Occupy Bulgaria
Or, The Emergence of the Post-Communist Contestatory Citizenship
In: Southeastern EuropeSearch for other papers by Anna Krasteva in
Current site
Google Scholar
This article examines the reinvention of post-communist democracy through contestation and new mobilizations on and offline. The hypothesis of this analysis is that we are currently witnessing a second democratic revolution: following the velvet revolution of the 1990s, a second, digital and contestatory revolution has been occurring in the 2010s. Whereas the first revolution introduced parliamentary democracy into the post-communist states, the new revolution sets the conditions for the emergence of contestatory citizenship. The article is structured in three parts. The first section analyses the emergence of a new type of citizenship and identifies its ‘3 I’ formula: indignation, Internet, and imagination. Furthermore, the conception of contestatory (e-)citizenship is articulated along four axes: the ‘augmented’ citizen, the digital indignados, ‘speaking up’, and the networked individual. The second part examines the political cartography of protests and their uses (politization, aesthetization, self-reflexivity, civic takeover of political temporality, ‘exit or voice’). The article compares three waves of mobilization and, armed with the analytic toolkit of contestatory citizenship and a scheme of four axes, proposes a classification. The third part of the paper, finally, looks at the new mobilizations through the perspective of the new actors.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Braithwaite J., 2007. “ Contestatory Citizenship ; Deliberative Denizenship,” in Brennan G. et al (eds.), Common Minds. Themes from the Philosophy of Philip Pettit (Oxford: Clarendon Press): 161–181.
-
Cardon D.2010. La démocratie Internet. Promesses et limites (Paris: Seuil).
-
Castells M.2010a, 1996. The Rise of the Network Society (The Information Age: Economy, Society and Culture, Vol. I, 2nd edition (Malden, ma and Oxford, uk: Wiley-Blackwell).
-
——— 2010b, 1997. The Power of Identity, The Information Age: Economy, Society and Culture, Vol. ii. 2nd edition (Malden, ma, and Oxford, uk: Wiley-Blackwell).
-
——— 2012. Networks of Outrage and Hope. Social Movements in the Internet Age (Cambridge: Polity Press).
-
Coleman S. and Blumler. 2010. The Internet and the democratic citizenship (Cambridge University Press).
-
Della Porta D., and Mattoni A., . 2014. “ Patters of diffusion and the trasnational dimension of protest in the movements of the crisis: an introduction,” in Della Porta D., and Mattoni A. (eds.), Spreading protest. Social movements in times of crisis (Colchester: ecpr): 1–18.
-
Dinev I.2012. “ Mezhdu negativniya i pozitivniya protest [Between negative and positive protests],” In P.Pachkova (ed), Grazhdanskiyat protest. Minalo, nastoyashte, badeshte [Civil protests. Past, present, future]. (Blagoevgrad: Neofit Rilski Press): 182–193.
-
Ditchev I., 2011. “ Digitalniyat postkomunizam: iz virtualnite saloni na subpolitikata [Digital postcommunism: in the virtual salons of subpolitics],” in Ditchev I., and Spassov O. (eds,), Novi medii, novi mobilizatsii [New media, new mobilizations] (Sofia: Open Society Foundation): 15–36.
-
——— and Spassov O.. (eds.). 2011. Novi medii, novi mobilizatsii [New media, new mobilizations] (Sofia: Open Society Foundation).
-
Hay C.2007. Why We Hate Politics (Cambridge: Polity Press).
-
Hirschman A.1970. Exit, Voice and Loyalty. In Firms, Organisations and States (Cambridge, ma: Harvard University Press).
-
Hristov T., 2011. “ Tsenata na publichnostta: protestite sreshtu deregulatsiyata na genetichno modifitsiranite organizmi i proizvodstvoto na novini [The price of publicity: the protests against gmo deregulation, and news production],” in Ditchev I., and Spassov O. (eds.), Novi medii, novi mobilizatsii [New media, new mobilizations] (Sofia: Open Society Foundation): 187–223.
-
Kanev P., and Krastanova R.. (eds.). 2009. Myasto za badeshte [A place for the future] (Sofia: Shtastlivetsa Civic Association).
-
Krasteva A., 2012. “ Digitalnoto publichno prostranstvo – politicheskiyat proekt na Internet revolyutsiyata [The digital public sphere: the political project of the internet revolution],” in Cardon D. (ed.), The internet revolution. Promises and limits (Bulgarian translation) (Sofia: nbu): 7–13.
-
——— 2013a. “ Digitalnite vazmuteni [Digital indignants],” in Krasteva A. (ed.), Digitalniyat grazhdanin [E-citizens] (Sofia: New Bulgarian University Press): 99–117.
-
——— 2013b. “ Digitalniyat grazhdanin – politicheskiyat proekt na internet revolyutsiyata [E-citizens: the political project of the internet revolution],” in A.Krasteva (ed.), Digitalniyat grazhdanin [E-citizens] (Sofia: New Bulgarian University Press): 7–15.
-
——— 2013c. “ Dneshnata revolyutsiya e “Varnenska prolet” [Present-day revolution is ‘Varna Spring’],” Demokratsiya, 7–13 March.
-
——— (ed.). 2013d. Digitalniyat grazhdanin [E-citizens] (Sofia: New Bulgarian University Press).
-
Kriesi H.2014. “ The populist challenge,” East European Politics, vol. 37, N 2, 361–378.
-
McCaughey M., and Michael D.A., . 2003. “ Introduction,” in McCaughey M., and Ayers M. D. (eds.), Cyberactivism. Online activism in theory and practice (New York and London: Routledge): 1–14.
-
Mattoni A., and della Porta D, . 2014. “ Adapting theories on diffusion and transnational contention through social movements of the crisis: some concluding remarks,” in Della Porta D., and Mattoni A. (eds.), Spreading protest. Social movements in times of crisis (Colchester: ecpr): 277– 291.
-
Meyer D., and Tarrow S., . 1998. “ A movement society: contentious politics for a new century,” in Meyer D.S., and Tarrow S. (eds.), The social movement society (Lanham, md: Rowman &Littlefield): 1– 28.
-
Nikova K., 2011. “ Urok po mobilizatsii [A lesson in mobilizations],” in Ditchev I., and Spassov O. (eds.), Novi medii, novi mobilizatsii [New media, new mobilizations] (Sofia: Open Society Foundation): 101–118.
-
Occupy Wall Street! 2011. Textes, essais et temoignages des Indignes (Paris: Les Arenes).
-
Otova I., 2013. “ Ekologichnite mobilizatsii v Balgariya [Environmental mobilizations in Bulgaria],” in Krasteva A. (ed.) Digitalniyat grazhdanin [E-citizens] (Sofia: New Bulgarian University Press): 148–160.
-
Pettit Ph.1997. Republicanism: a theory of freedom and government (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
-
——— 2011. Republican Reflections on the 15-M Movement (Published in booksandideas.net 20 September 2011) ©booksandideas.ne.
-
Riesman D.2001. The Lonely Crowd. The Study of the Changing American Character, Revised version (New Haven, ct and London: Yale University Press).
-
Roos J. E., and Oikonomakis L., . 2014. “ They don’t represent Us! The Global Resonance of the Real Democracy Movement from the Undignados to Occupy,” in Della Porta D., and Mattoni A. (eds.), Spreading protest. Social movements in times of crisis (Colchester: ecpr): 117–136.
-
Rone Y., 2011. “ Politicheskoto sarfirane v YouTube i Vbox7 [Political surfing on YouTube and Vbox7],” in I.Ditchev and Spassov O. (eds.), Novi medii, novi mobilizatsii [New media, new mobilizations] (Sofia: Open Society Foundation): 156–173.
-
Sassen S., 2013. “ Interactions socio-techniques des pouvoirs et des sans pouvoirs,” in Krasteva A. (ed.), E-citoyennetés (Paris: Harmattan): 7–11.
-
Smilov D., and Vaisova L. (eds.). #Protestat. Analizi i pozitsii v balgarskata presa – lyato 2013 [#Protests. Analyses and positions in the Bulgarian press – summer 2013] (Sofia: Human and Social Studies Foundation/Iztok-Zapad Press).
-
Van de Donk W., , Loader B. D., , Nixon P. G., and Raucht D.. 2004. Cyberprotest. New Media, Citizens and Social Movements (New York: Routledge).
-
Van de Donk W., , Loader B. D., , Nixon P. G., and Raucht D., . 2004. “ Introduction: Social Movements and icts,” in Van de Donk W., , Loader B. D., , Nixon P. G., and Raucht D., Cyberprotest. New Media, Citizens and Social Movements (New York: Routledge): 1–26.
-
Wolton D., 2002. “ Fracture numérique ou facture numérique?” in Jauréguiberry Fr., and Proulx S. (eds.), Internet, nouvel espace citoyen? (Paris: Harmattan): 31–35.
-
5
This occurred in 1989, on the eve of the democratic transition.
Occupy Bulgaria
Or, The Emergence of the Post-Communist Contestatory Citizenship
In: Southeastern EuropeSearch for other papers by Anna Krasteva in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
This article examines the reinvention of post-communist democracy through contestation and new mobilizations on and offline. The hypothesis of this analysis is that we are currently witnessing a second democratic revolution: following the velvet revolution of the 1990s, a second, digital and contestatory revolution has been occurring in the 2010s. Whereas the first revolution introduced parliamentary democracy into the post-communist states, the new revolution sets the conditions for the emergence of contestatory citizenship. The article is structured in three parts. The first section analyses the emergence of a new type of citizenship and identifies its ‘3 I’ formula: indignation, Internet, and imagination. Furthermore, the conception of contestatory (e-)citizenship is articulated along four axes: the ‘augmented’ citizen, the digital indignados, ‘speaking up’, and the networked individual. The second part examines the political cartography of protests and their uses (politization, aesthetization, self-reflexivity, civic takeover of political temporality, ‘exit or voice’). The article compares three waves of mobilization and, armed with the analytic toolkit of contestatory citizenship and a scheme of four axes, proposes a classification. The third part of the paper, finally, looks at the new mobilizations through the perspective of the new actors.