The Human Right to Water in Latin America

Challenges to Implementation and Contribution to the Concept

in Brill Research Perspectives in International Water Law
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

This monograph investigates the development of the right to water (RtW) and of water law in the Latin American context. Specifically, it examines the significance of Latin American (la) constitutional evolution, doctrine, and jurisprudential contribution in stimulating the social, political, and economic debate on the RtW, regionally and worldwide. Firstly, an overview on the RtW in la constitutions is provided and the impact of the findings is highlighted. The main la water management systems are then reviewed with an acknowledgment that an analysis of the RtW has to take account of its application in specific contexts. The intrinsic connection between the RtW and the role of the private sector is examined through specific insights into the highly privatized Chilean water services. Lessons learnt from the la experience are outlined in the conclusion and their relevance for the global debate on the RtW is illustrated.

The Human Right to Water in Latin America

Challenges to Implementation and Contribution to the Concept

in Brill Research Perspectives in International Water Law

Sections

References

AlexanderW. L.‘Enduring Contradictions of the Neoliberal State in Chile’ in W. L. Alexander (ed.) Lost in the Long Transition: Struggles for Social Justice in Neoliberal Chile pp. 133 (Lanham, MD: Lexington Books2009).

Americas Watch CommitteeChile: Human Rights and the Plebiscite (New York: Americas Watch CommitteeJuly1988) http://www.corteidh.or.cr/tablas/4478.pdf.

Australia State of Victoria Department of Treasury and FinanceCost Recovery Guidelines (2013).

BarberaA.‘Commento all’art.2 della Costituzione’ in G. BrancaCommentario della Costituzione italiana (Bologna: Zanichelli1975).

BarrosR.Constitutionalism and Dictatorship Pinochet: the Junta and the 1980 Constitution (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press2002).

BateR.‘Let the Market Decide on Water Supply’Mail & Guardian (South Africa) (1March2001).

BauerC.‘Los Derechos de Agua y el Mercado: Efectos e implicancias del código de aguas chileno de 1981’Revista de Derecho de Aguas (IV & V) (1993).

BobbioN.L’età dei diritti (Torino: Einaudi1997).

BorzutzkyS.Vital Connections: Politics Social Security and Inequality in Chile (Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press2002).

BrownJ.‘How Chile Might Leave the “Chilean Model” Behind: President Bachelet’s Proposal to Reform the Country’s Famously Laissez-Faire Water Laws’kbh Center for Energy Law & Business University of Texas at Austin3July2014. http://kbhenergycenter.utexas.edu/2014/07/03/how-chile-might-leave-the-chilean-model-behind-president-bachelets-proposal-to-reform-the-countrys-famously-laissez-faire-water-laws/.

BuchananJ. M.‘Public Goods in Theory and Practice: A Note on the Minasian-Samuelson Discussion’Journal of Law and EconomicsVol. 10 (1967) pp. 193197.

ChourabiH.et al.‘Understanding Smart Cities: An Integrative Framework’ in Proceedings of the 45th Hawaii International Conference on System SciencesMaui, Hawaii, USA47 January 2012) pp. 22892297.

Consejo Andino de Ministros de Relaciones ExterioresEstrategia Andina para la Gestión Integrada de los Recursos HídricosDecisión 763 vigésimo tercera Reunión Ordinaria del Consejo Andino de Ministros de Relaciones Exteriores Lima Peru22August2011.

CordieroJ. L.Constitutions Around the World: The View from Latin America Institute of Developing EconomiesIDE Discussion Paper No. 164 (Chiba, Japan: Institute of Developing Economies2008).

DíazJ.R. Lüders & G. WagnerEconomía Chilena 18102000. Producto Total y Sectorial. Una Nueva MiradaDocumento de Trabajo IE-PUC No. 315 (Santiago: Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile, Instituto de Economia2007).

DonosoF. & R. FusterCrisis del agua: Diagnóstico y propuestas a partir de los consensos de la Iniciativa Agua y Medio AmbienteAndess ChileSantiago de Chile24July2014.

DourojeanniA. C. & A. JouravlevEl Código de Aguas de Chile: Entre la ideología y la realidad (Santiago de Chile: CEPAL1999).

DourojeanniA. C.Gestión integrada por Cuencas: una elección politica de gobernanza sobre territorios delimitados por razones naturales (Quito: Fundación Chile2010).

DourojeanniA. C.La Gestión del Agua en los Límites de Disponibilidad en Latinoamérica (Santiago: Gerencia de Agua & Medio Ambiente, Fundación Chile2012a).

DourojeanniA. C.Thematic Study on the Common Problems and Challenges in the Integrated Management of Water Resources and Coasts in the Context of Climate Change in Latin AmericaEuropeAid/129783/c/ser/multi Specific contract No. 2012/298550 Version 1 (2012b).

DourojeanniA. C.Los retos que impone la gestión del agua a la sustentabilidad empresarialDocumento de divulgación de Acción RSE (Santiago de Chile: Fundación Chile2014a).

DourojeanniA. C.Reformas a las leyes de agua en América Latina (Santiago de Chile; Fundación Chile2014b).

DourojeanniA. C. & C. GalleguillosSuizAgua Andina Chile: RSEAgua un compromiso necesario para la Sustenabilidad (Santiago de Chile: Fundación Chile2014).

European Commission Directorate-General Regional PolicyGuidelines for Successful Public-Private Partnerships (March2003) http://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/sources/docgener/guides/ppp_en.pdf.

European Commission Communication from the Commission on the European Citizens’ Initiative ‘Water and sanitation are a human right! Water is a public good not a commodity!’com(2014) 177 final19March2014.

European Communities Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union2012/C 326/02 (26October2012).

EustaceR.‘Fluid Constitutions: A Latin American Phenomenon Council on Hemispheric Affairs‘Council on Hemispheric Affairs (3July2014) http://www.coha.org/fluid-constitutions-a-latin-american-phenomenon/comment-page-1/.

FinneganW.‘Letter from Bolivia—Leasing the Rain’The New Yorker (8April2002) at 43.

FrancoH. J. & L. ArmellaLa cuenca Matanza-RiachueLo: Estado de situación de La sentencia de La Corte Suprema de Justicia de La nación en Los autos “Mendoza Beatriz y otros c/ Estado Nacional”Instituto de Política Ambiental (2010).

Fundación ChileEstándar Internacional de Gestión Sostenible del Agua (Santiago de ChileApril2013).

GinsburgT.The Lifespan of Written Constitutions (Chicago: University of Illinois, College of Law2007).

HachfeldD.P. Terhorst & O. HoedemanProgressive Public Water Management in Europe. In Search of Exemplary Cases (The Transnational Institute and Corporate Europe Observatory2009).

HearneR. R. & G. Donoso‘Water Institutional Reforms in Chile’Water Policy Vol. 7 (2005) pp. 5369.

JamiesonJ.PPP in Water and Sanitation: Don’t Believe the Hype (International Finance Corporation2010).

JampagliaB. & E. MolinariSalvare l’Acqua (Milan: Feltrinelli Editore2010).

JustoJ. B.El derecho humano al agua y al saneamiento frente a los Objetivos de Desarrollo del Milenio (Santiago de Chile: CEPAL2013). Kleemeier E. & H. Lockwood Public-Private Partnerships for Rural Water Service Briefing Note No. 4 (The Hague: irc International Water and Sanitation Centre 2012).

KornfeldI. E.‘Water: A Public Good or a Commodity?’ in Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the American Society of International Law Confronting ComplexityVol. 106 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press2012) pp. 4952.

LaserreF.Acqua. Spartizione di una risorsa (Milan: Ponte alle Grazie srl2004).

LeeT. R. & A. JouravlevPrices Property and Market in Water Allocation (Santiago de Chile: CEPAL1998).

LevitskyS. & M. V. MurilloBuilding Institutions on Weak Foundations: Lessons from Latin America (Harvard University and Columbia University2012).

LovemanB.Chile: The Legacy of Hispanic Capitalism (Oxford: Oxford Universiy Press2001).

LüdersR.La Misión Klein-Saks los Chicago Boys y la Política EconómicaDocumento de Trabajo IE-PUC No. 411 (Santiago: Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile, Instituto de Economia2012).

MarinP.Public-Private Partnerships for Urban Water Utilities: A Review of Experiences in Developing Countries (Washington, D.C.: The World Bank2009).

MassaruttoA.Privati dell’acqua? (Bologna: Il Mulino 2011).

McGrawG.‘Defining and Defending the Right to Water and its Minimum Core: Legal Construction and the Role of National Jurisprudence,’ Loyola University Chicago International Law ReviewVol. 8(2) (2011) pp. 127204.

MohajeriS.B. KnotheD-N. Lamothe & J-A. Faby (eds.) European Water Management between Regulation and Competition (Luxembourg: Office for Official Publicatons of the European Communities2003).

NaviaP. & J. Rios-Figueroa‘The Constitutional Adjudication Mosaic of Latin America’Comparative Political StudiesVol. 38 (2005) pp. 189217.

NegrettoG.‘The Durability of Constitutions in Changing Environments: A Study on Constitutional Stability in Latin America’paper presented at the American Political Science Association MeetingPhiladelphia, USA31 August 2006.

NegrettoG.The Durability of Constitutions in Changing Environments: Explaining Constitutional Replacement in Latin AmericaWorking Paper No. 350 (South Bend, IN: University of Notre Dame, Helen Kellogg Institute for International Studies2008).

NegrettoG.Replacing and Amending Constitutions: The Logic of Constitutional Change in Latin Americapaper prepared for delivery at the American Political Science Association MeetingWashington, D.C., USA1–4 September 2011.

NorthD.Institutions Institutional Change and Economic Performance (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press2004).

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (oecd)Key Messages and Draft Principles on Stakeholder EngagementDraft for Working Group Consultation, 18 April 2014, in preparation for the 3rd Meeting of the OECD Water Governance Initiative2829 April 2014Madrid, Spain.

OstromE.Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1990).

ParenaR. & E. Smeets‘Benchmarking Initiatives in the Water Industry’Water Science and TechnologyVol. 44 (2–3) (2001) pp. 103110.

PortuguezJ. M. & V. Dubois CisnerosImplementación del derecho humano al agua en América Latina Proceso Regional de las Américas Sub-región América del Sur VII Foro Mundial del Agua Corea (Caracas: Corporación Andina de Fomento2015).

RingskogK.M. E. Hammond & A. LocussolUsing Management and Lease-Affermage Contracts for Water Supply. How Effective are They in Improving Service Delivery?World Bank Grid Lines No.12 (Washington, D.C.: Public-Private Advisory Facility, The World Bank2006).

RogersP. & A. W. HallEffective Water GovernanceGlobal Water Partnership Technical Committee Background Paper no.7 (Stockholm: Global Water Partnership2003).

RothG.The Private Provision of Public Services in Developing Countries (Oxford: Oxford University Press for the World Bank1987).

RulliM. & J. B. JustoGuía de derechos humanos para empresas: proteger respetar y remediar: todos ganamos (Buenos Aires: Programa de las Naciones Unidas para el Desarrollo, Red Argentina Pacto Global2012).

Sáez-MuñozC. R.‘Privatized Water Rights and Services in Chile 19812011: Flowing Towards the Mainstream?’ (Ph.D. Thesis No. 1035Graduate InstituteGeneva2014).

SalmanM. A. S. & S. McInerney-LankfordThe Human Right to Water: Legal and Policy Dimensions (Washington, D.C.: The World Bank2004).

SalmanM. A. S.‘The Future of International Water Law: Regional Approaches to Shared Watercourses?’ in M. S. Arsanjaniet al. (eds) Looking to the Future: Essays on International Law in Honor of W. Michael Reisman (The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers2010) pp. 907928.

SalmanM. A. S.‘The Human Right to Water—Challenges of Implementation’in Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the American Society of International Law Confronting ComplexityVol. 106 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press2012) pp. 4446.

SalmanM. A. S.‘The Human Right to Water and Sanitation: Is the Obligation Deliverable?’Water International (2014) doi: 10.1080/02508060.2015.986616.

Schuch de AzambujaL.et al.‘A Smart City Initiative: A Case Study of Porto Alegre’ in Proceedings of the 15th Annual International Conference on Digital Government ResearchAguascalientes, Mexico18–21 June 2014 pp. 245252.

SchulteP.Corporate Water Disclosure Guidelines. Toward a Common Approach to Reporting Water Issues (Oakland, CA: The Pacific Institute, The CEO Water Mandate2014).

SegerfeldtF.Acqua in vendita? (2003) trad.it. (Torino: IBL2011).

Sjölander HollandA-C.Il Business dell’Acqua (2005) trad.it (Milan: Editorale Jaka Book SpA2006).

StaianoS.‘Note sul diritto fondamentale all’acqua. Proprietà del bene, gestione del servizio, ideologie della privatizzazione’Federalismi.itVol. 5 (2011).

Szigeti CorreaC.Reformas Constitucionales en materia de agua y reformas al Código de AguasComisiones de Trabajo Proyectos de Ley y Mociones Parlamentarias presentadas a tramitación (1992 y 2012) (Santiago de Chile: Edición Sara Larraín, Programa Chile Sustentable2013).

TanV.The Public-Private Partnership (PPP) (London: Advocates for International Development2012).

TegaD.I diritti in crisi. Tra Corti nazionali e Corte europea di Strasburgo (Milan: Università degli Studi di Milano Bicocca2012).

United NationsInternational Covenant on Economic Social and Cultural Rightsun General Assembly Res. 2200A (xxi)16December1966.

VergèsJ-F.Experiencias relevantes de marcos institucionales y contratos en agua potable y alcantarillado (Santiago de Chile: CEPAL2010).

WinpennyJ.Financing Water for AllReport of the World Panel on Financing Water Infrastructure Chair Michel Camdessus (World Water Council 3rd World Water Forum and Global Water Partnership March 2003) http://www.worldwatercouncil.org/en/publications/financing-water-all.

WolfA.T. (ed.) Sharing Water Sharing Benefits: Working Towards Effective Transboundary Water Resources Management (Paris: UNESCO2010).

World Health Organization (who)Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality (Geneva: WHO2011).

Zañartu RosselotH.‘Aguas subterráneas: ¿Necesidad de un nuevo enfoque?’Revista de Derecho Administrativo Económico de Recursos NaturalesVol. 3(2) (2001) pp. 539545.

ZoloD.‘Nuovi diritti e globalizzazione’Treccani.it L’Enciclopedia Italiana (2009) http://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/nuovi-diritti-e-globalizzazione_%28XXI-Secolo%29/.

Constitución Política De La República De ChileDecreto Supremo 1.150 Ministerio Secretaría General de la Presidencia1980.

Régimen de los Servicios Públicos DomiciliariosLey n.14211July1994.

Ley Indigena 19.2535de Octubrede 1993.

Código de Aguas 13 de Agosto de 1981 D.F.L. No 1.122.

Boletín N. 7543–12 Comparado Proyecto de Ley que reforma el Código de Aguas.

Ley General de Servicios de Saneamiento n. 2633824July1994.

Lei Nº 54/2005. dr 219 série I-A de 2005-11-15. Estabelece a titularidade dos recursos hídricos.

Reforma del Código de Aguas Ley No 20.01711de Mayode 2005.

Ley Nº 19.300 sobre Bases Generales del Medio Ambiente9de Marciode 1994.

D.F.L. No 850/1997 and D.F.L. No 1.115/1969 del Ministerio de Obras Públicas.

Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union2000/C 364/01.

European CommunitiesCouncil Directive 1998/83/ec of 3 November 1998 on the quality of water intended for human consumption ojl 3305December1998.

European CommunitiesDirective 2000/60/ec of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy ojl 327 22 December 2000 as amended by Decision 2455/2001/ec Directive 2008/32/ec and Directive 2009/31/ec.

European CommunitiesConsolidated Version of Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union 2008 oj C 115/47.

Corte Constitucional de ColombiaSentencias T-539/ 1993 T-1104/2005 T-091/ 2010 T-381/2009 T-418/2010 T-143/2010 T-595/ 2002 T-418/2010 T-614/2010 T-717/2010 T-740/2011 T-641/15 T-139/16 T-131/16 and T-100/17. Texts available at http://www.corteconstitucional.gov.co/relatoria/.

Sentencia M. 1569. xl/2006 MENDOZA Beatriz Silvia y Otros C/ ESTADO NACIONAL y Otros S/ Daños y Perjuicios (daños derivados de la contaminación ambiental del Río Matanza-Riachuelo). Available at http://www.elaw.org/system/files/caso.mendoza.riachuelo.pdf.

Cámara de Apelaciones en lo Contencioso Administrativo y Tributario de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires Causa Nº 20898/0 Asociación Civil por la Igualdad y la Justicia c/ gcba s/ amparo 18.07.2007.

Corte Constitucional de PerùSentencia n.6546/2006. Available at http://www.tc.gob.pe/jurisprudencia/2007/06546-2006-AA.html.

Corte Constitucional de BoliviaSentencia 684/2010-R19July2010.

Corte Constitucional de BoliviaSentencia 1106/2010-R27August2010.

Corte Constitucional de BoliviaSentencia 1230/2016-S38November2011.

Corte Constitucional de MéxicoSentencia 49/2014.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 35 35 14
Full Text Views 13 13 11
PDF Downloads 4 4 4
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0