John Ponet (1516–1556) was a central figure in the English Reformation—an intellectual, ecclesiastical leader, and political thinker. This monograph revisits Ponet’s contributions to theology, humanism, and political theory, revealing his vital role in the Edwardian Reformation as a leading member of the Cambridge “Athenians”. Using newly discovered archival material and his reconstructed personal library, this study offers a fresh perspective on Ponet's influence, from his promotion of evangelical reforms under Edward VI to his advocacy for limited monarchy and resistance against tyranny under Mary. By rightly remembering Ponet, this book challenges the prevailing narratives and reshapes our understanding of the early English Reformation and mid-Tudor England.
Mark Earngey, DPhil (2018, in Ecclesiastical History, University of Oxford), is Head of Church History and Lecturer in Christian Thought at Moore Theological College in Sydney, Australia. His research interests and publications have focused on English Reformation history, theology, liturgy, and marginalia.
"Mark Earngey has carried out a notable task of rediscovery on a Protestant bishop who was central to the mid-Tudor Reformation, but whose relatively early death in exile curtailed a career that would probably have made him one of the leading forces in the Elizabethan Church. Earngey retrieves the brilliance and originality of this multi-talented scholar, and has reconstructed much of his library now scattered right across Europe, providing extensive analysis of the lively and fascinating annotations in Ponet's books. This is a major achievement in English Reformation studies."
Diarmaid MacCulloch, University of Oxford
"Bishop John Ponet has been remembered, if at all, as the punch-line to a joke about scandalous clerical marriages. Mark Earngey’s book finally does justice to him – and more. Drawing on a hugely impressive range of archival discoveries, Earngey is able not only to reconstruct Ponet’s intellectual world, but to show how and why this theological street-fighter was made a bishop aged only 34, and became a central figure of Edward VI’s Reformation and of the English Protestant exile community in the 1550s. The book not only gives us a wealth of lost detail, but provides a compelling overview of a man who, had he not died at the age of forty, would have become a colossus of the Elizabethan Church of England."
Alec Ryrie FBA, Durham University
Foreword
Acknowledgements
List of Figures
Abbreviations
Notes on the Text
Introduction
1The Birth of a Cambridge Humanist (1516–1543)
1 The Early Years
2 Student at Queens’ College, Cambridge
3 Fellow of Queens’ College, Cambridge
4 Bursar of Queens’ College, Cambridge
5 Final Years at Queens’ College, Cambridge
6 Summary
2The Rise of an Evangelical Theologian (1543–1549)
1 Evangelical Patronage and Preparation
2 Evangelical Study and Publication
3 Summary
3The Accomplishments of an Edwardian Bishop (1550–1553)
1 The Notable Sermon
2 Bishop of Rochester
3 Bishop of Winchester
4 Summary
4The Life and Death of a Marian Insurgent (1553–1556)
1 The Rise of Queen Mary and the Rising of Thomas Wyatt
2 Settling in Strassburg
3 Tragedies and Terminus
4 Summary
5The Theological Writings of a Marian Insurgent (1553–1556)
1 The Debate over Clerical Marriage
2 Behind the Debate over Clerical Marriage
3 The Draft Reply: Provenance
3.1 Questions of Authorship
3.2 Dating of Annotations
4 The Draft Reply: Literary Structures
4.1 Organisation of Notation
4.2 Symbols and Structures
4.3 Corrections and Errors
4.4 Use of Sources
5 The Draft Reply: Polemical Processes
6 Theology in Strassburg: Holy Scripture
7 Theology in Strassburg: Clerical Marriage
7.1 The Tradition of Clerical Celibacy
7.2 Hermeneutical Framework
7.3 Old Testament Exegesis
7.4 New Testament Exegesis
7.5 Vows of Celibacy
7.6 The Gift of Celibacy
8 Theology in Strassburg: A Misattribution to Ponet on the Eucharist
9 Theology in Strassburg: Political Theology
9.1 Calvinist Resistance Theory?
10 Summary
Conclusion
Appendix 1: Letters Relative to John Ponet
Appendix 2: John Ponet’s Books
Appendix 3: List of Sources in the Draft Reply
Bibliography
Index
This book is ideal for academic institutes, libraries, specialists, and postgraduate students interested in Reformation studies, Tudor history, ecclesiastical history, political theology, and early modern European intellectual history. Keywords: Reformation, English Reformation, Tudor England, Church of England, Formularies, Thomas Cranmer, Nicholas Ridley, John Cheke, Thomas Smith, Evangelicalism, Humanism, Cambridge Connection, Athenian Tribe, Marian Exiles, Greek Linguistics, Astronomy, Political Theology, Limited Monarchy, Tyrannicide, King Henry VIII, King Edward VI, Queen Mary I, Lady Jany Grey, Wyatt’s Rebellion, Strasbourg, Zurich, Zürich, Monarchical Republicanism, Clerical Celibacy, Natural Law.