Freedom of Religion and Its Regulation in Nigeria: Analysis of Preaching Board Laws in Some States of Northern Nigeria

in Brill Research Perspectives in Law and Religion
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

The re-enactment of religious preaching board laws to regulate religious preaching in some states of Northern Nigeria generated debates between Government on the one hand and religious/human rights groups on the other. This research examines the Preaching Board Laws of Kano, Borno and Kaduna States in Northern Nigeria through the prism of the Nigerian Constitution and other democratic norms that relate to the right to freedom of religion in all democratic orders. It applies argumentative methodology to raise and analyse the following questions: how reasonable and justifiable are these religious preaching board laws in a democratic Nigeria?; what gave rise to the enactment of these laws in the states under study?; what judicial review mechanism would be employed to determine their reasonableness and justifiability in a democracy?; how do they accord with the freedom of religion clause in the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria? The research establishes that some of the provisions of these laws are inconsistent with the provisions of the Nigerian Constitution and, by extension, international freedom of religion norms operating in all democratic orders. Second, Nigerian courts have not developed suitable balancing mechanisms for resolving conflicts between the right of the state to regulate and citizens’ right to freedom of religion otherwise called the two competing rights, in the light of which the research calls for the amendment of the laws to accord with the provisions of the Constitution and international freedom of religion norms acceptable in all democracies. The paper further recommends a harmonised proportionality test or judicial standard of review based on Nigeria’s religion-state relations and local experience for the use of courts, legislators and administrative agents coming face to face with this type of conflict in their official capacity.

Freedom of Religion and Its Regulation in Nigeria: Analysis of Preaching Board Laws in Some States of Northern Nigeria

in Brill Research Perspectives in Law and Religion

Sections

References

Attorney-General of Ogun State v A.G. Federation and Ors (1982) 3 nclr 166

Attorney-General of Bendel State v A.G. Federation & Ors (1982) 3 nclr 358

Adamolekun v University of Ibadan (1968) nmlr 253

Lakanmi v Attorney-General of Western Region & Ors (1971) u.i.l.r. 201

Ojiegbe & Ors v Ubani & Ors (1961) All nlr 277

R. T. N. B. C. & Anor v The R.T. A. C.O. & Ors (1992)7 nwlr (PT251)

Shodeinde and Ors v Registered Trustees of Ahmadiyya (1983) nscc 523

Shugaba Darman v Minister of Internal Affairs and Ors (1982) 2 nclr 459

Cantwell v. Connecticut [310 u.s. 296303 (1940)]

Canwell v. Connecticut [310 u.s. 296 (1940)]

Christian Legal Society v. Martinez [130 S. Ct. 2971 (2010)]

Church of Lukumi Babalu Aye Inc v. City of Hialeah [508 u.s. 520 (1993)]

Employment Division v. Smith [494 u.s. 872 (1990)]

Frazee v. Illinois Department of Unemployment Security [80 u.s. (13 Wall) 679(1871)]

Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church & School v. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission [132 S. Ct. 694 (2012)]

Locke v. Davey [540 u.s. 712 (2004)]

McCollum v. Board of Education [333 u.s. 203 (1948)]

McGowan v. Maryland [366 u.s. 420 (1961)]

Reynolds v. United State [98 u.s. 145 (1879)]

Sherbert v. Verner [374 u.s. 398 (1963)]

Watson v. Jones [489 u.s. 829 834 (1989)]

Wisconsin v. Yoda [406 u.s. 205 (1972)]

Blake v. Associated Newspapers [(2003) ewhc 1960]

Bruker v. Marcovitz [(2007)3 scr 607]

Free Church of Scotland v. Overtoun [(1904) ac 515 at 644–5]

Handyside v. United Kingdom

Khaira v. Shergil [(2012) ewca Civ 983]

Kokkinakis v. Greece [260Eur.Ct. H.R.(ser. A) (1993)]

Singh v Eastern Media Group [2010] ewhc (qb) 1260]

Bauchi State Religious Preaching (Suspension) Law 1987

Bauchi State Religious Preaching Law 1984

Borno State Islamic Religious Preaching Law 2010

Kano State Religious Preaching Edict 1985

Katsina State Regulation Religious Preaching Law 1991

Kebbi State Religious Preaching Board Law 2004

Jigawa State Religious Preaching Edict 1985 [inherited from Kano]

Nassarawa State Regulation of Public Preaching Edict 1986 [inherited from Plateau state]

Niger State Islamic Religious Preaching Edict 1979

Niger State Islamic Religious Preaching Edict 1985

Plateau State Regulation of Public Preaching Edict 1986

Sokoto State Certain Religious Preaching Edict 1979/1986

Yobe State Religious Preaching Edict 1994

African Charter on Human and Peoples Rights 1981

International Covenant of Economic Social and Cultural Rights 1966

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966

The American Convention on Human Rights 1969

The European Declaration on Human Rights 1950

The United Nation Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief (Declaration on Religion) 1981

Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948

AbdullahiS.U.On the Search for a Viable Political Culture: Reflections on the Political Thought of Shaikh Abdullahi Dan FodioNew Nigerian Newspapers Ltd, Kaduna 1984.

AfolayanF.“Religion and Politics in Colonial Nigeria: The Life and Career of Sir Walter Miller, 1782–1952,” in Religion in Politics: Secularism and National Integration in Modern Nigeria ed. JuliusO. Adekunle (New Jersey Inc: Africa World Press, 2009) 3766.

AharonB.Constitutional Rights and Their LimitationsCambridge University PressU.K. 2012.

BerkeyJ.P.Popular Preaching and Religious Authority in the Medieval Islamic near EastUniversity of Washington PressSeattle2001.

BrendanS.Why Politics Needs Religion: The Place of Religious Arguments in the Public SphereIVF AcademicIllinois2006.

BrianJ.G. and Roger F.The Price of Freedom DeniedCambridge University PressNew York2011.

BrianJ. Grim and Roger FinkeInternational Religion Index: Government Favouritism and Social Regulation of Religion (Interdisciplinary Journal of Research on Religion)2006.

EdwardM. and Jonathan. V.The Power of Religion In The Public Sphere (Columbia University PressNew York2011).

GumiA. with TsigaI.A.Where I StandSpectrum Books LtdIbadan1992.

HanaV.O.Religious Symbols in Public Functions: A Comparative Analysis of Dutch English and French Justifications for Limiting the Freedom of Public Officials to Display Religious SymbolsIntersentiaCambridge2012.

HareI. and WeinsteinJ.Extreme Speech and Democracy (Oxford University PressOxford2009).

IslamA.M.Freedom of Religion in Sharia: A Comparative Analysis (A.S. NoordeenKuala Lumpur2008.

JohnW. J and ChristianM.G.Religion and Human Rights: An IntroductionOxford University PressNew York2012.

LoimeierR.Islamic reform and political change in northern NigeriaNorth Western University PressEvanston 1997.

KukaM.H.Religion Power and Politics in Northern NigeriaIbadan: Spectrum Books Limited2011.

MohammedB.Infaq al-Mansur ed. C.E.J. Whiting (London1957).

OstienP.A Survey of the Muslims of Nigeria’s North Central Geo-Political Zone in: Nigeria Research Network (nrn) Oxford Department of International DevelopmentQueen Elizabeth House, Oxford Univerisy (NRN) Working Paper No. 1.

PadenJ.N.Faith and politics in Nigeria: Nigeria as a pivotal state in the Muslim worldUnited States Institute of Peace PressWashington, D.C.2008.

PadenJ.N.Muslim Civic Cultures and Conflict Resolution: The Challenge of Democratic Federalism in NigeriaBrookings Institution PressWashington, D.C.2005.

PeltzeAudreyA Survey of Constitutional Challenges to Municipal Regulation of Religious Solicitation and a Suggested Legislative Compromise Fordham Urban Law JournalVolume 11Issue 4Article 191982.

RicardoR.L.Islamic Law and Politics In Northern NigeriaAfrica World PressNew Jersey2011.

SaeedA.G.The British Policy Towards the Mahdiyya in Northern Nigeria: A Study of the Arrest Detention and Deportation of Shaykh Said b. Hayat 1923–1959 Kano StudiesII/3198219851985.

SalterM. and MasonJ.Writing Law Dissertations: An Introduction and Guide to the Conduct of Legal ResearchPearson Education LtdEngland2007.

ShedrackG.B. (ed) Religion and PostConflict Peacebuilding in Northern Nigeria (John Archers LtdIbadan2011).

SmithJ.M.‘Redefining Normative Legal Science: Towards an Argumentative Discipline’ in: A.P.M. Coomans and F. Grunfeld (eds) Methods of human rights researchIntersentia, Antwerp2009.

StephenV.M. and ChristopherJ.S.Church and State in Five Democracies: The Challenge of Pluralism 2nd edition (Rowman and Littlefield Publishers IncNew York2009).

SulaimanI.The Islamic State and the Challenge of History: Ideals Policies and Operation of the Sokoto Caliphate Mansell, London1987.

ToftM.D.PhilpottD. and ShahT.S.God’s CenturyW.W. Norton & CompanyLondon2011.

TomlinsonG.J.F. and LethemG.J.History of Islamic political propaganda in NigeriaWaterlow, London1927.

UbahC.N.British Measures against Mahdism at Dumbulwa in Northern Nigeria 1923: A Case of Colonial Overreaction Islamic Culture I/31976 pages 169183.

UdomaU.History and the Law of the Constitution of NigeriaMalthouse Press LtdUK1994.

UmarM.S.Islam and Colonialism: Intellectual Responses of Muslims of Northern Nigeria to British Colonial RuleBrill, Leiden & Boston2006.

UsmanB.Y.The Manipulation of Religion in Nigeria 1977–1987Vanguard Printers and PublishersKaduna1987.

VincentP.M.Religious Liberty and the American Supreme Court: The Essential Cases and Documents (Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc2013).

ZahradeenNasir B.The Maitatsine SagaHudahuda Publishing Co.Zaria1988.

AdekunleJ.O. (ed) Religion in Politics: Secularism and National Integration in Modern Nigeria Africa World PressTrenton, NJ 2009.

AllenD.H. (ed) The Future of Religious Freedom: Global ChallengesOxford University Press 2013.

BarkindoB.M.“Growing Islamism in Kano City since 1970: Causes, Form and Implications” in: BrennerL. (ed) Muslim Identity and Social Change in Sub-Saharan AfricaIndiana University Press, Bloomington and Indianapolis1993 pages 91105.

ChrisS.Dennis. R.H. and PaulettaO. (ed) The Routledge Handbook of Religion and SecurityRoutledge, New York2013.

ClarkeP.“The Maitatsine Movement in Northern Nigeria in Historical and Current Perspective” in: R.I.J. Hackett (ed) New Religious Movements in NigeriaE. Mellen PressLewiston, N.Y.1987.

CristianaC.DurhamW.C.Jr. and DonluT. (eds) Law Religion and Constitution: Freedom of Religion Equal Treatment and the LawAshgate Publishing Company, USA2013.

GamalielJ.D.“An analysis of Religion under the 1999 Constitution and Prospects for Peace building in Nigeria” in: BestG.S. (ed) Religion and Post Conflict Peace Building in Northern Nigeria (John Archers, Ibadan2011) page 114115.

GunnJ.T in: WitteJ. Jr. & GreenM.C. (eds) Religion & Human rights: An IntroductionOxford University PressNew York2012.

GwanduA.A.“Aspects of the Administration of Justice In The Sokoto Caliphate And Shaykh Abdullahi Ibn Fodio’s Contribution to it” in: RashidK.S (ed) Islamic Law in Nigeria (Islamic Publications BureauKaduna1986) Page 1027.

HellelF.HusainH.Eric Brown and HassanM. (ed) Current Trends in Islamists Ideologyvol. 14Hudson InstituteNew York2013.

HellelF.HusainH.Eric Brown and HassanM. (ed) Current Trends in Islamists Ideologyvol. 15Hudson InstituteNew York2013.

HellelF.HusainH.Eric Brown and HassanM. (ed) Current Trends in Islamists Ideologyvol. 16Hudson InstituteNew York2014.

HellelF.HusainH.Eric Brown and HassanM. (ed) Current Trends in Islamists Ideologyvol. 17Hudson InstituteNew York2014.

JamesT.R. (ed) Regulating Religion: Case Studies from Around the Globe (Kluwer Academic/Plenum PublishersNew York2004).

JamesT.R.“Major Controversies involving New Religious Movements” in: Olav Hammer and Mikael Rothstein (eds) The Cambridge Companion to New Religious Movements (Cambridge University Press, UK2012).

JohnL.John. K. and Wilfried. S.Rutledge Handbook of Regionalism and FederalismRutledgeNew York2013.

JuliusO.A. (ed) Religion In Politics: Secularism and National Integration in Modern NigeriaAfrica World Press IncNew Jersey2009.

KabirA.“Nature of Legal Research for New Researchers” in: AhmedA.BIssues in Research Methodology in Law (ed) Faculty of Law, B.U.K.Kano2010.

KumoS.“Shari’ia Under Colonialism-Northern Nigeria” in: AlkaliN.et al. (ed) Islam in West AfricaSpectrum Books LtdKaduna1993 Page 122.

Last M.Reform in West Africa: The Jihad Movements of the Nineteenth Century In: J.F.A. Ajayi (ed) History of West Africavol. 21987 page 147.

LovejoyP.E. and J.S. Hogendorn“Revolutionary Mahdism and Resistance to Colonial Rule in the Sokoto Caliphate, 1905–6” in: The Journal of African History31/2 (1990) pages 217244.

MarkT.ThomasF. and CherylS. (eds) Rutledge Handbook of Constitutional LawRutledgeNew York2013.

MazruiA.A.“African Islam and Comprehensive Religion :Between Revivalism and Expansion” in AlkaliN. et al.Islam in AfricaSpectrum Books LimitedIbadan1993 Page 247265.

McConvilleM. & ChuiW.H. (eds) Research Methods for LawEdinburgh University Press LtdEdinburgh2007.

MorenoP. (ed) Handbook on Religious Liberty around the WorldRutherford InstituteCharlottesville, Virginia1996.

PieterC.GreenM.C. and LenH. (eds) Law and Religion in Africa: The Quest for Common good in pluralistic societiesSun MediaStellenbosch2015.

SmithJ.M.‘Redefining Normative Legal Science: Towards an Argumentative Discipline’ in: A.P.M. Coomans and F. Grunfeld (eds) Methods of Human Rights ResearchIntersentiaAntwerp2009.

StephenM.F. (ed) Law and Religion: A Critical AnthologyNew York University PressNew York2000.

UmarM.S.“Changing Islamic Identity in Nigeria from the 1960s to the 1980s: From Sufism to anti Sufism” in: BrennerL. (ed.) Muslim Identity and Social Change in Sub-Saharan Africa154178Indiana University Press, Bloomington and Indianapolis1993.

Dan FodioA.(here: b. Foduye A.) Diya al-Umara: A Guide for Rulers Concerning their Demands and Obligations. With Arabic and English texts edited and translated by Hamidu Alkali (Centre for Islamic Studies, Usmanu Danfodiyo UniversitySokoto2004).

Dan FodioA.Diya al-Hukkam. Published in Arabic by Dar al-Arabia Li Diba’ati wa al-Nashur (Cairo n.d.) Hausa Translation Published by Gaskiya Corporation (n.d.) and reprinted by (Sidi Umaru PressSokoto1984).

Dan FodioU.Kitab al-Farqpublished in Arabic with English translation by M. Hiskett in Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 23 (1960).

GumiA.M.Al-aqidah al-sahihah bi muwafiqah al-shari’ah (The right belief is based on the shari’ah) in Arabic with English translation by Dr. M.O.A. Abdul. Ankara: Hilal Publishing House, n.d. [The Arabic text of the Al-aqidah al-sahihah was published in 1972; date of publication of the text with English translation is not given.]

MaghiliM.Bayreuth: Imprimerie Catholique. The Obligations of Princes: An Essay on Moslem kingship. Translated from the Arabic by T.H. Baldwin (1932).

MaghiliM.Sharīʻa in Songhay: The replies of al-Maghīlī to the questions of Askia al-Ḥājj Muḥammad. Edited and translated with an introduction and commentary by John O. Hunwick. Published for the British Academy by Oxford University PressLondon; New York1985.

ChristelowA.“Religious Protest and Dissent in Northern Nigeria from Mahdism to Quranic integralism”Journal of the Institute of Muslim Minority Affairs6/2 (1985) Pages 375393.

ClarkeP.“Islamic Reform in Contemporary Nigeria: Aims and Methods” In: Third World Quarterly 10/2 (1988) Page 519538.

GamboY.L. and OmirinM.M.“Ethno Religious Conflict and Settlement Pattern in Northern Nigeria”Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciencesvol. 3 (3) September2012.

HackettR.I.J.“Regulating Religious Freedom in Africa” in: Sharia Family And Democracy: Religious Norms and Family Law in Pluralistic Democratic States Emory Int’ L.L.Rev. Emory University School of Law Atlanta Georgia2011.

HiskettM.“The Maitatsine Riots in Kano, 1980: An Assessment”Journal of Religion in AfricaXVII/3 (1987) 209223.

LassonKennethIncitement in the Mosques: Testing the Limits of Free Speech and Religious Liberty27 Whittier L. Rev. 32005–2006.

Rev. VishighR.I.“The Separation of Church and State: Nigeria’s Constitutional Contrivance. Another View”Current Jos Law Journal (1998) cjljVol. 4 No. 4. Pages 107123.

ReynoldsJ.“Good and Bad Muslims: Islam and Indirect Rule in Northern Nigeria”. The International Journal of African Historical Studies34/3 (2001).

ShikylS.S.Judicial Attitude to Human Rights in Nigeria Under Civilian DispensationVol.31997Unijos lsj Pp. 90100.

Terwase SampsonIsaacReligious Violence in Nigeria: Causal Diagnosis and Strategic Recommendations to the State and Religious CommunitiesAfrican Journal on Conflict Resolution2012.

VollJ.O.“The British, the Ulama, and Popular Islam in the Early Anglo-Egyptian Sudan”. International Journal of Middle East Studies2/3 (1971).

YaduduA.H.The Separation of Church and State: Nigeria’s Constitutional Contrivance. Lawyers Bi-AnnualJournal of the Nigerian and Comparative Law (1994) vol. 1&2.

Francis U. “Nigeria: Boko Haram- Islamic Leaders to vet Clerics.” In: Daily Trust Newspaper page 11 4 August 2009.

New Nigerian Newspaper Paid advertorial by “Katsina State Government.” September 2011.

This Day Newspaper Nigeria: Borno Approves 150 Preachers for Ramadan” August 2009.

Anwar A. Gardawa Ulama and the State in Northern Nigeria: the Maitatsine Phenomenon 1962–1985. Ph.D. dissertation (unpublished) University of Maiduguri (1997).

Bako S. The Maitatsine revolts: A Socio-Political Explanation of the Islamic Insurrections in Northern Nigeria 1980–1985. Ph.D. dissertation (unpublished) Ahmadu Bello University Zaria. (1992).

Chamberlin J.W. The Development of Islamic Education in Kano City Nigeria With Emphasis on Legal Education in the 19th and 20th Centuries Ph.D Dissertation (unpublished) Columbia University (1975).

Wakili H. The Phenomenon of Revolts and Riots in Kano 1983–1995: an historical perspective. Ph.D. dissertation (unpublished) Bayero University Kano (1997).

Imam G.A. Malam Lawal Kalarwi: Nazarin Sassan Adabi A Cikin Ayyukansa. M.A. Hausa thesis (unpublished) Department of Hausa Bayero University Kano (2005)

Borno State of Nigeria Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Religious Disturbances in Bullum Kuttu Area of Maiduguri Between the 26th–29th October 1982–1983.

Centre for Democratic Research and Training Report of a Commissioned Study on the Ulama in Contemporary Northern States of Nigeria Submitted to the Federal Government of Nigeria. Kano: Mambayya House Bayero University Kano. (2005).

Da’wah Coordination Council of Nigeria The “Boko Haram” Tragedy: Responses to 26 of the most commonly asked questions regarding the “Boko Haram” crisis and tragedy (Da’wah Coordination Council of Nigeria Minna Nigeria 2009).

Federal Government of Nigeria Report of Tribunal of Inquiry on Kano Disturbances. (Federal Government Press Lagos 1981).

Federal Republic of Nigeria Report of the Jimeta Disturbances Tribunal of Inquiry 1984.

Federal Republic of Nigeria Views of the Government of the Federation on the Report of the Kano Disturbances Tribunal of Inquiry (National Assembly Press Lagos 1981).

Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life Global Restrictions on Religion (Pew Research Center Washington d.c. 2009).

United States Commission on International Religious Freedom’s Reports for 2014 2013 2012 2011 and 2010 available at www.uscirf.gov/sites/default/files/USCIRF%20A accessed on the 19th day of October 2015 at 2:00pm.

Middleton H.H. Memo to Residents Kano Zaria Sokoto and Niger. Missionary Activities in Muslim Centres 13 December 1926.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 165 165 61
Full Text Views 48 48 15
PDF Downloads 6 6 3
EPUB Downloads 19 19 7