Secularism in the Troubled ‘Waters’ of ‘Hindu nationalism’
A Case Study of the Conflict between Freedom of Expression and Religion in India
In: Secular StudiesSearch for other papers by Amit Singh in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
This article presents an Indian case study of how Hindu nationalists challenge freedom of expression and secularism. Focusing on the film ‘Water’ (2005) and the related controversy (2000) in a north Indian district in Varanasi in 2000, this article examines the conflict between Hindu nationalists and those who oppose them. Through the theoretical lens of ‘contextual secularism’, this article analyses the narratives of Hindu nationalists and resistance groups involved in the secular-religious impasse. In particular, the article focuses on the most important interrelated aspect of this situation—the tension between freedom of expression and Hindu religious intolerance. This study applies qualitative research methods, particularly semi-structured interviews, and narrative analysis. The study concludes that Indian secularism tolerates Hindu religious bigotry toward dissent and that Hindu nationalism is incompatible with secular democracy and, to some extent, with freedom of expression and dissent. However, there is the possibility of resistance to hegemonic Hindu nationalism.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Ali, Amir (2001). ‘Evolution of Public Sphere in India’, Economic and Political Weekly, June. 30-Jul. 6, Vol. 36. No. 26, pp. 2419–2425.
-
Aloysius, G. (2006). ‘Nationalism without a Nation in India’, 7th edition, Oxford University Press: New Delhi
-
Balsekar, Ameya (2014). “Seeking Offense: Censorship as Strategy” in Indian Party Politics. Comparative Politics, Vol. 46, No. 2, pp. 191–208
-
Banaji, Shakuntala (2018). Vigilante Publics: Orientalism, Modernity and Hindutva Fascism in India, Javnost—The Public, 25:4, 333–350, DOI: 10.1080/13183222.2018.1463349
-
Bhargava, Rajiv (2013). Reimagining Secularism: Respect, Domination and Principled Distance. Economic and Political Weekly, 48(50), 79–92. http://www.jstor.org/stable/24479049
-
Bhargava, Rajiv (2006). The Distinctiveness of Indian Secularism in The Future of Secularism, (ed. by Srinivasan), Oxford University Press: Delhi
-
Brass, Paul (2005). The Production of Hindu-Muslim Violence in Contemporary India, University of Washington Press: Seattle
-
Berger, Peter (1969). The Sacred Canopy, Anchor books: New York
-
Bryman, Alan (2012). Social Research Methods, 4th edition, Oxford University press: Oxford
-
Butler, Judith, Spivak, Gayatri (2010). Who Sings the Nation-state? Seagull: London
-
Casolari, Marzia (2020). In the Shadow of the Swastika The relationship between Indian Radical Nationalism, Italian Fascism and Nazism, Oxon: Routledge
-
Casolari, Marzia (2002). Role of Benares in Constructing Political Hindu Identity, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 37, No. 15 (Apr. 13–19, 2002), pp. 1413–1420
-
Chandhoke, Neera (1999). Beyond Secularism: The Rights of Religious Minorities, Oxford University Press: New Delhi
-
Constitution of India (1947). Retrieved from https://india.gov.in/my-government/constitution-india
-
Dainik Jagran (2000). ‘Film set of Water thrown in Ganga by enraged crowd’ 30th January, Print version, Varanasi
-
Dainik Jagran (2000). ‘Shooting of Water will not be allowed anywhere in the country’ 14th Feburary, Print version, Varanasi, The Quotation is from the original
-
Dainik Jagran (2000). ‘Deepa and Shabana left the city on instruction by the District administration’ 8th Feburary, Print version.
-
Democracy report (2022). ‘Autocratization Changing Nature?’ V-Dem Institute, University of Gothenburg, Sweden, available at https://v-dem.net/media/publications/dr_2022.pdf, accessed on 14th June, 2022
-
Diamond, J. Larry (1994). ‘Toward Democratic Consolidation’, Journal of Democracy 5 (2): 4–17.
-
Exploring Secularism A Guide for Teachers (2002). Published by National Secular Society, London, available at https://exploringsecularism.org/uploads/exploring-secularism---a-guide-for-teachers.pdf, accessed on 2nd June 2021
-
Freitag, Sandria (1990). Collective Action and Community, Public Arenas and the Emergence of Communalism in North India, Oxford University Press: New Delhi
-
Frøystad, Kathinka (2013). ‘A Fine Balance Censoring for Respect and Social Harmony’ in Navigating Social Exclusion and Inclusion in Contemporary India and Beyond, (eds. by Skoda, Nielsen and Fibiger), Anthem Press: New Delhi
-
Gittinger, Juli (2011). Saffron Terror: Splinter or Symptom? Economic and Political Weekly, 46(37), 22–25. http://www.jstor.org/stable/23047273
-
Gottschalk, Peter (2007). A categorical difference: communal identity in British epistemologies in Religion and Violence in South Asia Theory and Practice, (eds) Hinnells and King, Routledge: New York
-
Human rights watch (2022). available at https://www.hrw.org/asia/india, accessed on 22 June 2022
-
Inden, Ronald (2001). Imagining India, Indiana University Press; 5th ed. Edition
-
Jacob, Satish (2006). ‘Water’ Fires Up Hindu Controversy, abcNews, available at https://abcnews.go.com/International/Entertainment/story?id=2007642&page=1, accessed on July 10, 2021
-
Jaffrelot, Christophe (2022). From Hindu Rashtra to Hindu Raj? A de facto or a de jure ethnic democracy? In Routledge Handbook of autocratization in South Asia (eds, Widmalm S.), Routledge: New York
-
Jaffrelot, Christophe (1996). The Hindu Nationalist Movement and Indian Politics 1925–1990s: Strategies of Identity-Building, Implantation and Mobilization, New Delhi: C. Hurst & Co
-
Kaur, Raminder, William Mazzarella (2009). Censorship in South Asia: Cultural Regulation from Sedition to Seduction. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
-
Khilnani, Sunil (2016). The Idea of India, Penguin India: New Delhi
-
Kinnvall, Catarina, and Singh, Amit 2022. “Enforcing and Resisting Hindutva: Popular Culture, the COVID-19 Crisis and Fantasy Narratives of Motherhood and Pseudoscience in India” Social Sciences 11, no. 12: 550. https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci11120550
-
Kinnvall, Catarina (2006). Globalization and Religious Nationalism in India The search for ontological security, New York: Routledge
-
Kumar, Sanjay (2015). Hindu Extremists Creep Ahead in India, The Diplomate, available at https://thediplomat.com/2015/09/hindu-extremists-creep-ahead-in-india/, accessed on 17th July 2021
-
Kumar, Girija (1997). Fundamentalism and Social Censorship, in The Book on Trial: Fundamentalism and Censorship in India, Har Anand publication: New Delhi
-
Madan, Triloki N. (1987). ‘Secularism in its Place’ Journal of Asian Societies, vol. 46. No. 4
-
Madan, Triloki N. (1999). ‘Secularism in Its Place,’ in Secuarism and its Critics, Rajeev Bhargava (ed), New Delhi: Oxford University Press, pp. 297–320
-
Mason, Edwina (2002). The water controversy and the politics of Hindu nationalism, South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies, 25:3, 253–263, DOI: 10.1080/00856400208723501
-
Nandey, Ashis (1985). ‘An Anti-Secularist Manifesto’, Seminar, vol. 314, 1–12, October
-
Panikkar, Kavalam N. (1997). Communal threat, secular challenge, Earthworm Book: Madras
-
Pardesi, Manjeet, Oetken, Jennifer (2008). Secularism, and Hindu Nationalism in India, Asian Security, vol. 4, no. 1
-
Parekh, Bhiku (2005). Rethinking Multiculturalism: Cultural Diversity and Political Theory, 2nd edition, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
-
Raychaudhuri, Tapan (1997). ‘Hindu Nationalism or Proto-Fascism: the Nature of Hindu Communal Politics in India’ Jahrbuch, available at https://www.wiko-berlin.de/fileadmin/Jahrbuchberichte/1997/1997_98_Raychaudhuri_Tapan_Vortrag_Jahrbuchbericht.pdf, accessed on 1st February, 2021
-
Riessman, C. Kohler (2012). Analysis of Personal Narratives, In, The Sage handbook of interview research eds (Gubrium, Holstein, Marvasti, McKinney), Sage publication, California
-
Rubinstein, Robert L. (1995). The engagement of life history and the life review among the aged: A research case study. Journal of Aging Studies, 9(3), 187–203. https://doi.org/10.1016/0890-4065(95)90001-2
-
Sachar Committee Report (2006). available at https://prsindia.org/files/policy/policy_committee_reports/1242304423--Summary%20of%20Sachar%20Committee%20Report.pdf, accessed on 19th June 2021
-
Santos, Boaventura D. Sousa (2012) Public Sphere and Epistemologies of the South, Africa Development, Vol. XXXVII, No. 1, pp. 43–67
-
Satya, Laxman (2006). A Reinterpretation of Buddhism [Review of Buddhism in India: Challenging Brahmanism and Caste, by G. Omvedt]. Economic and Political Weekly, 41(50), 5121–5124. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4419025
-
Sen, Amartya (2005). ‘Secularism and Its Discontent’ In The Argumentative Indian. Writings on Indian History, Culture and Identity. London: Penguin Books, pp. 294–316.
-
Silverman, David. (1993). Interpreting Qualitative Data: Methods for Analysing Qualitative Data. London: Sage.
-
Tharoor, Shashi (2020). The Battle of Belonging, on nationalism, patriotism and what it means to be Indian, Aleph book publication: New Delhi
-
Thaper, Romila (2022). ‘I don’t like Modi’s India, it’s too Narrow & Limited; History won’t be Kind to Him’ The interview with Karan Thapar, 10th August, available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x65z6USSfPQ, accessed on 10 Feburary 2023
-
Thaper, Romila (2015). The Public Intellectual in India, Aleph Book Company: New Delhi
-
Truschke, Audrey (2020). Hindutva’s Dangerous Rewriting of History, South Asia Multidisciplinary Academic Journal [Online], 24/25 | 2020, Online since 23 October 2020, connection on 15 December 2020. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/samaj/6636; DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/samaj.6636
-
Silverman, D. (1993). Interpreting Qualitative Data: Methods for Analysing Qualitative Data. London: Sage.
-
Varshney, Ashutosh (1992). India: Liberalism Vs. Nationalism, Journal of Democracy, 3:1, pp. 147–153
-
Water (2005) A Film by Deepa Mehta, video made available by Neo Pav Studio, available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MFbuhRqplE
-
Van, der Veer, P. (1994). Hindu Nationalism and the Discourse of Modernity: The Vishva Hindu Parishad, Accounting for Fundamentalisms, pp. 653–668, Chicago university Press, available at http://dspace.library.uu.nl/handle/1874/7047
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 722 | 583 | 103 |
| Full Text Views | 13 | 10 | 1 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 38 | 30 | 3 |
Secularism in the Troubled ‘Waters’ of ‘Hindu nationalism’
A Case Study of the Conflict between Freedom of Expression and Religion in India
In: Secular StudiesSearch for other papers by Amit Singh in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
This article presents an Indian case study of how Hindu nationalists challenge freedom of expression and secularism. Focusing on the film ‘Water’ (2005) and the related controversy (2000) in a north Indian district in Varanasi in 2000, this article examines the conflict between Hindu nationalists and those who oppose them. Through the theoretical lens of ‘contextual secularism’, this article analyses the narratives of Hindu nationalists and resistance groups involved in the secular-religious impasse. In particular, the article focuses on the most important interrelated aspect of this situation—the tension between freedom of expression and Hindu religious intolerance. This study applies qualitative research methods, particularly semi-structured interviews, and narrative analysis. The study concludes that Indian secularism tolerates Hindu religious bigotry toward dissent and that Hindu nationalism is incompatible with secular democracy and, to some extent, with freedom of expression and dissent. However, there is the possibility of resistance to hegemonic Hindu nationalism.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 722 | 583 | 103 |
| Full Text Views | 13 | 10 | 1 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 38 | 30 | 3 |