Under the Weight of the Soviet Legacy and Political Repressions: The Radical Left in Late Soviet and Post-Soviet Russia
In: The Soviet and Post-Soviet ReviewAbstract
Mass protest movements of the early 2010s, particularly the Occupy movement, stimulated the rise of radical left organizations globally. In Southern Europe, radical left parties celebrated their first electoral successes. In Russia, radical left organizations were also influenced by this upsurge of social protest movements and participated in the Bolotnaya protests in 2011–2012 but were marginalized and disintegrated shortly after, resuming their activities only by 2019. This article explores the radical left movements and groups in Russia and offers projections for their future. The Russian radical left is divided into three sub-groups: fundamentalist communists who identify with Stalin and the Soviet Union, libertarian socialists and communists (subdivided into neo-anarchists, autonomists, and neo-Trotskyists), and hybrid organizations (e.g., the Left Front). These organizations face two major constraints unknown to their Western counterparts. First, Russia’s authoritarian regime blocks opportunities for independent, particularly electoral, politics. This reveals itself in targeted repressions against left radicals and anarchists. Second, the dominance of the CPRF blocks any potential of strong left opposition. Unless these restrictions are lifted, radical left organizations in Russia will not be able to overcome their current crisis.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Agustin, Oscar Garcia; Briziarelli, Marco (eds). 2018. Podemos and the New Political Cycle. Left-Wing Populism and Anti-Establishment Politics. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
-
Alekseeva, Lyudmila. 1992. Istoriya inakomysliya v SSSR. Novejshij period. Vil’nyus—Moskva: Vest’.
-
Al’terglobalizm i antiglobalistskie dvizheniya v sovremennom mire: sb. obzorov i ref. 2006. Moskva: RAN INION.
-
Ancelovici, Marcos; Dufour, Pascale; Dufour, PascaleNez Helois (eds). 2016. Street Politics in the Age of Austerity. From the Indignados to Occupy. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
-
Antonov, Cyril. 2020. “« Kommunisty Rossii » obidelis’ na “spojlerov”. Partiya hochet vzyskat’ s KPRF 1 mln rublej za klevetu,” Kommersant (Kazan), 22 avgusta. https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4067654.
-
Apellyacionnoe opredelenie ot 16 iyulya 2020 g. po delu № AKPI20-3. 2020. sudact.ru, https://sudact.ru/vsrf/doc/JjIjL6hUBimH/.
-
Buchenkov, Dmitrij. 2009. Anarhisty v Rossii v kontse XX v. Moskva: Librokom.
-
Buchenkov, Dmitrij. [2019] “Vtoraya volna grazhdanskih protestov v Rossii i nesistemnye levye,” Avtonom.org. https://avtonom.org/freenews/vtoraya-volna-grazhdanskih-protestov-v-rossii-i-nesistemnye-levye.
-
Budrajtskis, Il’ya. 2017. Dissidenty sredi dissidentov. Moskva: Svobodnoe marksistkoe izdatel’stvo.
-
Buzgalin, Aleksandr. 2003. “Al’terglobalizm kak fenomen sovremennogo mira,” Polis, no. 2: 71–85.
-
Buzgalin, Aleksandr. 2003. Al’terglobalizm: teoriya i praktika “antiglobalistskogo dvizheniya.” Moskva: URSS.
-
Buzgalin, Aleksandr; Kolganov, Andrej. 2005. Postsovetskij marksizm v Rossii: otvety na vyzovy XXI veka (tezisy k formirovaniyu nauchnoj shkoly). Moskva: Lenand.
-
Chernyahovskij, Sergej. 2007. Kommunisticheskaya oppoziciya v sovremennoj Rossii: genezis, protivorechivost’, perspektivy. Dr. Sc. (polit) Diss. Moskva.
-
Crouch, Colin. 2003. Postdemocracy. Roma-Bari: Laterza.
-
Dam’e, Vadim. 2010. Istoriya anarho-sindikalizma. Kratkij ocherk. Moskva: Librokom.
-
Ermakov, Vladimir. 1997. Anarhistskoe dvizhenie v Rossii: istoriya i sovremennost’. Saint Petersburg: SPbGAK.
-
Gel’man, Vladimir. 2015. “Political Opposition in Russia: A Troubled Transformation” Europe-Asia Studies, 67:2:177–191.
-
Globalizaciya soprotivleniya: bor’ba v mire. 2004. Pod red. S. Amir i F. Utar. Pod red. s predisl. A. Buzgalina. Moskva: URSS.
-
Holmskaya, Marina. 1998. Kommunisty Rossii: fakty, idei, tendencii. Moskva.
-
Holmskaya, Marina. 2000. Sovremennoe kommunisticheskoe dvizhenie v Rossii: ideologiya i praktika. Cand. Hist. Diss. Moskva.
-
Informacionnoe soobshchenie o chrezvychajnom plenume C VKPB 15 avgusta 2020 g. 2020. Serp i Molot Bol’shevika, 9, http://www.vkpb-skb.ru/images/11052019/09-2020-site.pdf.
-
Ivanov, Maxim. 2016. “CPSS ne puskayut v byulleten’. U CPRF budet na odnogo spojlera men’she”, Kommersant, 16 maya. https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2988198.
-
Kagarlickij, Boris. 2007. Politologiya revolyucii. Moskva: Algoritm.
-
Katsambekis, Giorgos; Kioupkiolis, Alexandros (eds). 2019. The Populist Radical Left in Europe. L.; N.Y.: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group.
-
Kozlova D. 2020. “Anarhiya—mat’ posadok”. Novayagazeta.ru. https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2020/03/11/84250-anarhiya-mat-posadok.
-
Kramola. Inakomyslie v SSSR pri Khrushcheve i Brezhneve. 1953–1982 gg. Rassekrechennye dokumenty Verhovnogo suda i Prokuratury SSSR. 2005. Pod red. V.A. Kozlova i S.V. Mironenko. Moskva: Materik.
-
Krit, Gera, Raskol’nikov Daniil. 2019. “Dopuskaj i otpuskaj! Moskvu ohvatyvayut protesty”. Socialist. News, 5: 3–6.
-
Kuz’min, Vasilij. 2018. Komsomol imeni Letova. Hroniki soprotivleniya pod flagom AKM. Moskva: Common place.
-
Levye u vlasti. Programma-minimum Levogo fronta. 2013. Anatomiya protesta. Oppoziciya v licah, interv’yu, programmah. Moskva: Algoritm.
-
London, Eric, Van Auken, Bill. 2018. “Workers Party in Argentina seeks to “refound” Fourth International in alliance with Stalinism” wsws.org, https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2018/06/07/crfi-j07.html.
-
Magun, Artemij. 2013. “Protestnoe dvizhenie 2011–2012 godov v Rossii: identichnost’ rossijskogo protesta.” Politika apolitichnyh: grazhdanskie dvizheniya v Rossii 2011–2013 godov. Moskva: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie: 311–349.
-
March, Luke. 2012. Radical left parties in contemporary Europe (Basingstoke: Routledge).
-
March, Luke. 2007. “Rossijskie levoradikaly v postkommunisticheskuyu epohu.” Russkij nacionalizm v politicheskom prostranstve (issledovaniya po nacionalizmu v Rossii). Sost. M. Laryuel’. Moskva: 100–120.
-
March, Luke. 2002. The Communist Party in Post-Soviet Russia. Manchester: Manchester Univ. Pr.
-
Luke March. 2013. “The Russian left has barely emerged from the shadow of Stalin, but there are significant signs of change”. blogs.lse.ac.uk, http://bit.ly/105eNKN.
-
Markelov, Stanislav. 2012. Krasnaya kniga antifa. https://avtonom.org/news/krasnaya-kniga-antifa-statya-stanislava-markelova.
-
Manifest Avtonomnogo Dejstviya [2012] http://autonom.org/ad/manifesto.html.
-
Merzlikin, Pavel. 2019. “Razgrom russkih anarhistov. V Rossii vedetsya nastuplenie na levyh aktivistov. Dela zavodyat i na sluchajnyh lyudej.” Meduza.io. https://meduza.io/feature/2019/04/18/razgrom-russkih-anarhistov, accessed 09.09.2020.
-
Mills, Charles W. 1960. “Letter to the New Left,” New Left Review, no. 5: 18–23.
-
Mitin, Aleksandr. 2014. Molodezhnaya politika i levye molodezhnye organizacii sovremennoj Rossii. Cand. Polit. Diss., Chita.
-
Mitrokhin, Nikolaj. 2003. “Russkaya partiya”. Dvizhenie russkih nacionalistov v SSSR 1953–1985. Moskva: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie.
-
Muhametshina, Elena. 2021. “Kandidatam ot KPRF na vyborah v Gosdumu nashli spojlerov-odnofamil’cev. “Kommunisty Rossii” vystavili takih lyudej v semi stolichnyh okrugah,” Vedomosti, 9 ijulya. https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2021/07/08/877494-kandidatam-ot-kprf-nashli-spoilerov-odnofamiltsev.
-
Na politicheskoj paneli. 2015. rotfront.su, https://www.rotfront.su/на-политической-панели/.
-
Nemzer, Anna, Venyavkin, Il’ya. [2013] “Lev Krasnopevcev. Nas ne brali v 52-m, potomu chto bylo ne do etogo,” svoboda.org, https://www.svoboda.org/a/24920097.html.
-
Obrashchenie sekretariata CK VKPB k chlenam i kandidatam v chleny CC VKPB i ko vsem chlenam partii “Ob antipartijnoj raskol’nicheskoj deyatel’nosti Sekretarya CC VKPB N.A. Degtyarenko,” 2020, Bol’shevistskij Serp i Molot, 9, http://vkpb.ru/images/pdf/SiM/2020/serp_i_molot_09_20.pdf.
-
Polikovskij, Alexei. 2011. “Ulica Udal’tsova. Interv’yu s S. Udal’tsovym.” Novayagazeta.ru. https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2011/04/03/6200-ulitsa-udaltsova.
-
Poltavskaya, Yuliya. 2013. Osobennosti politicheskogo uchastiya molodezhnyh levoradikal’nyh organizacij sovremennoj Rossii. Cand. Polit. Diss., Saratov.
-
Programma politicheskoj partii “Rossijskij Ob’edinyonnyj Trudovoj Front.” 2012. rotfront.su, https://www.rotfront.su/program.
-
Programma RCRP-CPSS. 2010. rkrp-rpk.ru, https://rkrp-rpk.ru//программа-ркрп-кпсс/.
-
Programma Revolutionary Workers’ Party. 2016. rwp.ru, http://rwp.ru/ррп/программа/.
-
Programma Rossijskogo socialisticheskogo dvizheniya. 2021. anticapitalist.ru, http://anticapitalist.ru/programm/.
-
Programma sekcii ISA v SNG. 2016. socialist.news, https://socialist.news/isa/program-russia/.
-
Rajhshtat, Anton. 2021. “‘Veselye starty’ i neveselyj finish: soglasovannyj miting ne oboshelsya bez zaderzhanij,” kazanreporter.ru, https://kazanreporter.ru/post/4487_veselye-starty-i-neveselyj-finis-soglasovannyj-miting-ne-oboselsa-bez-zaderzanij.
-
“Reshenie po delu ‘Seti’—samyj nastoyashchij akt terrora.” Kto i kak podderzhal figurantov rezonansnogo dela ‘Seti’. 2020. Znak.com. https://www.znak.com/2020-02-18/kto_i_kak_podderzhal_figurantov_rezonansnogo_dela_seti.
-
Reshenie Verhovnogo Suda Rossijskoj Federacii ot 27 fevralya 2020 g. № AKPI20-23. 2020. sudact.ru. https://sudact.ru/vsrf/doc/qoa5K1R74i6t/.
-
Rublev, Dmitrij. 2019. Rossijskij anarhizm v XX veke. Moskva: Rodina.
-
Ruff, Philip (ed.). 1991. Anarchy in the USSR. L.: ASP.
-
Sergeev, Sergej. 2004. Politicheskaya oppoziciya v sovremennoj Rossijskoj Federacii (federal’nyj i regional’nyj aspekty). Kazan’: Kazan’ Univ. Pr.
-
Sergeev, Sergej. 2013. “Levye radikaly v rossijskoj provincii: dvizhenie ‘antifa’”, POLITEKS (Politicheskaya ekspertiza), 9, no. 1: 38–50.
-
Sergeev, Sergej. 2015. “Russkij oppozicionnyj vneparlamentskij nacionalizm—vse cveta spektra?” Soviet and Post-Soviet Review, 42: 321–351.
-
Sergeev, Vsevolod. 2012.“‘Universitetskoe delo’: formirovanie oppozicionnyh vzglyadov gruppy L. Krasnopevceva—L. Rendelya,” http://mkonf.iriran.ru/papers.php?id=69.
-
Shubin, Aleksandr. 2006. Predannaya demokratiya. SSSR i neformaly 1986–1989. Moskva: Evropa.
-
Spisok politzaklyuchennyh (bez presleduemyh za religiyu). 2021. Memohrc.org. https://memohrc.org/ru/pzk-list.
-
Tarasov, Aleksandr; Cherkasov, Gleb; Shavshukova, Tat’yana. 1997. Levye v Rossii: ot umerennyh do ekstremistov. Moskva: Centr “Panorama.”
-
Tarasov, Aleksandr. 2005. Revolyuciya ne vser’yoz. Shtudii po teorii i istorii kvazirevolyucionnyh dvizhenij. Ekaterinburg: Ul’tra.Kul’tura.
-
Tarasov, Aleksandr. 1997. “Zatmenie. Ne po Antonioni (Studencheskie besporyadki i mass media: issledovanie odnogo yavleniya).” Polis, no. 6: 87–103.
-
Tilman, Rick. 1984. C. Wright Mills a Native Radical and His American Intellectual Roots. University Park: Penn. State UP.
-
Udal’cov, Sergej. 2013. “Aktivnost’ grazhdan postepenno rastet” Sergej Udal’cov. Putinu—boj! Kogda Levyj front pobedit. Moskva: Algoritm.
-
Udartsev, Sergey. 1994. Politicheskaya i pravovaya teoriya anarhizma v Rossii: istoriya i sovremennost’. Almaaty: Adilet.
-
Urban, Joah Barth; Solovei, Valerii. 1997. Russia’s Communists at the Crossroads. Boulder (Co): Westwiew Pr.
-
Urban, Joah Barth. 2003. “The Russian Left and the French Paradigm,” Democratizatsya 11, no.1: 79–85.
-
Van Auken, Bill. 2018. “‘History never teaches anyone anything’. Russian neo-Stalinist defends Partido Obrero’s « refounding » of Fourth International,” wsws.org, https://www.wsws.org/ru/articles/2018/09/29/gafu-s29.html.
-
Verhovskij, Aleksandr; Papp, Aleksandr; Pribylovskij, Vladimir. 1996. Politicheskij ekstremizm v Rossii. (Moskva: Institut eksperimental’noj sociologii.
-
Veroyatnye zhertvy, ne vklyuchennye v spiski. 2021. Memohrc.org https://memohrc.org/ru/aktualnyy-spisok-potencialnyh-zhertv.
-
Yulbarisov, Rustam. 2020. “Kak ya stal Antifa,” zanovo.media, https://zanovo.media/istoriya-2-2-2/kak-ya-stal-antifa.
-
Zotova, Natal’ya; Fel’dman, Evgenij. 2012. “Sergej Udal’cov: ‘Glavnoe—lyudyam, vyhodyashchim na mitingi, predlozhit’ kakoe-to dal’nejshee obshchee delo’”. Novayagazeta.ru. https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2012/01/04/47620-sergey-udaltsov-171-glavnoe-151-lyudyam-vyhodyaschim-na-mitingi-predlozhit-kakoe-to-dalneyshee-obschee-delo-187.
-
Zhuravlev, Oleg; Savel’eva, Natal’ya; Alyukov, Maksim. 2015. “Kuda dvizhetsya dvizhenie: anatomiya rossijskogo protesta.” Politika apolitichnyh: grazhdanskie dvizheniya v Rossii 2011–2013 godov. Moskva: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie: 350–389.
-
Zyuganov, G.A.: Kitaj daet recepty pobed vsemu chelovechestvu. 2021. kprf.ru, https://kprf.ru/party-live/cknews/203631.html.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 255 | 255 | 17 |
| Full Text Views | 95 | 95 | 3 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 155 | 155 | 5 |
Under the Weight of the Soviet Legacy and Political Repressions: The Radical Left in Late Soviet and Post-Soviet Russia
In: The Soviet and Post-Soviet ReviewAbstract
Mass protest movements of the early 2010s, particularly the Occupy movement, stimulated the rise of radical left organizations globally. In Southern Europe, radical left parties celebrated their first electoral successes. In Russia, radical left organizations were also influenced by this upsurge of social protest movements and participated in the Bolotnaya protests in 2011–2012 but were marginalized and disintegrated shortly after, resuming their activities only by 2019. This article explores the radical left movements and groups in Russia and offers projections for their future. The Russian radical left is divided into three sub-groups: fundamentalist communists who identify with Stalin and the Soviet Union, libertarian socialists and communists (subdivided into neo-anarchists, autonomists, and neo-Trotskyists), and hybrid organizations (e.g., the Left Front). These organizations face two major constraints unknown to their Western counterparts. First, Russia’s authoritarian regime blocks opportunities for independent, particularly electoral, politics. This reveals itself in targeted repressions against left radicals and anarchists. Second, the dominance of the CPRF blocks any potential of strong left opposition. Unless these restrictions are lifted, radical left organizations in Russia will not be able to overcome their current crisis.
| All Time | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 255 | 255 | 17 |
| Full Text Views | 95 | 95 | 3 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 155 | 155 | 5 |