Genocide, the Bible, and Biblical Scholarship

in Brill Research Perspectives in Biblical Interpretation
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

This essay makes the case that the ongoing scholarly conversation around divinely sanctioned violence can be enriched by engaging with the emerging field of comparative genocide studies. The argument proceeds in four parts. Part 1 introduces the term genocide and the scholarly debates that have emerged around it. I posit the existence of two generations of genocide scholarship, with the first focusing on definitional issues and appropriate terminology and the second on the historical-structural conditions that make genocide possible. Regarding the latter, particular attention shall be devoted to the emerging consensus that, far from being an atavistic irruption outside the world of civilized modernity, genocide is made possible by the very structure of modernity itself. Parts 2 and 3 look closely at genocide in the Hebrew Bible and New Testament era, respectively. These parts will examine the extermination campaigns of ancient empires (Assyria, Babylon, Rome) that brought destruction upon the biblical Israelites and will compare these imperial actions with modern settler and colonial genocides. This is one area where biblical scholars could fill in a lacuna in comparative genocide studies, since the topic has received modest attention in that particular field. I pay attention to the ways that the Bible appears complicit in genocide, whether through the command to exterminate the Canaanites or through the Gospels’ tendency to cast blame upon the Jews for the death of Jesus. I also analyze a variety of hermeneutical approaches developed to respond to these thorny issues, paying particular attention to the presumed views of genocide in each hermeneutical position. The final part of the essay explores the issue of genocidal ideology itself, emphasizing that the content of genocidal ideology is much broader than usually assumed by scholarly critiques of anti-Judaism and that genocidal ideology maintains a complex relationship to the actual practice of genocide. This part encourages scholars to reexamine the widely held beliefs on the ways that biblical ideology led to horrific events like the Holocaust and to take seriously the widely held conclusion that ideology alone is an inadequate explanation for genocide. The essay will conclude by suggesting possible future directions that could be taken by scholars who wish to confront the legacy of genocide in the Bible and its interpretation.

Genocide, the Bible, and Biblical Scholarship

in Brill Research Perspectives in Biblical Interpretation

Sections

References

AlyG. CooperBelindaBrownAllison “Final Solution”: Nazi Population Policy and the Murder of the European Jews 1999 London Arnold

AvalosH. Fighting Words: The Origins of Religious Violence 2005 Amherst, NY Prometheus Books

AvalosH. “Genocide: Biblical Scholarship as Biblical Apologetics” 2013 unpublished paper presented at the “Biblical ‘Genocide’” session for the Use Influence and Impact of the Bible and the Metacriticism of Biblical Scholarship groups at the Annual Meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature Baltimore Maryland

BaptistE. The Half Has Never Been Told: Slavery and the Making of American Capitalism Hardcover 2014 New York Basic

BauerY. ChorbajianL.ShirinianG. “Comparison of Genocides” 1999 31 46 1999

BaumanZ. Modernity and the Holocaust 1989 Ithaca Cornell University Press

BorgenP. EvansHagner “Polemic in the Book of Revelation” 1993 199 211 1993

BrownR. The Death of the Messiah. From Gethsemane to the Grave: A Commentary on the Passion Narratives in the Four Gospels 1994 Volume I New York Doubleday

BrowningC. Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland 1992 New York HarperPerennial

BrowningC. The Origins of the Final Solution: The Evolution of Nazi Jewish Policy September 1939–March 1942 2004 Lincoln University of Nebraska Press with contributions by J. Matthäus

CarterW. Matthew and Empire: Initial Explorations 2001 Harrisburg Trinity Press International

CaveA. Stone “Genocide in the Americas” 2008 273 295 2008

ChalkF.JonassohnK. The History and Sociology of Genocide 1990 New Haven Yale University Press

CharnyIsrael Meierhenrich “Genocidal Massacre” 2014 85 86 2014

ChiltonBruce EvansHagner “Jesus and the Question of Anti-Semitism” 1993 39 52 1993

ChorbajianL. ChorbajianL.ShirinianG. “Introduction” 1999 xv xxxiv 1999

ChorbajianL.ShirinianG. Studies in Comparative Genocide 1999 New York St. Martin’s

ChurchillW. A Little Matter of Genocide: Holocaust and Denial in the Americas 1492 to the Present 1998 San Francisco City Lights

CollinsJ. “The Zeal of Phinehas: The Bible and the Legitimation of Violence” jbl 2003 122 3 21

CopanP.FlannaganM. Did God Really Command Genocide? Coming to Terms with the Justice of God 2014 Grand Rapids Baker

CowlesC. S. CowlesMerrillGardLongmann “The Case for Radical Discontinuity” 2003 13 44 2003

CowlesC. S.MerrillE.GardD.LongmannT. Show Them No Mercy: Four Views on God and the Canaanite Genocide 2003 Grand Rapids Zondervan

CrossanJ. D. Who Killed Jesus? Exposing the Roots of Anti-Semitism in the Gospel Story of the Death of Jesus 1995 San Francisco HarperSanFrancisco

CurthoysA.DockerJ. Stone “Defining Genocide” 2008 9 41 2008

DubeM. The Postcolonial Feminist Interpretation of the Bible 2000 St. Louis Chalice

DunnJ. EvansHagner “Anti-Semitism in the Deutero-Pauline Literature” 1993 151 65 1993

EvansC. EvansHagner “Faith and Polemic: the New Testament and First-Century Judaism” 1993 1 17 1993

EvansC.HagnerD. EvansHagner “Preface” 1993 xix xx 1993

EvansC.HagnerD. Anti-Semitism and Early Christianity: Issues of Polemic and Faith 1993 Minneapolis Fortress

FeinH. AndreopoulousGeorge “Genocide, Terror, Life Integrity and War Crimes: The Case for Discrimination” Genocide: Conceptual and Historical Dimensions 1994 Philadelphia University of Pennsylvania Press 95 107

FeinH. Meierhenrich “A Sociological Definition” 2014 73 75 2014

FlemingM. GellatelyRobertKiernanBen “Genocide and the Body Politic” The Specter of Genocide: Mass Murder in Historical Perspective 2003 Cambridge Cambridge University Press 97 113

FogelR. W. Without Consent or Contract: The Rise and Fall of American Slavery 1989 New York Norton

FriedlanderH. The Origins of the Nazi Genocide: From Euthanasia to the Final Solution 1995 Chapel Hill University of North Carolina Press

FriedländerS. Nazi Germany and the Jews: 1939–1945 The Years of Extermination 2007 New York HarperCollins

GardD. CowlesMerrillGardLongmann “The Case for Eschatological Continuity” 2003 113 141 2003

GellatelyR.KiernanB. The Specter of Genocide: Mass Murder in Historical Perspective 2003 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

GerdmarAnders The Roots of Theological Anti-Semitism: German Biblical Interpretation and the Jews from Herder and Semler to Kittel and Bultmann 2009 Leiden Brill

GuelichR. EvansHagner “Anti-Semitism and/or Anti-Judaism in Mark?” 1993 80 101 1993

HagnerD. EvansHagner “Paul’s Quarrel with Judaism” 1993 128 150 1993

HarffB.GurrT. Meierhenrich “Politicide” 2014 75 76 2014

HatzfeldJ. CoverdaleL. Machete Season: The Killers in Rwanda Speak 2005 New York Farrar, Straus, and Giroux

HeschelS. Abraham Geiger and the Jewish Jesus 1998 Chicago University of Chicago Press

HeschelS. The Aryan Jesus: Christian Theologians and the Bible in Nazi Germany 2008 Princeton Princeton University Press

HorselyRichard A. Jesus and Empire: The Kingdom of God and the New World Disorder 2003 Minneapolis Fortress

JonesA. Genocide: A Comprehensive Introduction 2011 2nd edn London Routledge

KatzS. The Holocaust in Historical Context The Holocaust and Mass Death before the Modern Age 1994 Volume 1 Oxford Oxford University Press

KelleyShawn Racializing Jesus: Race Ideology and the Formation of Modern Biblical Scholarship 2002 London Routledge

KelleyShawn NasrallahLauraFiorenzaElisabeth Schüssler “Race, Aesthetics, and Gospel Scholarship: Embracing and Subverting the Aesthetic Ideology” Prejudice and Christian Beginnings: Investigating Race Gender and Ethnicity in Early Christian Studies 2009 Minneapolis Fortress 191 209

KelleyShawn Liew “Put Them to the Sword: The Bible and Gender in the Wake of Genocide” 2011 302 315 2011

KelleyShawn “Hear Then No More Parables: The Case against ‘Parable,’” jshj 2013 11 153 169

KelleyShawn “Hermeneutics and Genocide: Giving Voice to the Unspoken” Palgrave Communications 2015 Accessed on October 1 2015 http://www.palgrave.journals.com/articles/palcomms201531

KershawI. Hitler: 1889–1936 Hubris 1999 New York W. W. Norton & Company

KershawI. Hitler: 1936–1945 Nemesis 2000 New York W. W. Norton & Company

KiernanB. Blood and Soil: A World History of Genocide and Extermination from Sparta to Dafur 2007 New Haven Yale University Press

KuperL. Genocide: Its Political Use in the Twentieth Century 1981 New Haven Yale University Press

KysarR. EvansHagner “Anti-Semitism and the Gospel of John” 1993 113 127 1993

LangilleT. “Memories of Imagined Genocide in Book of Joshua: Narratives of Destruction, Purification, and Empty Lands” 2015 unpublished paper presented for the Hebrew Bible and Political Theory group at the Annual Meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature Atlanta Georgia

LemkinR. Axis Rule in Occupied Europe: Laws of Occupation Analysis of Government Proposals for Redress 2005 Clark Lawbook Exchange [original 1944]

LemkinR. Meierhenrich Genos and Cide 2014 57 61 2014

LeveneM. Genocide in the Age of the Nation State. Volume I : The Meaning of Genocide. 2008 London I. B. Tauris

LeveneM. Genocide in the Age of the Nation State The Rise of the West and the Coming of Genocide 2013 Volume II London I. B. Tauris

LewyG. Meierhenrich “Were the American Indians Victims of Genocide?” 2014 178 180 2014

LiewT-S. B. Politics of Parousia: Reading Mark Inter(con)textually 1999 Leiden Brill

LiewT-S. B. Liew “Introduction: Intervening on the Postcolonial” 2009 1 24 2009

LiewT-S. B. Postcolonial Interventions: Essays in Honor of R. S. Sugirtharajah 2009 Sheffield Sheffield Phoenix

LindsayB. Murder State: California’s Native American Genocide 1846–1873 2012 Lincoln University of Nebraska Press

LongerichP. Holocaust: The Nazi Persecution and the Murder of the Jews 2010 Oxford Oxford University Press

MackB. A Myth of Innocence: Mark and Christian Origins 1988 Philadelphia Fortress

MadleyB. “From Africa to Auschwitz: How German South West Africa Incubated Ideas and Methods Adopted and Developed by the Nazis in Eastern Europe” European Historical Quarterly 2005 35 429 464

MamdaniM. When Victims Become Killers: Colonialism Nativism and the Genocide in Rwanda 2001 Princeton Princeton University Press

MannM. The Dark Side of Democracy: Explaining Ethnic Cleansing 2005 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

MarcusM. EvansHagner “Epilogue” 1993 291 296 1993

MazowerM. Hitler’s Empire: How the Nazis Ruled Europe 2008 New York Penguin

McKnightS. EvansHagner “A Loyal Critic” 1993 55 79 1993

MeierhenrichJ. Meierhenrich “Introduction” 2014 3 55 2014

MeierhenrichJ. Genocide: A Reader 2014 Oxford Oxford University Press

MooreStephen D. Empire and Apocalypse: Postcolonialism and the New Testament 2006 Sheffield Sheffield Phoenix

MosesD. Stone “Genocide and Modernity” 2008 156 193 2008

MoshmanD. Stone “Conceptions of Genocide and Perceptions of History” 2008 71 92 2008

MurphyF. Early Judaism from the Exile to the Time of Jesus 2002 Peabody Hendrickson

NersessianD. Meierhenrich “Cultural Genocide” 2014 80 82 2014

NewmanC. FredriksenP.ReinhartzA. “Forward” Jesus Judaism and Christian Anti-Judaism: Reading the New Testament after the Holocaust 2002 Louisville Westminster John Knox ix xi

N. A. “Nuremberg Trial Proceedings” The Avalon Project: Documents in Law History and Diplomacy 1945–49 Accessed on April 28 2016 (http://avalon.law.yale.edu/imt/count.asp)

PattersonO. Slavery and Social Death: A Comparative Study 1982 Cambridge Harvard University Press

PattersonW. “Introduction” We Charge Genocide: The Historic Petition to the United Nations for Relief for a Crime of the United States Government against the Negro People 1951 New York Civil Rights Congress xi xiii

PowerS. A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide 2002 New York Harper Perenniel

ReutherR. Faith and Fratricide: The Theological Roots of Anti-Semitism 1974 New York Seabury

SaldariniA. Matthew’s Christian-Jewish Community 1994 Chicago University of Chicago Press

SandersE. P. Paul and Palestinian Judaism: A Comparison of Patterns of Religion. 1977 Minneapolis Fortress

SandersJ. EvansHagner “Forward” 1993 ix xvii 1993

SchwartzR. The Curse of Cain: The Violent Legacy of Monotheism 1997 Chicago University of Chicago Press

SegoviaFernando F. Decolonizing Biblical Studies: A View from the Margins 2000 Maryknoll Orbis

SeibertE. The Violence of Scripture: Overcoming the Old Testament’s Troubling Legacy 2012 Minneapolis Fortress

ShawM. What Is Genocide? 2007 Cambridge Polity

SnyderT. Bloodlands: Europe between Hitler and Stalin 2010 New York Basic Books

StannardDavid Meierhenrich “American Holocaust” 2014 176 178 2014

StoneD. Stone “Introduction” 2008 1 6 2008

StoneD. The Historiography of Genocide 2008 New York Palgrave Macmillan

StraussS. “Second Generation Comparative Research on Genocide” World Politics 2007 59 476 501

TiedeD. EvansHagner “Fighting Against God: Luke’s Interpretation of Jewish Rejection of the Messiah Jesus” 1993 102 112 1993

TodorozT. Meierhenrich “The Conquest of America” 2014 181 183 2014

TolbertM. Sowing the Gospel: Mark’s World in Literary-Historical Perspective 1989 Minneapolis Fortress

VargasJ. Never Meant to Survive: Genocide and Utopias in Black Diaspora Communities 2008 Lanham Rowman & Littlefield

WahlR.LaneW. EvansHagner “Polemics in Hebrew and Catholic Epistles” 1993 166 198 1993

WarrenM. Meierhenrich “Gendercide” 2014 78 80 2014

WeheliyeA. Habeas Viscus: Racializing Assemblages Biopolitics and Black Feminist Theories of the Human 2014 Durham Duke University Press

Weiss-WendtA. Stone “Problems in Comparative Genocide Scholarship” 2008 42 70 2008

WimbushV. WimbushV. “Introduction” Theorizing Scriptures: New Critical Orientations to a Cultural Phenomenon 2008 New Brunswick Rutgers University Press 1 20

2

See Kuper 1981: 22 for an explanation of some of the terminological complexity.

8

Regarding individual lifespan see Jones 2011: 59 n. 105; Fogel 1989: 424 n. 2 p. 424; and Patterson 1982: 164.

23

One very promising exception is Langille 2015which is part of a larger project that is informed by genocide and trauma theory on the imaginative and mythical function of the genocidal narratives in Joshua. It asks what it means for a people who survived genocide to create a genocidally inflected myth of origins. I am grateful to Dr. Langille for sharing his paper with me.

29

On this framing technique see Tolbert 1989: 311–15Appendix A.

31

For my analysis of Mack see Kelley 2009: 200–202.

32

See Crossan 1995: 12–13120–27 on the place of scripture in the process of creating tradition and Crossan 1995: 100–112 for his identification of Mark’s literary fingerprints in constructing and indeed inventing most of the Passion Narrative.

41

See especially Mazower 2008: 204–211245–56 412–14; Snyder 2010: 159–61 172–73 187–89 227.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 15 15 8
Full Text Views 7 7 7
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0