Fr. Luis Martín García was superior general of the Society of Jesus during one of the most fractious periods in western history, from 1892 to his death in 1906. Fortunately for both the church and his order, he was endowed with remarkable gifts of mind and spirit. He was also troubled with personal challenges that he had to face almost entirely on his own. As an aid, he kept a memoir, prodigious in both size and content, to be published posthumously. The memoir appeared in a critical Spanish edition in 1988. In this present book, David Schultenover provides a condensed English version of it along with an interpretation that engages the question, why would a Jesuit superior general leave to posterity such a candid memoir? The subtitle “Showing Up” provides a clue.
David G. Schultenover, S.J., PhD (1975), is professor emeritus of historical theology at Marquette University. His publications on Roman Catholic Modernism include
George Tyrrell: In Search of Catholicism (1981) and
A View from Rome: On the Eve of the Modernist Crisis (1993). He served as editor-in-chief of
Theological Studies from 2006 to 2016.
“David Schultenover, S.J.’s monumental study of the Jesuit superior general Luis Martín (1846–1906) leaves all students of modern Jesuit, Catholic, and Spanish history in his debt. […] This archival and editorial triumph will inform the work of the next generation of historians of Spanish Catholicism, at a minimum, but should influence scholars of the modern Catholic world more generally.”
John T. McGreevy, University of Notre Dame. In:
Journal of Jesuit Studies, Vol. 9, No. 2 (2022), pp. 299–302.
“By any measure, this work is monumental. […] It is an invaluable resource for historians of nineteenth-century Spain, modernization and laicism, church-state conflict, religion and religious life, mentalities and emotions.”
Stephen Schloesser, Loyola University Chicago. In:
Church History, 2022.
Acknowledgments List of Abbreviations Introduction: “Showing Up”
Period 1. Formation, 1846–78: Melgar, Burgos, Loyola, Vals, Poyanne
1 Childhood, 1846–55 2 Latin School, 1855–58 3 Philosophy, 1858–61 4 Theology, 1861–64 5 Luis Martín’s Vocation to the Society of Jesus 6 Novitiate, Year 1, 1864–65 7 Novitiate, Year 2, 1865–66 8 Juniorate, 1866–68 9 Philosophy, 1868–70 1 First Year of Philosophy—Vals, France, 1868–69
2 Second Year of Philosophy—Poyanne, France, 1869–70
10 Regency: professor of Rhetoric, 1870–73 1 Academic Year 1, 1870–71
2 Academic Year 2, 1871–72
3 Academic Year 3, 1872–73
11 Study of Theology, 1873–77 1 First and Second Years of Theology, 1873–75
2 Third Year of Theology, 1875–76
3 Fourth Year of Theology, 1876–77
12 Third Probation (Tertianship), 1877–78
Period 2. Professor and Superior, 1878–86: Poyanne, Salamanca, Bilbao
13 Professor of Theology, 1878–80 1 First Year, 1878–79
2 Second Year, 1879–80
14 Seminary Rector in Salamanca: Year 1, 1880–81 15 Seminary Rector in Salamanca: year 2, 1881–82 16 Seminary Rector in Salamanca: year 3, 1882–83.Semester 1, Centenary of Saint Teresa 17 Seminary Rector in Salamanca: year 3, 1882–83.
Semester 2
18 Seminary Rector in Salamanca: year 4, 1883–84 19 Seminary Rector in Salamanca: year 5, 1884–85 20 Bilbao: director of the
Messenger
, 1885–86 21 Bilbao: superior in Deusto, Trip to Italy, 1886
Period 3. Provincialate, 1886–91: Valladolid
22 Provincialate: year 1, December 1886–July 1887 23 Provincialate: year 1, July to December 1887 24 Provincialate: year 2, January to June 1888 25 Provincialate: year 2, July to September 1888 26 Provincialate: works in Loyola, Deusto, Bilbao, 1887–88 27 Provincialate: year 3, January to June 1889 28 Provincialate: year 3, Semester 2, 1889 29 The Residence of Santander and the College of Gijón, 1887–89 30 The Colleges of Burgos, Tudela, Valladolid, 1868–90 31 Provincialate: year 4, Semester 1, 1890, Jesuits Meddling in Politics 32 Provincialate: final Year, April 1890 to April 1891 33 Founding the Seminary of Comillas, 1878–91
Period 4. 1891–92: Substitutus, Vicar General, General Congregation 24
34 Substitutus in Jesuit Curia, Fiesole, 1891 35 Vicar General, 1892 36 Preparation for General Congregation 24, 1892 37 Trip to Loyola for General Congregation 24, 1892 38 General Congregation 24: first Sessions, September 23–28, 1892 39 Election of Luis Martín as the Twenty-Fourth Superior General, October 2, 1892 40 Felicitations on the Election 41 General Congregation 24:
other
Elections 42 General Congregation 24:
discussion
of the First
Postulata
43 General Congregation 24:postulata on Religious Discipline 44 General Congregation 24:
decree
on Poverty 45 General Congregation 24: decree on Studies 46 General Congregation 24: conclusion
Period 5. Generalate, 1892–1906
47 Procurators Congregations, 1896, 1899, 1902 1 Procurators Congregation of 1896 2 Procurators Congregation of 1899 2.1 First Address of Luis Martín to the Procurators Congregation of 1899 2.2 Second Address of Luis Martín to the Procurators Congregation of 1899 3 Procurators Congregation of 1902 3.1 First Address of Luis Martín to the Procurators Congregation of 1902 3.2 Second Address of Luis Martín to the Procurators of 1902 48 Problems in Spain: salamanca, 1894 49 Problems in Spain: father Mir, 1896 50 Spanish Politics 1 Bishop Cámara and the Jesuits of Salamanca 2 Audience with the Pope 3 Interviews with the Spanish Ambassador to the Holy See 4 Correspondence with Cánovas del Castillo 5 Visits of Don Carlos and Don Jaime de Borbón 6 The Integrist Split and Its Repercussions in the Society 7 The 1894 Pilgrimage of Laborers 8 The Complaints of Segismundo Moret and Cardinal Rampolla 9 The Proposed Journal of Fr. Francisco de Paula Garzón 10 The Situation in the Three Spanish Provinces during 1895–97 11 The Attacks of Pey y Ordeix in El urbión 12 New Political Nuances at the End of the Century 13 Fr. Alarcón and El Mensajero 14 Opinions and Actions of Luis Martín in the Carlism-Integrism Polemic 15 New Siege of the Society of Jesus by Nocedal, 1900 16 The Complaints of Cardinal Cascajares 17 The Opening of Electra and Its Consequences 18 The Situation in Spain at the Beginning of the New Century 18.1 Persecution of the Religious Orders 18.2 A New Attack by Pey y Ordeix 18.3 Relations with the Carlist Royal Family 18.4 Integrism and the Unión de los Católicos 18.4.1 Attempts to Found the Unión Católica in 1902 18.4.2 The Tensions between Razón y fe and El Mensajero and Pius X’s Letter to the Bishop of Madrid (1905–6) 18.4.3 El Siglo futuro Is Allowed to Be Received in the Houses of the Society 51 The War of Cuba and the Philippines, 1895–98 1 Interviews with Very Reverend Father General 52 Luis Martín’s Account of His Final Illness, 1905
Epilogue Bibliography Index
All interested in the history of “the long nineteenth century,” church-state issues, the wars for Cuba and the Philippines, and Jesuit history after the restoration of the Society of Jesus (1814 ff.).