In this article, I focus on Pope Francis’s “green” encyclical, Laudato Si’. After outlining some of its characteristics, I single out the pope’s engagement with anthropocentrism for critical discussion. The pope criticizes anthropocentrism (the view that human beings alone have intrinsic value), seeing it as a root cause of ecological destruction. Instead, he proposes what I would call a theocentric conception of nature. I criticize this view. First, I suggest that the pope is insufficiently critical in adopting a theocentric approach to the common creation story. Secondly, I argue from both a biblical-theological and a philosophical perspective against the pope’s resistance to the anthropocentrism of Genesis 1:26. Thirdly, I argue that because the pope opts for non-anthropocentrism, the encyclical falls short of offering a constructive way forward in relation to functioning in a technocratic society. Through these comments, I seek to strengthen the powerful and important message of this encyclical.
CapitanoW.E. (2005). A Study of the Anthropocentric Nature of Roman Catholic Church Teaching on the Environment from Vatican II to 2003. Ph.D. dissertationUniversity of St. Michael’s College and University of Toronto.
ColyvanM.LinquistS.GreyW.GriffithsP.OdenbaughJ. and PossinghamH.P. (2009). Philosophical Issues in Ecology: Recent Trends and Future Directions. Ecology and Society14 (2) art. 22. http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol14/iss2/art22/.
OrioliL. (2016). Laudato sì and the New Paradigm of Catholic Environmental Ethics: Reflections on Environmentalist Movements in Italy. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics29 (6) pp. 931–943.
RyanP.F. (2006). Secularist and Christian Views of Human Nature and Its Fulfillment: Implications for Bioethics and Environmentalism. In: RobinsonD.N.SweeneyG.M. and GillR. eds. Human Nature in Its Wholeness: A Roman Catholic PerspectiveWashington: The Catholic University of America Press57–79.
TristE.L. and BamfordK.W. (1951). Technological Content of the Work System. Defences of a Work Group in Relation to the Social Structure and of Coal-Getting: An Examination of the Psychological Situation and Some Social and Psychological Consequences of the Longwall Method. Human Relations4 (3) pp. 3–38.