Competing Frames of the Gülen Movement

The Case of Malaysia

in Sociology of Islam
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


This paper identifies and describes the three main competing frames of the Gulen movement, namely the moderate, tolerant and modern frame; the secretive Islamist agenda frame; and the security risk frame, which the Gülen movement’s followers, detractors and the Turkish government promoted over the span of the movement’s growth, expansion and decline. We use the identified frames as conceptual tools to analyze the development and decline of the movement in Malaysia. In our analysis, we determine the cultural and political factors that made it easier for the Gülen movement to promote its moderate, tolerant and modern frame in Malaysia; how Gülen followers and Malaysians navigated the secretive Islamist agenda frame in ways that enabled the Gülen movement to operate in Malaysia; and the Malaysian response to the security risk frame that was promoted by the Turkish government, which eventually curtailed the movement’s activities in Malaysia.

Competing Frames of the Gülen Movement

The Case of Malaysia

in Sociology of Islam



  • Abu Bakar Mohamad (1981). Islamic revivalism and the political process in Malaysia. Asian Survey21(10): 10401059.

  • Alianak Sonia L. (2013). Islamic mediators and creators of grassroots demands: The ghm compared to the mb Egypt and mb Jordan. In Balci Tamer and Miller Christopher L. (eds.) The Gülen Hizmet Movement: Circumspect Activism in Faith-Based Reform pp. 91117. Newcastle Upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

  • Aljazeera (2016). Turkey court issues arrest warrant for Fethullah Gülen. August 5. Retrieved June 19 2017 (ülen-160804134641736.html).

  • Anadolu Agency (2016). Malaysia hands over ‘3 feto members’ to Turkey. October 14. Retrieved July 10 2017 (

  • Aydintasbas Asli (2016). The Good The Bad and the Gülenists: The Role of the Gülen Movement in Turkey’s Coup Attempt. London: European Council of Foreign Relations.

  • Balcı Bayram (2003). Fethullah Gülen’s missionary schools in Central Asia and their role in the spreading of Turkism and Islam. Religion State and Society31(2):151177.

  • Balci Bayram (2014). The Gulen movement and Turkish soft power. Carnegie Endownment for International Peace4 February. Retrieved July 31 2017. (

  • Barton Greg (2013). Preaching by example and learning for life: Understanding the Gulen movement in the global context of religious philanthropy and civil religion. In Barton Greg Weller Paul and Yilmaz Ihsan (eds.) The Muslim World and Politics in Transition: Creative Contributions of the Gulen Movement pp. 1533. uk: Bloomsbury Academic.

  • Barton Greg (2014). How Hizmet works: Islam, dialogue and the Gülen movement in Australia. Hizmet Studies Review1(1): 925.

  • Başkan-Canyaş Filiz and Canyaş F. Orkunt (2016). The interplay between formal and informal institutions in Turkey: The case of the Fethullah Gülen community. Middle Eastern Studies52(2): 280294.

  • Basturk Levant (2013). The clash of allies: The ak party vs Gülen movement. World Bulletin . December 31. Retrieved June 30 2017 (

  • bbc (2008). Anwar quits Turkey embassy refuge. June 30. Retrieved July 6 2017 (

  • Benford Robert D. (1987). Framing Activity Meaning and Social Movement Participation: The Nuclear Disarmament Movement. PhD thesis. University of Texas Austin.

  • Benford Robert D. and Snow David A. (2000). Framing processes and social movements: An overview and assessment. Annual Review of Sociology26: 611639.

  • Bilici Mucahit (2008). Said Nursi’s moral philosophy. Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations19(1): 8998.

  • Bilir Ünal (2004). ‘Turkey-Islam’: Recipe for success or hindrance to the integration of the Turkish diaspora community in Germany? Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs24(2): 259283.

  • Cantürk Safure (2015). Turkey’s allies mobilizing support against Gülen movement’s schools abroad. Daily Sabah . May 19. Retrieved July 3 2017 (ülen-movements-schools-abroad).

  • Cetin Muhammed (2011). The Gulen Movement: Civic Service Without Borders. New York: Blue Dome Press.

  • Dalay Galip (2014). Turkey’s parallel state strikes back. Al Jazeera . January 6. Retrieved June 30 2017 (

  • Demir Cennet E. Balcı Ayse and Akkok Fusun (2000). The role of Turkish schools in the educational system and social transformation of Central Asian countries: The case of Turkmenistan and Kyrgyzstan. Central Asian Survey19(1): 141155.

  • Department of Statistics Malaysia (2010). Population Distribution and Basic Demographic Characteristic Report 2010. Population and Housing Census.

  • Disney Nina Adlan (2013). Schools of thought: Developments in the Malaysian school sector. iem Spotlight NewsletterVol. 19 Issue 2. Retrieved 4 July 2017 (

  • Ebaugh Helen Rose (2009). The Gulen Movement: A Sociological Analysis of a Civic Movement Rooted in Moderate Islam. Springer Press.

  • El-Kazaz Sarah (2015). The akp and the Gülen: The end of a historic alliance. Middle East BriefNo. 94 Brandeis University. Retrieved July 3 2017 (

  • Ergene Mehmet Enes (2011). Tradition Witnessing the Modern Age: An Analysis of the Gülen Movement. New Jersey: Tughra Books.

  • Esen Berk and Gumuscu Sebnem (2017). Turkey: How the coup failed. Journal of Democracy28(1): 5973.

  • Farooq Umar (2016). Inside the secretive religious movement that is being blamed for Turkey’s attempted coup. Los Angeles Times. August 17. Retrieved June 27 2017 (ülen-snap-story.html).

  • Filkins Dexter (2016). Turkey’s thirty-year coup. The New Yorker. October 17. Retrieved June 30 2017 (

  • Fuller Graham E. (2008). The New Turkish Republic: Turkey as a Pivotal State in the Muslim World. Washington dc: United States Institute of Peace Press.

  • Giersdorf Stephan and Croissant Aurel (2011). Civil society and competitive authoritarianism in Malaysia. Journal of Civil Society7(1): 121.

  • Gurbuz Mustafa E. and Bernstein Mary (2012). ‘Thou shall not protest!’: Multi-institutional politics, strategic nonconfrontation and Islamic mobilizations in Turkey. In Nepstad Sharon Erickson and Kurtz Lester R. (eds.) Nonviolent Conflict and Civil Resistance (Research in Social Movements Conflicts and Change Volume 34) pp. 6391. Emerald Group Publishing Limited.

  • Hendrik Joshua D. (2011). Neo-liberalism and ‘Third way’ Islamic activism: Fethullah Gülen and Turkey’s new elite. In Keskin Tugrul (ed.) The Sociology of Islam: Secularism Economy and Politics pp. 6189. uk: Ithaca Press.

  • Hendrik Joshua D. (2013). The Ambiguous Politics of Market Islam in Turkey and the World. New York: nyu Press.

  • Holmes Oliver (2017). Turkish headmaster accused of Isis links met Malaysian pm, pictures reveal. The Guardian. May 5. Retrieved July 10 2017 (

  • Ibrahim Rozita (2007). Multiculturalism and Education in Malaysia. Culture and Religion8(2): 155167.

  • Interview 1 (2009). Irfan TibetJune 20.

  • Interview 2 (2013). Turgay Karaman principal of the second Gülen school in MalaysiaNovember 18.

  • Interview 3 (2013). Malaysian Gülen school administrators school teachers and studentsNovember 20.

  • Interview 4 (2013). Interviews with Malaysian-Turkish Dialogue Society membersNovember 20.

  • Interview 5 (2014). Interview with Kamaruddin NoordinApril 6.

  • Interview 6 (2014). Interview with Fadli Ghani a pas Youth Committee memberJuly 9.

  • Interview 7 (2015). Hadi Awang pas PresidentApril 28.

  • Interview 8 (2015). Dr. Dzulkefly Ahmad a former pas leaderJune 20.

  • Interview 9 (2017). Unnamed source for confidentiality reasonJune 7.

  • Jones Gareth and Gurses Ercan (2016). Turkey’s Erdogan shuts schools, charities in first state of emergency decree. Reuters. July 23. Retrieved June 30 2017 (

  • Khalid Adeeb (2003). A secular Islam: Nation, state, and religion in Uzbekistan. International Journal of Middle East Studies35(4): 573598.

  • Kurzman Charles (2008). Mean-making in social movements. Anthropological Quarterly81(1): 515.

  • Lacey Jonathan (2014). Turkish Islam as good Islam: How the Gülen movement exploits discursive opportunities in a post-9/11 milieu. Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs34(2): 95110.

  • Latiff Rozanna (2017). Malaysia deports three Turks amid u.n. fears of widening Turkish crackdown. Reuters. May 12. Retrieved July 10 2017 (

  • Liow Joseph (2004). Political Islam in Malaysia: Problematising discourse and practice in the umno-pas ‘Islamisation Race.’ Commonwealth & Comparative Politics Vol. 42(2): 184204.

  • McAdam Doug (1996). The framing function of movement tactics: Strategic dramaturgy in the American civil rights movement. In McAdam Doug McCarthy John D. Zald Mayer N. (eds.) Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements Opportunities Mobilizing Structures and Framing pp. 338355. Cambridge uk: Cambridge University Press.

  • Ministry of Education Putrajaya (2013). Preliminary Report for Malaysia Educational Blueprint: 2013–2025.

  • Mohamad Maznah . 2010. The ascendance of bureaucratic Islam and the secularization of the Sharia in Malaysia. Pacific Affairs 83(3): 505524.

  • Osman Mohamed Nawab Mohamed (2010). Towards a middle way: Islam in Southeast Asia and the contributions of the Gulen movement. In Esposito John L. and Yilmaz Ihsan (eds.) Islam and Peacebuilding: Gulen Movement Initiatives pp. 269288. New York: Tughra Books.

  • Osman Mohamed Nawab Mohamed (2013). The Gülen movement as a civil-Islamic force in Indonesia. In Barton Greg Weller Paul and Yilmaz Ihsan (eds.) The Muslim World and Politics in Transition: Creative Contributions of the Gülen Movement pp. 16879. uk: Bloomsbury Academic.

  • Mohamed Osman Mohamed Nawab (2017). The Islamic conservative turn in Malaysia: Impact and future trajectories. Contemporary Islam11(1): 120.

  • Mortimer Caroline (2016). Turkish court issues arrest warrant for us-based cleric Fethullah Gülen. Independent. August 4. Retrieved June 30 2017 (ülen-arrest-warrant-erdogan-a7172211.html).

  • Musa Mohd Faizal and Hui Tan Beng (2017). State-backed discrimination against Shia Muslims in Malaysia. Critical Asian Studies49(3): 308329.

  • Noakes John A. and Johnston Hank (2005). Frames of protest: A road map to a perspective. In Noakes John A. and Johnston Hank (eds.) Frames of Protest: Social Movements and the Framing Perspective edited by pp. 129. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

  • Othman Mohammad Redzuan (2002). Persepsi terhadap orang Turki dalam minda Melayu selepas perang dunia i . In Hassan Abdullah (ed.) Prosiding Persidangan Antarabangsa Pengajian Melayu Beijing Ke-2: Volume 1 pp. 604606. Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.

  • Özbudun Ergun (2014). akp at the crossroads: Erdoğan’s majoritarian drift. South European Society and Politics19(2): 155167.

  • Saleem Saleena (2018). State use of public order and social cohesion concerns in the securitisation of non-mainstream Muslims in Malaysia. Journal of Religious and Political Practice. doi: 10.1080/20566093.2018.1525899 [forthcoming]

  • Saritoprak Zeti and Unal Ali (2005). An Interview with Fethullah Gülen. The Muslim World Special Issue95(3): 447467.

  • Sharon-Krespin Rachel (2009). Fethullah Gülen’s grand ambition: Turkey’s Islamist danger. The Middle East Quarterly16(1): 5566.

  • Skinner Anthony (2016). Turkish business suffers under Erdogan’s post-coup Gülen purge. cnbc7 November. Retrieved June 15 2017 (ülen-purge.html).

  • Snow David A. (2012). Framing and Social Movements. The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia of Social and Political Movements.

  • Snow David A. and Benford Robert D. (1988). Ideology, frame resonance, and participant mobilization. In Bert Klandermans Hanspeter Kriesi and Sidney Tarrow (eds.) International Social Movement Research: From Structure to Action pp. 197218. Greenwich ct: jai Press.

  • Tarrow Sidney (1998). Power in Movement: Social Movements and Contentious Politics. 2nd ed. New York: Cambridge University Press.

  • Tee Caroline (2016). The Gülen Movement in Turkey: The Politics of Islam and Modernity. New York: I.B. Taurus & Co. Ltd.

  • The Star (2017). dpm: We believe Turkish duo have links to is. May 5. Retrieved July 10 2017 (

  • Tittensor David (2012). The Gülen movement and the case of a secret agenda: Putting the debate in perspective. Islam and Christian – Muslim relations23(2): 163179.

  • Tittensor David (2014). The House of Service: The Gulen Movement and Islam’s Third Way. New York: Oxford University Press.

  • Toprak Binnaz (2009). Being Different in Turkey: Religion Conservatism and Otherization: Research Report on Neighbourhood Pressure. Boğaziçi University, Open Society Foundation (Turkey).

  • Turam Berna (2006). Between Islam and the State: The Politics of Engagement. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

  • Unal Ali and Williams Alphonse (2000). Advocate of Dialogue: Fethullah Gulen. Fairfax, Virginia: The Fountain.

  • Uras Umut (2013). Turkish probe marks akp-Gülen power struggle. Al Jazeera. 24 December. Retrieved June 27 2017 (ülen-power-struggle-2013122473646994231.html).

  • Whittier Nancy (2002). Meaning and structure in social movements. In Meyer David S. Whittier Nancy and Robnett Belinda (eds.) Social Movements: Identity Culture and the State pp. 289308. New York: Oxford University Press.

  • Worldbank (2013). Malaysia Trade Summary 2013. Retrieved June 19 2017 (

  • Yavuz M. Hakan (2013). Toward an Islamic Enlightenment: The Gulen Movement. New York: Oxford University Press.

  • Yavuz M. Hakan and Koç Rasim (2016). The Turkish coup attempt: The Gülen movement vs. the state. Middle East Policy Vol. xxiii (4): 136148.

  • Yildirim A. Kadir (2013). New Democrats: Religious actors, social change and democratic consolidation in Turkey. Contemporary Islam7: 311331.

  • Yilmaz Ihsan (2013). Beyond Islamism: The transformation of Turkish Islamism to non-Islamism. In Barton Greg Weller Paul and Yilmaz Ihsan (eds.) The Muslim World and Politics in Transition: Creative Contributions of the Gulen Movement pp. 6781. uk: Bloomsbury Academic.

  • Yükleyen Ahmet and Tunagür (2013). The Gülen movement in Western Europe and the usa . In Kortmann Matthias and Rosenow-Williams Kerstin (eds.) Islamic Organizations in Europe and the usa: A Multidisciplinary Perspective pp. 224241. uk: Palgrave Macmillan.

  • Zeynalov Mahir (2017). Two Turks kidnapped in Malaysia, families fear of extradition. The Globe Post. May 2. Retrieved July 10 2017 (

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 206 206 60
Full Text Views 14 14 5
PDF Downloads 14 14 8
EPUB Downloads 1 1 0