This article discusses Morton Smith’s famous manuscript find, Clement’s Letter to Theodore (including the so-called Secret Gospel of Mark), and critically assesses Stephen C. Carlson’s study of its handwriting (2005). Carlson’s analysis is found to be wanting due to line screen distortion introduced by the halftone reproduction process in the images he used. We conclude that the script in the manuscript of Clement’s Letter to Theodore lacks all and any kind of “signs of forgery”.
P. Foster“Books of the Month: Secret Mark is no Secret Anymore—Secret Mark: Uncovering a Hoax”Expository Times117 (2005) 64-68; M.J. Kruger “Book Reviews: The Gospel Hoax: Morton Smith’s Invention of Secret Mark. By Stephen C. Carlson” Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 49 (2006) 422-424; C. Tuckett “Review: The Gospel Hoax: Morton Smith’s Invention of Secret Mark. By Stephen C. Carlson” Journal of Theological Studies 58 (2007) 193-195. For more in-depth treatment of Carlson’s reception consult Paananen “From Stalemate to Deadlock” 9-10.
V. Anastasopoulou“Experts Report Handwriting Examination”Biblical Archaeology Review36 (2010) 9http://www.bib-arch.org/pdf/secret-mark-analysis.pdf. We asked Anastasopoulou for feedback on an early draft of this article. Regarding our study of the line screen distortion she said: “I got the answer to my questions about Carlson’s findings which I could not see”; personal communication.