In this collected volume fourteen experts in the fields of Classics and Ancient History study the textual strategies used by Herodotus and Livy when recounting the disastrous battles at Thermopylae and Cannae. Literary, linguistic and historical approaches are used (often in combination) in order to enhance and enrich the interpretation of the accounts, which for obvious reasons confronted the authors with a special challenge. Chapters drawing a comparison with other battle narratives and with other genres help to establish genre-specific elements in ancient historiography, and draw attention to the particular techniques employed by Herodotus and Livy in their war narratives.
Lidewij van Gils obtained her PhD in 2009 with an analysis of the narrationes in Cicero’s speeches. Currently, her focus is on Latin historiography and the linguistic aspects of common ground. She is assistant professor of Latin at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. Irene de Jong is professor of Ancient Greek at the University of Amsterdam. She specializes in the analysis and interpretation of the forms and functions of narrative (Homer, Herodotus, and Greek narrative at large), making use of the modern theory of narratology. Publications include A narratological commentary on the Odyssey (Cambridge 2001), Homer Iliad Book XXII (Cambridge 2012), and Narratology and Classics. A Practical Guide (Oxford 2014). Caroline Kroon, Ph.D. (1995), is professor of Latin at the University of Amsterdam. She is author of the monograph Discourse Particles in Latin (Gieben/Brill, 1995), and of many articles on discourse linguistic topics. Her current research is characterized by an interdisciplinary approach crossing the border between linguistics and literary studies.
"[T]his volume contains many substantial papers and reflects high standards of scholarship: in addition to examining their chosen themes, many of the papers offer wider reflection on methodological questions. The introduction likewise introduces methodological considerations, providing a short introduction to narratology and discourse linguistics. (...) this volume, which will prove useful to scholars examining the Thermopylae and Cannae narratives from a large variety of perspectives." Edith Foster, BMCR, 2019.11.15.
PrefaceNotes on Contributors 1 IntroductionLidewij van Gils, Irene de Jong and Caroline Kroon
Part 1 Thermopylae
2 Thermopylae: Herodotus versus the LegendHans van Wees 3 A Narratological Comparison of Herodotus and Diodorus on ThermopylaeMathieu de Bakker 4 Narrative and Identity in Thermopylae (Herodotus 7.201–7.239)Antonis Tsakmakis 5 Herodotus’ Handling of (Narratological) Time in the Thermopylae PassageIrene J.F. de Jong 6 Herodotus and Thucydides: Distance and ImmersionRutger Allan
Part 2 Cannae
7 Livy on Cannae: a Literary OverviewStephen Oakley 8 Discourse-Linguistic Strategies in Livy’s Account of the Battle at CannaeLidewij van Gils and Caroline Kroon 9 Who Knows What Will Happen Next? Livy’s fraus Punica from a Literary Point of ViewDennis Pausch 10 Livy’s Use of Spatial References in the Cannae Episode: from Structure to StrategyLidewij van Gils 11 ET RATIO ET RES: Characterization of Roman Conduct through Speech Representation in the Battle of CannaeMichel Buijs 12 Words When It’s Time for Action: Representations of Speech and Thought in the Battles of Cannae and ZamaSuzanne Adema
Part 3 Beyond Thermopylae and Cannae
13 Thermopylae and Cannae: How One Battle Narrative Enriches AnotherMathieu de Bakker and Michiel van der Keur 14 The Great and the Small: Thermopylae and SphacteriaAdriaan Rademaker 15 Force, Frequency and Focalisation: the Function of Similes in the Battle Narrative of Vergil, Aeneid 10Stephen Harrison 16 Parallel Plotlines: the Function of Similes in the Battle-Narrative of Vergil, Aeneid 10 (2)Michiel van der Keur Index
All interested in narratology and pragmatics applied to Ancient Languages, and anyone interested in the rhetoric of ancient historiography.