Caregiver/Orangutan Relationships at Auckland Zoo

Empathy, Friendship, and Ethics between Species

in Society & Animals
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Drawing on ethnographic, ethological, and historical data, we examined the relationships between orangutans and caregivers at Auckland Zoo. Caregivers displayed high levels of empathy and adjusted their husbandry routines to their interpretations of the orangutans’ moods. Caregivers experienced conflicts arising from their efforts to empathize. Although they agreed their husbandry approach improved welfare, they worried their interpretations of orangutan behavior were inaccurate anthropomorphic projections. However, caregivers’ interpretations aligned well with ethological observations and with current knowledge of orangutan behavior. Caregivers’ shared view of great apes as moral persons led to personal conflicts about the ethics of sacrificing individual orangutans’ freedom for the greater good of the species. By exploring caregivers’ personal conflicts, we aimed to inform debates about the politics of empathizing with animals, the role of zoos, and the ethics of keeping great apes in captivity. We argue the use of empathy is essential for engaging in intersubjective relationships.

Society & Animals

Journal of Human-Animal Studies

Sections

References

AcamporaR. Zoos and eyes: Contesting captivity and seeking successor practices Society & Animals 2005 13 1 69 88

AlgerJ. M.AlgerS. F. Cat culture, human culture: An ethnographic study of a cat shelter Society & Animals 1999 7 3 199 218

AltmannJ. Observational study of behavior: Sampling methods Behaviour 1974 49 3-4 227 267

ArlukeA.SandersC. Regarding animals. 1996 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press

AsquithP. ElseJ. G.LeeP. C. Anthropomorphism and the Japanese and Western traditions in primatology Primate ontogeny, cognition, and social behaviour 1986 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press 61 72

AsquithP. Of bonds and boundaries: What is the modern role of anthropomorphism in primatological studies? American Journal of Primatology 2011 73 3 238 244

Auckland Council Archives Orangutan record cards. 1983-1992 Auckland, New Zealand Auckland Council Archives Record cards for primates, 1956-1992, akc 380

Auckland Zoological Park Keeping staff manual. no date Auckland, New Zealand Auckland Council Archives Auckland Council Archives, Zoo Publications, akc 355, 1c

BeardsworthA.BrymanA. The wild animal in late modernity Tourist Studies 2001 1 1 83 104

BekoffM.GruenL.TownsendS. E.RollinB. E. Animals in science: Some areas revisited Animal Behaviour 1992 44 3 473 484

BergerJ. Why look at animals? About looking 1980 London, United Kingdom Bloomsbury 3 28

BulbeckC. Facing the wild: ecotourism, conservation, and animal encounters. 2005 London, United Kingdom Earthscan

CandeaM. Different species, one theory: Reflections on anthrpomorphism and anthropological comparison Cambridge Anthropology 2012 30 2 118 135

CandeaM. Suspending belief: Epoché in animal behavior science American Anthropologist 2013 115 3 423 436

CavalieriP.SingerP. The Great Ape Project: Equality beyond humanity. 1994 New York, NY St. Martin’s Press

CorbeyR. The metaphysics of apes: Negotiating the animal-human boundary 2005 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

CreweB. The prisoner society: Power, adaptation, and social life in an English prison. 2012 Oxford, United Kingdom Oxford University Press

De WaalF. B. Anthropomorphism and anthropodenial: Consistency in our thinking about humans and other animals Philosophical Topics 2000 27 1 255 280

FoucaultM. Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison 1977 New York, NY Pantheon Books

FoucaultM. GordonC. Two lectures Power/knowledge: Selected interviews and other writings, 1972-1977 1980 Brighton, United Kingdom Harvester Press 78 108

HarawayD. Primate visions: Gender, race, and nature in the world of modern science. 1989 New York, NY Routledge

HarawayD. Encounters with companion species: Entangling dogs, baboons, philosophers, and biologists Configurations 2006 14 1 97 114

HarawayD. When species meet. 2008 Minneapolis, MN University of Minnesota Press

HertoghC. M.TheB. A.MiesenB. M.EefstingJ. A. Truth telling and truthfulness in the care for patients with advanced dementia: An ethnographic study in Dutch nursing homes Social Science and Medicine 2004 59 8 1685 1693

JenkinsD.PriceB. Dementia and personhood: A focus for care? Journal of Advanced Nursing 1996 24 1 84 90

KaplanG.RogersL. Orang-utans in Borneo. 1994 Armidale, Australia University of New England Press

KaplanG.RogersL. NadlerR. D. On human fear and indifference The neglected ape 1995 New York, NY Plenum Press 3 12

KolberA. Standing upright: The moral and legal standing of humans and other apes Stanford Law Review 2001 54 1 163 204

MaddenR. Being ethnographic: A guide to the theory and practice of ethnography. 2010 London, United Kingdom Sage

MalamudR. Reading zoos: Representations of animals and captivity 1998 New York, NY New York University Press

Marangos-FrostS.WellsD. Psychiatric nurses’ thoughts and feelings about restraint use: A decision dilemma Journal of Advanced Nursing 2000 31 2 362 369

MiltonK. KnightJ. Anthropomorphism or egomorphism? Animals in person: Cultural perspectives on human-animal intimacy 2005 Oxford, United Kingdom Berg 255 271

MitchellR. W.ThompsonN. S.MilesH. L. Anthropomorphism, anecdotes, and animals 1997 Albany, NY State University of New York Press

MossA.EssonM. The educational claims of zoos: Where do we go from here? Zoo Biology 2012 32 1 13 18

MullanB.MarvinG. Zoo culture. 1987 London, United Kingdom Weidenfeld and Nicolson

PatrickP. G.MatthewsC. E.AyersD. F.TunnicliffeS. D. Conservation and education: Prominent themes in zoo mission statements Journal of Environmental Education 2007 38 3 53 60

ReesA. Reflections on the field: Primatology, popular science, and the politics of personhood Social Studies of Science 2007 37 6 881 907

ReganT. The case for animal rights. 1983 Berkeley, CA University of California Press

RothfelsN. Savages and beasts: The birth of the modern zoo 2002 Baltimore, MD Johns Hopkins University Press

RussellC. L. The social construction of orangutans: An ecotourist experience Society & Animals 1995 3 2 151 170

SabloffA. Reordering the natural world: Humans and animals in the city 2001 Toronto, Canada University of Toronto Press

SiegelS. DastonL.MitmanG. Reflections on anthropomorphism in “The disenchanted forest” Thinking with animals: New perspectives on anthropomorphism 2005 New York, NY Columbia University Press 196 222

SmutsB. Between species: Science and subjectivity Configurations 2006 14 1 115 126

StrumS. C.FediganL. M. Primate encounters: Models of science, gender, and society. 2000 Chicago, IL University of Chicago Press

tv3 Inside New Zealand: Zoo. 1997 Auckland, New Zealand TV3 Video recording screened on tv3. Accessed in the University of Auckland audiovisual library.

Van NoordwijkM. A.SaurenS. E. B.NuzuarA. A.Morrogh-BernardH. C.Utami AtmokoS. S.Van SchaikC. P. WichS. A.Utami AtmokiS. S.Mitra SetiaT.van SchaikC. P. Development of independence Orangutans: Geographic variation in behavioral ecology and conservation 2009 Oxford, United Kingdom Oxford University Press 189 204

VitaleA. Primatology between feelings and science: A personal experience perspective American Journal of Primatology 2011 73 3 214 219

ZuckerE. L.ThibautS. GaldikasB. M. F.NadlerR. D.RosenN.SheeranL. Proximity, contact, and play interactions of zoo-living juvenile and adult orangutans, with focus on the adult male The neglected ape 1995 New York, NY Springer 239 250

ZuckerE. L.DennonM. B.PuleoS. G.MapleT. L. Play profiles of captive adult orangutans: A developmental perspective Developmental Psychobiology 1986 19 4 315 326

ZuckerE. L.MitchellG.MapleT. Adult male-offspring play interactions within a captive group of orang-utans (Pongo pygmaeus). Primates 1978 19 2 379 384

Figures

  • Mean percentagestwo standard errors) of five-minute proximity scans per one-hour sample in which dyads were within two meters.
    View in gallery

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 27 27 15
Full Text Views 5 5 5
PDF Downloads 1 1 1
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0