European Governments’ Responses to the ‘Refugee Crisis’

The Interdependence of eu Internal and External Controls

in Southeastern Europe
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


In the face of the ‘refugee crisis’, many European governments, even in traditionally liberal states, unilaterally introduced a number of restrictive and, often, controversial migration, asylum, and border control policies. The author argues that past legal-bureaucratic choices on migration and asylum policies, ongoing developments in international relations at that time, the structural and perceived capacity of receiving states to cope with the refugee influx, and long-standing migration-related security concerns influenced the responses of many European governments amid the mass population movement. However, the author also suggests that the surfacing of particular policies across Europe was related to the newly elected Greek government’s attempted U-turn from similar repressive and controversial policies during that time. In this regard, the author maintains that repressive and controversial migration, asylum, and border control policies cannot simply be abolished within the context of the eu common market and interdependence of eu internal and external controls.

European Governments’ Responses to the ‘Refugee Crisis’

The Interdependence of eu Internal and External Controls

in Southeastern Europe



Adamson F.B. 2006. ‘Crossing Borders: International Migration and National Security’International Security31(1): 165199.

Aljazeera 2015. ‘Greece outlines radical immigration reforms’ 5 March. Available from:

Amnesty International 2015. ‘Lockdown at the Macedonian border – illegal pushbacks of refugees to Greece’ 17 December. Available from:

Amnesty International 2016. ‘Amnesty International Report 2015/16: The state of the world’s human rights’. Available from:

Anderson M. 1996. Frontiers. Territory and State Formation (Cambridge: Polity).

Aradau C. 2008. “Forget equality? Security and liberty in the ‘War on Terror’”Alternatives: global local political33(3): 293314.

Balzacq T. Basaran T. Bigo D. Guittet E.P. and Olsson C. 2010. ‘Security Practices’. International Studies Encyclopedia Online. Denemark R. A (ed). Blackwell Publishing Blackwell Reference Online. 18 March 2010. Available from:

Basaran T. 2008. ‘Security, law, borders: spaces of exclusion’International Political Sociology2(4): 339354.

Bigo D. and Guittet E.-P. 2011. “Northern Ireland as metaphor: exception, suspicion and radicalization in the ‘War on Terror’”Security dialogue42(6): 483498.

Bigo D. and Tsoukala A. 2008. Terror insecurity and liberty: illiberal practices of liberal regimes after 9/11 (London: Routledge).

Bigo D. Bonditti P. and Olsson C. 2010. ‘Mapping the European Field of Security Professionals’ in Bigo D. Carrera S. Guild E. and Walker R.B.J. (eds.) Europe’s 21st century challenge: delivering liberty (Surrey: Ashgate): 4963.

Bigo D. Carrera S. Guild E. and Walker R.B. 2008. ‘The changing landscape of European liberty and security: the mid-term report of the challenge project’International Social Science Journal59(192): 283308.

Bolani L. Gemi E. and Skleparis D. 2016. ‘Refugee Crisis and Asylum Policies in Greece and Italy’ in Shteiwi M. (Ed.) Migrants and Refugees. Impact and Policies. Case Studies of Jordan Lebanon Turkey and Greece. (EuroMeSCo Joint Policy Study 4): 82109.

Boswell C. 2007. ‘Theorizing Migration Policy: Is There a Third Way?’International Migration Review41(1): 75100.

Brouwer E. 2003. ‘Immigration, Asylum and Terrorism: A Changing Dynamic Legal and Practical Developments in the eu in Response to the Terrorist Attacks of 11.09’European Journal of Migration and Law 4: 399424.

Burridge A. 2012. “The ‘Added Value’ of rabits: Frontex, Emergency Measures and Integrated Border Management at the External Borders of the European UnionConsortium for Comparative Research on Regional Integration and Social Cohesion.

Carrera S. Blockmans S. Gros D. and Guild E. 2015. ‘The eu’s response to the Refugee Crisis: Taking Stock and Setting Policy Priorities’ceps Essay No. 2016 December. Available from:

Ceyhan A. 2008. ‘Technologization of Security: Management of Uncertainty and Risk in the Age of Biometrics’Surveillance & Society5(2): 102123.

Ceyhan A. and Tsoukala A. 2002. ‘The Securitization of Migration in Western Societies: Ambivalent Discourses and Policies’Alternatives: Global Local Political27: 2139.

Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe 2013. ‘Report by Nils Muižnieks, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, following his visit to Greece from 28 January to 1 February 2013Comm DH (2013)6 16 April. Available from:

Cornelius W.A. Martin P.L. and Hollifield J.F. 1994. ‘Introduction: The Ambivalent Quest for Immigration Control’ in Cornelius W.A. Martin P.L. and Hollifield J.F. (eds.) Controlling Immigration: A Global Perspective (Stanford: Stanford University Press): 341.

cpt 2016. ‘Report to the Greek Government on the visit to Greece carried out by the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (cpt) from 14 to 23 April 2015’. Available from:

Crawley H. Duvell F. Jones K. and Skleparis D. 2016. ‘Understanding the dynamics of migration to Greece and the eu: drivers, decisions and destinationsmedmig Research Brief No.2. Available from:

Cross H.M. 2009. ‘The eu Migration Regime and West African Clandestine Migrants’Journal of Contemporary European Research5(2): 171187.

Dauvergne C. 2007. ‘Security and migration law in the less brave new world’Social & Legal Studies16(4): 533549.

EurActiv 2016. ‘Austrian cap on asylum seekers infuriates Commission’ 19 February. Available from:

Euronews 2015. ‘Germany tightens rules for asylum seekers’ 15 October. Available from:

European Commission 2016. ‘Spring 2016 Standard Eurobarometer: Strong public support for Commission’s political prioritiesPress Release 29 July. Available from:

Eurostat 2016. ‘Asylum in the eu Member States: Record number of over 1.2 million first time asylum seekers registered in 2015’Newsrelease 44/2016 4 March. Available from:

Ewald F. 1991. ‘Norms, Discipline and the Law’ in Post R. (ed.) Law and the Order of Culture (Berkeley: University of California Press): 138161.

Frontex 2013. ‘Annual risk analysis 2013’. Available from:

Gordenker L. 1987. Refugees in international politics (London: Croom Helm).

Guild E. Groenendijk C.A. and Carrera S. 2009. Illiberal liberal states: immigration citizenship and integration in the eu (Aldershot: Ashgate).

Hollifield J.F. 2004. ‘The Emerging Migration State’International Migration Review38(3): 885912.

hrw 2015a. ‘Hungary: Locked Up for Seeking Asylum’ 1 December. Available from:

hrw 2015b. ‘Greece: Address Longstanding Rights Issues’ 19 February. Available from:

hrw 2015c. ‘Dispatches: Greece Vows to End Anti-Immigrant Police Operation’ 5 February. Available from:

hrw 2016. ‘Austria: Drastic, Unjustified Measures against Asylum Seekers’ 27 April. Available from:

Huysmans J. 2000. ‘The European Union and the Securitization of Migration’Journal of Common Market Studies38(5): 751777.

Huysmans J. and Buonfino A. 2008. ‘Politics of exception and unease: immigration, asylum and terrorism in parliamentary debates in the ukPolitical Studies56(4): 766788.

Jabri V. 2006. ‘War, security and the liberal state’Security Dialogue37(1): 4764.

Jacobsen K. 1996. ‘Factors influencing the policy responses of host governments to mass refugee influxes’International Migration Review30(3): 655678.

Joppke C. 2001. ‘The legal-domestic sources of immigrant rights: The United States, Germany, and the European Union’ Comparative Political Studies34(4): 339366.

Karyotis G. 2007. ‘European Migration Policy in the Aftermath of September 11’Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research20(1): 117.

Karyotis G. 2012. ‘Securitization of migration in Greece: process, motives, and implications’International Political Sociology6(4): 390408.

Karyotis G. and Patrikios S. 2010. ‘Religion, securitization and anti-immigration attitudes: the case of Greece’Journal of Peace Research47(1): 4357.

Karyotis G. and Skleparis D. 2013. ‘Qui bono? The winners and losers of securitising migration’Griffith Law Review22(3): 683706.

Kathimerini 2015. ‘Migrant centers to be shut down after suicide’ 14 February. Available from:

Katsiaficas C. 2015. ‘A New Day for Greek Migration Policy? The New Government and Prospects for Reform’bref Commentary No. 333 March. Available from:

Lavenex S. 1998. ‘“Passing the Buck”: European Union Refugee Policies Towards Central and Eastern Europe’Journal of Refugee Studies11(2): 126145.

Lazaridis G. and Skleparis D. 2016. ‘Securitization of Migration and the Far Right: The Case of Greek Security Professionals’International Migration54(2): 176192.

Lippert R.K. and Williams J.W. 2012. ‘Taking Exception: The Cases of Financial and Urban Governance’Social & Legal Studies21(1): 5172.

Loescher G. 1992. Refugee movements and international security (London: Brassey’s).

Lohrmann R. 2000. ‘Migrants, Refugees and Insecurity. Current Threats to Peace?’International Migration38(4): 322.

Mitsilegas V. 2015. The criminalisation of migration in Europe: challenges for human rights and the rule of law (New York: Springer).

Neal A.W. 2009. ‘Securitization and risk at the eu border: The origins of frontex’jcms: Journal of common market studies47(2): 333356.

orf 2016. ‘Europarat kritisiert neues Asylrecht’22 April. Available from:

Sassen S. 1999. ‘Beyond Sovereignty: De-Facto Transnationalism in Immigration Policy’European Journal of Migration and Law1(2): 177198.

Skleparis D. 2016. ‘(In)securitization and illiberal practices on the fringe of the euEuropean Security25(1): 92111.

Skleparis D. 2017. ‘The Greek response to the migration challenge: 2015–2017kas Katoptron #5Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung Greece.

Skleparis D. and Armakolas I. 2016. ‘The refugee crisis and the role of ngos, civil society, and media in Greece’ in Phillips D.L. (ed.) Balkan Human Corridor: Essays on the Refugee and Migrant Crisis from Scholars and Opinion Leaders in Southeast Europe (New York: Columbia University): 171184.

Soysal Y. 1994. Limits of Citizenship: Migrants and Postnational Membership in Europe (Chicago: University of Chicago).

Strik T. 2013. ‘Migration and asylum: mounting tensions in the Eastern Mediterranean’23 January. Available from:

The Guardian 2016. ‘Ban Ki-moon attacks “increasingly restrictive” eu asylum policies’28 April. Available from:

The Local 2015. ‘Government criticized for fast-tracking asylum laws’ 24 November. Available from:

The New York Times 2012. ‘As Greece rounds up migrants official says “invasion” imperils national stability’7 August. Available from:

Topak Ö.E. 2014. ‘The biopolitical border in practice: surveillance and death at the Greece-Turkey borderzones’Environment and Planning D: Society and Space32(5): 815833.

To Vima 2015. ‘Citizenship to all children – the end of “Xenios Zeus”’ 5 February. Available from: [In Greek].

Trauner F. 2016. ‘Asylum policy: the eu’s ‘crises’ and the looming policy regime failure’Journal of European Integration38(3): 311325.

Tsoukala A. 2006. ‘Democracy in the light of security: British and French political discourses on domestic counter-terrorism policies’Political Studies54(3): 607627.

unhcr 2016a. ‘Observations by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees Regional Representation for Northern Europe on the draft law proposal on restrictions of the possibility to obtain a residence permit in Sweden’ 10 March. Available from:

unhcr 2016b. ‘ unhcr Observations on the proposed amendments to the Danish Aliens legislation’ 6 January. Available from:

Weiner M. 1992. ‘Security, Stability, and International Migration’International Security17(3): 91126.


  • View in gallery

    Number of apprehended irregular migrants per year, 2011–2014.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 28 28 20
Full Text Views 13 13 13
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0