The Place of the Dog in the Family

A Comparative Case Study of Dog Adoption

in Society & Animals
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This paper explores how perspectives on the appropriate place of the dog in the family shape the practice and experience of dog adoption. This research is based on a comparative case study of a traditional shelter and an independent animal rescue organization. The data were collected through participant observation and interviews with directors and volunteers at these organizations, and with people who adopted dogs through shelter or independent animal rescue organizations. The independent rescue organizations tended to use “dog-centric” discourse to describe the relationship between the dog and its prospective family, while the traditional animal shelter and some adoptive families used “human-centric” discourse. These perspectives were tied to the adoption practices of the organizations and individuals’ experiences while adopting a dog. The implications of these findings for the practice of dog adoption are discussed, and suggestions for shelters and animal rescue organizations are presented.

The Place of the Dog in the Family

A Comparative Case Study of Dog Adoption

in Society & Animals



AdamelliS.MarinelliL.NormandoS.BonoG. Owner and cat features influence the quality of life of the cat Applied Animal Behaviour Science 2005 94 89 98

ArlukeA. Just a dog: Understanding animal cruelty and ourselves 2006 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press

ArlukeA.KilleenC. Inside animal hoarding: The case of Barbara Erickson and her 552 dogs 2009 West Lafayette, IN Purdue University Press

ArlukeA.SandersC. R. Regarding animals 1996 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press

AtkinsonP.HammersleyM. DenzinN. K.LincolnY. S. Ethnography and participant observation Handbook of qualitative research 1994 Thousand Oaks, CA Sage 248 261

Atwood-HarveyD. Death or declaw: Dealing with moral ambiguity in a veterinary hospital Society & Animals 2005 13 4 315 342

BalcomS.ArlukeA. Animal adoption as negotiated order: A comparison of open versus traditional shelter approaches Anthrozoös 2001 14 3 135 150

BeckA. M.KatcherA. H. Between pets and people 1983 New York, NY Putnam Press

BeckA. M.KatcherA. H. Future directions in human-animal bond research American Behavioral Scientist 2003 47 1 79 93

BelkR. Possessions and the extension of the self Journal of Consumer Research 1988 15 139 168

BilgerB. The last meow The New Yorker 2003 46 53 September 8 2003

CristE. Images of animals: Anthropomorphism and animal mind 1999 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press

Frank-CarlisleP.FrankJ. M. Owners, guardians, and owner-guardians: Differing relationships with pets Anthrozoös 2006 19 3 225 242

FrommerS. S.ArlukeA. Loving them to death: Blame-displacing strategies of animal shelter workers and surrenderers Society & Animals 1999 7 1 1 16

FudgeE. Can we differ from, and live on equal terms with, nonhuman animals? Society & Animals 2007 15 401 408

GreenebaumJ. It’s a dog’s life: Elevating status from pet to ‘fur baby’ at Yappy Hour Society & Animals 2004 12 2 117 135

GreenebaumJ. The throw away society and the family dog: An exploration of the consumption and dispossession of companion animals Journal of Social and Ecological Boundaries 2007 2 2 34 55

HickrodL.SchmittR. A naturalistic study of interaction and frame: The pet as “family” member Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 1982 11 1 55 77

IrvineL. Animal problems/people skills: Emotional and interactional strategies in humane education Society & Animals 2002 10 1 63 91

IrvineL. Cat-egorically family Network News 2003a Winter 15 19 The Sociologists for Women in Society Newsletter 9

IrvineL. The problem of unwanted pets: A case study in how institutions “think” about clients’ needs Social Problems 2003b 50 4 550 566

IrvineL. Pampered or enslaved? The moral dilemmas of pets International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 2004a 24 9 5 17

IrvineL. A model of animal selfhood: Expanding interactionist possibilities Symbolic Interaction 2004b 27 1 3 21

IrvineL. If you tame me: Understanding our connection with animals 2004c Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press

LincolnY. S.GubaE. G. Naturalistic inquiry 1985 Beverly Hills, CA Sage

NolenR. S. Shelter vets aim to raise level of care for millions of animals javma 2011 238 2 130 132

ParryD. C. Women’s experiences with infertility: The fluidity of conceptualizations of “family.” Qualitative Sociology 2005 28 3 275 291

PhillipsM. T. Proper names and the social construction of biography: The negative case of laboratory animals Qualitative Sociology 1994 17 119 142

PlanchonL. A.TemplerD. I.StokesS.KellerJ. Death of a companion cat or dog and human bereavement psychosocial variables Society & Animals 2002 10 1 93 105

RobertsF. Speaking to and for animals in a veterinary clinic: A practice for managing interpersonal interaction Research on Language and Social Interaction 2004 37 4 421 446

RubinH. J.RubinI. S. RubinH. J.RubinI. S. Listening, hearing, and sharing social experiences Qualitative interviewing: The art of hearing data 2005 Thousand Oaks, CA Sage 1 18

SandersC. R. Annoying owners: Routine interactions with problematic clients in a general veterinary practice Qualitative Sociology 1994 17 2 159 170

SandersC. R. Understanding dogs: Living and working with canine companions 1999 Philadelphia, PA Temple University Press

SandersC. R. Actions speak louder than words: Close relationships between humans and nonhuman animals Symbolic Interaction 2003 26 3 405 426

SerpellJ. A. In the company of animals: A study of human-animal relationships 1986 Oxford, United Kingdom Basil Blackwell

SerpellJ. A. Anthropomorphism and anthropomorphic selection—beyond the ‘cute response.’ Society & Animals 2003 11 1 83 100

SerpellJ.PaulE. ManningA.SerpellJ. Pets and the development of positive attitudes to animals Animals and human society: Changing perspectives 1994 London, United Kingdom, and New York, NY Routledge 127 144

ShoreE. R.DouglasD. K.RileyM. L. What’s in it for the companion animal? Pet attachment and college students’ behavior towards pets Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science 2005 8 1 11

TannenD. Talking the dog: Framing pets as interactional resources in family discourse Research on Language and Social Interaction 2004 37 4 399 420

TaylorN. Animal shelter emotion management: A case of in situ hegemonic resistance? Sociology 2010 44 85 101

VeeversJ. E. The social meaning of pets: Alternative roles for companion animals Marriage & Family Review 1985 8 3-4 11 30

WebbE. J.CampbellD. T.SchwartzR. D.SechrestL. Nonreactive measures in the social sciences 1981 Boston, MA Houghton Mifflin Company

WeissE.GramannS. A comparison of attachment levels of adopters of cats: Fee-based adoptions versus free adoptions Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science 2009 12 360 370

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 31 31 16
Full Text Views 13 13 13
PDF Downloads 6 6 6
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0