禪宗空間歷史初探:宋燈錄記載之宗派

Lineages, Networks, and the Lamp Records

in Review of Religion and Chinese Society
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

This paper lays a foundation for spatial religious histories of Chan Buddhism in the Northern and Southern Song dynasties (960–1279). The Lamp Records (denglu 燈錄) texts are genealogically organized hagiographic records of members of the Chan lineages. Scholarly consensus holds that these records are primarily religious texts and of questionable historicity, but with a critical methodology it is possible to discover patterns in these documents which can be amplified and visualized using digital techniques. This paper blends gis geospatial analysis and traditional close reading of sectarian Buddhist sources and nonsectarian historical sources (such as “gazetteers” 地方誌). The author assembled a gis dataset to study the Chan abbots named in the Song-era Lamp Records texts, including each abbot’s lineage identity, temple location, and the number of full-fledged disciples recorded in a Lamp Records text. The results suggest that Chan lineages during the Northern Song as presented in the Lamp Records correspond to regional networks and were not necessarily doctrinal opponents. This paper concludes with a series of critiques regarding the power and limits of computational methods like gis. The author proposes that the task of the digital humanist is to go beyond building infrastructure and to engage in critical interpretation.

本文奠立了北、南宋時期(960–1279)禪宗空間歷史研究的基礎。作者援引由宋代禪林所撰《燈錄》以搜集北宋每位禪師的宗派、主持寺地名、弟子數量等信息,並運用gis系統呈现上述资料。《燈錄》系統地記載了禪宗的發展譜系。但是,學界普遍認為《燈錄》的記載頗具宗教導向,在史實性方面尚待考證。本文將gis空間分析技術(所謂遙距閲讀)與對宗派佛教文獻及非宗教歷史文獻(諸如地方誌)的近距閲讀相結合。分析結果顯示,根據《燈錄》的記載,北宋禪林宗派的劃分是基于地區網絡而不是教义竞争。論文还讨论了gis與宗教歷史研究方法論。 (This article is in English.)

禪宗空間歷史初探:宋燈錄記載之宗派

Lineages, Networks, and the Lamp Records

in Review of Religion and Chinese Society

Sections

References

Abe Chōichi 阿部肇一. 1963. Chūgoku Zenshūshi no kenkyū: Nanshūzen sēritsu igo no seiji shakaiteki kōsatsu 中国禅宗史の研究: 南宗禅成立以後の政治社会的考察 (Research on the History of Chinese Chan: Political and Social Investigations after the Establishment of the Southern School). Tokyo: Seishin Shobō. Expanded and revised; Tokyo: Kenbun Shuppan1986.

AhnJuhn. 2009. “ Who Has the Last Word in Chan? Transmission, Secrecy and Reading during the Northern Song Dynasty.” Journal of Chinese Religions37: 171.

AscariMaurizio. 2014. “ The Dangers of Distant Reading: Reassessing Moretti’s Approach to Literary Genres.” Genre47 (1): 119.

BodenhamerDavid. 2010. “ The Potential of Spatial Humanities.” In Spatial Humanities: gis and the Future of Humanities Scholarship edited by BodenhamerDavid. pp. 1430. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

BoesTobias. 2014. “ The Vocations of the Novel: Distant-reading Occupational Change in Nineteenth-Century German Literature.” In Distant Readings: Topologies of German Culture in the Long Nineteenth Century edited by ErlinMatt and TatlockLynne pp. 259283. Rochester, NY: Camden House.

BolPeter. 2011. “ What Do Humanists Want? What Do Humanists Need? What Might Humanists Get?” In Geohumanities: Art History Text at the Edge of Place edited by DearMichael et al. pp. 296308. New York: Routledge.

BosslerBeverly. 1998. Powerful Relations: Kinship Status and the State in Sung China (960–1279). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Council on East Asian Studies 1998.

BroseBenjamin. 2015. Patrons and Patriarchs: Regional Rulers and Chan Monks during the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms. Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i.

ErlinMatt and TatlockLynne. 2014. “ Introduction: ‘Distant Reading’ and the Historiography of Nineteenth-Century German Literature.” In Distant Readings: Topologies of German Culture in the Long Nineteenth Century edited by ErlinMatt and TatlockLynne pp. 133152. Rochester, NY: Camden House.

FaureBernard. 1993. Chan Insights and Oversights: An Epistemological Critique of the Chan Tradition. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

FoulkT. Griffith. 1987. “The ‘Ch’an school’ and Its Place in the Buddhist Monastic Tradition.” PhD diss.University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.

GregoryIan. 2010. “ Exploiting Time and Space: A Challenge for gis in the Digital Humanities.” In Spatial Humanities: gis and the Future of Humanities Scholarship edited by BodenhamerDavid. pp. 5875. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

GregoryIan and GeddesAlistair. 2014. “ Introduction: From Historical gis to Spatial Humanities.” In Toward Spatial Humanities: Historical gis and Spatial History edited by Ian N. Gregory and Alistair Geddes ix–xxii. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

HarrisonPaul. 2003. “ Relying on the Dharma and Not the Person: Reflection on Authority and Transmission in Buddhism and Buddhist Studies.” Journal of the International Association of Buddhist Studies26 (1): 924.

黃啟江Huang Ch’i-chiang1997. Bei Song Fo jiao shi lun gao 北宋佛教史論稿 (Essays on the History of Buddhism under the Northern Song). Taipei: Taiwan Shangwu yinshu guan.

石井修道Ishii Shūdō. 1987. Sōdai Zenshū shi no kenkyū: Chūgoku Sōtōshū to Dōgen Zen 宋代禅宗史の研究: 中国曹洞宗と道元禅 (Research on Song Dynasty Chan: The Chinese Caodong Lineage and Dōgen Zen). Tokyo: Daitō Shuppansha.

鏡島元隆Kagamishima Genryū. 1961. “Nansō Zenrin no ichi kōsatsu” 南宋禪林の一考察 (An Investigation of Chan under the Southern Song). Komazawa Daigaku Bukkyō gakubu kenkyū kiyō19: 4862.

KontjeTodd. 2014. “ The Case for Close Reading after the Descriptive Turn.” In Distant Readings: Topologies of German Culture in the Long Nineteenth Century edited by ErlinMatt and TatlockLynne pp. 133152. Rochester, NY: Camden House.

McRaeJohn. 2003. Seeing Through Zen: Encounter Transformation and Genealogy in Chinese Chan Buddhism. Berkeley: University of California Press.

MorettiFranco. 2000. “ Conjectures on World Literature.” New Left Review 1 (January–February).

MorettiFranco. 2005. Graphs Maps Trees: Abstract Models for Literary History. London: Verso.

MosternRuth. 2011. Dividing the Realm in Order to Govern”: The Spatial Organization of the Song State (960–1276 ce). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Asia Center.

YoshioNishiguchi. 1990. “Ōryo Enan no Rinzaishū tenkō to Ryokutan Echō” 黄龍慧南の臨済宗転向と泐潭懐澄 (Huanglong Huinan’s conversion to Linji and Letan Huaicheng). Zen Bunka kenkyūjo kiyō16: 223250.

KeijiNishitani and SeizanYanagida eds. 1974. Zenke goroku ii 禅家語錄 ii (Zen Recorded Sayings). Tokyo: Chikuma shobō.

GuanQin. (1994) 2000. Huaihaiji jianzhu 淮海集箋注 (Annotations on Qin Guan’s Collected Works). Edited by Xu Peijun 徐培均. Shanghai: Shanghai guji.

SchlütterMorten. 2008. How Zen Became Zen. Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i Press.

椎名宏雄Shiina Koyu. 1993. Sō Gen ban zenseki no kenkyū 宋元版禪籍の研究 (Song and Yuan Dynasty Editions of Chan Texts). Tokyo: Daitō shuppansha.

鈴木哲雄Suzuki Tetsuo. 1986. “Kohoku no zenshū ni kan suru shiryō: Tō Godai” 湖北の禅宗に関する資料・唐五代 (Information pertaining to Chan lineages in Hubei during the Tang and Five Dynasties). Aichi Gakuin Daigaku Bungakubu kiyō 16: 92–135b.

TrumpenerKatie. 2009. “ Paratext and Genre System: A Response to Franco Moretti.” Critical Inquiry36 (1): 159171.

土屋太祐Tsuchiya Taisuke. 2008. Bei Song chan zong si xiang ji qi yuan yuan 北宋禪宗思想及其淵源 (Chan Thought in the Northern Song and its Origins). Chengdu Shi: Ba Shu shu she.

汪聖鐸Wang Shengduo. 2010. Songdai zheng-jiao guanxi yanjiu 宋代政教關係研究 (Relations between Government and Religions in the Song Dynasty). Beijing: Renmin chuban she.

WelterAlbert. 2006. Monks Rulers and Literati: The Political Ascendancy of Chan Buddhism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

WrightJohn K.1942. “ Map Makers Are Human: Comments on the Subjective in Maps.” Geographical Review32 (4): 527544.

WuJiang. 2008. Enlightenment in Dispute: The Reinvention of Chan Buddhism in Seventeenth-Century China. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

WuJiangTongDaoqin and RyavecKarl. 2013. “ Spatial Analysis and gis Modeling of Regional Religious Systems in China: Conceptualization and Initial Experiment.” In Chinese History in Geographical Perspective edited by YongtaoDu and Kyong-McClainJeff pp. 179196. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.

SeizanYanagida. 1983. “The Development of the ‘Recorded Sayings’ Texts of Chinese Ch’an Buddhism.” Translated by John McRae. In Early Ch’an in China and Tibet edited by LaiWhalen and LancasterLewis pp. 185205. Berkeley: Asian Humanities Press.

SeizanYanagida. 1985. “Goroku no rekishi: Zen bunken no seiritsushiteki kenkyū” 語録の歴史 - 禪文獻の成立史的研究 (History of Recorded Sayings: On the Creation of Chan Literature). Tōhōgakuhō57: 211663.

杨曾文Yang Zengwen. 2006. Song Yuan Chan zong shi 宋元禅宗史 (History of Chan in the Song and Yuan Dynasties). Beijing: Zhongguo she hui ke xue chu ban she.

1

Tsuchiya Taisuke (2008) for example has made major contributions to our understanding of the development of Linji Chan in the Northern Song dynasty including an analysis of contests between sub-branches.

13

Between 1973 and 1986Suzuki Tetsuo published a series of at least eight papers composed of tables charts and maps describing the cities and prefectures of Chan abbots from the Tang and Song. A citation to one of the eight papers is included in the bibliography.

Figures

  • View in gallery

    Northern Song Chan lineages before the personal reign of Emperor Renzong.

  • View in gallery

    Chan lineages roughly during the personal reign of Emperor Renzong (1034–1063).

  • View in gallery

    Northern Song Chan lineages after the reign of Emperor Renzong.

  • View in gallery

    Early Southern Song Chan lineages after the Jingkang Calamity of 1127.

  • View in gallery

    A section of an early version of the dataset.

  • View in gallery

    A section of the final dataset, formatted for use with gis software.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 28 28 13
Full Text Views 16 16 16
PDF Downloads 5 5 5
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0