Discontinuities in the Trajectory of Solar Photovoltaic (spv) Technology Development in India

in Perspectives on Global Development and Technology
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


The objective of this paper is to understand different phases of solar photovoltaic (spv) technology in India and the interplay of scientific, technological, economic, and political factors in each of the phases. There are four distinct phases. In the first-phase (1947-1970), spv technology was recognized as an important source of energy for countries like India. In the second phase (1971-1990), the oil crisis led to the formulation of new scientific and technological initiatives and programs in spv, but due to a lack of political commitment the initiatives disintegrated. In the third phase (1991-2003), several factors seemed to have undermined the development of spv sector. Currently in the fourth phase (2003 to the present), India has virtually lost the race for development of photovoltaic technology. Within the context of climate change and resource constraint, India has reformulated its strategy which has taken the form of the Jawaharlal Nehru National Solar Mission Plan (jnnsm).This paper examines how jnnsm influences indigenous attempts in photovoltaic technology development. The paper shows how scientific, technological, economic and political factors have contributed to discontinuities in the development of the technology.

Discontinuities in the Trajectory of Solar Photovoltaic (spv) Technology Development in India

in Perspectives on Global Development and Technology



AbrahamI. “Geopolitics and Biopolitics in India’s High Natural Background Radiation Zone.” Science Technology and Society 2012 17 1 105 122

AbrolD.UpadhyayV.SikkaP. BanerjeeP Financing of S and T in India India: Science and Technology 2008 2008 New Delhi NISTADS

AbrolD. Colonised Minds or Progressive Nationalist Scientists: The Science and Culture Group. In MacLeod and Raj Technology and the Raj 1995 New Delhi Sage Publications

AlsemaE.A.NieuwlaarE. “Energy Viability of spv System.” Energy Policy 2000 28 14 999 1010

AndersonR.S. “Empire’s Setting Sun? Patrick Blackett and Military and Scientific Development of India.” Economic and Political Weekly 2001 36 39 3703 20

AndersonR.S. McGill University Center for Developing-Area Studies Building Scientific Institutions in India: Saha and Bhbha 1975 Montreal

AroraD.S.BuscheS.CowlinS.EngelmeierT.JaritzH.MilbrandtA.WangS. India Renewable Energy Status Report 2010 Retrieved June 12 2012 (http://www.ren21.net/:http://www.ren21.net/Portals/0/documents/Resources/Indian_re_Status_Report.pdf)

BaskaranA. “Competence building in complex systems in the developing countries: the case of satellite building in India.” Technovation 2001 21 2 109 121

BeetzB. India accuses us of “ruining” domestic pv industry 2012 Retrieved October 10 2012 (http://www.pv-magazine.com/news/details/beitrag/india-accuses-us-of-ruining-domestic-pv-industry_100008128/#axzz2G28Sm2Zv).

BhargavaB. “Overview of Photovolatic Technologies in India.” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 2001 67 1 639 646

BhattacharyaS.C.JanaC. “Renewable energy in India: Historical Developments and prospects.” Energy 2009 34 8 981 991

BravermanH. Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century 1974 New York Monthly Review Press

Committee on Solar Energy Solar Energy: Promise and Challenge 1974 New Delhi National Committe on Science and Technology and Council of Scientific and Industrial Research

DeshmukhC. Damodar Dharmanand Kosambi (Jivanani Karya) (The Life and Work of ddk) 1993 Mumbai Granthali

DeshmukhR.GambhirA.SantG. “Need to Realign India’s National Solar Mission.” Economic Political Weekly 2010 45 12 41 50

DevarajP. “Innovations in Solar Photovoltaic Technology in India: The Mode 2 Knowledge Production Perspective.” 2013 Unpublished PhD Thesis Submitted to Department of Sociology University of Hyderabad, Hyderabad

D’SaA.MurthyN.K.V.ReddyA.K.N. “India’s Power Sector Liberalisation: An Overview.” Economic and Political Weekly 1999 34 23 1427 1434

GadgilM.GuhaR. The Fissured Land: An Ecological History of India 1996 New York Oxford University Press

GhoshA. “Eighth Plan: Challenges and Opportunities-V: Energy: Overall Scenario, Rural Energy, Renewable Sources and Oil and Natural Gas.” Economic and Political Weekly 1991 26 7 331 37

GoetzbergerA.LutherJ.WillekeG. “Solar Cells: past, present, future.” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 2002 74 1 11

Government of India Report on Technologically Important Crystal 2008 New Delhi Office of the Principle Scientific Advisor to the Government of India

GreenM.A. “Photovoltaics: Technology Overview.” Energy Policy 2000 28 14 989 998

HabermasJ. IngramD. “Technology and Science as Ideology.” Critical Theory: The Essential Readings 1991 USA Paragon House 117 150

Harriss-WhiteB.RohraS.NigelS. “Political Architecture for India’s Technology System for Solar Energy.” Economic Political Weekly 2009 44 47 49 60

Harriss-WhiteB.RohraS.NigelS. “Companies: Opportunities in Power Equipment.” Economic and Political Weekly 1979 14 40 1664 65

Hansavivek “Companies: Accent on Technology.” Economic and Political Weekly 1981 16 47 1885 86

HarishS.M.RaghavanS.V.SahuA.K. Rural Energy S and T—Solar Energy Options 2011 New Delhi NISTADS

JacobssonS.LauberV. “The politics and policy of energy system transformation—explaining the German diffusion of renewable energy technology.” Energy Policy 2006 34 256 276

JacksonT.OliverM. “The Viability of Solar pv Photovoltaic.” Energy Policy 2000 28 14 983 988

JishnuL. “D.D. Kosambi on Solar Energy Vs Atomic Energy.” 2008 Retrieved December 01 2010 (http://www.dianuke.org/d-d-kosambi-on-solar-vs-atomic-energy/).

KosambiD.D. Problems of Science and Technology in Under-developed Countries 1972 Bombay Lalvani Publishing House 64 78 In A Committee of Experts Appointed by Dr. A.V. Baliga Memorial Committee Science and Society: Essays in Honour of Dr. A.V. Baliga

KosambiM. “D D Kosambi: The Scholar and the Man.” Resonance 2011 16 6 504 513

KoshyP.J. “Policy hampering India’s solar mission.” 2012 Retrieved November 2012 (http://www.livemint.com/Companies/7SPQWXxKV9TNJ4P7m3I3QP/Policy-hampering-India8217s-solar-mission.html).

LacyM.G. “Sociological Work on Energy: The Opportunity and Some Prescriptions.” Mid-American Review of Sociology 1982 7 2 67 68

MathewsJ.HuChih-MeiYan-WuC. “Fast-Follower Industrial Dynamics: The Case of Taiwan’s Emergent Solar Photovoltaic Industry.” Industry and Innovation 2011 18 2 177 202

MitraN. “Energy Policy Planning in India: Case of Petroleum and Natural Gas.” Economic and Political Weekly 1992 27 35 M109 M115

NandyA. “The Traditions of Technology.” Alternatives 1978 4 3 371 385

PaliwalA. “New guidelines for national solar mission power projects.” 2011 Retrieved November 26 2012 (http://www.downtoearth.org.in/content/new-guidelines-national-solar-mission-power-projects).

PanikarP.G. “Oil: From Crisis to Crisis.” Economic and Political Weekly 1991 26 9/10 479 481

PatelJ. “Irrelevance on Solar Energy: Industrial Applications of Solar Energy.” Economic and Political Weekly 1978 13 51/52 2076 77

PendseD.R. “Energy Crisis and its Impact on Energy Consumers in Third World: ii.” Economic and Political Weekly 1980 15 4 175 84

PendseD.R. “Dilemmas of Energy Strategies in India: Implication for Third World.” Economic and Political Weekly 1984 19 13 556 66

PerlinJ. From Space to Earth 1999 Michigan: usa Aatec Publications

RadulovicV. “Are New Institutional Economics Enough?” Energy Policy 2005 33 14 1883 1899

RaghavanS.V.BharadwajA.ThatteA.A.HarishS.IychettiraK.K.PerumalR.NayakG. Harnessing Solar Energy: Options for India 2010 Bengulore Center for Study of Science, Technology and Policy

RangaraoB.V. “Hesitant Approach to Science and Technology.” Economic and Political Weekly 1973 8 19 877 80

RangaraoB.V. “Alternatives to Energy Development.” Economic and Political Weekly 1974 9 27 1063 69

RaoV. “Commercializing Solar Photovoltaics: India. In United Nations Development Program. Technical Cooperation among Developing Countries.” Special Unit Third World Academy of Sciences Third World Network of Scientific Organisations Volume 8: Examples of Successful Uses of Renewable Energy Sources in the South 2003 Cornell University UNDP 49 56

ReddyA.K.N. “Goals, Strategies and Policies for Rural Energy.” Economic and Political Weekly 1999 34 49 3435 445

ReddyA.K.N. “Defendus vs Consensus.” Economic and Political Weekly 1991 26 43 2485 488

ReddyA.K.N.PrasadK.K. “Technological Alternatives and the Indian Energy Crisis.” Economic and Political Weekly 1977 12 33/34 1465 1502

ReddyA.N.SudhakarB.R. “Energy in a Stratified Society: A Case Study of Firewood in Bangalore.” Economic and Political Weekly 1983 18 41 1757 1770

ReddyC.R.D’SaA.ReddyA.K.N. “The Debt-Energy Nexus: A Case Study of India.” Economic and Political Weekly 1992 27 27 1401 141

SastryE.V.R. “The Photovoltaic Program in India: An Overview.” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 1997 47 1-4 63 69

ScheerH. A Solar Manifesto: The need for a total solar energy supply and how to achieve it 1994 London, UK James and James (Science Publishers) LTD.

ScheerH. The Solar Economy: Renewable Energy for a Sustainable Global Future 2004 London, UK Earth Scan

ScheerH. Energy Autonomy: The economic social and technological case for renewable energy 2007 UK and USA EarthScan

SharmaM. “Utility grid-connected solar photovoltaic power plants for meeting energy needs for rural area in developing countries—A case of India.” Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 1994 35 11 469 476

ShreyaJ. “Solar equipment makers seek anti-dumping duty on imports from China, Malaysia, Taiwan.” 2012 Retrieved August 11 12 http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/-2012-06-02/news/31984187_1_anti-dumping-duty-dgad-local-manufacturers).

SinghS. “Moser Baer Burning the Burnt on Chinese Onslaught.” 2012 Retrieved June 2012 (http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-06-05/news/32055732_1_moser-baer-solar-panels-ratul-puri).

SinghN. “The Role of the National Solar Mission in Climate Change Mitigation and the Twin Objective of Energy Security.” Strategic Analysis 2012 36 2 260 75

SinghS.PrasadR. “India’s fledgling solar-equipment industry under Chinese onslaught.” 2012 Retrieved October 11 2012 (http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-06-05/news/32055830_1_solar-equipment-solar-power-lanco-solar).

SinhaB. Mapping Solar Photovoltaic Research in India 2011 New Delhi NISTADS

SwaminanthanP. “Budgetary Silences.” Economic and Poltical Weekly 1995 30 22 1329 32

United Nation Environment Program (unep) Patents and Clean Energy:Bridging the Gap Between Evidence and Policy 2010 Mediengruppe Universal, Munich UNEP, EPO, ICTSD Retreived December 12 2012 (http://www.unep.ch/etb/events/unep%20epo%20ictsd%20Event%2030%20Sept%202010%20Brussels/Study%20Patents%20and%20clean%20energy_15.9.10.pdf).

VisvanathanS. “The Laboratory and the World: Conversation with C.V. Seshadri.” Economic and Political Weekly 2002 37 22 2163 170

VisvanathanS. Organizing for Science: The Making of an Industrial Research Laboratory 1985 New Delhi Oxford University Press

WrightJ.N. Solar Capabilities: Promoting Technological Learning in South Africa’s Photovoltaic Supply Industry 2003 Unpublished M.A. Porject Thesis USA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology

WinnerL. WinnerL. “Do Artifacts Have Politics?” The Whale and Reactor: A Search for Limits in an Age of High Technology 1986 Chicago Chicago Univeristy Press 19 39

ZeluckS. Energy Crisis—A Marxist View n.d. Retrieved December 25 2011 (http://www.sojournertruth.net/energy.pdf).


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 24 24 11
Full Text Views 67 67 52
PDF Downloads 5 5 3
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0