Paradiplomacy as a Diplomatic Broker

Between Separating Differences and Engaging Commonalities

in Brill Research Perspectives in Diplomacy and Foreign Policy
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Since the publication of Der Derian’s seminal work “On Diplomacy”, diplomacy has been thought of as the mediation of estrangement between separated individuals, groups or political entities. This article focuses on paradiplomacy, the diplomatic practices of sub-state entities, as a specific site of diplomatic mediation, striking a middle ground between “realist” power play and the humanist need to connect to and engage with others. Indeed, the mediating of estrangement can be situated between both extremes of a continuum, with on the one hand absolute humanist diplomacy, aimed at rescinding all forms of separation between peoples, and on the other hand absolute power play diplomacy, maximizing these differences.



AcutoMichele Global cities, governance and diplomacy: The urban link 2013 Oxford Routledge

Adler-NissenRebecca “Just Greasing the Wheels? Mediating Difference or the Evasion of Power and Responsibility in Diplomacy.” The Hague Journal of Diplomacy 2015 10 22 28

BanaiHusein “Diplomatic imaginations: mediating estrangement in world society.” Cambridge Review of International Affairs 2014 27 3 459 474

BélangerLuis “Les enjeux actuels de la participation du Québec à la francophonie multilatérale: de la paradiplomatie à la protodiplomatie.” Politique et Sociétés 1997 16 1 39 59

BetsillMicheleCorellElisabeth NGO Diplomacy: The Influence of Nongovernmental Organizations in International Environmental Negotiations 2008 Cambridge MIT Press

BhabhaHomi K. “Of Mimicry and Man: The Ambivalence of Colonial Discourse.” October 1984 28 125 133

BizouxAngélique Catalogne: l’émergence d’une politique extérieure 2006 Strasbourg L’Harmattan

BjolaCorneliu “Understanding Enmity and Friendship in World Politics: the Case for a Diplomatic Approach. ” The Hague Journal of Diplomacy 2013 8 1 20

BlackJeremy A History of Diplomacy 2010 London Reaktion Books

BrennanT. Corey EilersClaude “Embassies gone wrong: Roman diplomacy in the Constantinian Excerpta De Legationibus.” Diplomats and Diplomacy in the Roman World 2009 Leiden Brill 171 192

BrubakerRogers Ethnicity Without Groups 2004 Cambridge Harvard University Press

BursensPeterDeforcheJana “Going beyond paradiplomacy? Adding historical institutionalism to account for regional foreign policy competences.” The Hague Journal of Diplomacy 2010 5 1–2 151 171

ButlerRohan SarkissianArshag O. “Paradiplomacy.” Studies in Diplomatic History and Historiography in Honor of G.P. Gooch 1961 London Longman 12 25

CantirCristian “Russian-Backed Paradiplomacy in the ‘Near Abroad’: Gagauzia, Moldova and the Rift over European Integration.” The Hague Journal of Diplomacy 2015 10 261 284

CardinalMario Breaking Point: Quebec, Canada, The 1995 Referendum 2005 Montreal Bayard Canada Books

Carod-RoviraJosep El papel de Catalunya en l’Europa del segle XXI 2009 Barcelona C.l.d.i. conferències, Generalitad de Catalunya

Carod-RoviraJosep the Generalitad de Catalunya “Introduction.” Catalonia Foreign Affairs Strategy 2010 11 Barcelona Generalitad de Catalunya

ConstantinouCostas “On homo-diplomacy.” Space and Culture 2009 9 351 364

ConstantinouCostasDer DerianJames ConstantinouCostasDer DerianJames “Sustaining Global Hope: Sovereignty, Power and the Transformation of Diplomacy.” Sustainable Diplomacies 2010 Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan 1 22

ConstantinouCostas ConstantinouCostasDer DerianJames “Diplomacy, Spirituality, Alterity.” Sustainable Diplomacies 2010 Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan 67 88

CornagoNoé “On the Normalization of Sub-state Diplomacy.” The Hague Journal of Diplomacy 2010a 5 1–2 11 36

CornagoNoé ConstantinouCostasDer DerianJames “Perforated Sovereignties, Agonistic Pluralism and the Durability of (Para)Diplomacy.” Sustainable Diplomacies 2010b Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan 89 108

CornagoNoé Exploring the global dimensions of paradiplomacy: Functional and normative dynamics in the global spreading of subnational involvement in the international affairs 2010c Ottawa Forum des federations

CornagoNoé “(Para)Diplomatic Cultures: Old and New” 2013 Paper presented at the International Workshop “Alternative Cultures of Diplomacy November, 2013 UNPO/The Hague

CriekemansDavidDuranManuelMelissenJan Towards a ‘third wave’ in sub-state diplomacy? 2009 Antwerp Policy Research Center on Foreign Policy

CriekemansDavidDuranManuel SteinmetzRobert “Small state diplomacy compared to sub-state diplomacy: more of the same or different?” Small states in Europe: challenges and opportunities 2010 Farnham Ashgate 31 46

CriekemansDavid CriekemansDavid “Regional sub-state diplomacy from a comparative perspective: Quebec, Scotland, Bavaria, Catalonia, Wallonia and Flanders.” Regional sub-state diplomacy today 2010a Leiden Martinus Nijhoff 37 64

CriekemansDavid Foreign Policy and Diplomacy of the Belgian Regions: Flanders and Wallonia 2010b The Hague Clingendael Discussion Papers in Diplomacy

DelmartinoFrank Pacheco AmaralCarlos E. “The international policy of Flanders.” Autonomie régionale et relations internationals 2011 Paris L’Harmattan 45 74

DenzaEileen Diplomatic law: Commentary on the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations 2004 Oxford Oxford University Press

DuchacekIvo The territorial dimension of politics within, among and across nations 1986 Boulder Westview Press

DuchacekIvo D. MichelmannHansSoldatosPanayotis “Perforated Sovereignties: Towards a Typology of New Actors in International Relations.” Federalism and International Relations. The Role of Subnational Units 1990 Oxford Clarendon Press 1 34

DuranManuelCriekemansDavidMelissenJan Een vergelijkend onderzoek naar en bestedingsanalyse van het buitenlands beleid en de diplomatieke representatie van regio’s met wetgevende bevoegdheid en kleine staten 2008 Antwerpen Vlaams Steunpunt Buitenlands Beleid

DuranManuel “An archaeology of Mediterranean diplomacy: the evidence of paradiplomacy.” International journal of Euro-Mediterranean Studies 2013 5 147 158

DuranManuel Mediterranean Paradiplomacies. Dynamics of Diplomatic Reterritorialization 2015 Boston Brill

ElazarDaniel Exploring Federalism 1987 Tuscaloosa University of Alabama Press

FlemingChris René Girard: Violence and Mimesis 2004 Cambridge Polity

FoucaultMichel YoungRobert “The Order of Discourse.” Untying the Text: A Post-Structuralist Reader 1981 Boston, London, Henley Routledge & Kegan Paul 48 78

FresaMatilde “Le politiche della Regione Emilia-Romagna con il popolo saharawi: Una ‘borderlinking line’ tra cooperazione decentrata e paradiplomacy.” Afriche e orienti: rivista Di studia i confini tra Africa, Mediterraneo e Medio Oriente 2006 3 4

GirardRené Violence and the Sacred 1977 Baltimore The Johns Hopkins University Press

GirardRené Quand les choses commenceront. Entretiens avec Michel Treguer 1996 Paris Arléa

GrayDavid Doing Research in the Real World 2009 London Sage

GrydehœjAdam GrydehœjAdam “Goals, capabilities, and instruments of paradiplomacy by subnational jurisdictions.” Paradiplomacy 2014 Brussels Centre Maurits Coppieters 10 21

Guerrero i TarragóMarc La identitat en l’actuació exterior subestatal: Actuacions governementals de Catalunya i de l’estat de Washington 2007 Barcelona University of Barcelona Ph.D for the Departement de sociologia i analisi de les organitzacions Barcelona

HansenThomas BlomStepputatFinn States of Imagination: Ethnographic Explorations of the Postcolonial State 2001 Durham Duke University Press

HockingBrian Localizing Foreign Policy. Non-Central Governments and Multilayered Diplomacy 1993 New York St. Martin’s Press

HockingBrian “Beyond ‘newness’ and ‘decline’: the development of catalytic diplomacy.” Diplomatic Studies Programme Discussion Paper (dspdp) 1995 10 Diplomatic Studies Programme, Leicester University

HockingBrian AldecoaFransiscoKeatingMichael “Patrolling the ‘Frontier’: Globalization, Localization and the ‘Actorness’ of Non-Central Governments.” Paradiplomacy In Action: The Foreign Relations of Subnational Governments 1999 London Frank Cass 17 39

HockingBrian Futures for diplomacy. Integrative Diplomacy in the 21st Century 2013 The Hague Netherlands Institute of International Relations ‘Clingendael’

IzzoMarina Questioni e prospettive della cooperazione decentrata dall’ Andalusia alla Toscana. Un’indagine sulla governance multilivello 2006 CeSPI Working Papers 27/2006

JacobsonJon When the Soviet Union entered world politics 1994 Berkeley University of California Press

KeatingMichael “Regions and International Affairs: Motives, Opportunities and Strategies.” Regional and Federal Studies 1999 9 1 1 16

KeatingMichael Plurinational Democracy: Stateless Nations in a Post-Sovereign Era 2001 Oxford Oxford University Press

KenealyDaniel “Commercial Interests and Calculated Compassion: The Diplomacy and Paradiplomacy of Releasing the Lockerbie Bomber.” Diplomacy and Statecraft 2012 23 555 575

KhannaParag How to Run The World: Charting a Course to the Next Renaissance 2011 New York Random House

Kocho-WilliamsAlastair Russian and Soviet Diplomacy, 1900–39 2012 Basingstoke Palgrave MacMillan

KuznetsovAlexander Theory and Practice of Paradiplomacy: Subnational Governments in International Affairs 2015 Milton Park Routledge

LachapelleGuyPaquinStéphane “Quebec’ international strategies: mastering globalization and new possibilities of governance.” 2013 Paper presented at the Conference Québec and Canada in the New Century: New Dynamics, New Opportunities Queen’s University School of Policy Studies 31 October–1 November 2003

LancasterCarol Foreign Aid: Diplomacy, Development, Domestic Politics 2007 Chicago University of Chicago Press

LecoursAndré “Paradiplomacy: Reflections on the Foreign Policy and International Relations of Regions.” International Negotiation 2002 7 1 91 114

LecoursAndré DuthoitVirginieHuijghEllen “Political Issues of Paradiplomacy: Lessons from the Developed World.” Discussion Papers on Diplomacy 2008 The Hague Netherlands Institute of International Relations ‘Clingendael’

Lohmar Sainz de VicuňaRamón “Catalan Paradiplomacy, Secessionism and State Sovereignty. The Effects of the 2006 Statute of Autonomy and the Artur Mas Government on Catalan Paradiplomacy.” 2015 ma thesis, University of Leiden

MarksGaryHoogheLiesbetSchakelArjan H “Measuring regional authority.” Regional and Federal Studies 2008 18 2–3 111 121

McConnellFionaMoreauTerriDittmerJason “Mimicking state diplomacy: The legitimizing strategies of unofficial diplomacies.” Geoforum 2012 43 4 804 814

MelissenJan Innovation in diplomatic practice 1999 Basingstoke New York Palgrave

MintzAlexDeRouenKarl Understanding foreign policy decision making 2010 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

MouffeChantal Agonistics. Thinking the World Politically 2013 London Verso

NicolsonHarold The Evolution of Diplomacy 1962 Springfield Collier Books

NietzscheFriedrich ScarpittiMichael A. HolubRobert C. On the Genealogy of Morals 2013 New York Penguin Classics

PaquinStéphane Paradiplomatie identitaire en Catalogne 2003 Québec Les Presses de l’ Université Laval

PaquinStéphane Paradiplomatie et relations internationales: Théorie des strategies internationales des regions face à la mondialisation 2004 Brussel P.I.E.-Peter Lang

PaquinStéphaneLachapelleGuy LachapelleGuyPaquinStephane “Why do sub-states and regions practice international relations?” Mastering Globalization. New substates’ governance and strategies 2005 London and New York Routledge 77 89

PauwelsJacques R. De Groote Klassenoorlog 1914–1918 2014 Berchem EPO Uitgeverij

PetricErnest Foreign Policy: from conception to diplomatic practice 2013 Leiden and Boston Martinus Nijhoff

PhilippartEric “Gouvernance à niveaux multiples et relations extérieures: le développement de la ‘paradiplomatie’ au sein de l’Union européenne et la nouvelle donne belge.” Revue Études internationales 1998 XXIX 3 631 646

PipesRichard The Russian Revolution 1991 New York Vintage Books

PujolJordi StrubellToni “Interview with Jordi Pujol.” What Catalans Want? 2011 Ashfield Catalonia Press 54 59

RanaKishan S. 21st Century Diplomacy. A practitioner’s guide 2011 London and New York Bloomsbury

RegioneEmilia-Romagna Progetti di cooperazione internazionale, pace e diritti umani 2010 Bologna Servizio Politiche Europee e Relazioni Internazionali

RiordanShaun The New Diplomacy 2002 Cambridge Polity Press

RutanGerard “Provincial Participation in Canadian Foreign Relations.” Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs 1971 13 2 230 245

SatowErnest Mason A guide to diplomatic practice 1932 London Longmans

SchacterNoelBeebeJimZanasiLuigi Globalization and the North: Impacts of Trade Treaties on Canada’s Northern Governments 2004 Ottawa Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives

SharpPaul Diplomatic Theory of International Relations 2009 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

SoldatosPanayotis MichelmannHansSoldatosPanayotis “An Explanatory Framework for the Study of Federated States as Foreign-policy Actors.” Federalism and International Relations. The Role of Subnational Units 1990 Oxford Clarendon Press 34 53

StavridisStelios “The Parliamentary Forum of the Euro-Mediterranean Partnership: An Assessment.” Mediterranean Politics 2002 7 2 30 53

StavridisStelios KöllingM.StavridisS.SolaN. Fernandez “Parliamentary Diplomacy: Any Lessons for Regional Parliaments?” Las relaciones internacionales de las regiones: actores sub-nacionales, para-diplomacia y gobernanza multinivel / The International Relations of the Regions: Subnational Actors, Paradiplomacy and Multilevel Governance 2007 Zaragoza Universidad de Zaragoza 55 81

StocchieroAndrea I nodi dell’evoluzione della cooperazione decentrata italiana 2007 CeSPI Working Papers 37/2007

Van AlsteinMaarten The Great War Remembered: Commemoration and Peace in Flanders Fields 2011 Brussels Flemish Peace Institute

VelaersJan JudoFrankGeudensGodfried “ ‘In foro interno, in foro externo’: De internationale bevoegdheden van gemeenschappen en gewesten.” Internationale Betrekkingen 2006 Ghent Larcier 3 86

VerbruggenDidier Vredesopbouw en conflictpreventie in het Vlaamse buitenlandbeleid: een blauwdruk voor de inzet van expertise 2015 Brussels Vlaams Vredesinstituut

WaeterloosEvert Vlaamse ontwikkelingssamenwerking en de zoektocht naar doeltreffende hulp 2008 Antwerp Vlaams Steunpunt Buitenlands Beleid

WernickAndrew Bataille’s Columbine: The Sacred Space Of Hate 1999 online article, Centre for the Study of Theory, published 11/3/1999

Wheeler-BennettJohn W. “The Meaning of Brest-Litovsk Today.” Foreign Affairs 1938 137 152 October 1938

ZanonBruno “Infrastructure Network Development, Re-territorialization Processes and Multilevel Territorial Governance: A Case Study in Northern Italy.” Planning Practice and Research 2011 26 3 325 347


Cited by Didier Verbruggen, Vredesopbouw en conflictpreventie, 9.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 33 33 16
Full Text Views 14 14 7
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 2 2 0