Pragmatists and Believers: Dynamics of Ideology and Compromise within the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, 1941-1942

in The Soviet and Post-Soviet Review
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

The significance of World War II within the Russian historiography is unequivocal– but the impact of that great cataclysm on the Soviet state and Soviet society is frequently understated or overstated. The early 1940s brought massive losses to the upper echelons of the Communist Party, resulting in a rapid mobilization of the state, but these upheavals took place in a society that was already hamstrung by both the traditional scarcity of qualified professionals and the strain that Marxist-Leninist purism placed on an already strained education system. Long before the October Revolution, Russia was plagued with the enduring problem of scarcity of the qualified managerial cadres; after the Revolution, this problem was exacerbated by factional disputes between ideologues, who were primarily concerned with the ideological purity of the Soviet state, and pragmatists, who favoring a greater focus on vocational education. Caught between these two factions was the proto-middle class from which the professional stratum of Russian society was to be recruited.

During the opening years of World War II, the demand for educated professionals rose, forcing compromises in their ideological purity. In the long term, the result was a gradual, piecemeal shift toward pragmatic compromise. In the short term, however, faced with a dilemma between under-staffed and under-indoctrinated, caught in a decision-making paradigm locked in by Marxism-Leninism, the Soviet matrix opted for personalized networks and regional cliques over the professional apparatus in its quest for short-term efficiency.

Drawing on archival materials such as memoir literature, epistolary documentation and state reports from Moscow and provincial (particularly those of the Tver’ Oblast’) collections, this article examines the tensions that underpinned the conditions of the proto-middle class from throughout the 1940s, tracing the ideological constraints that structured the political landscape, the repeating cycles of essentially identical attempts at reform, and the ways in which the strain of the ideological/pragmatic conflict on Russian professionals was, and was not, resolved in the wake of World War II.

Pragmatists and Believers: Dynamics of Ideology and Compromise within the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, 1941-1942

in The Soviet and Post-Soviet Review

References

2)

John Barber and Mark HarrisonThe Soviet Home Front 1941–1945: A Social and Economic History of the USSR in World War II (New York: Longman1991) 50.

3)

Rodric BraithwaiteMoscow 1941: A City and Its People at War (New York: Alfred A. Knopf2006) 115.

4)

Walter S. Dunn Jr.Hitler’s Nemesis: The Red Army 1930-1945 (London: Praeger1994) 49 215.

6)

ArmstrongThe Politics of Totalitarianism131.

7)

Stephen KotkinMagnetic Mountain: Stalinism as a Civilization (Berkeley: University of California Press1995) 297.

8)

T. H. RigbyCommunist Party Membership in the USSR: 1917–1967 (Princeton: Princeton University Press1968) 241.

9)

I. P. PetrovPartiinoe stroitel’stvo v sovetskoi armii i flote (Moscow: Voennoe Izdatelstvo Ministerstva Oborony SSSR1964) 349.

10)

Dale R. HerspringSoldiers Commissars and Chaplains: Civil-Military Relations since Cromwell (New York: Rowman and Littlefield2001) 167.

13)

PetrovPartiinoe stroitel’stvo354–55.

14)

HerspringSoldiers Commissars and Chaplains171–72.

15)

HerspringSoldiers Commissars and Chaplains169.

19)

T. H. RigbyCommunist Party Membership in the USSR251.

21)

N. A. KirsanovPartiinye mobilizatsii na front v gody Velikoi Otechestvennoi voiny (Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskgo Universiteta1970) 58–59.

23)

Sheila Fitzpatrick ed.Stalinism: New Directions (London: Routledge2000) 180–82 350 361; Sheila Fitzpatrick Everyday Stalinism: Ordinary Life in Extraordinary Times Soviet Russian in the 1930s (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1999) 226.

29)

John Barber and Mark HarrisonThe Soviet Home Front 1941–1945: A Social and Economic History of the USSR in World War II (New York: Longman1991) 46–49.

30)

Robert G. WessonLenin’s Legacy: The Story of the CPSU (Stanford: Hoover Institution Press1978) 170–71.

32)

Viktor CherpanovVlast’ i voina: Stalinskii mekhanizm gosudarstvennogo upravleniia v Velikoi Otechestvennoi voine (Moscow: Izdatelstvo Izvestiia2006) 233.

33)

Chris BellamyAbsolute War: Soviet Russia in the Second World War (New York: Alfred A Knopf2007) 229.

34)

V. S. PapinOrganizatsionno-partiinaia rabota v gody Otechestvennoi voiny (Moscow: Znanie1990) 10.

37)

BorisovZapiski sekretaria gorkoma160.

38)

B. BorisovZapiski sekretaria gorkoma (Moscow: Politizdat1964) 33–34.

39)

M. I. LikhomanovKhozaistvenno-organizatorskaia rabota partii v derevne v pervyi period Velikoi Otechestvennoi voiny (1941–1942) (Leningrad: Izdatelstvo Leningradskogo Universiteta1975) 29.

40)

Alec Nove“Soviet Peasantry in World War II,” in The Impact of World War II on the Soviet Union (Totowa: Rowman and Allanheld1985) 78.

41)

I. I. VinogradovPolitotdely MTS i sovkhozov v gody velikoi Otechestvennoi voiny (1941–1943) (Leningrad: Izdatelstvo Leningradskogo Universiteta1976) 12.

43)

Robert F. Miller“The Politotdel: A Lesson from the Past,” Slavic Review 25 no. 3 (Sept 1966): 475.

46)

Takeshi Tomita“Stalin, Politburo, and Its Commissions in the Soviet Decision-making Process in the 1930s,” in Empire and Society: New Approaches to Russian Historyed. T. Hara K. Matsuzato Proceedings of the July 1994 International Symposium at the SRC (Sapporo: SRC, Hokkaido University1997) 158.

47)

VinogradovPolitotdely MTS17.

48)

Robert F. MillerOne Hundred Thousand Tractors: The MTS and the Development of Controls in Soviet Agriculture (Cambridge: Harvard University Press1970) 267.

49)

Tomita“Stalin Politburo” 158.

50)

Robert F. Miller“The Politotdel” 477–78.

51)

VinogradovPolitotdely MTS16.

53)

Robert F. MillerOne Hundred Thousand Tractors267.

54)

VinogradovPolitotdely MTS18; Robert F. Miller One Hundred Thousand Tractors 268.

55)

VinogradovPolitotdely MTS19.

56)

V. S. MurmantsevaSovetskie zhenshchiny v Velikoi Otechstvennoi voine (Moscow: Izdatelstvo Mysl’1974) 37.

57)

VinogradovPolitotdely MTS25 39.

58)

MillerOne Hundred Thousand Tractors271; Papin Organizatsionno-partiinaia 11.

63)

Sanford R. Lieberman“Crisis Management in the USSR: the Wartime System of Administration and Control” in The Impact of World War II on the Soviet Union Susan J. Linz ed (Totowa: Rowman and Allanheld1985) 69–70.

64)

Barber and HarrisonThe Soviet Home Front 1941–194549.

65)

Richard J. BrodyIdeology and Political Mobilization: The Soviet Home Front During World War II (Pittsburgh: The Carl Beck Papers1994) 12–13.

68)

BrodyIdeology and Political Mobilization14.

71)

Robert F. MillerOne Hundred Thousand Tractors267.

75)

Cynthia Kaplan“The Impact of World War II on the Party,” in The Impact of World War II on the Soviet Unioned. Susan J. Linz (Totowa: Rowman and Allanheld1985) 173.

76)

ArmstrongThe Politics of Totalitarianism139.

78)

Kees BoterbloemLife and Death under Stalin: Kalinin Province 1945–1953 ( London: McGill-Queen’s University Press1999) 51.

81)

BraithwaiteMoscow 1941214.

83)

Morekhina“Voenno-ekonomicheskaia politika” 208.

86)

BrodyIdeology and Political Mobilization13.

87)

BraithwaiteMoscow 1941214.

89)

RigbyPolitical Elites in the USSR118.

90)

“Spravka” RGANI (1942) f.77 op.1 d.3 l.90.

92)

Jonathan HarrisThe Split in Stalin’s Secretariat 1939–1948 (Toronto: Lexington2008) 61–63.

93)

M. G. SobolevOrganizatsionnoe ukreplenie armeiskikh and frontovykh partiynykh organizatsii v gody Velikoi Otechestvennoi Voiny (Moscow: Znanie1975) 24-26.

95)

A. V. Mitrofanova ed.Sovetskii tyl v period korennogo pereloma v Velikoi Otechestvennoi voine 1942-1943 (Moscow: Nauka1989) 237.

96)

I. P. PetrovPartiinoe stroitel’stvo v sovetskoi armii i flote (Moscow: Voennoe Izdatelstvo Ministerstva Oborony SSSR1964) 393.

97)

Petro G. GrigorenkoMemoirs (London: W. W. Norton1982) 200.

98)

Elena ZubkovaRussia After the War: Hopes Illusions and Disappointments 1945–1957 (London: M.E. Sharpe1998) 175-177.

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 22 22 6
Full Text Views 4 4 4
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0