The Christian Quaker: George Keith and the Keithian Controversy
In: Brill Research Perspectives in Quaker StudiesSearch for other papers by Madeleine Ward in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
How did the early Quakers understand the relationship between Quakerism and Christianity? Did they think faith in Jesus was necessary? What did they mean by the ‘Light within’? These were the central issues in the Keithian controversy: an explosive schism which broke out among Philadelphian Quakers in the 1690s when George Keith – arguably the most influential Quaker theologian of the seventeenth century – was accused of focusing too heavily on the Incarnate Jesus in his preaching. Keith left the movement under a cloud, and the Keithian controversy has often been explained away in terms of personality and politics. However, this volume presents a theological reading of the dispute. Through a study of Keith’s personal theological development, Madeleine Ward presents his departure from the movement as a significant case – study in the contested relationship between Quakerism and Christianity – and, ultimately, as a battle for the spiritual heart of the Religious Society of Friends.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
‘A true Copy of ye ffriends in Maryland’, 4 October 1692, in Philadelphia Yearly Meeting’s Epistles Sent and Received, 1662–1699, Quaker & Special Collections, Haverford College, C5.1–3, vol. 1, 31.
-
‘Caleb Pusey’s Manuscript History of Quakers in Pennsylvania’, undated, in Records of Philadelphia Monthly Meeting (4th and Arch Streets), Quaker & Special Collections, Haverford College, 1250/JG5.5.
-
‘Correspondence between Allison C. Gottesman and Alice P. Allen’, 15 November 1965– 10 February 1966, in Keithian Controversy Manuscripts, Friends Historical Library, Swarthmore College, MSS 032.
-
‘Epistle of the Burlington Women at Yearly Meeting to the Box Meeting’ 7 September 1692, in Box Meeting Manuscripts, The Library of the Society of Friends, Friends House, 44.
-
‘Epistle from Public Friends’, 20 June 1692, in Keithian Controversy Manuscripts, Friends Historical Library, Swarthmore College, MSS 032, no. 3.
-
‘Epistle’, 7 September 1692, in Keithian Controversy Manuscripts, Friends Historical Library, Swarthmore College, MSS 032, no. 5 ½.
-
‘Gospel Order & Discipline Improved’, undated, in Keithian Controversy Manuscripts, Friends Historical Library, Swarthmore College, MSS 032.
-
Minutes of the Morning Meeting of Ministers and Elders 1692–1700, The Library of the Society of Friends, Friends House, YM/MfS/MOR/M2, vol. 2.
-
Minutes of London Yearly Meeting 1694–1701, The Library of the Society of Friends, Friends House, YM/M2, vol. 2.
-
Minutes of Philadelphia Men’s Monthly and Quarterly Meeting 1682–1705, Haverford Quaker & Special Collections Library, Haverford College, 1250/JB1.5.
-
Minutes of Philadelphia Women’s Yearly Meeting 1681–1820, Quaker & Special Collections, Haverford College, 1250/.
-
Minutes of Philadelphia Men’s Yearly Meeting 1681–1710, Quaker & Special Collections, Haverford College, 1250/A1.1–2.
-
Minutes of Philadelphia Meeting of Ministers and Elders 1686–1734, Friends Historical Library, Swarthmore College, MR-Ph476.
-
‘Testimony against George Keith’, 31 August 1692, in Rough papers of the Philadelphia Yearly Meeting, Quaker & Special Collections, Haverford College, box D1.1, item 37.
-
‘Some of our Principles’ undated, in Keithian Controversy Manuscripts, Friends Historical Library, Swarthmore College, MSS 032, no. 1 ½.
-
‘US Philadelphia YM of Women Friends to Philadelphia, 1698–1836’, 21 September 1698, in Philadelphia Yearly Meeting’s Epistles Sent and Received, 1662–1699, Quaker & Special Collections, Haverford College, 5.18.
-
Anon. Mr George Keiths reasons, M2265A (London: booksellers of London and Westminster, 1700).
-
Anon. One wonder more, added to the seven, O336B (London?: s.n., 1700).
-
Arscott, Alexander. Some considerations, ESTC T115189 (London: Lombard Street, 1779).
-
Barclay, Robert. An apology for the true Christian divinity, B720 (Aberdeen?: s.n. 1678).
-
Barclay, Robert. The possibility & necessity of the inward immediate revelation, B732 (s.l.: s.n, 1686).
-
Barclay, Robert. Theses theologicae, B737 (Amsterdam: Ben Christoffel Cunrat, 1675).
-
Barclay, Robert and George Keith. Quakerism confirmed, or, a vindication, B733 (London?: s.n., 1676).
-
Bealing, Benjamin, and George Keith. The pretended yearly meeting of the Quakers, K193 (London: Levis, 1695).
-
Budd, Thomas. A brief answer to two papers, B5355 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1692).
-
Budd, Thomas. An expostulation with Thomas Lloyd, B5357 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1692).
-
Budd, Thomas. A true copy of three judgements … against George Keith, B5361 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1692).
-
Budd, Thomas and George Keith. The plea of the innocent, K189 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1692).
-
Burnet, Gilbert. Bishop Burnet’s History of his own time, ed. Thomas Burnet, 2 vols, vol. 2, ESTC 144689 (London: Ward, 1724–1734).
-
Burnet, Gilbert. A supplement to Burnet’s History of My Own Time, ed. Helen C. Foxcroft (Oxford: Tanner Ritchie, 1902).
-
Conway, Anne. Principles, C5989 (London: s.n., 1692).
-
Croese, Gerard. A general history of the Quakers, C6965 (London: Dunton, 1696).
-
Ellwood, Thomas. An answer to George Keith’s narrative, E613 (London: Sowle, 1696).
-
Ellwood, Thomas. An epistle to Friends, E620 (London: Sowle, 1693).
-
Ellwood, Thomas. A further discovery of that spirit of contention … George Keith, E623 (London: Sowle, 1694).
-
Ellwood, Thomas. Truth defended … from the false charges of George Keith, E629 (London: Sowle, 1695).
-
Evans, Francis. The Diary of Francis Evans, secretary to Bishop Lloyd, 1699–1706, ed. David Robertson (Oxford: Parker and co., 1903).
-
Hicks, Elias. The Journal of Elias Hicks, ed. Paul Buckley (San Francisco: Inner Light Books, 2009).
-
Jennings, Samuel. The state of the case briefly, J670 (London: Sowle, 1694).
-
Keith, George. An advertisement of an intended meeting, K137C (London: s.n., 1696).
-
Keith, George. An appeal from the twenty-eight judges to the spirit of truth, K140 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1692).
-
Keith, George. The arraignment of worldly philosophy, K143 (London: Levis, 1694).
-
Keith, George. The benefit, advantage and glory of silent meetings, K144 (London: s.n., 1670).
-
Keith, George. The causeless ground of surmises, K149 (London: Levis, 1694).
-
Keith, George. The Christian faith of the people of God, K151 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1692).
-
Keith, George. The Christian Quaker, K153 (London: Keach, 1693).
-
Keith, George. The deism of William Penn, K156 (London: Aylmer, 1699).
-
Keith, George. Divine immediate revelation, K157A (London: s.n., 1684).
-
Keith, George. An exact narrative of the proceedings, K161 (London: Aylmer, 1696).
-
Keith, George. False judgements reprehended, K164 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1692).
-
Keith, George. Mr George Keith’s farewell sermon, K165 (London: booksellers of London and Westminster, 1700).
-
Keith, George. A farewel sermon to the Quakers, ESTC R490614 (Derby: Grice, 1700).
-
Keith, George. George Keith’s fourth narrative, K167 (London: Aylmer, 1700).
-
Keith, George. George Keith’s fifth narrative, ESTC T85231 (London: Aylmer, 1701).
-
Keith, George. The fundamental truths of Christianity, K168 (London: s.n., 1688).
-
Keith, George. A further discovery of the spirit of falsehood, K170 (London: Levis, 1694).
-
Keith, George. A general epistle to friends, K171 (Aberdeen?: s.n., 1671).
-
Keith, George. Help in time of need, K173 (Aberdeen: s.n., 1665).
-
Keith, George. The heresie and the hatred, K174 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1693).
-
Keith, George. Immediate revelation, K175 (Aberdeen: s.n., 1668).
-
Keith, George. Immediate revelation, K177 (London: s.n., 1676 edn.).
-
Keith, George. A journal of travels from New-Hampshire to Caratuck, ESTC TO61193 (London: Downing, 1706).
-
Keith, George. The light of truth triumphing, K179 (London: s.n., 1670).
-
Keith, George. A looking-glass for all those, K180 (London: s.n., 1674).
-
Keith, George. Mr Keith’s sermon preach’d, K210 (London: booksellers of London and Westminster, 1700).
-
Keith, George. A plain discovery, ESTC T85242 (London: Aylmer, 1701)
-
Keith, George. A plain short catechism, K188 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1690).
-
Keith, George. The Presbyterian and independent visible churches in New-England, K190 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1689).
-
Keith, George. The pretended antidoe [sic], K192A (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1690).
-
Keith, George. Quakerism no popery, K194 (London: s.n., 1675).
-
Keith, George. A refutation of three opposers of truth, K199 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1690).
-
Keith, George. A salutation of dear and tender love, K202 (Aberdeen?: s.n., 1665).
-
Keith, George. A second narrative of the proceedings at Turners Hall, K204 (London: Aylmer, 1697).
-
Keith, George. A sermon preach’d, 1700, K209A (London: Aylmer, 1700).
-
Keith, George. Some reasons and causes, K215 (Philadelphia: Bradford, 1692).
-
Keith, George. The standard of the Quakers examined, ESTC T85248 (London: Aylmer, 1702).
-
Keith, George. A third narrative of the proceedings at Turners Hall, K218 (London: Brome, 1698).
-
Keith, George. The true Christ owned, K219 (London: s.n., 1679).
-
Keith, George. Two Sermons, K226 (London: Bowyer, 1700).
-
Keith, George. The way cast up and the stumbling-blockes removed, K233 (Aberdeen: s.n., 1677).
-
Keith, George. The way to the city of God, described, K235 (London: s.n., 1678).
-
Keith, George, and George Whitehead. The light of truth triumphing, K179 (London: s.n., 1670).
-
Leslie, Charles. The snake in the grass, L1156 (London: Brome, 1696).
-
Leslie, Charles. Satan dis-rob’d from his disguise of light, L1149A (London: Brome, 1697).
-
Lodowick, Christian. A Letter from., L2813 (Boston?: Mather?, 1692).
-
Mather, Cotton. The principles of Protestant religion maintained, A1029 (Boston: Pierce, 1690).
-
More, Henry. Conjectura cabbalistica, M2647 (London: Flesher, 1653).
-
More, Henry. An explanation of the grand mystery of godliness, M2658 (London: Flesher, 1660).
-
More, Henry. The immortality of the soul, M2663 (London: Flesher, 1659).
-
More, Henry. Two letters concerning self-love, ESTC N64274 (London: Downing, 1708).
-
Penn, William. A discourse of the general rule of faith, P1277 (London: Sowle, 1699).
-
Penney, Norman (ed.). Extracts from State Papers relating to Friends 1654–1672 (London: Headley Brothers, 1913).
-
Philadelphia Monthly Meeting. An Exhortation & Caution to Friends, K162 (New York: Bradford, 1693).
-
Sewel, William. The history of the rise, increase, and progress of the Christian people called Quakers (London: Sowle, 1722).
-
Van Helmont, Francis Mercury. Two hundred queries moderately propounded, H1396 (London: Kettlewell, 1684).
-
Von Rosenroth, Christian Knorr. Kabbalah denudata, 2 vols, no ESTC (Sulzbach: Lichtenthaler, 1677–1678).
-
Whitehead, George. The power of Christ vindicated, ESTC T102435 (London: Sowle, 1708).
-
Whitehead, George. The Christian doctrin [sic] and society of the … Quakers, W1905 (London: Northcott, 1693).
-
Anon. ‘A Brief Review. Bishop Doane’s Sermon, – Rev. Mr. Keith, – and the Society of Friends’ (s.l.: s.n., 1838?).
-
Anon. ‘George Keith’, in The Friend: A religious and literary journal, 3, 12 (1830), 94–95.
-
Anon. ‘George Keith’, in The Friend: A religious and literary journal, 3, 16 (1830), 125–126.
-
Anon. ‘George Keith’, in The Friend: A religious and literary journal, 7, 32 (1834), 253–254.
-
Anon. ‘George Keith’, in The Friend: A religious and literary journal, 7, 33 (1834), 261–262.
-
Bailey, Richard. New Light on George Fox and Early Quakerism: The Making and Unmaking of a God (San Francisco: Mellen Research University Press, 1992).
-
Birkel, Michael. ‘Immediate Revelation, Kabbalah, and Magic: The Primacy of Experience in the Theology of George Keith’, in Stephen W. Angell, and Pink Dandelion (eds.) Early Quakers and their Theological Thought, 1647–1723 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015), 256–272.
-
Birkel, Michael. ‘Robert Barclay and Kabbalah’, in Quaker Studies, 21, 1 (2016), 1–15.
-
Bowden, James. The History of the Society of Friends in America, 2 vols, vol. 2 (London: Charles Gilpin, 1850).
-
Braithwaite, William. The Beginnings of Quakerism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1955 edn.).
-
Braithwaite, William. The Second Period of Quakerism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1961 edn.).
-
Brown, Iva V. ‘Pennsylvania’s Antislavery Pioneers, 1688–1776’, in Pennsylvania History, 55, 2 (1988), 58–77.
-
Brinton, Daniel. ‘George Keith, and the first schism in Penn’s colony’, in The Daily Evening Telegraph, 12 January 1880 (Philadelphia).
-
Burnet, George, and William Hutton Marwick. The Story of Quakerism in Scotland, 1650–1850 (London: Clarke, 2007).
-
Butler, Jon. ‘Gospel order improved: the Keithian schism and the exercise of Quaker ministerial authority’, in William and Mary Quarterly, 31 (1974), 431–452.
-
Butler, Jon. ‘Into Pennsylvania’s spiritual abyss: The rise and fall of the later Keithians, 1693–1703’, in The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, 10, 2 (1977), 150–171.
-
Butler, Jon. ‘The records of the first “American” denomination: The Keithians of Pennsylvania (1694–1700)’, in The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, 120, 1 (1996), 89–105.
-
Cadbury, Henry J. ‘George Keith to Henry More’, in Journal of the Friends Historical Society, 46, 1 (1954), 59–63.
-
Cadbury, Henry J., and J. William Frost. ‘Caleb Pusey’s Account of Pennsylvania’, in Quaker History, 64, 1 (1975), 37–57.
-
Cadbury, Henry J., and J. William Frost. ‘Caleb Pusey’s Account of Pennsylvania (concluded)’, in Quaker History, 64, 2 (1975), 116–124.
-
Champion, Justin. The Pillars of Priestcraft Shaken (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992).
-
Clarke, T.E.S., Helen C. Foxtrot and C.H. Firth (eds.). A life of Gilbert Burnet, Bishop of Salisbury (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1907).
-
Cody, Edward. ‘The Price of Perfection: The Irony of George Keith’, in Pennsylvania History: A Journal of Mid-Atlantic Studies, 39, 1 (1972), 1–19.
-
Coudert, Allison. ‘Henry More, the Kabbalah and the Quakers’, in Richard Kroll, Richard Ashcraft and Perez Zagorin (eds.), Philosophy, Science and Religion in England, 1640–1700 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992), 31–67.
-
Coudert, Allison. The Impact of the Kabbalah in the Seventeenth Century: The Life and Thought of Francis Mercury Van Helmont, 1614–1698 (Leiden: Brill, 1999).
-
Coudert, Allison. ‘A Quaker-Kabbalist Controversy: George Fox’s Reaction to Francis Mercury van Helmont’ in Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 39 (1976), 171–189.
-
Creasey, Maurice. ‘Inward and Outward: A Study in Early Quaker Language’, in Journal of the Friends Historical Society, supplement 30 (1962), 1–24.
-
Dan, Joseph. Kabbalah: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006).
-
Davies, Godfrey, and Paul H. Hardacre. ‘The Restoration of the Scottish Episcopacy, 1660–1661’, in Journal of British Studies, 1, 2 (1962), 32–51.
-
Evans, Oleh Charles. Friends in the Seventeenth Century (Philadelphia: Pile, 1876).
-
Ferlier, Louisiane. Itinéraire dans la dissidence George Keith (1639–1716), une biographie intellectuelle (Paris: Honoré Champion, 2016).
-
Frost, J. William. The Keithian Controversy in Early Pennsylvania (Norwood: Norwood Editions, 1980).
-
Frost, J. William. ‘Unlikely Controversialists: Caleb Pusey and George Keith’, in Quaker History, 64, 1 (1975), 16–36.
-
Geiter, Mary. ‘William Penn and Jacobitism: A Smoking Gun?’, in Historical Research, 73, 181 (2000), 213–218.
-
Gough, John. A history of the people called Quakers, 4 vols. (Dublin: Jackson, 1789–1790).
-
Hallamish, Moshe. An Introduction to the Kabbalah, transl. Ruth Bar-Ilan and Ora Wisking-Elper (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1999).
-
Hamilton, Alasdair. The Family of Love (Cambridge: Clarke, 1981).
-
Hamm, Thomas. The Transformation of American Quakerism: Orthodox Friends 1800–1907 (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1992).
-
Hampton, Jennifer May. ‘British Quaker Survey: Examining Religious Beliefs and Practices in the Twenty-first Century’, in Quaker Studies, 19, 1 (2014), 7–136.
-
Hill, Christopher. The World Turned Upside Down (London: Temple Smith, 1972).
-
Hull, William. Benjamin Furly and Quakerism in Rotterdam (Swarthmore: Swarthmore College, 1941).
-
Hutton, Sarah. Anne Conway: A Woman Philosopher (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009).
-
Johns, David L. ‘Convincement and Disillusionment: Printer William Bradford and the Keithian Controversy in Colonial Philadelphia’, in Journal of the Friends Historical Society, 57, 1 (1994–1996), 21–32.
-
Jones, Rufus. ‘Introduction’, in William Braithwaite, The Second Period of Quakerism (London: MacMillan, 1919), xxiii–xlv.
-
Kirby, Ethyn Williams. George Keith, 1638–1716 (New York: D. Appleton-Century co., 1942).
-
Lee, Maurice Jr. ‘James VI and the Revival of Episcopacy in Scotland: 1596–1600’, in Church History, 43, 1 (1974), 50–64.
-
Lewis, Simon. ‘Early Anti-Methodism as an Aspect of Theological Controversy in England c.1738–c.1770’, DPhil thesis, University of Oxford, 2017.
-
MacCulloch, Diarmaid. A History of Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years (London: Penguin, 2010).
-
MacCulloch, Diarmaid. Reformation: Europe’s House Divided, 1490–1700 (London: Allen Lane, 2003).
-
MacCulloch, Diarmaid. ‘Protestantism in Mainland Europe: New Directions’, in Renaissance Quarterly, 59, 3 (2006), 698–706.
-
Marsh, Christopher. The Family of Love in English Society, 1550–1630 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994).
-
Martin, Clare. ‘Controversy and Division in Post-Restoration Quakerism: the Hat, Wilkinson-Story and Keithian Controversies and Comparisons with the Internal Divisions of Other Seventeenth-Century Nonconformist Groups’, DPhil thesis, Open University, 2004.
-
McDowell, Nicholas. The English Radical Imagination: Culture, Religion and Revolution, 1630–1660 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003).
-
McInroy, Mark J. ‘Origen of Alexandria’, in Sarah Coakley and Paul Gavrilyuk (eds.), The Spiritual Senses: Perceiving God in Western Christianity (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011), 20–35.
-
Murphy, Andrew. Liberty, Conscience & Toleration: The Political Thought of William Penn (New York: Oxford University Press, 2016).
-
Nash, Gary B. Quakers and Politics: Pennsylvania, 1681–1726 (Boston: Northeastern University Press, 1993 ed.).
-
Nicolson, Marjorie. ‘George Keith and the Cambridge Platonists’, in Philosophical Review, 39 (1930), 36–55.
-
Nicolson, Marjorie (ed.). The Conway Letters, rev. Sarah Hutton (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992).
-
Norris, Richard A. Jr. (ed.). The Christological Controversy (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1980).
-
Parrish, Joseph (?). ‘Bishop Doane’s sermon, “Rev. Mr Keith” and the Society of Friends’, in A series of essays (Princeton: Horner, 1835), 1–21.
-
Pennington, Edgar Legare. Apostle of New Jersey: John Talbot, 1645–1727 (Philadelphia: Church Historical Society, 1938).
-
Peters, Kate. ‘Patterns of Quaker Authorship, 1652–1656’, in Prose Studies, 17 (1994), 6–28.
-
Peters, Kate. Print Culture and Early Quakers (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005).
-
Pocock, John. ‘Post-Puritan England and the Problem of the Enlightenment’, in Perez Zagorin (ed.), Culture and Politics: from Puritanism to Enlightenment (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1980), 91–111.
-
Pomfret, John. The Province of West New Jersey, 1609–1702 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1956).
-
Proud, Robert. The History of Pennsylvania, in North America, 2 vols, vol. 1 (Philadelphia: Poulson, 1797).
-
Raffe, Alasdair. ‘Presbyterians and Episcopalians: the Formation of Confessional Cultures in Scotland, 1660–1715’, in The English Historical Review, 125, 514 (2010), 570–598.
-
Raffe, Alasdair. ‘The Restoration, the Revolution and the Failure of the Episcopacy in Scotland’, in Tim Harris and Stephen Taylor (eds.), The Final Crisis of the Stuart Monarchy (Woodbridge: Boydell Press, 2013), 87–108.
-
Reay, Barry. The Quakers and the English Revolution (Southampton: Camelot Press, 1985).
-
Reid, Jasper. The Metaphysics of Henry More (Dordrecht: Springer, 2012).
-
Roads, Judith. ‘The Language of Historical Religious Controversies: The Case of George Keith and the Quaker Movement in England’, in Journal of Religion in Europe, 11 (2018), 46–72.
-
Rodes, John. A Quaker Post-bag, ed. Sophy Felicité de Rodes (London: Longmans, 1910).
-
Scholem, Gershom G. Major Trends in Jewish Mysticism (New York: Schoken, 1961).
-
Scott, Janet. Swarthmore Lecture 1980: What Canst Thou Say? Towards a Quaker Theology (London: Quaker Home Service, 1980).
-
Sharpless, Isaac. ‘Early Days – The Keith Controversy’, in Rufus Jones, The Quakers in the American Colonies (New York: Norton, 1966), 437–458.
-
Shelton, Kenneth A. ‘The way cast up: The Keithian schism in an English Enlightenment context’, PhD thesis, Boston College, 2009.
-
Smith, Joseph. A Descriptive Catalogue of Friends’ Books, 2 vols, vol. 2 (London: Smith, 1867).
-
Spurr, John. The Restoration Church of England, 1646–1689 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1991).
-
Thomas, Allen C. review of William Braithwaite, The Second Period of Quakerism (London, 1919), in Quaker History, 9, 2 (1919), 62–65.
-
Trowell, Stephen. ‘George Keith: Post-Restoration Quaker Theology and the Experience of Defeat’, in Bulletin of the John Rylands Library, 76, 1 (1994), 119–138.
-
Vann, Richard T. The Social Development of English Quakerism, 1655–1725 (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1969).
-
Wall, Alexander J. ‘William Bradford, Colonial Printer – A Tercentenary Review’, in Proceedings of the American Antiquarian Society, 73 (1964), 361–384.
-
Ward, Madeleine. ‘The Intellectual Context for the Development of Quakerism, 1647–1700’, DPhil thesis, University of Oxford, 2017.
-
Ward, Madeleine. ‘Robert Barclay’s Christology’ in Quaker Religious Thought, 131 (2018), 25–32.
-
Weimer, Adrian Chastain. Martyrs’ Mirror: Persecution and Holiness in Early New England (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011).
-
Wragge, Philip. ‘The Debt of Robert Barclay to George Keith: The Life and Writings of Keith to 1677, and their influence on Barclay’, PhD thesis, University of Birmingham, 1946.
-
Chamberlain, J.S. ‘Keith, George (1638?–1716)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004; online edn, Oct 2005. http://ezproxy-prd.bodleian.ox.ac.uk:2167/view/article/15264, accessed 19 Nov 2014.
-
Frost, J. William. ‘George Fox’s ambiguous anti-slavery legacy’, Quakers & Slavery Project, 1991. <http://web.tricolib.brynmawr.edu/speccoll/quakersandslavery/commentary/people/fox.php>, accessed 28th May 2018.
-
Howe, F.A. ‘St Andrew’s: The Keith Memorial Window’, Fulking.net, 19 February 2015. <http://fulking.net/st-andrews-the-keith-memorial-window/> accessed 2 January 2018.
-
Westminster Assembly. ‘Westminster Confession of Faith (1646)’, Center for Reformed Theology and Apologetics, 1996–2017. <https://reformed.org/documents/wcf_with_proofs/index.html> accessed 21 May 2018.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 2517 | 610 | 133 |
| Full Text Views | 58 | 2 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 85 | 5 | 0 |
The Christian Quaker: George Keith and the Keithian Controversy
In: Brill Research Perspectives in Quaker StudiesSearch for other papers by Madeleine Ward in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
How did the early Quakers understand the relationship between Quakerism and Christianity? Did they think faith in Jesus was necessary? What did they mean by the ‘Light within’? These were the central issues in the Keithian controversy: an explosive schism which broke out among Philadelphian Quakers in the 1690s when George Keith – arguably the most influential Quaker theologian of the seventeenth century – was accused of focusing too heavily on the Incarnate Jesus in his preaching. Keith left the movement under a cloud, and the Keithian controversy has often been explained away in terms of personality and politics. However, this volume presents a theological reading of the dispute. Through a study of Keith’s personal theological development, Madeleine Ward presents his departure from the movement as a significant case – study in the contested relationship between Quakerism and Christianity – and, ultimately, as a battle for the spiritual heart of the Religious Society of Friends.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 2517 | 610 | 133 |
| Full Text Views | 58 | 2 | 0 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 85 | 5 | 0 |
