Nonhuman Animal Pain and Capital Punishment in Beckett’s “Dante and the Lobster”

In: Society & Animals

This article offers a fresh examination of the representation of nonhuman animals in Beckett’s early aesthetics, using “Dante and the Lobster” as a case study. Beckett’s story is illuminated by historical documents including newspaper articles, which will allow readers to see more clearly the deliberate parallels drawn between the question of the lobster’s suffering and the planned execution of a criminal that Belacqua contemplates throughout the day. An alternative reading model of the text, focusing on the Joycean concept of parallax rather than the Dantean concept of pity, will be developed. The article closes by examining Beckett’s views on allegorical readings of texts containing representations of nonhuman animals and his later notes on E. P. Evans’s 1906 work, The Criminal Prosecution and Capital Punishment of Animals.

  • AckerleyC. J. Obscure Locks Simple Keys: The Annotated Watt 2010 Edinburgh, United Kingdom Edinburgh University Press

  • Anon. A hangman’s remorse. John Ellis a changed man. “Would not again hang a woman” The Advertiser. 1924 May 17 Retrieved from http://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/3667105

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Anon. Capital punishment in Ireland: Strong opposition Guardian 1925 May 7 9

  • Anon. Commons and the lobster: Its painful death Guardian 1930 April 17 11

  • Anon. Irish mansion murders: Gardener found guilty Guardian 1926 November 15 10

  • BeckettS. Watt 2009 London, United Kingdom Faber Original published 1953

  • BeckettS. More Pricks than Kicks 2010 London, United Kingdom Faber Original published 1934

  • BrowneR. M.MercerJ. P.DuncanM. J. A historical overview of the Republic of Ireland’s lobster (Homarus gammarus Linnaeus) fishery Coastal Shellfish: A Sustainable Resource 2001 Dordrecht, The Netherlands Kluwer

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • BrydenM. Beckett and Animals 2013 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

  • CarrollL. Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking-Glass 2009 New York, NY and Oxford, United Kingdom Oxford University Press Original published 1865

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • CasselliD. Beckett’s Dantes 2005 Manchester, United Kingdom Manchester University Press

  • ConnorS. BrydenM. Making flies mean something Beckett and Animals 2013 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

  • CraigG.Dow FehsenfeldM.GunnD.More OverbeckL. The Letters of Samuel Beckett 1929-1940 2014 Vol. 3 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • DonovanJ. Animal rights and feminist theory Signs 1990 15 2 350 375

  • DoyleD. Republicans, martyrology, and the death penalty in Britain and Ireland, 1939-1990 Journal of British Studies 2015 54 3 703 722

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • DoyleD.O’DonnellI. The death penalty in post-independence Ireland The Journal of Legal History 2012 33 1 65 91

  • DoyleD.O’DonnellI. A family affair? English hangmen and a Dublin jail, 1923-1954 New Hibernia Review 2014 18 4 101 118

  • DwyerR. Matters of life and death Irish Examiner 2013 January 28 Retrieved from http://www.irishexaminer.com/analysis/matters-of-life-and-death-220848.html

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • EllisJ. Diary of a Hangman 1996 London, United Kingdom Forum Press

  • EvansE. P. The Criminal Prosecution and Capital Punishment of Animals 1906 London, United Kingdom Heinemann

  • GibsonA. Samuel Beckett 2010 London, United Kingdom Reaktion

  • HeuselB. Parallax as a metaphor for the structure of Ulysses Studies in the Novel 1983 15 2 135 146

  • KingR. J. Lobster 2011 London, United Kingdom Reaktion

  • KrollJ. L. The surd as inadmissible evidence: The case of the Attorney-General v. Henry McCabe Journal of Beckett Studies 1977 2 47 58

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • McKayR. What kind of literary animal studies do we want, or need? MFS Modern Fiction Studies 2014 60 3 636 644

  • McNaughtonJ. KennedyS. The politics of aftermath: Beckett, Modernism, and the free state Beckett and Ireland: New Perspectives 2010 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press 56 77

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • NibertD. Animal Rights/Human Rights: Entanglements of Oppression and Liberation 2002 Lanham, MD Rowman and Littlefield

  • PillingJ. Samuel Beckett’s ‘More Pricks Than Kicks’: In a Strait of Two Wills 2011 London, United Kingdom Continuum

  • RabatéJ.-M. Van HulleD. Love and lobsters The New Cambridge Companion to Samuel Beckett 2015 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press 158 169

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • RandoD. The cat’s meow: Ulysses, animals, and the veterinary gaze James Joyce Quarterly 2009 46 3 529 543

  • RathjenF. Horses versus cattle in Ulysses Joyce Studies Annual 2001 12 172 175

  • SealL. Capital Punishment in Twentieth-Century Britain: Audience Justice Memory. 2014 Abingdon, VA, and New York, NY Routledge

  • SloteS. Garryowen and the bloody mangy mongrel of Irish Modernity James Joyce Quarterly 2009 46 3-4 545 557

  • SloteS. Stuck in translation: Beckett and Borges on Dante Journal of Beckett Studies 2010 19 15 28

  • StevensonK. G. McarthyP. A. Belacqua in the moon: Beckett’s revisions of “Dante and the Lobster” Critical Essays on Samuel Beckett 1986 Boston, MA G. K. Hall & Co.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Van HulleD.NixonM. Samuel Beckett’s Library. 2013 Cambridge, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press

  • WallaceD. F. Consider the Lobster and Other Essays. 2006 New York, NY Little, Brown and Company

  • WashizukaN. Pity and objects: Samuel Beckett’s “Dante and the Lobster” Journal of Irish Studies 2009 24 75 83

  • WeisR. Criminal Justice: The True Story of Edith Thompson 1990 London, United Kingdom Penguin

  • 1

    See for example Daniela Casselli (2005): pp. 59-62; Naho Washizuka (2009): pp. 75-83; Sam Slote (2010): pp. 15-28.

  • 2

    Pilling (2011) cites work by Phyllis Carey Adrian Hunter and Barbara Reich Gluck to show that “there have been persistent attempts to bring More Pricks as close to Dubliners as it will go and arguably closer than can comfortably be achieved” (p. 234).

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 203 138 8
Full Text Views 216 202 1
PDF Downloads 30 27 2