Social science literature on dog fighting illustrates an important element in the discourse of dog fighters, namely patriarchy. However, it has not addressed another common element, namely flourishing. According to this element of that discourse, some dog breeds are born to fight, and therefore dog fighters are helping them achieve their best lives. This argument is explicitly made by dog fighters, and it is inadvertently supported by those trying to give other dogs breed-specific flourishing, and those who advocate for breed-specific legislation. This poses a problem for advocates of using flourishing to understand animal welfare, particularly if they use kinds (like species and breed) to determine what counts as a flourishing life for a particular nonhuman animal. I argue that we can keep a slightly weakened version of breed-specific flourishing as a starting place for understanding individual dogs without endorsing sport fighting or breed-specific legislation for “vicious” breeds of dogs.
The Humane Society of the United StatesThe hsus launches national animal fighting tip line: Up to $5,000 reward for information leading to arrest and conviction of an animal fighter2009Retrieved 12/2013 from http://www.humanesociety.org/news/press_releases/2009/07/hsus_launches_national_animal_fighting_tip_line_071409.html#.
LockwoodR.SerpellJ.The ethology and epidemiology of canine aggressionThe domestic dog: Its evolution, behavior, and interactions with people1996Cambridge, United KingdomCambridge University Press131138
MirkóE.KubinyiE.GácsiM.MiklósiA.Preliminary analysis of an adjective-based dog personality questionnaire developed to measure some aspects of personality in the domestic dogApplied Animal Behaviour Science20121388898
OttS. A.SchalkeE.von GaertnerA. M.HackbarthH.Is there a difference? Comparison of golden retrievers and dogs affected by breed-specific legislation regarding aggressive behaviorJournal of Veterinary Behavior20083134140
SchalkeE.OttS. A.von GaertnerA. M.HackbarthH.MittmannA.Is breed-specific legislation justified? Study of the results of the temperament test of Lower SaxonyJournal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research20083397103
WalkerR.WalkerL.IvanhoeP. J.Animal flourishing: What virtue requires of human animalsWorking virtue: Virtue ethics and contemporary moral problems2007Oxford, United KingdomOxford University Press173189