Jewish Atheists in Foxholes?

Existential Beliefs and How War Feels

In: Secular Studies

Abstract

War and other forms of collective political violence raise existential questions for those touched by them. Recent advances in the study of ‘atheism in foxholes’ have been hitherto overlooked in the sociology of war. But they can further illuminate the relationship between war and existential questions. Bringing these literatures into conversation for the first time, this article analyses a sample of young, secular Jewish-Israelis (hilonim) interviewed in the aftermath of the 2014 Israel-Gaza War. It shows how speakers borrowed from both Jewish and Western secular formations to answer existential questions and ‘manage luck.’ Contributing to the theorization of war as social practice through a case study of ‘foxhole atheism’, the article also invites us to think of war as having a ‘secular’ ontology.

  • Allen, Lori. 2008. “Getting by the Occupation: How violence became normal during the Second Palestinian Intifada,” Cultural Anthropology 23(3): 453–487.

  • Almog, Oz and Tamar Almog. 2015 Generation Y—Research Report. Haifa: The Samuel Neaman Institute for Policy Research Press. [Hebrew]

  • Amoore, Louise. 2014. “Security and the Incalculable.” Security Dialogue 45(5): 423–439.

  • Asad, Talal. 1986. “Medieval heresy: an anthropological view.” Social History 11(3): 345–362.

  • Azaryahu, Maoz. 2000. “The Golden Arches of McDonalds: On the ‘Americanization’ of Israel,” Israel Studies 5(1): 41–64.

  • Baldacchino, Jean-Paul. 2011. “Miracles in the waiting room of modernity: The canonisation of Dun Gorg of Malta,” The Australian Journal of Anthropology 22(1): 104–124.

  • Bar-Tal, David, Dan Jacobsen and Tali Freund. 1995. “Security Feelings Among Jewish Settlers in the Occupied Territories: a Study of Communal and Personal Antecedents.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 39(2): 353–377.

  • Beck, Ulrich. 1999. World Risk Society. Cambridge: Polity Press.

  • Beit-Hallahmi, Benjamin. 2007. “The Secular Israeli (Jewish) Identity: An Impossible Dream?” In Secularism and Secularity: Contemporary International Perspectives, edited by Barry Kosmin and Ariela Keysar, 158–168. Hartford, CT: Institute for the Study of Secularism in Society and Culture.

  • Bellah, Robert, Richard Madsen, William M. Sullivan, Ann Swidler, Steven M. Tipton. 1985. Habits of the Heart: Individualism and Commitment in American Life. Berkeley: University of California Press.

  • Ben Meir, Yehuda and Olena Bagno-Moldavsky. 2013. The Voice of the People: Israeli Public Opinion on National Security, 2012. Tel Aviv: Institute for National Security Studies. 57–62.

  • Ben-Porat, Guy. 2013. Between Synagogue and State: the Secularization of Modern Israel. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Benatar, David. 2006. “What’s God Got to Do With It? Atheism and Religious Practice.” Ratio XIX: 383–400.

  • Berlinerblau, Jacques. 2013. “Jewish Atheism,” in Stephen Bullivant and Michael Ruse, eds. The Oxford Handbook of Atheism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Bourdieu, Pierre. 1984. Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgment of Taste. Translated by Richard Nice. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

  • Brenner, Reeve Robert. 1980. The Faith and Doubt of Holocaust Survivors. New York: Free Press.

  • Brighton, Shane. 2011. “Three Propositions on the Phenomenology of War.” International Political Sociology: 102–105.

  • Chambers, Samuel and Terrell Carver. 2008. William E. Connolly: Democracy, Pluralism and Political Theory. London and New York: Routledge.

  • Creswell, John W. 2013. Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Approaches, 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

  • da Col, Giovanni and Caroline Humphrey. 2012. “Subjects of Luck: Contingency, Morality, and the Anticipation of Everyday Life,” Social Analysis 56(2): 1–18.

  • da Col, Giovanni. 2012. “Natural Philosophies of Fortune—Luck, Vitality and Uncontrolled Relatedness,” Social Analysis 56(1):1–23.

  • Dalsheim, Joyce. 2007. “Deconstructing national myths, reconstructing morality: modernity, hegemony and the Israeli national past,” Journal of Historical Sociology 20(4): 521–554.

  • Day, Abby. 2011. Believing in Belonging: Belief and Social Identity in the Modern World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Elran, Meir, Yehuda Ben Meir and Gilead Sher, 2015. “The Impact of Operation Protective Edge on Political and Social Trends in Israel,” in Strategic Survey for Israel, 2014–15, eds. Anat Kurz and Shlomo Brom. Tel Aviv: Institute for National Security Studies. http://www.inss.org.il/publication/the-impact-of-operation-protective-edge-on-political-and-social-trends-in-israel/

  • Emmel, Nick. 2013. Sampling and Choosing Cases in Qualitative Research: A Realist Approach. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

  • Farman, Abou. 2013. “Speculative Matter: secular minds, bodies, persons,” Cultural Anthropology 28(4): 737–759.

  • Florian, Victor and Mario Mikulincer. 1992. “The Impact of Death-Risk Experiences on the Fear of Personal Death: the Case of Israeli Soldiers in Lebanon.” Omega 26: 101–110.

  • Furani, Khaled. 2014. “Is there a postsecular?,” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 83(1): 1–26.

  • Giddens, Anthony. 1991. Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age. Palo Alto: Stanford University Press.

  • Gregory, Thomas and Linda Ahäll. 2015. Emotions, Politics and War. Abingdon: Routledge.

  • Gutkowski, Stacey. 2019. “Love, War and Secular ‘Reasonableness’ among hilonim in Israel-Palestine,” in Secular BodiesAffects and Emotions: European Configurations, ed. Monique Scheer, Nadia Fadil and Birgitte Schepelern Johansen (London: Bloomsbury, 2019), 123–138.

  • Gutkowski, Stacey. 2013. Secular War: Myths of Religion, Politics and Violence. London: IB Tauris.

  • Hacking, Ian. 1990. The Taming of Chance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Han, Sam. 2015. “Disenchantment Revisited: Formations of the ‘Secular’ and ‘Religious’ in the Technological Discourse of Modernity,” Social Compass 62(1):pages

  • Hasanović, M. and I. Pajević. 2013. “Religious moral beliefs inversely related to trauma experiences severity and depression severity among war victims in Bosnia and Herzegovina.” Journal of Religion and Health 52(3): 730–739.

  • Hobfall, Steven E., Daphna Canetti-Nisim, Robert J. Johnson, Patrick A. Palmieri, Joseph D. Varley, Sandro Galea. 2008. “The Association of Exposure, Risk and Resiliency Factors with PTSD among Jews and Arabs Exposed to Repeated Acts of Terrorism in Israel.” Journal of Traumatic Stress, 21(1): 9–21.

  • Israeli Democracy Institute, Peace Index Archive, 2014–2016. http://www.peaceindex.org/DefaultEng.aspx

  • Israeli, Zipi. 2017. “The National Security Index: Public Support for an Arrangement Based on the Two-State Solution,” INSS Insight No. 916, 6 April. http://www.inss.org.il/publication/national-security-index-public-support-arrangement-based-two-state-solution/

  • Jong, Jonathan, Jamin Halberstadt and Matthias Bluemke. 2012. “Foxhole atheism, revisited: The effects of mortality salience on explicit and implicit religious belief.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48: 983–989.

  • Kaplan, Dana and Rachel Werczberger. 2017. “Jewish New Age and the Middle Class: Politics in Israel under Neo-liberalism,” Sociology 51(3): 575–591.

  • Keissar-Sugarman, Ayala. 2012. A Portrait of Israeli Jews: Beliefs, Observances and the Values of Israeli Jews, 2009. Jerusalem: The Israeli Democracy Institute and the Avi Chai Israel Foundation.

  • Keshet, Yael and Ido Liberman. 2014. “Seeking Empowerment and Spirituality in the Secular Age: secular and traditionalist Israelis consulting rabbis,” Sociology 48(1): 92–110.

  • Kleinreesink, LHE and Soeters, Joseph MML. 2016. “Truth and (self) censorship in military memoirs.” Current Sociology 64(3): 373–391.

  • Kuckartz, Udo. 2014. Qualitative Text Analysis: A Guide to Methods, Practice and Using Software. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

  • Lahav, Hagar. 2016. “What do Secular-believer Women in Israel Believe in?” Journal of Contemporary Religion 31(1): 17–36.

  • Landsman, Klaas and Ellen van Wolde, eds. 2016. The Challenge of Chance: A multidisciplinary approach from the science and humanities. New York: SpringerOpen. http://www.springer.com/la/book/9783319262987.

  • Langton, Daniel R. “Introduction,” in Melilah: Atheism, Skepticism and Challenges to Monotheism, ed. Daniel R. Langton (Manchester: University of Manchester and Gorgias Press, 2015).

  • Lazar, Aryeh. 2006. “Fear of Personal Death as a Predictor of Motivation for Religious Behavior.” Review of Religious Research 48(2): 179–189.

  • Lazar, Aryeh. 2014. “The Structure and Validity of the Multidimensional Prayer Inventory among Israeli Jewish Pray-Ers.” Psychology of Religion and Spirituality 6(3): 237–244.

  • Lee, Lois. 2015. Recognizing the Non-religious, Reimagining the Secular. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Liebman, Charles S. and Yaacov Yadgar. 2009. “Secular-Jewish Identity and the Condition of Secular Judaism in Israel” in Religion or Ethnicity? Jewish Identities in Evolution, ed. Zvi Gitelman. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press. pp. 149–170.

  • Liebman, Charles. 1997. Religion, Democracy and Israeli Society. Sherman Lecture Series, vol. 2. Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Publishers.

  • Loss, Joseph. 2010. “Buddha-Dhamma in Israel: Explicit Non-Religious and Implicit Non-Secular Localization of Religion.” Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions 13(4): 84–105.

  • Mackler, Aaron L. 2007. “Eye on Religion: a Jewish View of Miracles and Healing,” Southern Medical Journal 100(12): 1252–1254.

  • McSorley, Kevin, ed. 2015. War and the Body: Militarization, Practice and Experience. Abingdon: Routledge.

  • Miles, Matthew B. and Huberman, A. Michael. 1994. Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

  • Moscowitz, David. 2015. A Culture of Tough Jews: Rhetorical Regeneration and the Politics of Identity. Bern: Peter Lang.

  • Moss, Joshua L. 2015. “Satire, monotheism and skepticism,” in Melilah: Atheism, Skepticism and Challenges to Monotheism, ed. Daniel R. Langton. Manchester: University of Manchester and Gorgias Press.

  • Moustakas, Clark. 1994. Phenomenological Research Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

  • Patton, M.Q. 2002. Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods. 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

  • Pelksmans, Mathijs, ed. 2013. Ethnographies of Doubt: faith and uncertainty in contemporary societies. London and New York: I.B. Tauris.

  • Quack, Johannes. 2011. Disenchanting India: Organized Rationalism and Criticism of Religion in India. New York: Oxford University Press.

  • Ochs, Juliana. 2011. Security and Suspicion: An Ethnography of Everyday Life in Israel. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

  • Pew Research Center. 2016. Israel’s Religiously Divided Society. http://www.pewforum.org/2016/03/08/israels-religiously-divided-society/

  • Rubin, Barry. 1996. “The Arab-Israeli Conflict is Over,” Middle East Quarterly 3(3): 3–12.

  • Scarry, Elaine. 1980. The Body in Pain. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

  • Schielke, Samuli. 2012. “Being a Nonbeliever in a Time of Islamic Revival: Trajectories of Doubt and Certainty in Contemporary Egypt.” International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 44: 301–320.

  • Schacter, Daniel L. and Donna Rose Addis. 2007. “The cognitive neuroscience of constructive memory: Remembering the past and imagining the future.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 362(1481): 773–786.

  • Solomon, Norman. 2015. “The Attenuation of God in Modern Jewish Thought,” in Melilah: Atheism, Skepticism and Challenges to Monotheism, ed. Daniel R. Langton. Manchester: University of Manchester and Gorgias Press.

  • Solomon, Zahava and Rony Berger. 2005. “Coping with the Aftermath of Terror: Resilience of Zaka Body Handlers.” Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment and Trauma 10(1–2): 593–604.

  • Sosis, Richard. 2007. “Psalms for Safety: Magico-Religious Responses to Threats of Terror.” Current Anthropology 48: 903–911.

  • Sosis, Richard and W. Penn Handwerker. 2011. “Psalms and Coping with Uncertainty: Religious Israeli Women’s Response to the 2006 Lebanon War.” American Anthropologist 113(1): 40–55.

  • Taylor, Charles. 2007. A Secular Age. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

  • Thijssen, Johannes M.M.H. and David R. Loy, “Happiness and Invulnerability from Chance: Western and Eastern Perspectives,” in The Challenge of Chance: A multidisciplinary approach from science and the humanities, ed. Klaas Landsman and Ellen van Wolde. New York: SpringerOpen.

  • Wansink, Brian and Craig S. Wansink. 2013. “Are There Atheists in Foxholes? Combat Intensity and Religious Behaviour.” Journal of Religion and Health 52: 768–779.

  • Whittemore, R.S.K. Chase, and C.L. Mandle. 2001. “Validity in Qualitative Research.” Qualitative Health Research 11(4): 522–537.

  • Woodward, R. and K.N. Jenkings. 2011. Military identities in the situated accounts of

  • British military personnel. Sociology 45(2): 252–268.

  • Yadgar, Yaacov. 2009. “A Post-secular Look at Tradition: Towards a Definition of Traditionism.” Telos 156: 77–98.

  • Yadgar, Yaacov. 2017. Sovereign Jews: Israel, Zionism, and Judaism. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.

  • Zeidner, Moshe and Allen L. Hammer. 1992. “Coping with Missile Attack: Resources, Strategies and Outcomes.” Journal of Personality 60: 709–746.

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 331 332 11
Full Text Views 32 32 0
PDF Downloads 19 19 0