Lee Teng Hwee, Ho Pao Jin, and Educational Reform in Malacca, Singapore, Shanghai and Beyond, 1885–1945 (李登輝、何葆仁和麻六甲、新加坡、上海各處的教育改革及其它,一八八五-一九四五)

in Translocal Chinese: East Asian Perspectives
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

This essay focuses on Lee Teng Hwee and Ho Pao Jin, two “trans-local” activist educational reformers, in order to explore the interaction between changing social networks, governments, and educational reform movements in Shanghai, Singapore, and Malacca at critical moments between the 1880s and 1930s. Lee, as Fudan University President, and Ho, as Shanghai Student Union President, were key actors in the 1919 protest movement. Both were sons of families engaged in trans-regional trade, Lee moving from Batavia to Singapore, America, and Shanghai and Ho moving from Xiamen to Singapore, Shanghai, America, and Malacca. My purpose is to show how the shifting socio-economic networks and political structures and the activities of these educational reformers influenced each other, drawing on and contributing to local and trans-local experience. As these contributors were flexible in adapting to circumstances as they pursued their goals, we should also be flexible in our analysis of them.

本文聚焦在李登輝、何葆仁這兩位「跨越地域」(trans-local)的行動派教育改革者,從而探討在一八八零年代到一九三零年代的關鍵時刻,發生在麻六甲、新加坡和上海各地社會網絡、政府和教育改革運動之間的交流。兩位在一九一九年抗議運動時皆是活躍份子:李氏當時是復旦大學的校長,而何氏則是上海學生會的主席。兩人亦皆出身於從事跨區域貿易的商人家庭:李氏自巴達維亞移居到新加坡、美國和上海;而何氏則自廈門移往新加坡、美國和麻六甲。我的目的是要突顯出變動的社會經濟網絡、政治結構和這些教育改革者的活動之間彼此的影響,特別是一地的經驗如何在另一地被承續。由於這些貢獻者是探取相當彈性的方式在追求其目標,會因不同的情境而做出調整,我們對他們的活動之分析也應是彈性的。 (This article is in English).

Lee Teng Hwee, Ho Pao Jin, and Educational Reform in Malacca, Singapore, Shanghai and Beyond, 1885–1945 (李登輝、何葆仁和麻六甲、新加坡、上海各處的教育改革及其它,一八八五-一九四五)

in Translocal Chinese: East Asian Perspectives

Sections

References

BakerArchibald GilliesThe Religious Ideals of the Student Volunteer MovementThe Journal of Religion 4.2 (March 1924) 192202.

BastidMarianne. Educational Reform in Early Twentieth-Century China . Translated by BaileyPaul J.. Ann Arbor: Center for Chinese Studies, University of Michigan1988.

BergèreMarie-Claire. The Golden Age of the Chinese Bourgeoisie 1911–1937. Translated by LloydJanet. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1989.

BergèreMarie-ClaireShanghai: China’s Gateway to Modernity. Translated by LloydJanet. Stanford: Stanford University Press2009.

Bijou: The Ohio Wesleyan Yearbook. Delaware, Ohio: Ohio Wesleyan University1895.

British Documents on Foreign Affairs: Reports and Papers from the Foreign Office Confidential Print Part ii Series E: Asia 1914–1939 ed. TrotterAnn. (University Publications of America 1994) vol. 23: China January 1919–December 1920.

ChenBoping 陳伯萍. “Wei Tongji ‘jugong jincui’ de He Baoren boshi 為同濟《鞠躬盡瘁》的何葆仁博士 [Dr. Ho Pao Jin – Who Gave His All for Tong Chai].” In Tongji yiyuan 130 zhounian jinian tekan 同濟醫院130週年紀念特刊 [Tong Chai Hospital 130th Year Anniversary Volume]177180. Singapore: Tongzhai Hospital1998.

ChenJinghe 陳荊和 and YusongChen 陳育崧 comp. and eds. Xinjiapo hua wen bei ming ji lu 新加坡華文碑銘集錄 [A Collection of Chinese Inscriptions in Singapore]. (Hong Kong: Chinese University Press1970).

ChenJoseph T. The May Fourth Movement in Shanghai; The Making of a Social Movement in Modern China. Leiden: Brill1971.

Cheng Tianfang 程天放Zao nian hui yi lu 早年回憶錄 [Memoirs of My Youth]. Taibei: Zhuan ji wenxue chubanshe1968.

Chenzhong yexue liu’er huigu teji 晨鐘夜學:六二回顧特輯 [Seng Cheong Night School: 62-Year Retrospective Special Edition]. Melaka: Seng Cheong Association1995.

Chinese Recorder and Missionary Journal. Shanghai1868–1912.

ChngD.K.Y. 莊欽永. “Ying-hua xiaoyou Li Denghui boshi 英華校友李登輝博士 [acs Old Boy Li Denghui],Xinjiapo huaren shiluncong 新加坡華人史論叢 [Collected Essays on Chinese in Nineteenth Century Singapore] (Singapore: South Seas Society1986) 4456.

Christian Students and World Problems: Report of the Ninth International Convention of the Student Volunteer Movement for Foreign Missions Indianapolis Indiana December 28 1923 to January 1 1924. New York: Student Volunteer Movement for Foreign Missions1924.

College Transcript . Delaware oh: Ohio Wesleyan University. Five Colleges of Ohio Digital Collections: Student Newspapers.

ConradSebastion. What is Global History. Princeton: Princeton University Press2016.

Daily Illini. University of Illinois Student Newspaper. Champaign: University of Illinois1918–25.

Daonan xuexiao 85 nian jinian tekan 道南學校85年紀念特刊 [Daonan School 85th Anniversary Volume]. Singapore: Fujian huiguan1991.

DennerlineJerry. “‘Isaiah’ Revisited: The Missionaries, the Educational Reformers, and the Civic Religion of Lim Boon Keng in Singapore, 1885–1905.” Unpublished manuscript 2016.

DillonNara and OiJean eds. At the Crossroads of Empires: Middlemen Social Networks and State Building in Republican Shanghai. Stanford: Stanford University2008.

DrabbleJohn H.The Rubber Industry in Melaka” in Melaka: The Transformation of a Malay Capital c. 1400–1980 ed. by SandhuKernial Singh and WheatleyPaul Vol. 156888. Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press1983.

FewsmithJoseph. Party State and Local Elites in Republican China: Merchant Organizations and Politics in Shanghai 1890–1930. Honolulu: Univeristy of Hawai’i Press1985.

Formation of the Singapore Institution a.d. 1823. Malacca: Mission Press1823.

FrostMark Ravinder. “Emporium in Imperio: Nanyang Networks and the Straits Chinese in Singapore, 1819–1914Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 36.1 (Feb 2005): 2966.

Fudan daxue fuzhong sanshizhou jiniance 復旦大學附中三十周紀念冊 [Fudan University Attached Middle School 30th Anniversary Volume]. Shanghai: Fudan University1935.

Fudan daxue tongxue lu 復旦大學同學錄 [Students at Fudan University]. Shanghai: Fudan University December 1919.

Fudan daxue zhi 復旦大學志 [Fudan University Record]. Shanghai: Fudan daxue chubanshe1985). Vol 119051949.

Fudan gongxue tongxue lu 復旦剬學同學錄 summer 1916.

Fuh Tan Banner (Fudan University yearbooks) 1919–1926.

Geming zhi changdao yu fazhan 革命之倡導與發展 [Advocacy and Development of the Revolution] in Zhonghua minguo kaiguo wushinian wenxian 中華民國開國五十年文獻 [Documents from the First Fifty Years of the Republic of China] Vol 1.10. Taibei: Zhongzheng shuju1964.

Gospel in All Lands (Monthly). New York: Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church1880–1903.

HarperT.N.Globalism and the Pursuit of Authenticity: The Making of a Diasporic Public Sphere in Singapore Sojourn 12.2 (Oct. 1997) 26192.

HarrisonBrian. Waiting for China: The Anglo-Chinese College at Malacca 1818–1843 and Early Nineteenth-Century Missions. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press1979.

Ho Beng Teng interviewed by Moey Kok Keong. Oral History Special Project #002639. Singapore: National Archives 12 April 2002.

Ho Pao Jin. Pacific Blockade with Special Reference to its Use as a Measure of Reprisal. Ph.D. Thesis Abstract (1925). Urbana: University of Illinois1928.

HuangPhilip C.C. ed. “Symposium: ‘Public Sphere’/‘Civil Society’ in China?” Paradigmatic Issues in Chinese Studies iii. Modern China 19.2 (April 1993).

YangyingHuang 黃仰英 Yinshui siyuan 飲水思源 [When Drinking the Water Think of its Source]. Singapore: Xingjiapo xinlicun 星加坡信立村 1972.

Illiarch. 2012. “Ku Klux Klan” http://archives.library.illinois.edu/blog/ku-klux-klan/ (accessed March 20 2016).

KenleyDavid L. New Culture in a New World: The May Fourth Movement and the Chinese Diaspora in Singapore 1919–1932. New York: Routledge2003.

GuangzhaoKuang (Kuan Kong Chao) 匡光照 “Huiyi Peifeng 回憶培風 [Pay Fong Memoir]” (1963) in Peifeng 199429395.

KuoHuei-ying. Networks beyond Empires: Chinese Business and Nationalism in the Hong Kong-Singapore Corridor 1914–1941. Leiden: Brill2014.

Lat Pau 叻報. Singapore: National University of Singapore Digital Collection1887–1932.

LauEarnest and TeoPeter eds. The acs Story. Singapore: Anglo-Chinese Schools Board of Governors2007.

Lee Teng Hwee. “Letter,” in History of the Class of Eighteen Hundred Ninety-Nine Yale College compiled by DodgeMurray W.14445. Concord n.h.: The Rumford Press1919.

Li Yujie 李玉階. “上海學生響應五四愛國運動的經過 Shanghai xuesheng xiangying wusi aiguo yundongde jingguo [The Experience of the Shanghai Students’ Response in the May Fourth Patriotic Movement],” in Nian wusi yundong wushi ba zhounian 念五四運動五十八周年 [Remembering on the fifty-eighth anniversary of the May Fourth Movement]5962. 傳記文學 Zhuanji wenxue 30.5 (May 1977) 59–62.

Lin Bo’ai 林博愛 ed. Nanyang ming ren ji zhuan 南洋名人集傳 [Eminent Men of Nanyang: A Collective Biography]5 vol. Penang: Southern Seas Chinese Publishing Room1923–41.

MadsenRichard. “The Public Sphere, Civil Society and Moral Community: A Research Agenda for Contemporary China StudiesModern China 19.2 (April 1993) 18398.

Malacca GuardianMalacca1928–37. British Library microfilm.

Malacca ObserverMalacca1924–27. British Library microfilm.

Missionary Correspondence 1846–1912 . United Methodist Church Archives. Madison, New Jersey: gcah.

Monthly Report on Chinese Affairs (British Foreign Office Singapore 1933) #28–40.

Nanyang huaqiao jiaoyu huiyi baogao 南洋華僑教育會議報告 [Report of the Conference on Nanyang Overseas Chinese Education]. Shanghai: Jinan daxue1930.

Nie Zeng Jifen. Testimony of a Confucian Woman: The Autobiography of Mrs. Nie Zeng Jifen 1852–1942. Translated and edited by KennedyThomas L. and KennedyMicki. Athens ga: University of Georgia Press1993.

North China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette. Shanghai: North China Herald1870–1941.

Ohio Wesleyan Transcript. Delaware oh: Ohio Wesleyan University. Five Colleges of Ohio Digital Collections: Student Newspapers.

Oral History Project. Singapore: National Archives.

Pan Gongzhan 潘剬展. Xuesheng jiuguo quanshi 學生救國全史 [Complete History of the Student Patriotic Movement]. Shanghai1919.

Peifeng zhongxue shuangqing tekan 培風中學雙慶特刊 [Pay Fong Middle School Double Celebration Issue] Melaka: Pay Fong Middle School1994.

Qian Yimin (錢益民). Li Denghui zhuan 李登輝傳 [Biography of Lee Teng Hwee]. Shanghai: Fudan University2005.

RootsWeb. Ancestry.com (http://wc.rootsweb.ancestry.com/). Accessed March 25 2016.

SchwintzerErnst P. Education to Save the Nation: Huang Yanpei and the educational reform movement in early twentieth century China. Ph.D. thesis University of Washington1992.

SeahLeander. Conceptualizing the Chinese World: Jinan University Nanyang Migrants and Trans-regionalism 1900–1941. Ph.D. Dissertation History Department, University of Pennsylvania2011.

SeahLeander. “Rethinking the Making of Republican China: Jinan School, Chinese Migrants, and the Nanyang Connection, 1912–1926.” Paper delivered at the Association for Asian Studies Annual Meeting (national conference) 26–29 March 2015Chicagoilusa.

Shen Hongbai 沈鴻柏 (Sim Hung Peck). “Peifeng chuqi xiaoshi 培風初期校史 [Pay Fong History: The Early Years (1947).” In Peifeng 1994a3641.

Shen Muqing 沈慕卿. “Peifeng xiaoshe zhanggu 培風校舍掌故 [Pay Fong School Anecdotes]” in Peifeng 1994b32–51.

Shen Muyu 沈慕羽 (Sim Mow Yu). Shen Muyu shiji xinian 沈慕羽事跡繫年 [Sim Mow Yu Year by Year] in Shen Muyu ziliao huibian 沈慕羽資料彙編 [Sim Mow Yu: Selected Sources] ed. WenhuiLiao 廖文輝 (Lew Bon Hoi). Kuala Lumpur: Malaixiya huaxiao jiaoshi hui zonghui1997 Vol 3.

Singapore Free Press and Mercantile AdvertiserSingapore.

Singapore Infopedia: An Electronic Encyclopedia on Singapore’s History Culture People and Events. National Library Board Singapore. http://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/infopedia Feb 24 2016.

Song Ong Siang. One Hundred Years’ History of the Chinese in Singapore. London: J. Murray1923.

Straits Chinese Magazine. Singapore: Straits Times Press1897–1907.

Straits TimesSingapore.

Tan Seng Huat. History of the Chinese High School 1919–1941 . Academic Exercise: Senior Honors Dept. of History National University of Singapore 199192.

TsengTimothyReligious Liberalism, International Politics, and Diasporic Realities: The Chinese Students Christian Association of North America, 1909–1951Journal of American-East Asian Relations 5.3–4 (fall-winter 1996) 30530.

TsinMichael. 2004. “Introduction, Symposium, Beyond Habermas: Text and Performance in the Making of the ‘Public’ in Late Qing and Republican ChinaTwentieth-Century China 29.2 (April 2004) 15.

Urbana Daily CourierChampaign-Urbana, Illinois.

Van der VeerPeter. Imperial Encounters: Religion and Modernity in India and Britain. Princeton2001.

Van der VeerPeter ed. Conversion to Modernities: The Globalization of Christianity (New York: Routledge1996).

Wang GungwuLu Xun, Lim Boon Keng and Confucianism” in China and the Overseas Chinese ed. GungwuWang16384. Singapore: Times Academic Press1991. (Times Media Private Ltd. Reprint 2003).

WeeTong Bao. The Development of Modern Chinese Vernacular Education in Singapore: Society Politics & Policies 1905–1941. m.a. dissertation Dept. of History National University of Singapore 2001.

World’s Chinese Students’ Journal (bimonthly). July 1906–? Shanghai: World’s Chinese Students’ Federation (環球中國學生會).

Wu Tiren 吳體仁. Zhi chan xiang jiao tuo huang ren 殖產橡膠拓荒人 [Pioneer Rubber Planters]. Singapore: World Book Co.1966.

Xiamen daxue shizhounian jinian kan 廈門大學十週年紀念刊 [Xiamen University Tenth Anniversary Volume]. (Xiamen: Xiamen University1931).

Yang Jinfa 楊進發 (Yong Ching Fatt). “He Baoren boshi 何葆仁博士 [Dr. Ho Pao Jin],” in Zhanqian xinghua shehui jiegou yu lingdao ceng chutan 戰前星華社會結構與領導層初探 [Social Structure and Leadership in Pre-war Singapore: A Preliminary Exploration] 11727. Singapore: Nanyang xuehui1977.

Yeh Hua FenHandbook to Christ Church Malacca: with notes for revision. Singapore: Yeh Hua Fen Institute of Malaysia, typescript1959. Lee Kong Chian Reference Library.

Yeh Wen-hsin. “Huang Yanpei and the Chinese Society of Vocational Education in Shanghai Networking,” in At the Crossroads of Empires: Middlemen Social Networks and State Building in Republican Shanghai ed. by DillonNara and OiJean C.2544. Stanford University Press2008.

YongC.F. Tan Kah-kee: The Making of an Overseas Chinese Legend. Singapore: Oxford University Press1986.

YongC.F. and McKennaR. B.. The Kuomintang Movement in British Malaya 1912–1949. Singapore: Singapore University Press1990.

Young China. No. 1–8. Urbana: The Publicity Bureau of the Chinese Students, University of Illinois1919–1921.

Zhu Zhonghua 朱仲華 (承洵). “Wusi yundong zai Shanghai 五四運動在上海 [The May Fourth Movement in Shanghai] (1963)” in Wusi yundong huiyi lu 五四運動回憶錄 [Memoirs of the May Fourth Movement] vol. 326573. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Social Sciences1979.

18

Marie-Claire BergèreThe Golden Age of the Chinese Bourgeoisie 1911–1937 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1989) 207–17; Wen-hsin Yeh “Huang Yanpei and the Chinese Society of Vocational Education in Shanghai Networking” in At the Crossroads of Empires: Middlemen Social Networks and State Building in Republican Shanghai ed. Nara Dillon and Jean Oi (Stanford: Stanford University Press 2008) 25–44.

20

Joseph FewsmithParty State and Local Elites in Republican China: Merchant Organizations and Politics in Shanghai 1890–1930 (Honolulu: U of Hawai’i Press1985) 51–61; Bergère Marie-Claire Shanghai: China’s Gateway to Modernity tr. Janet Lloyd (Stanford: Stanford University Press 2009) 162.

22

Joseph T. ChenThe May Fourth Movement in Shanghai: The Making of a Social Movement in Modern China (Leiden: Brill1971) 118 and passim; Ho Pao-jin “Letter to the Municipal Council” North China Herald 7 June 1919 650; Letter from Ho Pao-yen (per T.H. Lee) to E.C. Pearce in “Students’ Activities” Ibid. 14 June 1919 723–24.

24

PanXuesheng114–15.

26

Brian HarrisonWaiting for China: The Anglo-Chinese College at Malacca 1818–1843 and Early Nineteenth-Century Missions (Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press1979) 19–44.

29

SongOne Hundred Years177 210 214 222; see “William F. Oldham” and “Celestial Reasoning Association” in Singapore Infopedia: An Electronic Encyclopedia on Singapore’s History Culture People and Events. (National Library Board Singapore. http://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/infopedia/ accessed Feb 24 2016); Earnest Lau and Peter Teo The acs Story. (Singapore: Anglo-Chinese Schools Board of Governors 2007) 23.

31

D.D. Moore“Glances at our Malaysia Mission,” Gospel in All Lands (New York: Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church 1880–1903) May 1896 222–26; Song One Hundred Years 291–93; Details forthcoming in Jerry Dennerline “‘Isaiah’ Revisited: The Missionaries the Educational Reformers and the Civic Religion of Lim Boon Keng in ­Singapore 1885–1905.” Unpublished manuscript 2016.

32

Charles Buchanan“Our Educational System,” Straits TimesJan 13 1904 5; “Student Volunteer Band” Lee Teng Hwee and Charles Buchanan members in Bijou: The Ohio Wesleyan Yearbook (Delaware Ohio: Ohio Wesleyan University 1895) 150–56; Charles Buchanan at Singapore acsCollege Transcript (Delaware: Ohio Wesleyan University) Dec 12 1896; and Ohio Wesleyan Transcript Oct 29 1902 7.

33

SongOne Hundred Years365–68.

34

Lee Teng Hwee“Letter,” in History of the Class of Eighteen Hundred Ninety-Nine Yale ­Collegecomp. Murray W. Dodge (Concord nh: The Rumford Press 1919) 144–45.

36

Lee Teng Hwee“The Effects of Ancestral Worship on Society in China,” Straits Chinese Magazine 5.20 (Dec. 1901) 130–35.

41

W.W. Yen [Yan Huiqing]“A Historical Sketch of the Federation,” World’s Chinese1.1 (­July–Aug 1906) 8–11; “World’s Chinese Students’ Federation” North China Herald 7 July 1905 23; “Notes” The Chinese Recorder 1 Aug 1905 409–411.

48

John H. Drabble“The Rubber Industry in Melaka,” in Melaka: The Transformation of a Malay Capital c. 1400–1980ed. Kernial Singh Sandhu and Paul Wheatley (Kuala Lumpur: Oxford University Press 1983) Vol 1 571–78.

56

C.F. YongTan Kah-kee: The Making of an Overseas Chinese Legend (Singapore: Oxford ­University Press1986); Kuo Networks 132–46.

57

Seng Huat TanHistory of the Chinese High School 1919–1941 (Academic Exercise: Senior Honors, Dept of History, National University of Singapore1992) 15–17.

58

YongTan Kah-kee112–114; Xiamen daxue shizhounian jinian kan 廈門大學十週年紀念刊 [Xiamen University Tenth Anniversary Volume] (Xiamen: Xiamen University 1931) 9 42; Lim Boon Keng “On the Tenth Anniversary” ibid. English section 6.

64

Timothy Tseng“Religious Liberalism, International Politics, and Diasporic Realities: The Chinese Students Christian Association of North America, 1909–1951,” Journal of American-East Asian Relations 5.3–4 (fall-winter 1996) 305–30.

65

Archibald Gillies Baker“The Religious Ideals of the Student Volunteer Movement,” The Journal of Religion 4.2 (March 1924) 195; see addresses by Y.Y. Tsu and Sherwood Eddy in Christian Students and World Problems: Report of the Ninth International Convention of the Student Volunteer Movement for Foreign Missions Indianapolis Indiana December 28 1923 to January 1 1924 (New York: Student Volunteer Movement for Foreign Missions 1924) 99–102 113–29.

68

Gungwu Wang“Lu Xun, Lim Boon Keng and Confucianism,” in China and the Overseas Chinese (Singapore: Times Academic Press, 1991; Times Media Private Ltd. Reprint2003) 163–84.

72

Yang“He Baoren” 120–24; Tan History 32–39 and Appendix i.

73

David L. KenleyNew Culture in a New World: The May Fourth Movement and the Chinese Diaspora in Singapore 1919–1932. (New York: Routledge2003) 49–52; Wee Development 41–47.

75

Shen Hongbai“Peifeng chuqi” 39–41; Shen Muyu Shiji xinian 17–18; Sim Mow Yu ­personal interview 1906.

77

Yeh Hua Fen“Anglo-Chinese College: A Chapter in Malacca History,” Malacca Guardian27 March 1933 “Father Francois Disagrees” 10 April “Father Cardon’s Views” 1 May “Mr. Yeh Hua Fen’s Reply to Father Cardon” 8 May and passim; Yeh Hua Fen Handbook to Christ Church Malacca (Singapore: Yeh Hua Fen Institute of Malaysia typescript 1959) 13.

78

SeahConceptualizing115–20.

94

Nara Dillon and Jean Oi“Introduction,” At the Crossroads of Empires3–24.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 51 51 31
Full Text Views 78 78 50
PDF Downloads 6 6 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0