Knowledge and Attitudes of European Kosher Consumers as Revealed through Focus Groups

in Society & Animals
No Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

There is a very small, yet important minority within the community of European Union kosher consumers. There is a great deal of research regarding objective aspects of the kosher religious as well as civil laws and their implementation, but comparatively little research about the subjective attitudes, opinions, and concerns of those who actually purchase and consume kosher food. Such information can be important for a variety of interested parties including suppliers, distributors, regulatory agencies, legislators, and certifying agencies as well as religious authorities. We collected relevant data by organizing hour-long Focus Groups (FG) in five European cities and a suburb of Tel Aviv. The FG addressed consumer attitudes related to shopping practices, commitment, trust, and certification as well as their knowledge and opinions regarding nonhuman animal welfare as it relates to shechita (kosher slaughter) and knowledge of the issue of stunning animals at the time of killing. One of the significant findings was a high level of secularization among Jews that translates to a low level of commitment to eating kosher. But this was accompanied by assertions that eating kosher was an important religious obligation and complaints of low availability and high cost. There was a strong feeling, even among those less committed to eating kosher, that shechita was the preferred method of slaughtering an animal (more animal friendly) and a strong suspicion of anti-Semitism as a motivation for any attempt to impose a stunning obligation.

Knowledge and Attitudes of European Kosher Consumers as Revealed through Focus Groups

in Society & Animals

Sections

References

Agri-Food Trade Service United States kosher food market brief 2010 Retrieved from http://www.ats.agr.gc.ca/amr/4975-eng.htm#b.

AnilM. H.YesildreT.AksuH.MaturE.McKinstryJ. L.ErdoganO.MasonC. Comparison of religious slaughter of sheep with methods that include pre-slaughter stunning, and the lack of differences in exsanguination, packed cell volume and meat quality parameters Animal Welfare 2004 13 387 392

Bergeaud-BlacklerF. New challenges for Islamic ritual slaughter: A European perspective Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 2007 33 6 965 980

Bergeaud-BlacklerF. GöleN. French animal welfare activists and ritual slaughter: Postmortem of a moribund campaign Islam and public controversy in Europe 2013 Surrey, United Kingdom Ashgate Global Connections Series 128 146

Bergeaud-BlacklerF.FerrettiM. P. More politics, stronger consumers? A new division of responsibility for food in the European Union Appetite 2006 47 2 134 142

Bergeaud-BlacklerF.EvansA.ZivotofskyA. Final report consumer and consumption issues, halal and kosher focus groups results 2010 Retrieved from www.dialrel.eu/images/report-consumption.pdf.

CooreR. R.BarrF. J.McKinstryJ. L.AnilM. H. Neural embolism and cerebral venous drainage at stunning and slaughter The Veterinary Record 2004 155 86 87

EvansA.MieleM. Between food and flesh: How animals are made to matter (and not to matter) within food consumption practices Environment and Planning D-Society and Space 2012 30 2 298 314

EvansA.MieleM. Consumers’ views about farm animal welfare, Part I: National reports based on focus group research Welfare quality reports no. 4 2007 Cardiff, United Kingdom Cardiff University

Faye Clark Marketing & Communications Inc. Canada kosher foods latest trends in kosher foods 2002 2002 Retrieved (n.d.) from http://www.usda.gov/info/agexporter/.

GormanJ. Animal studies cross campus to lecture hall New York Times 2012 January 2

GrandinT. Animal welfare and humane slaughter 2004 Retrieved March 3 2005 from http://www.grandin.com/.

GrandinT.RegensteinJ. M. Religious slaughter and animal welfare: A discussion for meat scientists Meat Focus International March 1994 1994 115 123

GronowJ.WardeA. Ordinary consumption 2001 London, United Kingdom Rutledge

HickmanM. End ‘cruel’ religious slaughter The Independent 2009 June 22

KalofL.FitzgeraldA. The animals reader: The essential classic and contemporary writings 2007 Oxford, United Kingdom, and New York, NY Berg

KlugB. Ritual Murmur: The undercurrent of protest against religious slaughter of animals in Britain in the 1980s Patterns of Prejudice 1989 23 2 16 28

LeverJ.MieleM. The growth of the halal meat markets in Europe: An exploration of the supply side theory of religion Journal of Rural Studies 2012 28 528 537

MieleM.EvansA. When foods become animals: Ruminations on ethics and responsibility in care-full spaces of consumption Ethics Policy & Environment 2010 13 2 171 190

MieleM.ParisiV. Atteggiamento dei consumatori e politiche di qualità della carne in Italia e in Europa negli anni novanta 2000 Milano, Italy Franco Angeli

MieleM.VeissierI.EvansA.BotreauR. Animal welfare: Establishing a dialogue between science and society Animal Welfare 2011 20 103 117

MorganD. L. Focus groups as qualitative research 1997 2nd ed. London, United Kingdom Sage

RosenS. D. Physiological insights into Shechita The Veterinary Record 2004 154 759 765

USDA What’s to nosh? A growing niche market for kosher foods, that’s what 1998 Retrieved (n.d.) from http://www.usda.gov/info/agexporter/1998/September%201998/whatsto.html

VelardeA.RodriguezP.FuentesC.LlonchP.Von HollebenK.von WenzlawowiczP.DalmauA. Improving animal welfare during religious slaughter 2010 Recommendations for good practice. Official deliverable 2.4 DIALREL project. Retrieved July 23 2013 from http://issuu.com/florencebergeaud-blackler/docs/dialrel-recommandations-final-edited?e=2152254/2596337.

VelardeA.RodriguezP.FuentesC.LlonchP.Von HollebenK.von WenzlawowiczP.DalmauA. Guía de buenas prácticas durante el sacrificio religioso.Eurocarne 2011 201 48 57

ZivotofskyA. Z. Government regulations of shechita (Jewish religious slaughter) in the 21st century: Are they ethical? Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 2012 25 5 747 763

ZivotofskyA. Z.StrousR. D. A perspective on the electrical stunning of animals: Are there lessons to be learned from human electro-convulsive therapy (ECT)? Meat Science 2012 90 4 956 961

5.

See Grandin (2004).

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 33 33 3
Full Text Views 50 50 33
PDF Downloads 7 7 0
EPUB Downloads 5 5 0