Constructing the Biotech Nonhuman Animal: Instrumentalism and Ambivalence

in Society & Animals
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This article was designed to give insight into the role of biotechnology in redefining the complex human-animal relations of our times. In particular, it is used to examine accounts of nonhuman animals and animal usage in the context of biotechnology, as covered in the leading scientific journal Nature Biotechnology. Data consist of editorials, commentaries, and research news for four years (N = 104), and has been analyzed using discourse analysis. The journal constructs a consistent, yet one-sided, view on animals as they are represented through physico-material, technical and biomedical discourses, as well as discourses on human benefits and manageable risks. The biotechnological epistemology of the animal is positioned at the far end of the subjectification-instrumentalization continuum in our treatment of other animals. It also clashes with simultaneous discussions on animal mind, subjectivity, and moral status. These developments are likely to further intensify the discrepancies in human-animal relations in science and society.

Constructing the Biotech Nonhuman Animal: Instrumentalism and Ambivalence

in Society & Animals



BauerM. W.GaskellG Biotechnology: The making of a global controversy 2002 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

BaumanZ. Modernity and ambivalence 1991 Cambridge, United Kingdom Polity Press

BeckU.BonssW.LauC. The theory of reflexive modernization. Problematic, hypotheses and research programme Theory Culture & Society 2003 20 2 1 33

BeckU.GiddensA.LashS. Reflexive modernization. Politics tradition and aesthetics in the modern social order 1994 Cambridge, United Kingdom Polity Press

BirkeL. Feminism animals and science. The naming of the shrew 1994 Buckingham, United Kingdom Open University Press

BirkeL. Who—or what—are the rats (and mice) in the laboratory Society & Animals 2003 11 3 207 224

BirkeL.ArlukeA.MichaelM. The sacrifice. How scientific experiments transform animals and people 2007 West Lafayette, IN Purdue University Press

BowringF. Science seeds and cyborgs. Biotechnology and the appropriation of life 2003 London, United Kindom Verso

BruceA. GM animals—Another GM crops? Genomics Society and Policy 2007 3 3 1 14

CristE. Images of animals. Anthropomorphism and animal mind 1999 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press

de WaalF. B. M.TyackP. L. Animal social complexity. Intelligence culture and individualized societies 2003 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

EderK. The new politics of class. Social movements and cultural dynamics in advanced societies 1993 London, United Kingdom Sage

EtzkowitzH.LeydesdorffL. Universities and the global knowledge economy. A triple helix of university–industry–government relations 1997 London, United Kingdom Cassell Academic

FaircloughN. Critical discourse analysis. The critical study of language 1995 London, United Kingdom Longman

FaircloughN.WodakR. van DijkT. A. Critical discourse analysis Introduction to discourse analysis 1997 London, United Kingdom Sage 258 284

FranklinA. Animals and modern cultures. A sociology of human-animal relations in modernity 1999 London, United Kingdom Sage

FranklinS. Sheepwatching Anthropology Today 2001 17 3 3 9

Genoway Humanized mouse 2011 Retrieved June 7 2011 from

GeorgeA. HollandA.JohnsonA. Animal biotechnology in medicine Animal biotechnology and ethics 1998 London, United Kingdom Chapman and Hall 27 49

GriffinD. Animal minds: Beyond cognition to consciousness 2001 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

HarawayD. Simians cyborgs and women: The reinvention of nature 1991 London, United Kingdom Free Association Books

HarawayD. Modest–Witness@Second–Millennium.FemaleMan–Meets–OncoMouse: Feminism and technoscience 1997 New York, NY Routledge

HarveyM. Animal genomics in science, social science and culture Genomics Society and Policy 2007 3 2 1 28

Hillcoat-NallétambyS.PhillipsE Sociological ambivalence revisited Sociology 2011 45 2 202 217

Hobson-WestP. Beasts and boundaries. An introduction to animals in sociology, science and society Qualitative Sociology Review 2007 3 1 23 41

HollandA.JohnsonA. Animal biotechnology and ethics 1998 London, United Kingdom Chapman and Hall

HolmbergT. A feeling for the animal: On becoming an experimentalist Society & Animals 2008 16 4 316 335

HolmbergT.IdelandM. Transgenic silences: The rhetoric of comparisons and transgenic mice as “ordinary treasures” BioSocieties 2009 4 2-3 165 181

Home Office Statistics of scientific procedures on living animals Great Britain 2010 2011 London, United Kingdom HMSO

ISI Web of Knowledge The 2004 journal citation reports 2006 Retrieved February 16 2006 from

ISI Web of Knowledge The 2010 journal citation reports 2012 Retrieved May 18 2012 from

JamiesonD.BekoffM. BekoffM.JamiesonD. Afterword: Ethics and the study of animal cognition Readings in animal cognition 1999 Cambridge, MA The MIT Press 359 371

Knorr-CetinaK. Epistemic cultures. How the sciences make knowledge 1999 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press

LaFolletteH.ShanksN. Brute science. Dilemmas of animal experimentation 1996 London, United Kingdom Routledge

LaunisV. Geeniteknologia arvot ja vastuu 2003 Helsinki, Finland Gaudeamus

LynchM. E. Sacrifice and the transformation of the animal body into a scientific object: Laboratory culture and ritual practice in the neurosciences Social Studies of Science 1988 18 2 265 289

MacnaghtenP. Animals in their nature: A case study on public attitudes to animals, genetic modification and “nature” Sociology 2004 38 3 533 551

MichaelM. Technoscientific bespoking: Animals, publics and the new genetics New Genetics and Society 2001 20 3 205 224

MidgleyM. Biotechnology and monstrosity: Why we should pay attention to the “yuk factor” Hastings Center Report 2000 30 5 7 15

Nature Biotechnology. Guide to authors 2006 Retrieved April 15 2006 from

NielsenK. M. Transgenic organisms—Time for conceptual diversification? Nature Biotechnology 2003 21 3 227 228

PeggsK. A hostile world for nonhuman animals: Human identification and the oppression of nonhuman animals for human good Sociology 2009 43 1 85 102

PeggsK. Risk, human health, and the oppression of nonhuman animals: The development of transgenic nonhuman animals for human use Humanimalia 2011 2 2 49 69

PlumwoodV. Feminism and the mastery of nature 1993 London, United Kingdom Routledge

ReissM. J.StraughanR. Improving nature? The science and ethics of genetic engineering 1996 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

RollinB. E. The Frankenstein syndrome. Ethical and social issues in the genetic engineering of animals 1995 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

SchicktanzS. Ethical considerations of the human-animal-relationship under conditions of asymmetry and ambivalence Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 2006 19 1 7 16

SeidelG. HollandA.JohnsonA. Biotechnology in animal agriculture Animal biotechnology and ethics 1998 London, United Kingdom Chapman and Hall 50 68

SiipiH. Artefacts and living artefacts Environmental Values 2003 12 4 413 430

SingerP. Animal liberation: A new ethics for our treatment of animals 1975 New York, NY Random House

ThomasK. Man and the natural world: Changing attitudes in England 1500-1800 1983 Oxford, United Kingdom Oxford University Press

TwineR. Animal genomics and ambivalence: A sociology of animal bodies in agricultural biotechnology Genomics Society and Policy 2007a 3 2 99 117

TwineR. Thinking across species—a critical bioethics approach to enhancement Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 2007b 28 6 509 523

TwineR. Animals as biotechnology: Ethics sustainability and critical animal studies 2010 London, United Kingdom Earthscan

UngS. Tieteen toiset tekijät. Eläin ja ihminen bioteknologia-alan tieteellisessä aikakauslehdessä 2007 (Unpublished master’s thesis). University of Tampere Finland.

WetherellM.PotterJ. Mapping the language of racism: Discourse and the legitimation of exploitation 1992 New York, NY Columbia University Press

WilmutI.CampbellK.TudgeC. The second creation: Dolly and the age of biological control 2000 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press


Etzkowits and Leydersdorff (1997) consider the academia-industry-government interactions involved as the triple helix.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 25 25 15
Full Text Views 4 4 4
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0