Judicial Globalization, Europeanization and (G)localization: Evidence from the Balkans

in Southeastern Europe
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Over the last decades, academic interest in judicial globalization and judicial reforms has increased. The literature has gone through three distinctive waves of research. One part of this literature examines judicial reforms from a top-down perspective, revealing the origins and evolution of European/international prescriptions related to rule of law consolidation. By looking at the motivations and actions on the ground, another strand of the existing research examines the effects of these prescriptions at the domestic level. In addition, in recent years, a more reflexive and critical approach to judicial reforms has emerged, questioning not only the modest outcomes of these reforms but also the limitations of the international rule of law community in promoting them. This introductory article reviews this growing body of studies, highlighting the main findings and pointing out new avenues for research. In its final section, it provides an overview of the lines of reasoning and the content of this special issue. Overall, it endeavors to shed more light on judicial reforms in the region and to promote this research agenda, which implies to examine the complex relationship between judicial globalization, Europeanization and glocalization.

Judicial Globalization, Europeanization and (G)localization: Evidence from the Balkans

in Southeastern Europe



AcharyaA. 2004. “How Norms Spread: Whose Norms Matter? Norm Localization and Institutional Change in Asian Regionalism” in: International Organization 58: 2239275.

BarnettM. N. and FinnemoreM. 1999. “The Politics, Power, and Pathologies of International OrganizationsInternational Organizations53(4): 699732.

BaudenbacherC. 2003. “Judicial Globalization: New Development or Old Wine in New Bottles?” Texas International Law Journal38: 505526.

BerglingP. 2006. Rule of Law on the International Agenda. International Support to Legal and Judicial Reforms in International Administration Transition and Development Co-operation (Antwerpen – Oxford: Intersentia).

BieberF. 2011. “Building Impossible States? State-Building Strategies and eu Membership in the Western BalkansEurope-Asia Studies 63(10): 17831802.

BorzelT. 2011. “When Europeanization Hits Limited Statehood. The Western Balkans as a Test Case for the Transformative Power of Europekfg Working Papers Series 30.

CarothersT. 2006. “The Rule-of-Law Revival” in T. Carothers T. (ed.) Promoting the Rule of Law Abroad. In Search of Knowledge (Washington: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace): 315.

ChestermanS. 2008. “An International Rule of Law?” The American Journal of Comparative Law 56(2): 331361.

ComanR. 2009. Reformer la justice dans un pays post-communiste. Le cas de la Roumanie. Bruxelles: Editions de l’Université.

ComanR. 2014. “The Normative Power of the eu and Contentious Europeanization: The Case of Judicial Politics.” Journal of European Integration 117 doi:10.1080/07036337.2014.894036

ComanR. forthcoming. “Rule of Law Promotion: us and eu Experiences in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Ukraine” in Pal L et al. (eds.) Micro-Dynamics and Macro-Effects of Policy Transfers Edward Elgar.

ComanR. and DallaraC. (eds.). 2010. Handbook On Judicial Politics (Iasi: Editura Institutul European).

CommailleJ. 2012. “Les vertus du glocalismeJournal Perspectives. Réseau français des Instituts d’études avancés 8.

CommailleJ. 2013. “Justice et globalization” in A. J. Arnaud (dir.) Dictionnaire de la globalisation (Paris: LGDJ).

CommailleJ. and DumoulinL. 2012. Prendre la mesure de la judiciarisation. Un état international des savoirs et des modes de production des savoirs sur la justice Rapport final gip Mission de recherche Droit et justice - convention n°

CommailleJ. and JobertB. 1998. “Introduction. La regulation politique: l’émergence d’un nouveau regime de connaissance” in CommailleJ. and JobertB. (eds.) Les metamorphoses de la regulation politique (Paris: LGDJ).

CommailleJ. and KaluszynskiM. (eds.). 2007. La fonction politique de la justice (Paris: La Découverte).

CremonaM. 2011. “Values in eu Foreign Policy” in EvansM. and KoutrakosP. (eds.) Beyond the Established Legal Orders (OxfordHard Publishing).

DallaraC. 2009. “Serbia: Borderline Democracy?” In A. Magen and L. Morlino (eds.) International Actors Democratization and the Rule of Law (New York: Routledge): 156188.

DallaraC. 2014. Democracy and Judicial Reforms in South-East Europe. Between the eu and the Legacies of the Past (Cham Heidelberg New York Dordrecht London: Springer).

DelpeuchT. 2007. “Evaluation of Sociological Critiques of International Legal Reforms Transfers based on an Analysis of American Judicial Assistance in Bulgaria” in R. Coman and J. M. De Waele (eds.) Judicial Reforms in Central and Eastern European Countries (BrugesVanden Broele): 79107.

DelpeuchT. 2009. “Comprendre la circulation internationale des solutions d’action publique: panorama des policy transfer studies Critique internationale 2(43): 153165.

DelpeuchT. and VassilevaM. 2010. “Des transferts aux apprentissages: réflexions à partir des nouveaux modes de gestion de développement économique local en BulgarieCritique internationale 3(48): 2252.

DezalayY. and GarthB. G. 2005. Global Prescriptions. The Production Exportation and Importation of a new Legal Orthodoxy (Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press).

DezalayY. and GarthB. G. 2011. Lawyers and the Rule of Law in an era of Globalization (Oxfordshire: Routledge).

DimitrijevicV. 2009. “Domestic war crimes trials in Serbia Bosnia-Herzegovina and Croatia” Chaillot Paper 116.

DjuricI. 2010. “The Post-War Repatriation of Serb Minority Internally Displaced Persons and refugees in Croatia – Between Discrimination and Political SettlementEurope-Asia Studies 62(10): 16391660.

DolowitzD. P. and MarshD. 2000. “Learning from Abroad: The Role of Policy Transfer in Contemporary Policy-MakingGovernance: An International Journal of Policy and Administration 13(1): 524.

DzihicV. and WieserA. 2011. “Incentives for Democratization? Effects of eu Conditionality on Democracy in Bosnia and HercegovinaEurope-Asia Studies63(10): 18031825.

ElbasaniA. 2013. “Europeanization Travels to the Western Balkans/ Element Strategy, Domestic Obstacle and Diverging Reforms” in A. Elbasani (ed.) European Integration and Transformation in the Western Balkans. Europeanization or Business as Usual? (London and New York: Routledge): 421.

EppC. R. 1998. Rights Revolutions Lawyers Activists and Supreme Courts in Comparative Perspective (Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press).

FebbrajoA. 2010. “Legal Cultures in Transition: A System-theory Approach” in A. Febbrajo and W. Sadurski (eds.) Central and Eastern Europe After Transition. Towards a New Socio-legal Semantics (Farnham: Ashgate): 3573.

FinnemoreM. and SikkinkK. 1998. “International Norm Dynamics and Political Change.” International Organization 52(4): 8871061.

FreyburgT. and RichterS. 2010. “National Identity Matters: the Limited Impact of eu Political Conditionality in the Western BalkansJournal of European Public Policy 17(2): 263281.

GaraponA. 1999. “La démocratie à l’épreuve de la justice” in Justices: Ce qui a changé dans la justice depuis 20 ans (Paris: Dalloz).

GaraponA. 2005. Les juges dans la mondialisation (Paris: Le Seuil).

GrabbeH. 2002. European Union Conditionality and the Acquis communautaire. International Political Science Review 23(3): 249268.

HammerslevO. (2011) “The European Union and the United States in Eastern Europe: Two Ways of Exporting Law, Expertise and State Power” in Y. Dezalay and B. G. Garth (eds.) Bryant Lawyers and the Rule of Law in an Era of Globalization (Routledge).

HilbinkL. 2007. Judges Beyond Politics in Democracy and Dictatorship. Lessons from Chile (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).

KleinfeldR. 2006. “Competing Definitions of the Rule of Law” in T. Carothers (ed.) Promoting the Rule of Law Abroad. In Search of Knowledge (Washington: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace): 3173.

KleinfeldR. 2012. Advancing the Rule of Law Abroad: Next Generation Reform (Washington, dc: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace).

KleinfeldR. 2013. “How to Advance the Rule of Law AbroadCarnegie Endowment for International Peace. Retrieved from http://carnegieendowment.org/files/Kleinfeld-po-web.pdf (accessed 15 July 2014).

KonitzerA. 2011. “Speaking European: Conditionality, Public Attitudes and Pro-European Party Rhetoric in the Western BalkansEurope-Asia Studies 63(10): 18531888.

KotzianP.KnodtM. and UrdzeS. 2011. Instruments of the eu’s External Democracy Promotion. Journal of Common Market Studies 49(5): 9951018.

MagenA. and MorlinoL. (eds.). 2009. International Actors Democratization and the Rule of Law (New York: Routledge).

MannersI. 2008. “The Normative Ethics of the European UnionInternational Affairs 84(1): 4560.

MarshallD. (ed.). 2014. The International Rule of Law Movement. A Crisis of Legitimacy and the Way Forward (Harvard Law School: Human Rights Program Series).

MemisevicT. 2009. “ eu Conditionality in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Police Reform and the Legacy of War CrimesChaillot Paper 116: 4956.

MendelskiM. 2013. “Where Does the European Union Make a Difference. Rule of Law Development in the Western Balkans and Beyond” In A. Elbasani (ed.) European Integration and Transformation in the Western Balkans. Europeanization or Business as Usual? (London and New York: Routledge):101118.

Mungiu-PippidiA. 2011. “A House of Cards? Building the Rule of Law in the Balkans” In J. Rupnik J. The Western Balkans and the eu: “The Hour of Europe” Institute for Security Studies 145163.

NicolaidisK. and KleinfeldR. 2012. “Rethinking Europe’s Rule of Law and Enlargement Agenda: The Fundamental DilemmaThe Jean Monnet Working Papers Series.

NoutchevaG. and Aydin-DuzgitS. 2012. “Lost in Europeanization: the Western Balkans and TurkeyWest European Politics 35(1): 5978.

PalL. A. (2012) Frontiers of Governance. The oecd and Global Public Management Reform. New York: Palgrave.

D.Papadimitriou and PetrovP. 2012. “Whose Rule, Whose Law? Contested Statehood, External Leverage and the European Union’s Rule of Law Mission in Kosovo Journal of Common Market Studies 50(5): 746763.

PechL. 2012. “Rule of Law as a Guiding Principle of the European Union’s External Actioncleer Working PapersNo. 3.

PhinnemoreD. 2013. “The Stabilization and Association Process. A framework for European Union Enlargement?” In A. Elbasani (ed.) European Integration and Transformation in the Western Balkans. Europeanization or Business as Usual? (London and New York: Routledge): 2235.

PianaD. 2010. Judicial Accountabilities in New Europe. From Rule of Law to Quality of Justice (Burlington: Ashgate).

PickeringP. M. 2011. “The Constraints on European Institutions’ Conditionality in the Western BalkansEurope-Asia Studies 63(10): 19391944.

PřibáňJ. 2010. “Constituting the Heterarchy of European Constitutionalism in the eu’s New Member States,” in A. Febbrajo and W. Sadurski (eds.) Central and Eastern Europe After Transition. Towards a New Socio-legal Semantics (Ashgate):1335.

RametS. P. 2007. “The Denial Syndrome and its Consequences: Serbian Political Culture since 2000Communist and Post-Communist Studies 40(1): 451.

SchimmelfennigF. and SedelmeierU. 2002. “Theorizing eu Enlargement: Research Focus, Hypotheses, and the State of ResearchJournal of European Public Policy 9(4): 500528.

SedelmeierU. 2011. “Europeanization in New Member and Candidate CountriesLiving Reviews in European Governance 61(1): 532.

ShapiroM. and Stone SweetA. 2002. On Law Politics and Judicialization. (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

SikkinkK. 2005. “Transnational Advocacy Networks and the Social Construction of Legal Rules” in Dezalay Y. and Garth B. G. (2005) Global Prescriptions. The Production Exportation and Importation of a new Legal Orthodoxy (Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press): 37–65.

SlaughterA. M. 2000. “Judicial GlobalizationVirginia Journal of International Law 40: 11031124.

SpoerriM. 2011. “Justice Imposed: How Policies of Conditionality Effect Transitional Justice in the Former YugoslaviaEurope-Asia Studies 63(10): 18271851.

SuboticJ. 2009. Hijacked Justice: Dealing with the Past in the Balkans (Ithaca and ny: Cornell University Press).

SuboticJ. 2010. “Explaining Difficult States: The Problems of Europeanization in SerbiaEast European Politics and Society 24(4): 595616.

SuboticJ. 2011. “Europe is a State of Mind: Identity and Europeanization in the BalkansInternational Studies Quarterly 55(2): 309330.

TateN. and VallinderT. 1995. The Global Expansion of Judicial Power (New York: New York University Press).

TraunerF. 2011. The Europeanization of the Western Balkans. eu Justice and Home Affairs in Croatia and Macedonia (Manchester: Manchester University Press).

Ulas EralpD. 2012. Politics of the European Union in Bosnia-Herzegovina . Between Conflict and Democracy (Lexington Books).

UlusoyK. 2009. “The Changing Challenge of Europeanization to Politics and Governance in TurkeyInternational Political Science Review 30(4): 363384.

WollC. JacquotS. (eds.). 2004. Les usages de l’Europe: acteurs et transformations européennes (Paris: L’Harmattan).

ZambelliN. 2010. “A Journey Westward: A Poststructuralist Analysis of Croatia’s Identity and the Problem of Cooperation with the International Criminal Tribunal for the former YugoslaviaEurope-Asia Studies 62(10): 16611682.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 21 21 12
Full Text Views 9 9 9
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0