Imperial and Philological Encounters in the Early Modern Era
European Readings of the Codex Mendoza
In: Philological EncountersAlthough the history of philology is merely an addition to the rediscovery of textual traditions which have been neglected for too long by academic philology, it is nonetheless an important one for its ability alone to provide an explanation of the existing asymmetric situation. When the world opened up after the 16th century following transoceanic navigations, European encounters with written traditions in America, Africa and Asia led to a variety of attitudes—from denial to fascination, from destruction to collection. These “philological encounters”, both material and conceptual, largely contributed to shape the views of the European Renaissance and the Enlightenment regarding language and writing. To understand the semiological and epistemological consequences of these views, this paper focuses on a single text produced at the time of the Spanish conquest of Mexico, the Codex Mendoza, and on the different interpretations to which the latter was subjected in Europe after crossing the Atlantic. The history of the Codex Mendoza would have us believe that it was during the 18th century, and not before, that writing became exclusively synonymous with alphabet, resulting in the marginalisation of non-alphabetic written systems—and this mainly for historiographical reasons.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Aarsleff Hans From Lock to Saussure. Essays on the Study of language and Intellectual History 1982 London Athlon Press
-
Acosta José de De procuranda Indorum Salute [1580] 1984 Madrid CSIC
-
Acosta José de Historia natural y moral de las Indias [1590] 2006 México Fondo de Cultura Económica
-
Anghiera Pedro Martyr d’ Décadas del Nuevo Mundo 1964 México Porrúa
-
Atikson Geoffroy Les Nouveaux horizons de la Renaissance française 1935 Paris Droz
-
Auroux Sylvain Histoire des idées linguistiques 1989-2000 Paris Madraga 3 vols.
-
Balagna Coustou Josée Arabe et humanisme dans la France des derniers Valois 1989 Paris Maisonneuve et Larose
-
Berdan Frances F. & Anawalt Patricia Rieff The Codex Mendoza 1992 Berkeley University of California Press 4 volumes
-
Brading David The First America. The Spanish Monarchy, Creole Patriots, and the Liberal State 1492-1867 1991 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Buffon Georges-Louis Leclerc de Histoire naturelle générale et particulière 1749-1767 Paris Imprimerie Royale 15 volumes
-
Cage Thomas Histoire de l’empire mexicain représenté par figures. Relation du Mexique ou de la nouvelle Espagne Paris André Cramoisy s.d.
-
Caldari Bevilacqua Franca Balmas Enea “Montaigne alla Biblioteca Vaticana” Montaigne e L’Italia. Atti del Congresso Internazionale di studi di Milano-Lecco, 26-30 ottobre 1988 1991 Genève Slatkine Gruppo di studio sul cinquecento francese
-
Cañizares Esguerra Jorge How to write the history of the New World. Historiographies, epistemolgies and identities in the eighteenth century Atlantic world 2001 Stanford Stanford University Press
-
Chartier Roger Écouter les morts avec les yeux. Leçon inaugurale au Collège de France 2008 Paris Fayard
-
Clavijero Francisco Javier Historia Antigua de México [1780] 2003 México Porrua
-
David Madeleine V. Le Débat sur les écritures et l’hiéroglyphe aux xviième et xviiième siècles et l’application de la notion de déchiffrement aux écritures mortes 1965 Paris Sevpen
-
Delmas Adrien & Penn Nigel Written Culture in a Colonial Context. Africa and the Americas 1500-1900 2012 Leiden Brill
-
Delmas Adrien & Penn Nigel Les Voyages de l’écrit. Culture écrite and expansion européenne à l’époque moderne. Essais sur la Compagnie Hollandaise des Indes Orientales 2013 Paris Honoré Champion
-
Durán Diego Historia de las Indias de Nueva Espana e islas de la tierra firme 1967 México Porrúa
-
Duret Nicolas Thrésor des langues de cet univers 1613 Cologne
-
Elliott John H. The Old World and the New 1970 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Escalante Gonzalbo Pablo Los códices mesoamericanos antes y después de la conquista española. Historia de un lenguaje pictográfico 2010 México Fondo de Cultura Económica
-
Findlen Paula Athanasius Kircher, the Last Man who Knew Everything 2004 New York-London Routledge
-
Fréret Nicolas “Réflexions sur les principes généraux de l’art d’écrire” Mémoires de littérature tirés des registre de l’Académie royale des inscriptions et belles-lettres 1731 9 Paris 328 369
-
Galindo y Villa Jesús Colección de Mendoza o Codice Mendocino 1979 México Editorial Cosmos
-
García-Arenal Mercedes & Mediano Fernando Rodríguez Un Oriente español. Los Moriscos y el Sacromonte en tiempos de Contrarreforma 2010 Madrid Marcial Pons
-
Gerbi Antonello La Disputa del Nuovo mondo, storia di una polemica, 1750-1900 1955 Milano R. Ricciardi
-
Gessner Conrad Mithridates, sive de dfferentis linguarum 1555 Tiguri exudebat Froschoverus
-
Gómez de Orozco Federico “Quién fue el autor material del Codice Mendocino” Revista Mexicana de Estudios Antropologicos V 1941 43 52
-
Grafton Anthony Rome reborn. The Vatican library and Renaissance culture 1993 Washington Library of Congress
-
Grafton Anthony Joseph Scaliger. A study in the history of classical scholarship 1983-1993 Oxford Clarendon Press
-
Grafton Anthony What was History? The Art of History in Early Modern Europe 2007 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Grévin Benoît Le Parchemin des Cieux. Essai sur le Moyen Âge du langage 2012 Paris Seuil
-
Griffin Clive Los Cromberger. La historia de una imprenta del siglo xvi en Sevilla y Méjico 1991 Madrid Cultura Hispánica
-
Groenewald Gerald “To Leibniz, from Dorha: A Khoi prayer in the Republic of Letters” Itinerario 28/1 2004
-
Gruzinski Serge L’Aigle et le dragon. Démesure européenne et mondialisation au xvie siècle 2011 Paris Fayard
-
Gruzinski Serge Les Quatre parties du Monde. Histoire d’une mondialisation 2004 Paris La Martinière
-
Hamilton Alastair Vrolijk Arnoud & van Ommen Kasper “Scaliger, The Orientalist” Scaliger’s Oriental legacy in Leiden, 1609-2009: catalogue of an exhibition on the quatercentenary of Scaliger’s death 2009 Leiden University of Leiden
-
Humboldt Alexander. von Vues des Cordillères, et monumens des peuples indigènes de l’Amérique 1813 Paris F. Schoell
-
Hummel Pascale Histoire de l’histoire de la philologie. Étude d’un genre épistémologique et bibliographique 2000 Genève Droz
-
Johansson Patrick Delmas & Penn “From pictures to letters: The early steps in the Mexican tlahcuilo’s alphabetization process during the 16th century” Written Culture in a Colonial Context. Africa and the Americas 1500-1900 2012 Leiden Brill 31 56
-
Kircher Athanasius China Illustrata 1667 Amsterdam
-
Kircher Athanasius Oedipus oegipciacus 1652-54 Rome
-
Kuhlmann Peter & Schneider Helmuth History of Classical Scholarship. A Biographical Dictionary 2013 Leiden Brill
-
Landa Diego de Relación de las cosas de Yucatán 1986 México Porrúa
-
La Peyrère Isaac de Præ-Adamitæ. Sive Exercitatio super versibus duodecimo, decimotertio and decimoquarto capitis quinti Epistolae D. Pauli ad Romanos, Systema theologicum ex Praeadamitarum hypothesi s.l., 1655
-
Laet Johannes de Histoire du Nouveau Monde ou description des Indes Occidentales 1640 Leiden Elzeviers
-
Lestringant Frank L’Atelier du cosmographe 1991 Paris A. Michel
-
Morales Padrón Francisco Teoría y leyes de la conquista 2008 Sevilla Universidad de Sevilla
-
Nebrija Elio Antonio de Gramática castellana [1492] 1992 Madrid Fundación Antonio de Nebrija
-
O’Gorman Edmundo de Acosta J. “Prólogo” Historia natural y moral de las Indias 2006 México Fondo de Cultura Económica
-
Olender Maurice Les Langues du Paradis 1994 Paris Le Seuil
-
Parker John Books to build an Empire 1965 Amsterdam N. Israël
-
Pauw Cornelius de Recherches philosophiques sur les Américains, ou mémoires intéressants pour servir à l’histoire de l’espèce humaine, par Mr de P. Nouvelle édition, augmentée d’une Dissertation critique par Dom Pernet; & de la Défense de l’Auteur des Recherches contre cette Dissertation 1768-1769 Berlin Decker
-
Pfeiffer Rudolf History of Classical Scholarship 1978 Oxford Clarendon Press
-
Pollock Sheldon “Future philology,” Critical Enquiry 35 2009
-
Pollock Sheldon, Elman Benjamin A. & Chang Ku-ming Kevin World Philology 2015 London Harvard University Press
-
Postel Guillaume De originibus seu de hebraicæ linguae et gentis antiquitate, deque variarum linguarum affinitate 1538 Paris D. Lescuier
-
Prescott William H. History of The Conquest of Mexico 1904 New York AMS Press
-
Purchas Samuel “Haklutus posthumus” or Purchas, his Pilgrims containing a history of the world in sea voyages and land travels by Englishmen and others 1625-1626 London H. Fetherston
-
Raynal Guillaume-Thomas Histoire philosophique et politique des établissements et des commerces des Européens dans les deux Indes 1770 Amsterdam 6 volumes
-
Roberston William History of America 1777 London Stahan
-
Roberston William The Works of William Robertson 1818 Edinburgh Hill
-
Sahagún Bernardino de Historia universal de las cosas de Nueva España 1969 México Porrúa
-
Sandys John E. A History of Classical Scholarship 1903-1908 Cambridge Cambridge University Press
-
Sebastiani Silvia “L’Amérique des Lumières et la hiérarchie des races. Disputes sur l’écriture de l’histoire dans l’Encyclopaedia Britannica (1768-1788)” Annales hss 67 2 (2012) 327 361
-
Simon Fabien Sortir de Babel. Une République des langues en quête d’une “langue universelle” à la Renaissance and a l’âge classique? 2011 Unpublished doctoral thesis
-
Subrahmanyam Sanjay “Intertwined Histories: Crónica and Tārīkh in the Sixteenth-Century Indian Ocean World,” History and Theory 49 2010 118 145
-
Thévet André Cosmographie universelle 1575 Paris Chaudière
-
Thévet André Grand insulaire 1586 Paris
-
Thévet André Singularitez de la France antarctique 1558 Anvers Plantin
-
Thouvenot Marc “Fray Bernardino de Sahagún et le Codex de Florence: un exemple de non-découverte de l’écriture aztèque” Amerindia, revue d’Ethnolinguistique amérindienne 19-20 1995 389 401
-
Torquemada Juan de Monarchia Indiana 1969 México Porrúa
-
Vico Giambattista La scienza nuova 1744 Napoli Muziana
-
Vie-Wohrer Anne-Marie “Découverte des écritures indigènes au xvie siècle dans le Mexique central” Amerindia, revue d’Ethnolinguistique amérindienne 19-20 1995 421 431
-
Waquet Françoise Le Latin ou l’empire d’un signe, xvie-xxe siècle 1998 Paris A. Michel
-
Warburton William The Divine Legation of Moses Demonstrated 1738-41 London F. Gyles
-
Webb John The Antiquity of China or an Historical Essay, Endeavouring a Probability that the Language of the Empire of China is the Primitive Language, Spoken Through the Whole Word, Before the Confusion of Babel 1669 London N. Brook
-
Wilkins John An Essay towards a Real Character and a Philosophical Language 1668 London S. Gellibrand and J. Martin
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 426 | 52 | 2 |
| Full Text Views | 47 | 7 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 66 | 17 | 0 |
Imperial and Philological Encounters in the Early Modern Era
European Readings of the Codex Mendoza
In: Philological EncountersAlthough the history of philology is merely an addition to the rediscovery of textual traditions which have been neglected for too long by academic philology, it is nonetheless an important one for its ability alone to provide an explanation of the existing asymmetric situation. When the world opened up after the 16th century following transoceanic navigations, European encounters with written traditions in America, Africa and Asia led to a variety of attitudes—from denial to fascination, from destruction to collection. These “philological encounters”, both material and conceptual, largely contributed to shape the views of the European Renaissance and the Enlightenment regarding language and writing. To understand the semiological and epistemological consequences of these views, this paper focuses on a single text produced at the time of the Spanish conquest of Mexico, the Codex Mendoza, and on the different interpretations to which the latter was subjected in Europe after crossing the Atlantic. The history of the Codex Mendoza would have us believe that it was during the 18th century, and not before, that writing became exclusively synonymous with alphabet, resulting in the marginalisation of non-alphabetic written systems—and this mainly for historiographical reasons.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 426 | 52 | 2 |
| Full Text Views | 47 | 7 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 66 | 17 | 0 |