Religious Slaughter: Data from Surveys and Spot-Check Visits in Italy and Animal Welfare Issues

in Society & Animals
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Abstract

The public is becoming increasingly concerned about how nonhuman animals are treated, and many studies show that European citizens are concerned about farm animal welfare. Religious slaughter has always been a controversial and emotive subject, caught between animal welfare considerations, cultural and human rights issues. There is considerable variation in current practices, and the rules regarding religious requirements are still confusing. Similarly, consumer demands and concerns also need to be addressed. Therefore, there is a need for information relating to slaughter techniques as well as product range, consumer expectations, market share, and socioeconomic issues. This research aims at identifying the procedures for current methods of religious slaughter in Italy. Conventional slaughter is performed with prior stunning; kosher slaughter is practiced without stunning. Halal slaughter is performed for most of the animals without stunning. Halal slaughter with prior stunning is accepted for 5.9% of small ruminants. Questionnaires were sent to regional health authorities, and spot-check visits were conducted on cattle, sheep, and poultry abattoirs in Italy from October 2008 to March 2009. The observed parameters are discussed in regards to the risk to animal welfare. Observations not only on restraining methods, but also on post-cut, clinical indicators of consciousness are considered. This research is the first, systematic attempt to analyze the methods of religious slaughter and to discuss the implications for animal welfare.

Religious Slaughter: Data from Surveys and Spot-Check Visits in Italy and Animal Welfare Issues

in Society & Animals

Sections

References

  • AnilM. H.McKinstryJ. L.GregoryN. G.WottonS. B.SymondsH. Welfare of calves—2. Increase in vertebral artery blood flow following exsanguination by neck sticking and evaluation of chest sticking as an alternative slaughter method Meat Science 1995 41 113 123

  • AnilM. H.McKinstryJ. L.WottonS. B.GregoryN. G. Welfare of calves—1. Investigation into some aspects of calf slaughter Meat Science 1995 41 2 101 112

  • Bergeaud-BlacklerF. New challenges for Islamic ritual slaughter: A European perspective Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 2007 33 6 965 980

  • BonneK.VerbekeW. Religious values informing halal meat production and the control and delivery of halal credence quality Agriculture and Human Values 2008 25 1 35 47

  • CampagnoloM. T.PeroccoF. La comunicazione degli immigrati e le tecniche dei nuovi media: l’associazionismo in rete. Riflessioni sulla comunità islamica digitale 2002 Venezia, Italy Università di Venezia, Tesi di Master Dip., Filosofia e Teoria delle Scienze

  • Caritas/Migrantes Dossier statistico immigrazione caritas-migrantes 2009 2009 Rome, Italy Edizioni Idos

  • CataneseB.Cenci-GogaB. Religious slaughter: Data from Italy Religious slaughter improving knowledge and expertise through dialogue and debate on issues of welfare legislation and socio-economic aspects 2010 Istanbul, Turkey Dialrel Project workshop (FP6-2005-FOOD-4-C) 15-16 March 2010

  • CataneseB.MattiacciC.De AngelisG.MariniP.CuccureseA.RossiR.Cenci-GogaB. T. Valutazione dei metodi correnti di macellazione secondo rito religioso in Italia Rivista dell’Associazione Italiana Veterinari Igienisti 2009 5 34 39

  • Cenci-GogaB.CataneseB. Religious slaughter of poultry in Italy: Animal welfare issues Hygiena Alimentorum XXX 2009 59 162

  • Cenci-GogaB. T. La macellazione rituale: Benessere animale e aspetti giuridici Ingegneria Alimentare Giugno 2009 2009 55 58

  • Cenci-GogaB. T.FermaniA. G. La macellazione religiosa. Protezione degli animali e produzione igienica della carne 2010 Milano, Italy Point Veterinaire Italie

  • Cenci-GogaB. T.MattiacciC.De AngelisG.MariniP.CuccureseA.RossiR.CataneseB. La macellazione religiosa in Italia Atti della Società Italiana delle Scienze Veterinarie LXIII 2009 356 358

  • Cenci-GogaB. T.MattiacciC.De AngelisG.MariniP.CuccureseA.RossiR.CataneseB. Religious slaughter in Italy Veterinary Research Communications 2010 34 S139 143 (Suppl. 1)

  • Comitato Nazionale per la Bioetica Macellazioni Rituali e Sofferenza Animale 2005 Roma, Italy Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato S.p.A.

  • Comité Permanent de Coordination des Inspections (COPERCI) Comité permanent de coordination des inspections (COPERCI) Conseil général du génie rural, des eaux et forêts conseil général vétérinaire inspection générale de l’agriculture Enquete sur le champ du Halal 2005 Paris, France

  • Consolidated Versions of the Treaty on European Union and the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union Official Journal of the European Union. European Union 2010 Art. 13.

  • Council Directive 91/628/EEC of 19 November 1991 on the Protection of Animals During Transport and Amending Directives 90/425/EEC and 91/496/EEC Official Journal L 1991 340 17 27

  • Council Directive 95/29/EC of 29 June 1995 Amending Directive 90/628/EEC Concerning the Protection of Animals During Transport Official Journal L 1995 148 52 63

  • Council Regulation (EC) No 1099/2009 of 24 September 2009 on the Protection of Animals at the Time of Killing Official Journal of the European Union L 2009 303 1 30

  • DalyC. C.KallweitE.EllendorfF. Cortical function in cattle during slaughter: Conventional captive bolt stunning followed by exsanguination compared with shechita slaughter Veterinary Record 1998 122 325 329

  • Decreto Legislativo 333/98 Attuazione Della direttiva 93/119/CE Relativa Alla Protezione Degli Animali Durante la Macellazione o l’abbattimento Gazzetta Ufficiale 1998 226

  • DorffE. N.RothJ. Shackling and hoisting The Committee on Jewish Law and Standards of the Conservative movement 2002 New York, NY The Rabbinical Assembly

  • DrewnowskiA.SpecterS. E. Poverty and obesity: The role of energy density and energy costs The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2004 79 6 16

  • DunnC. S. Stress reactions of cattle undergoing ritual slaughter using two methods of restrain Veterinary Record 1990 126 522 525

  • EC Directive 93/119/EC on the Protection of Animals at the Time of Slaughter or Killing Official Journal of European Union 1993 340 21 34

  • EFSA European Food Safety Authority Opinion of the Scientific Panel on Animal Health and Welfare on a request from the Commission related to welfare aspects of the main systems of stunning and killing the main commercial species of animals The EFSA Journal 2004 45 1 29

  • EU-Consolidated versions of the Treaty on European Union and the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. Art. 13 Official Journal C 115 0001 0388 09/05/2008

  • EvansA.Ayshe AnilL.Bergeaud-BlacklerF.ColeM.TerragniL.Arne TufteP.von HollebenK. Public debates on religious slaughter in Germany, the United Kingdom, France and Norway: A comparative report 2010 United Kingdom Cardiff University Press C. University Dialrel Reports No. 4.2. Cardiff

  • FrancioneG. L.GarnerR. The animal rights debate: Abolition or regulation? 2010 New York, NY Columbia University Press

  • GibsonT. J.JohnsonC. B.MurrellJ. C.ChambersJ. P.StaffordK. J.MellorD. J. Components of electroencephalographic responses to slaughter in halothane-anaesthetised calves: Effects of cutting neck tissues compared with major blood vessels New Zealand Veterinary Journal 2009 57 2 84 89

  • GibsonT. J.JohnsonC. B.MurrellJ. C.HullsC. M.MitchinsonS. L.StaffordMellorD. J. Electroencephalographic responses of halothane-anaesthetised calves to slaughter by ventral-neck incision without prior stunning New Zealand Veterinary Journal 2009 57 2 77 83

  • GibsonT. J.JohnsonC. B.MurrellJ. C.MitchinsonS. L.StaffordK. J.MellorD. J. Amelioration of electroencephalographic responses to slaughter by non-penetrative captive-bolt stunning after ventral-neck incision in halothane-anaesthetised calves New Zealand Veterinary Journal 2009a 57 2 96 101

  • GibsonT. J.JohnsonC. B.MurrellJ. C.MitchinsonS. L.StaffordK. J.MellorD. J. Electroencephalographic responses to concussive non-penetrative captive-bolt stunning in halothane—anaesthetised calves New Zealand Veterinary Journal 2009b 57 2 90 95

  • GibsonT. J.JohnsonC. B.StaffordK. J.MitchinsonS. L.MellorD. J. Validation of the acute electroencephalographic responses of calves to noxious stimulus with scoop dehorning New Zealand Veterinary Journal 2007 55 152 157

  • GiovagnoliG. La macellazione. L’uccisione degli animali a scopo alimentare—Documenti del Comitato Bioetico per la Veterinaria 2003 Torino, Italy C. G. Edizioni Medico Scientifiche

  • GrandinT.RegensteinJ. M. Religious slaughter and animal welfare: A discussion for meat scientists Meat Focus International 1994 115 123 March 1994

  • GraysonL. Animals in research: For and against 2000 London, United Kingdom The British Library

  • GregoryN.G. GregoryN. G. Solving livestock handling problems in slaughter plants Animal welfare and meat science 1998 Wallingford, United Kingdom CAB International 42 63

  • GregoryN.G. Physiology and behaviour of animal suffering 2004 Oxford, United Kingdom Blackwell Publishing

  • GregoryN. G.FieldingH. R.WenzlawowiczM. v.HollebenK. v. Time to collapse following slaughter without stunning in cattle Meat Science 2010 85 66 69

  • GregoryN. G.WenzlawowiczM. v.AlamR. M.AnilH. M.YesildereT.Silva-FletcherA. False aneurysms in carotid arteries of cattle and water buffalo during shechita and halal slaughter Meat Science 2007 79 285 288

  • GregoryN. G.WenzlawowiczM. v.HollebenK. v. Blood in the respiratory tract during slaughter with and without stunning in cattle Meat Science 2009 82 13 16

  • Halal Advocates of America Halal Advocates of America 2013 Retrieved July 28 2013 from http://halaladvocates.net/site/our-issues/machine-slaughter/

  • Halal Food Authority Halal food manufacturers/suppliers 2007 Retrieved July 28 2013 from http://halalfoodauthority.com

  • Haut conseil a l’integration L’Islam dans la Republique 2000 Retrieved July 2013 from http://www.islamlaicite.org/IMG/pdf/isl_repu_Ht_conseil.pdf

  • KantI. MathieuV.MilanoBompiani Fondazione della metafisica dei costumi 1785/2003

  • KjaernesU.BockB.RoeE.RoexJ. Consumption distribution and production of farm animal welfare. Welfare Quality Report Series No. 7 2008 Norfolk, United Kingdom MPG Biddles Ltd.

  • LeverJ.MieleM. The growth of halal meat markets in Europe: An exploration of the supply side theory of religion Journal of Rural Studies 2012 28 4 528 537

  • LevingerI. M. Shechita in the light of the year 2000 1995 Jerusalem, Israel Maskil L’David

  • MieleM.EvansA. When foods become animals: Ruminations on ethics and responsibility in care-full practices of consumption Ethics Place & Environment 2010 13 2 171 190

  • OFIVAL Terre verte 2004 Retrieved July 28 2013 from http://www.ofival.fr.

  • Regolamento (CE) N. 1/2005 del Consiglio del 22 Dicembre 2004 Sulla Protezione Degli Animali Durante il Trasporto e le Operazioni Correlate Che modifica le Direttive 64/432/CEE e 93/119/CE e il Regolamento (CE) n. 1255/97 Gazzetta ufficiale dell’Unione europea L 3 del 5 gennaio 2005 2005 Brussels, Belgium [Official Journal of European Union]

  • ReissM. J.StraughanR. Improving nature? 1996 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

  • RosenS. D. Physiological insights into Shechita Veterinary Record 2004 154 759 765

  • SingerP.MasonJ. The ethics of what we eat why our food choices matter 2006 Emmaus, PA Rodale

  • SingerP. A. D. Heavy petting Nerve 2001 Archived on March 16 2008. Retrieved July 28 2013 from http://web.archive.org/web/20080316030814/http://www.nerve.com/Opinions/Singer/heavyPetting/main.asp

  • Special Eurobarometer: 270 Attitudes of EU Citizen Towards Animal Welfare European Commission 2007 Retrieved July 2013 from http://ec.europa.eu/food/animal/welfare/survey/sp_barometer_aw_en.pdf

  • SztybelD. Subject: Philosophy and animal rights page 2004 Retrieved June 2013 from http://davidsztybel.info

  • Treaty of Rome 1957 Belgium, France, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands and West Germany

  • VelardeA.HollebenK. v.WenzlawowiczM. v.Cenci-GogaB.CataneseB.FrenciaJ. P.DalmauA. Assessment of the incidence and scale of current religious slaughter practices 2010 Cardiff, United Kingdom Cardiff University Dialrel Deliverable n. 2.1

  • VelardeA.RodriguezP.DalmauA.FuentesC.LlonchP.von HollebenK.Cenci-GogaB. Religious slaughter: Evaluation of current practices Meat Science 2013

  • von HollebenK. v.WenzlawowiczM. v.GregoryN.AnilH.VelardeA.RodriguezP.Lambooij. B. Report on good and adverse practices Animal welfare concerns in relation to slaughter practices from the viewpoint of veterinary sciences Dialrel Deliverable n. 1.3 2010 Cardiff, United Kingdom Cardiff University

  • Wan HassanW. M. Globalising halal standards: Issues and challenges The Halal Journal July/August 2007 2007 38 40

  • wordiQ Subject: Animal welfare 2004 Retrieved July 28 2013 from http://www.wordiq.com/definition/Animal_welfare

Figures

  • View in gallery
    Average time of struggling (s) before and after sticking as recorded during spot-check visits
  • View in gallery
    Average time (s) from restraint to sticking and from sticking to next handling as recorded during spot-check visits

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 54 51 9
Full Text Views 65 65 0
PDF Downloads 13 13 0
EPUB Downloads 19 19 0