Quentin Quesnell’s Secret Mark Secret

A Report on Quentin Quesnell’s 1983 trip to Jerusalem and his inspection of the Mar Saba Document

in Vigiliae Christianae
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

Unbeknownst to most, in June of 1983, Quentin Quesnell made a visit to Jerusalem in order to personally inspect the Mar Saba document known as the Letter to Theodore. This is significant because it adds Quesnell to a small group of people who have testified to have seen the Letter to Theodore in person, and an even smaller group who have commented on its appearance and contents first-hand. Following Quesnell’s death in 2012 many of his personal belongings were acquired by Smith College (Northampton) and recently released to the public for viewing. Among Quesnell’s belongings was a journal full of notes, along with photos and letters to his wife Jean Higgins, all relating to Morton Smith’s discovery of the Letter to Theodore at Mar Saba and to Quesnell’s 1983 visit to Jerusalem. On the basis of these documents the following article offers a summary of Quesnell’s part in the debate over Smith’s discovery and a report of his inspection of the manuscript.

Quentin Quesnell’s Secret Mark Secret

A Report on Quentin Quesnell’s 1983 trip to Jerusalem and his inspection of the Mar Saba Document

in Vigiliae Christianae

Sections

References

4

See Morton SmithClement of Alexandria and a Secret Gospel of Mark (Cambridge: Harvard University Press1973) 1; Smith The Secret Gospel 22-23.

5

SmithThe Secret Gospel13-14. It should be known that Scholem and Smith continued in correspondence for the remainder of their lives and Smith actively sought Scholem’s advice related to the Mar Saba document; see Guy G. Stroumsa (ed.) Morton Smith and Gershom Scholem Correspondence 1945-1982 (Leiden: Brill 2008).

6

SmithClement of Alexandria and a Secret Gospel of Mark1.

9

Tony Burke“Introduction,” in Ancient Gospel or Modern Forgery?: The Secret Gospel of Mark in Debate ed. Tony Burke (Eugene: Cascade Books2013) 5.

10

SmithClement of Alexandria and a Secret Gospel of Mark251.

11

SmithThe Secret Gospel114. For a detailed summary of Smith’s exegesis see Brown Mark’s Other Gospel 6-9.

12

Charles W. Hedrick and Nikolaos Olympiou“Secret Mark,” The Fourth R 13.5 (2000) 3. Brown notes that “By the end of the 1970s New Testament scholars still mentioned ‘secret’ Mark in an incidental manner but were generally reluctant to take the gospel too seriously and risk looking foolish should it be proved a fake.” See Scott G. Brown Mark’s Other Gospel: Rethinking Morton Smith’s Controversial Discovery (Waterloo: Wilfred Laurier University Press 2009) 14.

14

BrownMark’s Other Gospel34.

25

Quesnell“A Reply to Morton Smith” 202.

27

See Per BeskowStrange Tales about Jesus: A Survey of Unfamiliar Gospels (Philadelphia: Fortress1983) 103; Hans-Martin Schenke “The Mystery of the Gospel of Mark” SecCent 4.2 (1984) 71; Jacob Neusner and Noam M.M. Neusner The Price of Excellence: Universities in Conflict during the Cold War Era (New York: Continuum 1995) 78; Craig A. Evans “Morton Smith and the Secret Gospel of Mark: Exploring the Grounds for Doubt” in Ancient Gospel or Modern Forgery?: The Secret Gospel of Mark in Debate ed. Tony Burke (Eugene: Cascade Books 2013) 76; Stephen C. Carlson The Gospel Hoax: Morton Smith’s Invention of the Secret Gospel of Mark (Waco: Baylor University Press 2005) 13-14; Elizabeth A. Clark and J. Patout Burns (eds.) “Special Issue: The Secret Gospel of Mark: A Discussion” jecs 11.2 (2003).

28

See John Dominic CrossanFour Other Gospels: Shadows on the Contours of Canon (Minneapolis: Winston1985) 10; Marvin W. Meyer “The Youth in Secret Mark and the Beloved Disciple in John” in Gospel Origins & Christian Beginnings: In Honor of James M. Robinson ed. J.E. Goehring et al. (Sonoma: Polebridge Press 1990) 95; Shaye J.D. Cohen review of Are There Really Tannaitic Parallels to the Gospels? by Jacob Neusner jaos 116:1 (1996) 87 n. 9; Brown Mark’s Other Gospel 36-38; Timo S. Paananen “From Stalemate to Deadlock: Clement’s Letter to Theodore in Recent Scholarship” CBR 11.1 (2012) 87-125.

29

Thomas J. Talley“Liturgical Time in the Ancient Church: The State of Research,” Studia Liturgica 14 (1982): 34-51. Pierson Parker “On Professor Morton Smith’s Find at Mar-Saba” AThR 56 (1974) 53-57.

31

Hedrick and Olympiou“Secret Mark” 8-9.

32

See Jean-Daniel Kaestli“Introduction de l’Évangile secret de Marc,” in Écrits apocryphes chrétiensed. François Bovon and Pierre Geoltrain 2d ed. (Paris: Gallimard 1997) 1:59-60 n. 4.

34

James H. CharlesworthAuthentic Apocrypha: False and Genuine Christian Apocrypha (North Richland Hills: Bibal Press1998) 30-32; James R. Edwards “Appendix: The Secret Gospel of Mark” in James R. Edwards The Gospel According to Mark (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 2002) 510 n. 2; John Dart Decoding Mark (Harrisburg: Trinity Press International 2003) 138-39. Also see Brown Mark’s Other Gospel 25.

36

BrownMark’s Other Gospelix-x.

37

Timo S. Paananen“A Short Interview with Quentin Quesnell,” Salainen evankelista [cited 19 Feb. 2015]. http://salainenevankelista.blogspot.com/2011/06/short-interview-with-quentin-quesnell.html .

38

See Burke“Introduction,” Ancient Gospel or Modern Forgery?: The Secret Gospel of Mark in Debate ed. Tony Burke (Eugene: Cascade Books 2013) 10.

54

Stroumsa“Comments on Charles Hedrick’s Article: A Testimony” 147-53.

92

Agamemnon Tselikas“Handwriting Analysis Report: Did Morton Smith Forge ‘Secret Mark’?” Bible History Daily14 October 2009 section “The Presence of Morton Smith”: http://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/biblical-topics/bible-interpretation/agamemnon-tselikas-handwriting-analysis-report/

Figures

  • View in gallery
    Isaac Voss’s Epistolae geniunae S. Ignatii martyris (1646) from the Mar Saba Monastery

Index Card

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 15 15 13
Full Text Views 12 12 12
PDF Downloads 2 2 2
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0