

AminehM.P.HouwelingH. ‘Global Energy Security and its Geopolitical Impediments: The Case of the Caspian Region.’ Perspective on Global Development and Technology 2007 6 365 388

AminehM.P.HouwelingH. AminehM.P. ‘China and Transformation of the post-Cold War Geopolitical Order.’ State Society and International Relations in Asia 2010 Amsterdam Amsterdam University Press 215 271

AminehM.P.GuangY. The Globalization of Energy. China and the European Union 2010 Leiden-Boston Brill

AminehM.P.GuangY. Secure Oil and Alternative Energy: The Geopolitics of Energy Paths of China and the European Union 2012 Leiden-Boston Brill

AminehM.P.GuangY. AminehM.P.YangG. “Introduction: China’s and the European Union’s Energy Security Challenges in the Twenty-First Century.” Secure Oil and Alternative Energy: The Geopolitics of Energy Paths of China and the European Union 2012 Leiden-Boston Brill 1 40

AndersonI. Aramco the United States and Saudi Arabia: A Study of the Dynamics of Foreign Oil Policy 1933-1950 1981 Princeton Princeton University Press

BahgatG. ‘Oil Funds: Perils and Opportunities.’ Middle Eastern Studies 2009 45 283 293

BassamH. ‘Knowledge Production on the Middle East in Times of Upheaval.’ Political Science & Politics 2013 46 240 243 (Islamic Politics in Arab Uprisings)

BayatA. ‘The Arab Spring and its Surprises.’ Development and Change 2013 44 587 601

BeblawiH. El SeznecJ.-F.KirkM. ‘Gulf industrialization in perspective.’ Industrialization in the Gulf: A Socioeconomic Revolution 2011 London Center for Contemporary Arab Studies, Georgetown University/Routledge

BergerL. ‘The Missing Link? us Policy and the International Dimensions of Failed Democratic Transitions in the Arab world.’ Political Studies 2011 59 38 55

BlanchardC. ‘Saudi Arabia: Background and us Relations.’ Congressional Research Service 2012 27 November 2012

British Petroleum bp Energy Outlook 2011 2011 Retrieved 28 July 2013 from:

British Petroleum bp Energy Outlook 2012 2012 Retrieved 28 July 2013 from:

British Petroleum bp Statistical Review of World Energy 2013 2013 Retrieved 27 July 2013 from:

BromleyS. American Hegemony and World Oil 1991 Cambridge Polity Press

BromleyS. ‘The United States and the Control of World Oil.’ Government and Opposition 2005 40 225 255

BrownN. ‘Egypt’s Failed Transition.’ Journal of Democracy 2013 24 45 58

BurnellP. ‘Democratisation in the Middle East and North Africa: Perspectives from Democracy Support.’ Third World Quarterly 2013 34 838 855

BymanD. ‘Regime Change in the Middle East: Problems and Prospects.’ Political Science Quarterly 2012 127 25 46

CarlosGarcía-Rivero ‘Democratisation, State and Society in the Middle East and North Africa.’ Comparative Sociology 2013 12 477 504

CastellsM. End of Millennium 1997 Oxford Blackwell

ChangH. Kicking Away the Ladder: Development Strategy in Historical Perspective 2002 London Anthem Press

ChenJ. ‘The Emergence of China in the Middle East.’ Strategic Forum 2011 National Defense University

ColganJ. ‘Oil and Resource-Backed Aggression.’ Energy Policy 2011 39 1969 1676

CoxR.W. Production Power and World Order: Social Forces in the Making of History 1987 Columbia University Press

DannreutherR. ‘China and Global Oil: Vulnerability and Opportunity.’ International Affairs 2011 87 6 1345 1364

DeffeyesK.S. ‘Another Wolf at the Door. Oil Industry Crisis.’ The American Prospect 2001 12 18 31

DittmerL.YuG.T. China the Developing World and the New Global Dynamics 2010 Lynne Rienner Publishers

DiwanR. ‘The Current Implications of the World Energy Situation for United States Energy Supplies.’ Energy Markets in the 21st Century: Competition Policy in Perspective 2007 Presentation at Federal Trade Commission Conference 12 April 2007 Washington D.C.

Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (escwa) Economic Diversification in the Oil-Producing Countries: The Case of the Gulf Cooperation Council Economies 2001 New York United Nations

El-KharoufF.Al-QudsiS.ObeidS. ‘The Gulf Corporation Council Sovereign Wealth Funds: Are They Instruments for Economic Diversification or Political Tools?’ Asian Economic Papers 2010 9 1 124 151

European Commission ‘Green Paper—Towards a European Strategy for the Security of Energy Supply. com (2000)769’ 2000 November 29 Brussels European Commission

European Commission ‘Green Paper—A European Strategy for Sustainable, Competitive and Secure Energy. com (2006)105.’ 2006 March 8 Brussels European Commission

European Commission ‘Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions—20 20 by 2020: Europe’s climate change opportunity.’ 2008 Brussels European Commission com (2008)30 final. 23 January

European Commission set-plan: The European Strategic Energy Technology Plan Towards a Low-carbon future.’ 2010 Brussels European Commission

European Commission eu Energy, Transport and ghg Emission Trends to 2050. Reference scenario 2013.’ 2013d December 16 Brussels European Commission

European Environment Agency Energy and Environment Report 2008 2008 November 20

European Union Institute for Security Studies ‘The Shale Gas ‘Revolution’: Challenges and Implications for the eu.’ 2013 February 18 Brussels euiss.

Eurostat Statistics Database, European Commission 2014 last accessed on 16 June 2014 Available from:

FazilovF.XiangmingC. ‘China and Central Asia: A Significant New Energy Nexus.’ The European Financial Review 2013 April 38 43

GhilèsF. ‘Russia in Syria and the Shape of the Middle East.’ Barcelona Centre for International Affairs (cidob) 2013 June 18 Opinion no. 195.

HaassR.IndykM. ‘Beyond Iraq: A New u.s. Strategy for the Middle East.’ Foreign Affairs 2009 88 41 58

HarrisJerry ‘Statist Globalization in China, Russia and the Gulf States.’ Perspectives on Global Development and Technology 2009 8 139 163

HertogS. Princes, Borkers, and Bureaucrats: Oil and the State in Saudi Arabia 2010 Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press

Heritage Foundation ‘China’s Global Investment Tracker.’ The Heritage Foundation 2012 Retrieved June 2014 from:

HinnebuschR. ‘Authoritarian Persistence, Democratization Theory, and the Middle East: An overview and critique.’ Democratization 2006 13 3 373 395

HruskaM. ‘Subsidized Coal Mines to be Closed in 2014.’ 2010 July 21 eu observer

HvidtM. ‘Economic Diversification in gcc Countries: Past Record and Future Trends.’ Kuwait Program on Development Governance and Globalisation in the Gulf States 2014 Retrieved 5 May 2014 from:

IkedaS. HopkinsT.K.WallersteinI. ‘World Production.’ The Age of Transition: Trajectory of the World-System (1945-2025) 1996 London & New York Zed Books 38 64

International Energy Agency iea World Energy Outlook 2012.’ 2012 Paris International Energy Agency

International Energy Agency ‘Energy Balances of oecd and Non-oecd countries.’ 2013 Paris International Energy Agency

IseriE. ‘The us Grand Strategy and the Eurasian Heartland in the Twenty-First Century.’ Geopolitics 2009 14 26 46

JiangJ.SintonJ. Overseas Investments by Chinese National Oil Companies: Assessing the Drivers and the Impacts 2011 iea

KamravaM. ‘The Middle East’s Democracy Deficit in Comparative Perspective.’ Perspectives on Global Development and Technology 2007 6 1 3 189-213

KaplanRobert D. The Revenge of Geography: What the Map Tells Us About Coming Conflicts and the Battle Against Fate 2012 New York Random House

KarlTery Lynn The Paradox of Plenty: Oil Booms and Petro-States 1997 Oakland, CA University of California Press

KarshenasM.HakimianH. ‘Oil, Economic Diversification and the Democratic Process in Iran.’ Iranian Studies 2005 38 67 90

KlareM.T. Resource Wars. The New Landscape of Global Conflict 2001 New York Metropolitan/Owl Book

LeschD.HaasM. The Middle East and the United States: History Politics and Ideologies 2011 5th edition Westview Press

LeungG.C.K. ‘China’s Energy Security: Perception and Reality.’ Energy Policy 2011 1330 1337

LooneyR.E. Industrial Development and Diversification of the Arabian Gulf Economies 1994 Greenwich, CT JAI Press

MahdavyH. ‘The Patterns and Problems of Economic Development in Rentier States: The Case of Iran.’ Studies in Economic History of the Middle East 1970 Oxford University Press

MarcelV. Oil Titans; National Oil Companies in the Middle East 2006 Washington, D.C. Brookings and Chatham House

Market Observatory for Energy ‘Key Figures.’ 2011 Brussels European Commission

MeissnerH. ‘The Resource Curse and Rentier States in the Caspian Region: A Need for Context Analysis.’ 2010 giga Research Programme: Violence and Security Working Paper: 133.

MercilleJ. ‘The Radical Geopolitics of us Foreign Policy: Geopolitical and Geo-economics Logics of Power,’ Political Geography 2008 27 570 586

MichaelsJ. ‘Dysfunctional Doctrines? Eisenhower, Cater and us Military Intervention in the Middle East.’ Political Science Quarterly 2011 126 465 492.

MitchellS.MclaughlinR.JonathanJ.SpellmanM.K. ‘Domestic Legal Traditions and States’ Human Rights Practices.’ Journal of Peace Research 2013 50 189 202

MuttitG. ‘Fuel on the Fire. Oil and Politics in Occupied Iraq.’ 2012 London Vintage Books

NayyarD. ‘Globalization: The Past in our Present,’ twn Trade & Development Series 1998 Penang Third World Network

RamuS.S. The Dragons of Asia: Asia-Pacific Rim Countries and Their Multinationals 1995 New Delhi Wheeler Publishing

RashidA. Taliban: Militant Islam Oil and Fundamentalism in the Central Asia 2000 Yale Nota Bene Books

RatnerM.BelkinP.NicholJ.WoehrelS. ‘Europe’s Energy Security: Options and Challenges to Natural Gas Supply Diversification.’ 2013 August 20 Congressional Research Service

RossA. ‘China, the United States, and the Geopolitics of Sustainability.’ Journal of Communication Inquiry 2010 34 439 449

RossM. ‘Does Oil Hinder Democracy.’ World Politics 2001 53 325 361

RossM. ‘Will Oil Drown the Arab Spring: Democracy and the Resource Curse.’ Foreign Affairs 2011 September/October 2011 issue.

RoyO. The Politics of Chaos in the Middle East 2009 New York Columbia University Press

RoyO. ‘The Crisis in Syria is Leading the Middle East into Uncharted Territory.’ New Statesman 2011 August 24

SaberiM. ‘Dubai Rolls Out Medical Tourism Strategy.’ Gulf News (Dubai) 2014 Retrieved 12 April 2014

SalloukhBassel F. ‘The Arab Uprisings and the Geopolitics of the Middle East.’ The International Spectator 2013 48 32 46

SchwartzH.M. State versus Market: The Emergence of a Global Economy 1994 Basingstoke, etc. Macmillan Press

SchwartzHerman ‘Political Capitalism and the Rise of Sovereign Wealth Funds.’ Globalizations 2012 9 517 530

SchwartzR. ‘The Political Economy of State formation in the Arab Middle East: Rentier States, Economic Reform and Democratization.’ Review of International Political Economy 2008 15 599 621

Shiva RamuS. The Dragons of Asia: Asia-Pacific Rim Countries and their Multinationals 1995 New Delhi Wheeler Publishers

ShochatS. ‘The Gulf Cooperation Council Economies. Diversification and Reform: An Introduction.’ 2008 London London School of Economics, Kuwait Programme on Development, Governance and Globalisation in the Gulf States

Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute ‘Source on Sovereign Wealth Funds, Public Pensions, Central Banks and Public Funds.’ 2014 Retrieved 10 April 2014 from:

StokesD.RaphaelS. Global Energy Security and American Hegemony 2010 Baltimore The John Hopkins University Press

TekinA.WilliamsP.A. ‘Turkey and eu Energy Security: The Pipeline Connection.’ East 2009

us Energy Information Administration eia Annual Energy Outlook 2012—With Projections to 2035 (eia-aeo 2012) 2012 Last accessed 27 July 2013 Washington, US eia Available from:

us Energy Information Agency Technically Recoverable Shale Oil and Shale Gas Resources: An Assessment of 137 Shale Formations in 41 Countries Outside the United States 2013a Washington, US eia Available from:

us Energy Information Agency How much Shale Gas is Produced in the United States? 2013b Washington, US eia

us Energy Information Agency eia Country Analysis Brief: Azerbaijan Kazakhstan Turkmenistan Iran Russia United Arab Emirates Iraq Kuwait Oman Saudi Arabia North Africa Algeria Egypt Libya Tunisia 2013c Washington, US eia

us Energy Information Agency International Energy Outlook. Table A5 and A6 2013d Washington, US 184 185 eia

us Energy Information Agency The Annual Energy Outlook 2013 (AEO2013) 2013f Washington, US us-Energy Information Administration May 2014.

us Energy Information Agency Annual Energy Outlook 2014. Early Release Overview 2014 Washington, US eia

UmbachF. ‘Global Energy Security and the Implications for the eu.’ Energy Policy 2010 38 3 1229 1240

United Nations Development Programme World Energy Assessment: Overview 2004 Update 2004

United Nations Development Programme ‘Arab Development Challenges Report 2011: Towards the Developmental State in the Arab region.’ United Nations Development Programme 2011

Van der LindeC.AminehM.P.CorreljeA. ‘Study on Energy Supply Security and Geopolitics, eu-Tender Delivered to the European Union.’ 2004 This report was prepared for dgtrn Contract number tren/C1-06-2002 etap Programme January

VictorD.G.HultsD.R.ThurberM.C. Oil and Governance State-Owned Enterprises and the World Energy Supply 2012 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

WalshDeclan ‘WikiLeaks Cable Portray Saudi Arabia as a Cash Machine for Terrorists.’ The Guardian 2014 London Retrieved 11 April 2014.

WeberMax RothGuentherWittichClaus Economy and Society 1968 3 vols New York Bedminster Press

World Bank World Development Indicators database 2013 last accessed on 26 July 2013 Available from:

World Bank gdp Per Capita (Current us$).’ 2014 Retrieved 23 April 2014 from:

Wood Mackenzie ‘China to Surpass us Crude Oil Imports by 2020.’ 2014

YerginD. The Prize. The Epic Quest for Oil Money and Power 1991 New York, London, Toronto, Sydney Free Press


  • View in gallery
    Total primary energy use in eu27 by source (based on iea, 2013).
  • View in gallery
    Primary energy use in eu27 by source (based on iea, 2013).
  • View in gallery
    Natural gas supply in eu28 by country (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Natural gas supply in eu28 by country as shares (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Crude oil supply in eu28 by country of origin (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Crude oil supply to eu28 by country of origin as shares (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Coal supply in eu28 by country of origin (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Coal supply in eu28 by country of origin as shares (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Total primary energy use in eu28 by type of origin (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Total primary energy use in eu28 by country of origin as shares (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Fossil fuel production in eu28 by country in 2012 (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Fossil fuel production in eu28 in period 1990 to 2012 (based on Eurostat, 2014).
  • View in gallery
    Production and net imports in eu in period 1990-2050 in reference scenario (based on eu, 2013).
  • View in gallery
    Total Gulf Oil-Trade-Comparison (in usd millions): China, us, eu.

    Note: data for the eu for Qatar, Bahrain and uae is not available.

    Source: u.s. Census Bureau: u.s. Bureau of the Economic Analysis; National Bureau of Statistics of China; eia; European Commission, Market observatory for Energy, Registration of Crude Oil Imports and Deliveries in the European Union eu 27

  • View in gallery
    Trend trade relations of Iran, Iraq, Kazakhstan, Saudi Arabia with China: 2003-2011.

    Note: slight differences might occur due to rounding.

    Source: The Observatory of Economic Complexity, Massachusetts Institute for Technology (mit) Media lab


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 62 62 17
Full Text Views 125 125 55
PDF Downloads 8 8 4
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0