Fighting Nature: An Analysis and Critique of Breed-Specific Flourishing Arguments for Dog Fights

in Society & Animals
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


Social science literature on dog fighting illustrates an important element in the discourse of dog fighters, namely patriarchy. However, it has not addressed another common element, namely flourishing. According to this element of that discourse, some dog breeds are born to fight, and therefore dog fighters are helping them achieve their best lives. This argument is explicitly made by dog fighters, and it is inadvertently supported by those trying to give other dogs breed-specific flourishing, and those who advocate for breed-specific legislation. This poses a problem for advocates of using flourishing to understand animal welfare, particularly if they use kinds (like species and breed) to determine what counts as a flourishing life for a particular nonhuman animal. I argue that we can keep a slightly weakened version of breed-specific flourishing as a starting place for understanding individual dogs without endorsing sport fighting or breed-specific legislation for “vicious” breeds of dogs.

Society & Animals

Journal of Human-Animal Studies



AndersonK. A walk on the wild side: A critical geography of domestication Progress in Human Geography 1997 21 4 463 485

BekoffM.PierceJ. Wild justice: The moral lives of animals 2010 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

BorcheltP. L. Aggressive behavior of dogs kept as companion animals: Classification and influence of sex, reproductive status and breed Applied Animal Ethology 1983 10 45 61

BoykoA. R.QuignonP.LiL.SchoenebeckJ. J.DegenhardtJ. D.LohmuellerK. E.OstranderE. A. A simple genetic architecture underlies morphological variation in dogs Public Library of Science 2010 doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.1000451.

BynumT. W. Flourishing ethics Ethics and Information Technology 2006 8 157 173

Cesar Millan on animal, species, breed, name Retrieved 9/2013 from

ColieD. C. Encyclopedia of dog breeds 2005 Hauppauge, NY Barron’s Educational Series

de WaalF.TyackP. L. Animal social complexity: Intelligence, culture, and individualized societies 2005 Cambridge, United Kingdom Harvard University Press

DonaldsonS.KymlickaW. Zoopolis: A political theory of animal rights 2011 Oxford, United Kingdom Oxford University Press All page numbers from Kindle Edition

Federsen-PetersenD. U. Social behaviour of dogs and related canids The behavioural biology of dogs 2007 Oxford, United Kingdom CABI Publishing

ForsytheC.EvansR. Dogmen: The rationalization of deviance Society & Animals 1998 6 3 203 218

GibsonH. Dogfighting detailed discussion 2005 Retrieved 12/2013 from

GladwellM. Troublemakers: What pit bulls can teach us about profiling 2006 Retrieved 9/2013 from

HarawayD. J. For the love of a good dog: Webs of action in the world of dog genetics Race, nature, and the politics of difference 2003 Durham, NC Duke University Press Books

HarawayD. J. When species meet (Posthumanities, Vol. 3) 2007 Minneapolis, MN University of Minnesota Press

HartL. A. SerpellJ. Dogs as human companions: Review of the relationship The domestic dog: Its evolution, behavior, and interaction with people 1995 New York, NY Cambridge University Press 161 177

The Humane Society of the United States The hsus launches national animal fighting tip line: Up to $5,000 reward for information leading to arrest and conviction of an animal fighter 2009 Retrieved 12/2013 from

KalofL.IliopoulouM. A. BlazinaC.BoyrazG.Shen-MillerD. Abusing the human-animal bond: On the making of fighting dogs The psychology of the human animal bond 2011 New York, NY Springer 321 332

KalofL.TaylorC. The discourse of dog fighting Humanity and Society 2007 31 319 333

LineS.VoithV. L. Dominance aggression of dogs towards people: Behavior profile and response to treatment Applied Animal Behaviour Science 1986 16 1 77 83

LockwoodR. SerpellJ. The ethology and epidemiology of canine aggression The domestic dog: Its evolution, behavior, and interactions with people 1996 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press 131 138

LockwoodR. MillerL.ZawistowskiS. Animal fighting Shelter medicine for veterinarians and staff 2013 Ames, IA Blackwell Publishing Ltd. 441 452

MalloryC. Species trouble: The regulatory fictions of race, gender, and species 2013 International Association of Environmental Philosophy. [Conference Presentation]

MedlinJ. Pit bull bans and the human factors affecting canine behavior DePaul Law Review 2007 56 1285 1320

MirkóE.KubinyiE.GácsiM.MiklósiA. Preliminary analysis of an adjective-based dog personality questionnaire developed to measure some aspects of personality in the domestic dog Applied Animal Behaviour Science 2012 138 88 98

NewkirkI. Controlling an animal as deadly as a weapon 2005 Retrieved 9/2013 from

NietzscheF. NikolicD. On truth and lies in a nonmoral sense 2012 Chicago, IL Aristeus Books

NussbaumM. Animal rights: The need for a theoretical basis Harvard Law Review 2001 1506 (Review: Steven M. Wise, Rattling the cage: Toward legal rights for animals (2000)).

NussbaumM. NussbaumM.SunsteinC. Beyond ‘compassion and humanity’: Justice for non-human animals Animal rights: Current debates and new directions 2004 Oxford, United Kingdom Oxford University Press 299 320

NussbaumM. Frontiers of justice: Disability, nationality, species membership 2006 Cambridge, MA Belknap Press of Harvard University Press

OttS. A.SchalkeE.von GaertnerA. M.HackbarthH. Is there a difference? Comparison of golden retrievers and dogs affected by breed-specific legislation regarding aggressive behavior Journal of Veterinary Behavior 2008 3 134 140

RollinB. E. Animal ethics and breed-specific legislation Journal of Animal Law 2009 5 1 1 14

SchalkeE.OttS. A.von GaertnerA. M.HackbarthH.MittmannA. Is breed-specific legislation justified? Study of the results of the temperament test of Lower Saxony Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research 2008 3 3 97 103

SchlosbergD. Defining environmental justice: Theories, movements, and nature 2009 Oxford, United Kingdom Oxford University Press

ShieldsC. Aristotle Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy 2008 Retrieved 9/2013 from

SvartbergK. Breed-typical behaviour in dogs—Historical remnants or recent constructs? Applied Animal Behaviour Science 2006 96 293 313

SwannK. E. Irrationality unleashed: The pitfalls of breed-specific legislation University of Missouri Kansas City Law Review 2010 78 3 869 838

SykesG. M.MatzaD. Techniques of neutralization: A theory of delinquency American Sociological Review 1957 22 664 670

ThompsonP. B. Why using genetics to address welfare may not be a good idea Poultry Science 2010 89 4 814 821

TopálJ.CsányiV.DókaA. Attachment behavior in dogs (Canis familiaris): A new application of Ainsworth’s (1969) Strange Situation Test Journal of Comparative Psychology 1998 112 3 219 229

VeaseyJ. S.WaranN. K.YoungR. J. On comparing the behaviour of zoo housed animals with wild conspecifics as a welfare indicator Animal Welfare 1996 5 1 13 24

WalkerR. WalkerL.IvanhoeP. J. Animal flourishing: What virtue requires of human animals Working virtue: Virtue ethics and contemporary moral problems 2007 Oxford, United Kingdom Oxford University Press 173 189

WallenM. Foxhounds curs the dawn of breeding: The discourse of modern human-canine relations Cultural Critique 2011 79 125 151

WhiteT. In defense of dolphins: The new moral frontier 2007 Malden, MA Wiley-Blackwell

WilkinsJ. S. Species: A history of the idea (Species and systematics, Vol. 1) 2011 London, United Kingdom University of California Press

WolfeC. Animal rites: American culture, the discourse of species, and posthumanist theory 2003 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 38 38 31
Full Text Views 4 4 4
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0