An Overview of the Egyptian Judicial System, and its History

in Yearbook of Islamic and Middle Eastern Law Online
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?



Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.



Help

Have Institutional Access?



Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?



Connect

References

Some parts of this article are drawn from the author's previously published work on "The origins and developments of the Egyptian judicial system" in Kevin Boyle and Adel Omar Sherif (eds.), ), Human Rights and Democracy: The Role of the Supreme Constitutional Court of Egypt, London, Kluwer Law International, 1996, Chapter 2.

2 The distinction between formal and substantive criteria in defining legal acts has been one of the main characteristics of the civil law system. In France, and also in Egypt, it is very common for distinctions within legal acts to be based on either formal or substantive views.

During the early stages of history, including the Roman law period, family was not based upon marriage, but upon power. Those who formed the family were all subject to the rights or power of the same family head. See Andrew Stephenson, A History of Roman Law, Boston, Little, Brown, 1912, p. 26. The emperor, or ruler, under Roman law possessed in full that power over the community which belonged to the father in his household. He sat in judgment over all private and criminal processes. Some of his functions, including the judicial function, were delegated to subordinates, but in the last analysis these functions were controlled by him. Stephenson, Roman Law, p. 26. 5 Mahmmoud Salam Zanaty, Mogaz Tarekh ElQannon ElMasry [A Brief on the History of Egyptian Law] (Cairo, 1986), p. 75. 6 However, it has been historically proven that the pharaoh occasionally delegated his judicial power to either civil or religious judges. Mahmmoud El-Sakka, Tarekb ElQannon ElMasry [The History of Egyptian Law] Cairo, Dar El Nahda El Arabia, p. 60. For more details on the successive historical periods of Roman law, see Stephenson, Roman Law.

8 Penny Darbyshire, Ealdey on The English Legal System, 5th edn., London, Sweet & Maxwell, 1992, p. 184.

Calob Berry Patterson, TheAdministration ofJustice in GreatBritain, Austin, University of Texas, p. 1. Also, see Edward Jenks, The Book of EnBlish Law, Boston and New York, Houghton Mifrlin, 1929, pp. 12 and 28.

10 For more details, see Omar Sherif, Nozom Elbokm Wa El Edara Fe El Islam [The Systems of Government and Administration in Islam], Cairo, Islamic Studies Institute, 1989. 11 Abd El Hameed Mctwaly, Mabadee Nezam Elbokm Fe El Islam [Principles of Government Systems in Islam], Cairo, Dar El Mareef, 1966, p. 633.

12 The Constitution of Egypt, for instance, provides in Art. 3 that the people are the source of the state's powers.

13 3 Fathy El Marsafawy, Tarekh El Qannon El Masry [The History of Egyptian Law], Cairo, Dar El Fekr El Araby, p. 161. 14 Ibrahim Awad,AlQadda Fe Ellslam [The Judiciary in Islam: Its History and Organization], Cairo, Islamic Research Institute Publications, 1975, p. 101. ls Adel Omar Sherif, ElQadda El Dostory FeMesr [Constitutional Adjudication in Egypt] Cairo, Dar EI Shaab, 1988, p. 52. 16 Omar Sherif, Nozom Elhokm Wa El Edara Fe El Islam, p. 124.

17 Awad, Al Qadda Fe El Islam, p. 184. 18 Omar Sherif, El Qadda El Dostory Fe Mesr, p. 52.

19 Omar Sherif, Nozom Elhokm Wa El Edara Fe El Islam, p. 130. 20 Aziz Khanky, "El Mohamaa" [The Legal Profession], in The Golden Book of the National Courts, 2nd edn., Cairo, 1990, p. 386. xl Fathy Wally,Qannon ElQadda ElMadany [The Civil Judiciary Law], Cairo, Dar El Nahda El Arabia, 1980, p. 220.

22 Mohammed Hamed Fahmy, El Morafaat El Madania Wa El Togaria [Civil and Commercial Procedures], Cairo, Maktabet El Nasr, 1938, pp. 44, 224. 23 Omar Sherif, El Qadda El Dostory Fe Mesr, p. 67. 24 Ibid., p. 68. 25 Wally, Qannon El Qadda El Madany, p. 222. 26 Omar Sherif, El Qadda El Dostory Fe Mesr, p. 68.

27 According to Art. 68 of the 1971 Constitution, the term "natural judge" means the competent judge over the subject matter of the dispute. The said article states, "The right to litigation is inalienable for all, and every citizen has the right to be referred to his or her natural judge".

28 Dr Awad Mohammed El-Morr, "Human Rights and the Constitutional Systems of Islamic Countries", Cairo University Law Review, Cairo, 1988, p. 7.

z9 "The Court of Cassation", in An Outline of the Judicial System, Cairo, 1972.

30 The rule of the Mohammed Ali family ceased to exist in 1953, upon proclaiming the republic system in the country, which was one of the most significant changes that followed the outbreak of the Egyptian revolution in 1952. 31 The topic of the Egyptian Bar - its history, functioning and independence - was addressed in the author's previously published work on The Origins and Developments of the Egyptian Judicial System, Chapter 2. It should be mentioned however, that the Bar has faced several internal problems in the recent years, either between the Bar and the government or among members of the Bar themselves. Because of these problems the Bar was placed under court supervision in 1996. Furthermore, the increasing role of the syndicates and public associations, including the Bar, in both political and public life in Egypt has led the government to pass several pieces of legislation during the 1990s to reorganize the conditions of membership in these syndicates and consequently limit their political role in the society. The new promulgated legislation in this matter is viewed by human rights advocates as dramatically reducing the autonomy of syndicate elections, and allowing the government to control the elected councils.

Information

Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 10 10 7
Full Text Views 0 0 0
PDF Downloads 0 0 0
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0